본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

역사교육의전지구적전환: 새로운세계사와의연계

The Global Turn in History Education - Connecting with New World History -

김원수
한국역사교육학회 (The Korean Association of History Education)|2012.05|역사교육연구 (Studies on History Education)|제15호|pp. 101-124|DOI 10.16976/kahe.2012..15.101

0

조회

0

다운로드

9

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

global historybig history빅 히스토리universal history글로벌히스토리새로운 세계사new world history전지구적 전환global turn글로벌/트랜스내셔널global/transnationa

초록

오늘날 회자되는 세계사들은 기존의 전통적인 세계사와는 용어, 개념 및 접근방법 뿐 만아니라 교재 및 교수 학습 내용의 구성에 있어서도 전혀 새로운 패턴들을 보여주고 있다. 본고는 그 이해를 위한 시도적인 정리이다, 우선 최근 연구 동향을 통해 역사 연구와 역사교육에 있어서 세계사의 위상을 확인해 본다. 다음으로 역사학의 하위 영역(a subfield)으로서 전통적인 세계사와 새로운 세계사란 무엇인가를 알아 본다. 특히 universal history,new world history, global history, big history를 중심하여 그 개념화에 초점을 맞추었다. 어의, 과제와 방법, 그리고 기존의 세계사에서 새로운 세계사로의 전환과 그것이 가지는의미에 대해 살펴본다. 그것은 현재까지 학교교육을 통해서 세계사를 접해보지 못한 학생들뿐 만 아니라, 대학과 대학원 역사전공에서 세계사를 접해보지못한 교사들의 세계사 이해에일조할 수 있을 것이다.

Abstract

New World History began to emerge when historians failed to find solutions for the problems caused by the globalization, which widely spread across the world in the late 20st century and they tried to find alternative solutions for those problems. The global changes came to take place by the incidents of the German unification, the collapse of cold war followed by the fall of the Soviet Union, and in particular the September 11 attacks in the United States. These events made historians step further to seek a new world historical view. In this regard, the ideas regarding new world history started to be specified. We can see these changes from the following three cases. it con tains“ New world history”, “Global history”and “Big history”. First, the World History Association and the Journal of World History are the cases. Both of them were originally to establish the good status of the world history which was being globalized, Second, New Global History Initiative is another example. An intellectual group, which was established in 1989 and co-lead by Bruce Mazlish,a professor of MIT, and Wolf Schafer of Stony Brook University in New York,took a lead of this new field by publishing Conceptualizing Global History. Their work is specified through the course of‘ New Global History(2001)’taught by Bruce Mazlish and Akira Yiriye in Harvard University. Third example can be found in an effort to seek the concept of ‘a history of the whole universe,’which is more likely a general history. Maps of Time (2004) written by David Christian is an example of the effort. In the field of new world history which seeks the relationships and connectivity among groups based on the commonality of human beings, the concepts such as divergence, convergence, contagion, and systems are important and joint research are being promoted from multi-polar, pluralistic,and wide perspectives. The goal of the study is not to go back to the exclusive western supremacy of the modern history but to re-discover the enlightenment project, in other words, rationality of human actions. It is to make Humanocentric history not Eurocentric or Egocentric history. By this effort, it aims to transcend the traditional level of historical view, the developmental /improving historical view which is lineal, dualistic, and purposeful. This is to make new conceptualization of the Korean history possible in the context of new world history. Any researcher who is interested in making history globalized should first know that our historical experiences are closer to globality rather than modernity. In addition, he/she also needs to more focus on how to interpret the historical information rather than to collect the fundamental historical facts. With the information already given, it would be important for a researcher to infer, compare, seek relationships, find patterns, and interpret essential meanings of events of new world history. That is the way that we can be free from our ethnocentric ideas and seek creative and reflexive alternative solutions to prospect a better future.

참고문헌 (61)

  1. Christian, David, "The return of Universal History, History and Theory", Theme Issue, 49, pp.6~27 (2010)
  2. Geyer. Michael, "World History and General Education : How to Bring the World history into the Classroom, In The Nation, Europe, and the World : textbooks and curricula in transiition", pp.196~200 (2005), Berghann Books
  3. Carlyle, Thomas, "From On Heroes, Hero Worship, and the heroic in History, In The Varieties of History : From Voltaire to the Present", pp.101~107 (1972)
  4. Nietzche, "The Use and Abuse of History", pp.55~ (1957), Bobbs-Merrill
  5. 김원수, "초등학교에서의 세계사 교육을 위한 일고찰", 논문집, 27, pp.57~61 (1994), 서울교육대학교
  6. Momingliano, Arnold, "Greek Historiograph", History and Theory, 17, pp.1~28 (1978)
  7. Leyden, W.Won, "Review of Jacgueline de Romilly, Time in Greek Tragedy", History and Theory, pp.209~229 (1970)
  8. 유윤종, "유세비우스의 『연대기』와 『교회사』", 서양사론, (112), pp.320~347 (2012), 한국서양사학회
  9. Walsh, W. H, "Colligatory Concepts in History", Studies in the Nature and Teaching of History
  10. 볼테르, "Essai sur les moeurs et L’esprit des nations"
  11. Liebel, Helen, "Ranke’s Fragments of Universal History", clio, 2, pp.145~153
  12. Mink, Louis, "Narrative Form as a Cognitive Instument, In The Writing of History : Literary Form and Historical Understanding", pp.129~149 (1954), Bulletin
  13. Wolf, E. R, "Europe and the People without History" (1997), Berkeley
  14. 슈펭글러, "서구의 몰락" (1918)
  15. 토인비, "역사의 연구", pp.1934~1961
  16. 맥닐, "서구의 발흥" (1963)
  17. Pomper Philip, "World History-Ideologies, Structures, and Identities-", pp.21~ (1998), Malden, Mass. and Oxford
  18. Hodgson, "The Venture of Islam: Conscience and History in a World Civilization" (1974), University of Chicago Press
  19. Stavrianos, Leften, "Global history: From Prehistory to the Present" (1963), Prenticehall
  20. Stavrianos, Leften, "Global history: From Prehistory to the Present" (1963), Prenticehall
  21. Stavrianos Leften, "Lifelines From Our Past- A New World History" (1969), M.E.Sharpe
  22. Christian, David, "The return of Universal History", ~
  23. 차하순, "새로운 세계사의 조건"
  24. 배한극, "지구화 시대의 새로운 세계사", pp.23~ (2008), 도서출판 혜안
  25. 배한극, "지구화 시대의 새로운 세계사", pp.23~ (2008), 도서출판 혜안
  26. Albrow,Martin, "The Global Age: State and Society Beyond Modernity", pp.93~97 (1997), Stanford
  27. 김원수, "초등학교 역사교육의 발전방향- 지구규모의 역사인식과 관련하여-", 한국교육논총, 7, pp.79~81 (1995), 서울교육대학교 초등교육연구소
  28. Meyerowitz.Joanne, "History and September 11th" (2003), Philadelphia
  29. Casalilla Bartolome Yun, "‘Localism’, global History and Transnational History . A Reflection from the Historian of Early Modern Europe", Historisk Tidskrift num, 127, pp.1~6 (2007)
  30. Bentley, Jerry H, "Globalizing history and historicizing globalization", Globalization and Global History, 30
  31. Martha Nussbaum, "Cultivating Humanity: A classical defence of reform in liberal education" (1997), Cambridge
  32. Sachsenmaier Dominic, "Global history and critiques of western perspective", Comparative Education, 42(3), pp.455~463 (2006)
  33. Castells, Manuel, "The Intenet Galaxy: Reflections on the Intenet, Bussinesss, and Society" (2001), Oxford
  34. Giovanni Arrighi, "The Long Twentieth Century: Money, Power, and the Origins of Our Time" (1994)
  35. Geyer, "World History in a global Age"
  36. Hopkins, A. G, "Globalization in World History"
  37. Pomeranz,Kenneth, "The World that Trade Created: Society, Culture and the World Ecoonmy, 1400 to the Present" (1999)
  38. Pomeranz,Kenneth, "The Great Divergence: China, Europe, and the making of the Modern World Economy" (2000), Princeton
  39. Chandler, "Leviathan"
  40. Prasenjit Duara, "Rescuing History from theNation: Questioning Narratives of Modern China" (1995)
  41. Dirik, Arif, "Performing the World: Reality and Representation in the Making of World histor(ies)", Journal of World History, 16(4) (2005)
  42. Dirik, Arif, "Performing the World: Reality and Representation in the Making of World histor(ies)", Journal of World History, 16(4) (2005)
  43. "World history Connected", 3(32) (2006)
  44. Hughes-Warrington, "World History, and World Histories", History Connected, 3(3) (2006)
  45. Hughes-Warrington,Marni, "Palgrave advances in World Historise" (2005)
  46. 김원수, "글로벌히스토리의현재적의미", 서양사학연구, 15 (2006), 서양문화사학회
  47. Bentley. J.H, "The New World History, In A Companion to Western Historical Thought", pp.393~414 (2006), Blackwell
  48. Stearns. Peter, "World History : the basics" (2006), Routledge
  49. 김원수, "글로벌히스토리와 역 사들의지평을넘어서", 서양사론, 92, pp.277~286 (2007), 한국서양사학회
  50. Schafer, Wolf, "The New Global History toward a Narrative for Pangaea Two", EWA, 14, pp.75~85 (2003)
  51. Editorial, "Journal of Global History", 1 (2006)
  52. Bruce Mazlish, "The Global History Reader" (2005)
  53. Bruce Mazlish, "The Global History Reader" (2005)
  54. [URL]
  55. Spier, Fred, "Big History: The Emergence of an Interdisciplinary Science?", World History Connected, 6(3) (2009)
  56. Miller,Jacquelyn C, "Teaching the History of Motherhood as ‘Big’History", World History Connected, 4(3) (2007)
  57. Alvrez,Walter, "A Geological Perspective on Big History", World History Connected, 6(3) (2009)
  58. 배한극, "빅 히스토리(Big History)의 이론과 문제점", 역사교육논집, 46(46), pp.409~444 (2011), 역사교육학회
  59. [URL]
  60. Schissler Hanna, "World History : Making Sense of the Present, In The Nation, Europe, and the World : textbooks and curricula in transiition", pp.231~242 (2005), Berghann Books
  61. "Global History for Global Citizenship" (2010)[URL]

관련 논문AI추천

역사교육의 세계사적 맥락화를 위한 재구상 - 한일병합의 새로운 세계사 담론들 -김원수초등교육연구원 · 한국초등교육2011 · 제22권 제2호세계화와 역사교육 -새로운 패러다임을 위한 이론적 탐색-김미경, 김재춘대구사학회 · 대구사학2012 · 제108권 초등 사회과에서 글로벌 히스토리 교육을 위한 제언(提言)김원수초등교육연구원 · 한국초등교육2009 · 제19권 제2호중등 세계사 교육의 목적에 관한 논의박소연한국역사교육학회 · 역사교육연구2019 · 제35호세계화와 역사교육의 탈근대적 전환김미경대구사학회 · 대구사학2013 · 제113권 세계사 지식 체계의 변화와 교육과정 ― 2007, 2009 세계사 교육과정을 중심으로 ―이병인이화사학연구소 · 이화사학연구2012 · 제45호

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (7건)

국가수준 학업성취도 평가문항의 출제경향 분석우종정pp. 7-49외국의역사교과서 서술사례분석I - 교과체계와내용조직을 중심으로-구난희pp. 51-99동아시아사의관점에서본 초등학교역사교과서 - 전근대사를중심으로-임기환pp. 124-162문화·역사지리의관점에서 본중등학교역사교과서김한종pp. 163-200고등학교『한국사』교과서속 ‘시민’재해석구경남pp. 201-232
원문 보기