의료의 철학과 법정책: 양방-한방의료의 경계설정과 무면허 의료행위의 규율
Philosophy of Medicine and Law: Drawing the boundary between modern (western) and (oriental) traditional medicine
0
조회
0
다운로드
26
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
In Korea, there are two different areas of medicine ―traditional (oriental) medicine and western medicine― and the medical licence for one area does not give the possibility to take part in the sequence of the medical acts which take place in the other area. But the technological development makes the boundary between two fields increasingly vague. IMS is just the case, where it seems almost impossible to judge to which domain the therapy belongs. The origin and history of the medicine shows us that the western medicine had quite similar characters and principles with those of the oriental medicine. The development of the modern medicine has changed the paradigm of the medicine, but the principles of the traditional or oriental medicine need to be integrated with the modern medicine, especially when we think of the nature of the medicine: it needs to be understood as the ‘holistic’ therapy and ‘Healing/Caring’, which have more than ‘biomedical’ therapy or ‘Curing’ focused on just the disease itself. In this context, the well-being of the patient and the actual situation of the usage of the therapy could be the legal criteria for the decision, when it seems difficult to decide, which licence is required for a certain medical act. Furthermore, the courses provided in the medical schools could give some standards for the decision as well.
Abstract
In Korea, there are two different areas of medicine ―traditional (oriental) medicine and western medicine― and the medical licence for one area does not give the possibility to take part in the sequence of the medical acts which take place in the other area. But the technological development makes the boundary between two fields increasingly vague. IMS is just the case, where it seems almost impossible to judge to which domain the therapy belongs. The origin and history of the medicine shows us that the western medicine had quite similar characters and principles with those of the oriental medicine. The development of the modern medicine has changed the paradigm of the medicine, but the principles of the traditional or oriental medicine need to be integrated with the modern medicine, especially when we think of the nature of the medicine: it needs to be understood as the ‘holistic’ therapy and ‘Healing/Caring’, which have more than ‘biomedical’ therapy or ‘Curing’ focused on just the disease itself. In this context, the well-being of the patient and the actual situation of the usage of the therapy could be the legal criteria for the decision, when it seems difficult to decide, which licence is required for a certain medical act. Furthermore, the courses provided in the medical schools could give some standards for the decision as well.
참고문헌 (20)
- 이상돈, "의료법강의" (2009), 법문사
- "의협-한의협 ‘IMS 법정 다툼’ 누가 웃을까"[URL]
- 김나경, "의사의 설명의무의 법적 이해", 한국의료법학회지, 15(1), pp.7~28 (2007), 한국의료법학회
- 김나경, "주관적 구성요건 표지를 매개로 하는 생명공학의 규율원리 모색", 형사법연구, 19(3-하), pp.777~798 (2007), 한국형사법학회
- "한방의료기관, X-선 사용제한 부당하다"[URL]
- 이상돈, "무면허의료행위죄 ― 현황, 구조, 한계, 대안", 고려법학, 40 (2003)
- 이상돈, "의료체계와 법" (2000), 고려대학교 출판부
- Andrew M. Knoll, "The Reawakening of Complementary and Alternative Medicine at the Turn of the Twenty-First Century: Filling the Void in Conventional Biomedicine", Journal of Contemporary Health Law and Policy, 20 (2004)
- Na-Kyoung Kim, "Leben als Lebensgeschichte und subjektives Tatbestandsmerkmal bei der Praimplantationsdiagnostik" (2007), Peter Lang Verlag
- Hille Haker, "Narrative Bioethik, nerkennung, Ethik und Behinderung" (2005), LIT Verlag
- 강신익, "몸의 역사 몸의 문화" (2007), 휴머니스트
- 강신익, "앎과 삶으로서의 몸: 동.서 의학에서 바라본 몸", 과학철학, 4(1) (2001)
- 조병희, "질병과 의료의 사회학" (2006), 집문당
- 나선삼, "한의학은 철학이고, 서양의학은 과학인가?", 의철학연구, 6 (2008)
- 미셸 푸코, "임상의학의 탄생" (2006), 이매진
- Robert T. Vlasis, "The Doctor is Out, or Unconventional Methods for Healing: Resolving the Standard of Care for an Alternative Medicine Practitioner", Houston Law Review, 43 (2006)
- Barbara L. Atwell, "Mainstreaming Complementary and Alterative Medicine in the Face of Uncertainty", UMKC Law Review, 72 (2004)
- Joseph A. Barette, "The Alternative Medical Practice Act: Does it Adequately Protect the Right of Physicians to Use Complementary and Alternative Medicine?", Saint John’s Law Review, 77 (2003)
- 조병희, "생의학과 한의학의 관계: 갈등과 통합", 의철학연구, 2 (2006)
- Lawrence J. Schneidermann, "The (alternative) Medicalization of Life", Journal of Law, Medicine and Ethics, 31 (2003)