우리 대법원 법해석론의 전환: 로널드 드워킨의 눈으로 읽기 ― 법의 통일성(Law’s Integrity)을 향하여 ―
Taking Integrity Seriously: Recent Trend in Jurisprudence of the Korean Supreme Court
1
조회
0
다운로드
55
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
The essence of Dworkin’s legal philosophy is that law is and should be based on integrity. According to law as integrity, propositions of law are true if they figure in or follow from principles of justice, fairness and procedural due process that provide the best constructive interpretation of the community’s legal practice. Integrity in legislation means that legislators should try to preserve coherence in principles. Integrity in adjudication means that judges responsible for establishing and declaring “what law is in this case” should try to interpret the statute and case law coherently. Especially in statutory interpretation, the judge should treat the statutes with integrity and must give them the meaning that show its political history and legal practices of the community in best light. My thesis is that the Korean Supreme Court has changed its jurisprudence in important respects during recent periods and that the turn can be summarized as ‘taking integrity seriously’. By analyzing recent decisions of the Korean Supreme Court through the lens of Ronald Dworkin’s theory, I will try to demonstrate my thesis.
Abstract
The essence of Dworkin’s legal philosophy is that law is and should be based on integrity. According to law as integrity, propositions of law are true if they figure in or follow from principles of justice, fairness and procedural due process that provide the best constructive interpretation of the community’s legal practice. Integrity in legislation means that legislators should try to preserve coherence in principles. Integrity in adjudication means that judges responsible for establishing and declaring “what law is in this case” should try to interpret the statute and case law coherently. Especially in statutory interpretation, the judge should treat the statutes with integrity and must give them the meaning that show its political history and legal practices of the community in best light. My thesis is that the Korean Supreme Court has changed its jurisprudence in important respects during recent periods and that the turn can be summarized as ‘taking integrity seriously’. By analyzing recent decisions of the Korean Supreme Court through the lens of Ronald Dworkin’s theory, I will try to demonstrate my thesis.
참고문헌 (33)
- 이상돈, "법철학" (2003), 법문사
- 로널드 드워킨, "법의 제국" (2004), 아카넷
- S. Guest, "Ronald Dworkin" (1991)
- G. Postema, "Integrity: Justice in Workclothes, Dworkin and His Critics" (2004)
- 한인섭, "재심․시효․인권" (2007), 경인문화사
- 심헌섭, "분석과 비판의 법철학", 법문사
- 윤진수, "2006년도 주요 민법 관련 판례 회고. in: 민법논고 III" (2008), 박영사
- N. MacCormick, "Legal Reasoning and Legal Theory" (1978)
- Philip P. Frickey, "Legislation and Statutory Interpretation, 2nd ed" (2006)
- R. Koch, "Juristische Begründungslehre" (1982)
- 김성룡, "법적 논증의 기초" (2006), 경북대학교출판부
- 김영환, "법학방법론의 관점에서 본 유추와 목적론적 축소", 법철학연구, 12(2), pp.1~28 (2009), 한국법철학회
- 윤진수, "性別訂正 許可가 있기 전의 性轉換者의 法的 地位 —대상판결: 대법원 2009.9.10.선고 2009도3580 판결—", 가족법연구, 23(3), pp.239~262 (2009), 한국가족법학회
- 고종주, "성전환자(transexual)에 대한 법적 인식과 처우: 트랜스섹슈얼의 법률상 지위에 관한 선례와 이론의 검토", 사법논집, 35 (2002)
- 매슈 아놀드, "교양과 무질서" (2006), 한길사
- Jinsu Yune, "The Role of the Courts in the Protection of Transsexuals' Human Rights: A Comparison of Korea with Germany and the U.K., Lebendiges Familienrecht, Festschrift für Rainer Frank" (2008)
- 이흥재, "업무상 재해의 인정기준에 관한 판례의 경향", 서울대학교 법학, 40(2) (1999)
- 조홍식, "사법통치의 정당성과 한계" (2009), 박영사
- R. Dworkin, "Taking Rights Seriously" (1977)
- R. Alexy, "Theorie der juristischen Argumentation", Aufl., 3 (1996)
- 김재형, "2008년도 민법 판례 동향", 민사재판의 제문제, 18 (2009)
- 최병조, "제1조", 민법주해, 1, 박영사
- 김혁기, "법의 불확정성 연구", 박사, pp.2009
- P. Devlin, "The Enforcement of Morals" (1965)
- H.L.A. Hart, "Law, Liberty, and Morality" (1963)
- J. Feinberg, "Harm to Self" (1986)
- J. Feinberg, "Harmless Wrongdoing" (1988)
- R.P. George, "Making Men Moral" (1993)
- S. Munzer, "A Theory of Property" (1990)
- 양삼승, "제3조", 민법주해, 1 (1992), 박영사
- 김도균, "권리의 문법" (2008), 박영사
- 안준홍, "비실증주의 법원리론 비판", 박사, pp.2008
- 함재학, "드워킨의 헌법사상: 헌법적 통합성과 파트너십 민주주의", 법철학연구, 12(1), pp.183~222 (2009), 한국법철학회