본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

“止於至善”:仁與人性內在關係的哲學證明

“Reaching at Supreme Goodness”: Philosophical Analysis of the Intrinsic Relation between Benevolence and Human Nature

0

조회

0

다운로드

0

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

주제분류유교학

초록

從孔子“仁者安仁”肇始,儒家仁學開啟了綿延流長的一個文化道統:仁與人性有內在關聯,而人性之善又源自道德形上學。孟子從性命論、形式邏輯和生命經驗三大層次證明“仁”為天之所“命”,落實于人心為善端。“命”意味著無條件性和普遍性,普遍性意味著人性平等,無條件性說明仁是“善”,是“應當”,是自由。在中國哲學史上,二程、朱子“仁學”標誌著以仁為核心的儒家道德形上學達到了前所未有的新高峰。在邏輯上,天理之善屬於絕對性的“元善”, “元善”意味著無條件性、先在性。天理之善是至善,不是與惡對立的善,而是超越了善惡對立的善。換言之,天理“元善”是無條件命令。理善,所以“理之性”善;性善,所以仁善!仁在普遍的人性中是無條件的命令,無條件意味著自由,仁是儒家自由意志視域中的自由。因為天理至善,所以仁善。這一思路與康德有點神似之處。經過二程和朱子的創造性詮釋,儒家仁學廣度和深度上都獲得了重大的提升,理論形態趨向成熟與完備,儒家道德形上學臻於巔峰狀態。尋求至善,是儒家一大思想主題。從倫理學意義上的《大學》“止於至善”出發,經周敦頤太極“純粹至善”,一直到道德形上學意義上的程頤天理至善(元善)思想的誕生,歷代儒家探求至善的哲學步履遞進遞佳。二程朱子“仁善由於天理善”思想的誕生與論證,標誌著儒家仁學成為中國自由主義倫理基礎和文化依託得以可能。

Abstract

Ever since Confucius claimed that “the benevolent is always content with benevolence”, the concept of benevolence has enjoyed a long-standing importance within the Confucian philosophical and cultural tradition. Within Confucian thought, as seen in the writings of Mencius, for example, benevolence is believed to have an intrinsic connection with human nature, as goodness comes from human nature and enjoys an intrinsic connection with moral metaphysics. Despite its baseline significance, this paper argues that benevolence reached its peak position as the core of a Confucian moral metaphysics in the thought of the Cheng Brothers and Zhu Xi., who argued that benevolence belongs to the Heavenly principle and is a unconditional impulse shared in common by all humanity. Following the Cheng brothers and Zhu Xi's creative interpretations, Confucian theories of benevolence have enjoyed significant interest, and seeking for goodness has become one of the great themes of Confucian thought. This article contends that it is largely the Cheng brothers’ and Zhu Xi's view of benevolence as “com[ing] from the heavenly principle” which has laid the foundation for the subsequent development of Confucian liberalism and its ethical base.

참고문헌 (41)

  1. 陳淳, "北溪字義" (1983), 中華書局
  2. 程顥, "二程集" (2004), 中華書局
  3. 範曄, "後漢書" (1965), 中華書局
  4. 韓嬰, "韓詩外傳" (1980), 中華書局
  5. 胡巨集, "胡巨集集" (1987), 中華書局
  6. 黃宗羲, "宋元學案", pp.630~ (1986), 中華書局
  7. 王弼, "王弼集校釋" (1980), 中華書局
  8. 焦循, "孟子正義" (2006), 中華書局
  9. 黎靖德, "朱子語類" (1994), 中華書局
  10. 陸九淵, "陸九淵集" (1980), 中華書局
  11. 阮元, "經籍纂詁" (1982), 中華書局
  12. 孫希旦, "禮記集解" (1989), 中華書局
  13. 王夫之, "船山全書" (1996), 嶽麓書社
  14. 王聘珍, "大戴禮記解詁" (1983), 中華書局
  15. 張九成, "孟子傳" (2007), 國際文化出版公司
  16. 朱熹, "朱熹集" (1996), 四川教育出版社
  17. 朱熹, "四書章句集注" (1983), 中華書局
  18. 朱熹, "朱子全書" (2010), 上海古籍出版社, 安徽教育出社
  19. 陳來, "仁學本體論", 文史哲, (4) (2014)
  20. 馮友蘭, "中國哲學史" (2000), 華東師範大學出版社
  21. 何中華, "孟子“萬物皆備于我”章臆解", 孔子研究, (5) (2003)
  22. 黃俊傑, "中國孟學詮釋史論" (2004), 社會科學文獻出版社
  23. 劉釗, "郭店楚簡校釋" (2005), 福建人民出版社
  24. 牟宗三, "歷史哲學" (1988), 臺灣學生書局
  25. 龐朴, "龐朴文集" (2005), 山東大學出版社
  26. 唐君毅, "中國哲學原論導論篇" (2005), 中國社會科學出版社
  27. 王國維, "觀堂集林" (1959), 中華書局
  28. 王甯, "章太炎說文解字授課筆記" (2010), 中華書局
  29. 王獻唐, "山東古國考" (2007), 青島出版社
  30. 韋政通, "中國思想史" (2003), 上海書店出版社
  31. 徐複觀, "中國人性論史" (2005), 華東師範大學出版社
  32. 嚴靈峰, "老莊研究" (1966), 臺北中華書局
  33. 楊澤波, "孟子評傳" (1998), 南京大學出版社
  34. 楊澤波, "孟子與中國文化" (2000), 貴州人民出版社
  35. 楊榮國, "中國古代思想史" (1973), 人民出版社
  36. 章太炎, "國學講演錄" (1995), 華東師範大學出版社
  37. 章太炎, "名家與荀子" (2010), 吉林出版集團有限責任公司
  38. 章太炎, "中國哲學十九講" (2010), 吉林出版集團有限責任公司
  39. 章太炎, "中國哲學的特質" (1997), 上海古籍出版社
  40. 章太炎, "心體與性體" (2010), 吉林出版集團有限責任公司
  41. 亞里斯多德, "形而上學" (1991), 商務印書館

관련 논문AI추천

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (10건)