21세기 지방자치(행정)의 현대적 경향: 미국과 프랑스의 비교연구
Contemporary Trends in Local Autonomy (Administration) in the 21st Century: A Comparative Study between the United States and France
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
(Purpose) This study tried to diagnose the trend of local autonomy in the 21st century by comparing and analyzing the origins and progress of the local autonomy system in the United States and France. (Design/methodology/approach) Therefore, the analysis frame of the local autonomy administrative systems of the two countries was used as a frame of reference(Historical background, State(Etat)-Local Relations, Relationship between local government and residents, Structure and function of local government system) for comparative analysis to derive its characteristic explanation. (Findings) In brief, the flow of local autonomy(administration) in the two countries in the 21st century appeared as decentralization as a reform of local government. In the United States, the basic framework of the state government's autonomy and decentralization system, in particular, the Home Rule Act of local governments made it possible for local authority to be operated while respecting the diversity and specificity of the region. In addition, the direct democracy system, in which resident participation was actively developed, functioned as an institutional device to complement representative democracy. On the other hand, France, unlike the United States, led a uniform and unified powerful centralized state after the French Revolution to 'Jacobinisme' and 'Napoléonisme'(although of course writing the history of decentralization and centralization ups and downs), finally Decentralization policy was developed with the Socialist Party government of François Mitterand. (Research implications or Originality) In the case of the United States, in terms of federal and state government relations, it is a “state (separation) and federal democracy harmony model derived from Jeffersonism and Hamiltonism", which harmonizes both sides. Based on Dillon's rule, it can be pictured as a form of local autonomy that has an advantage over residents' autonomy dominated by Cooly's rule. On the other hand, in France, since the Mitterrand government, both left and right governments have continued to lead decentralization reform, but in the end, it is trying to promote decentralization in a single state-centered, strong centralized framework. It can be interpreted as “hybrid local autonomy” that seeks a new balance point between the central and local government according to the Jacobinisme appriviosé(Tamed Jacobinism).
Abstract
(Purpose) This study tried to diagnose the trend of local autonomy in the 21st century by comparing and analyzing the origins and progress of the local autonomy system in the United States and France. (Design/methodology/approach) Therefore, the analysis frame of the local autonomy administrative systems of the two countries was used as a frame of reference(Historical background, State(Etat)-Local Relations, Relationship between local government and residents, Structure and function of local government system) for comparative analysis to derive its characteristic explanation. (Findings) In brief, the flow of local autonomy(administration) in the two countries in the 21st century appeared as decentralization as a reform of local government. In the United States, the basic framework of the state government's autonomy and decentralization system, in particular, the Home Rule Act of local governments made it possible for local authority to be operated while respecting the diversity and specificity of the region. In addition, the direct democracy system, in which resident participation was actively developed, functioned as an institutional device to complement representative democracy. On the other hand, France, unlike the United States, led a uniform and unified powerful centralized state after the French Revolution to 'Jacobinisme' and 'Napoléonisme'(although of course writing the history of decentralization and centralization ups and downs), finally Decentralization policy was developed with the Socialist Party government of François Mitterand. (Research implications or Originality) In the case of the United States, in terms of federal and state government relations, it is a “state (separation) and federal democracy harmony model derived from Jeffersonism and Hamiltonism", which harmonizes both sides. Based on Dillon's rule, it can be pictured as a form of local autonomy that has an advantage over residents' autonomy dominated by Cooly's rule. On the other hand, in France, since the Mitterrand government, both left and right governments have continued to lead decentralization reform, but in the end, it is trying to promote decentralization in a single state-centered, strong centralized framework. It can be interpreted as “hybrid local autonomy” that seeks a new balance point between the central and local government according to the Jacobinisme appriviosé(Tamed Jacobinism).
참고문헌 (43)
- Bouvier, Michel, "Les finances locales" (2011), L. G. D. J
- Burns, James MacGregor, "State and Local Politics Government By the People" (1996), Pren tice Hall
- Choi, Chang-Soo, "Korea's Power Structure Controversy IV" (2005), Human love Publishing
- Choi, Jin-Hyuk, "Historical and constitutional origins of French local admini stration", Korean Society and Public Administration, 10(1), pp.193~206 (1999)
- 최진혁, "지방분권(개혁)을 위한 헌법개정에 관한 연구- 프랑스 사례를 중심으로 -", 한국지방자치학회보, 20(2), pp.77~101 (2008), 한국지방자치학회
- 최진혁, "국가와 지방자치단체간의 연계(협력)체제에 관한 연구 - 프랑스 사례를 중심으로 -", 한국비교정부학보, 15(1), pp.49~74 (2011), 한국비교정부학회[DOI]
- 최진혁, "21세기 지방자치의 현대적 경향 : 영국과 프랑스의 지방자치의 진화", 한국지방자치학회보, 27(3), pp.1~29 (2015), 한국지방자치학회[DOI]
- Choi, Jin-Hyuk, "A Study on Inter-regional Cooperation with Grand Paris as a Mega City Region of France", Super Greater Area Policy Forum (2022), KRIHS
- Chung, Sae-Wook, "Science of Local Autonomy" (2005), Beopmunsa Pub
- "City of Sacramento" (2019)[URL]
- Dye, Thomas R., "American Federalism : Competition Among Governments" (1990), Lexington Book
- Grant Alan, "Devolution and the Reshaping of American Federalism" (2000), Routledge
- Grant Alan, "American Government" (2002), Manchester Universit y Press
- Grodzins, Marton, "Goal for Americans : The Repor t of the President's Commission on National Goals" (1960), Columbia University Press
- 정준현, "미국 지방자치제와 현행 지방분권 논의의 문제점", 미국헌법연구, 30(2), pp.187~226 (2019), 미국헌법학회
- Kim, Jin-Ho, "American Local Politics" (2001), Daewangsa Pub
- Kim, Woong Ki, "Local government in the United States" (2001), Daeyoung publishing house
- Korea Research Institute for Local Administration, "Advanced Local Autonom y System: United States" (2012)
- Korea Research Institute for Local Administration, "Advanced Local Autonom y System: France" (2012)
- Luchaire, Yves, "Décentralisation et Constitution" (2003), Economica
- Mabileau, Albert, "Le Système local en France" (1991), Montchrestien
- Mény, Yves, "Le Système Politiques Français" (1993), Montchrestien
- Modèle présidentiel et executifs locaux, Quermonne, Jean-Lou is et Wahl Nocholas(sous la direction de), La France Présidentielle, "L'influe nce du suffrage universel sur la vie politique", Mény, Yves, 1995
- Mény, Yves, "The French political system" (1998), La documentation française
- Ministère de l'Intérieur, "Les collectivités locales en chiffres", DGCL, ~ (2012)
- Osborne, David, "Laboratories of Democracy" (1990), Harvard Business School Press
- Osborne M. Reynolds, Jr, "Handbook of Local Government Law" (2001), West Group
- "Polling agency Gallup", ~ (2009)
- Sadran, Pierre, "Le système administratif français" (1992), Montchrestien
- Skidmore, Max J., "American Government A Brief Introduction second edition" (1977), St. Martin's Press
- Thoenig, Jean-Claude, "La décentralisation dix ans après", Pouvoirs, (60) (1992), P.U.F
- Tocqueville, Alexis de, "De la Démocratie en Amérique I, Edition électronique réalisée avec le traitement de textes Microsoft Word 2001 pour Macintosh le 21 février 2002", ~ (1835)
- Tocqueville, Alexis de, "Democracy in America, Abridged with an Introductio n by Michael Kammen", pp.2009, Bedford
- Wikipedia, "US Federalism", ~ (2022)
- Wills, G., "A Necessary Evil : A History of American Distrust of Government" (1999), Simon & Schuster
- Wright., "Classics of Public Administration" (1987), The Dorsey press
- 유은정, "미국의 연방주의와 지방자치제도 - 우리나라 지방자치 및 지방분권이행 과정에의 시사점 -", 공법학연구, 11(3), pp.235~274 (2010), 한국비교공법학회[DOI]
- "Le Monde", ~ (2009)
- "Le Figaro", ~ (2009)
- "2017 Census of Governments - Organization"[URL]