본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

中国双层股权结构的法律规制小考

A Study on the Legal Regulation of China's Two-tier Equity Structure

0

조회

0

다운로드

0

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

초록

2019 年3月1日中国科创板正式开启后,迎来了中国第一家设置双层股权架构的公司——优刻得科技股份有限公司的上市申请,历经近一年最终成功上市。双层股权结构引入中国有着其现实背景,即中国企业和资本市场发展的需求。纵观世界上一些国家和地区,如美国、加拿大、新加坡和中国的香港已接受设置双层股权架构的公司上市,但也是有条件的接受。中国此次科创板引入双层股权结构也是在吸取了这些国家和地区的实践经验基础上,制定和修改相关立法,并发布相关规范文件给予其法律保障和监管。本文对优刻得公司上市前和上市后对于设置特别表决权作了何种说明和制约做了考察。双层股权结构并不是一个在世界范围内被广泛认可的公司股份形态,这种股权分类对于公司发展有利有弊,在公司初创期会促进公司快速发展壮大,但这之后进入平稳发展期,其固有的弊端就会显现。当前双层股权结构在中国科创板的实施过程中,也不可避免地会出现一些问题,如容易侵害中小股东权益、独立董事不够独立、监事会治理机制不完善、中小投资者风险识别和风险意识不强、中小投资者诉讼救济待完善等。本文对上述问题进行了分析,提出了相应的解决建议。双层股权结构是中国资本市场的一次大胆尝试,有利于境外上市企业的回归和高新科技企业的发展,更加有利于推动中国资本市场的发展,需要今后进一步加强治理和完善,发挥其应有作用。

Abstract

After the official opening of China's Sci-Tech Innovation Board on March 1, 2019, it welcomed the listing application of UCloud Technology Co., Ltd. It is the first company in China with dual-class share structure and successfully goes public after nearly a year. The introduction of the dual-class share structure in China has its realistic background. That is the needs of Chinese enterprises and capital market development. Throughout the world, countries and regions such as the United States, Canada, Singapore and Hong Kong in China have accepted the listing of companies with dual-class share structure, but they accept with conditions. The introduction of dual-class share structure to China's Sci-Tech Innovation Board is based on the practical experience of these countries and regions. China legislates and revises relevant legislation and regulatory documents to provide legal protection and supervision. This paper examines the explanation and restriction of setting special voting rights before and after the listing of UCloud Technology Co., Ltd. The dual-class share structure is not widely recognized in the world, and this kind of equity classification has advantages and disadvantages for the development of the company. In the company's initial stage, it can promote the rapid development of the companies. However, when companies enter into a smooth development period, its inherent disadvantages will appear. In the process of the implementation of the current dual-class share structure in China, there will inevitably be some problems, such as easily infringing the rights and interests of small and medium-sized shareholders, independent directors, not perfect supervisory board governance mechanism, small and medium-sized investors’ risk identification and risk awareness not being strong, and so on. This paper analyzes the above-mentioned problems and makes recommendations for a solution. The dual-class shares structure is a bold attempt of China's capital market, which is conducive to the return of overseas listed enterprises and the development of high-tech enterprises and benefits the development of China's capital market. But it also has the "original sin" and needs to be strengthened governance and improved in the future.

참고문헌 (21)

  1. 刑会强, "中华人民共和国证券法新旧条文对照与适用精解" (2020), 中国法制出版社
  2. 刑会强, "科创板政策解读与法律规范集成" (2019), 中国法制出版社
  3. 法律出版社法规中心, "公司法及司法解释汇编" (2020), 法律出版社
  4. 王骥跃, "科创板之道" (2019), 中国法制出版社
  5. 高菲, "新经济公司双层股权结构法律制度研究", 法律出版社 (2019)
  6. 于莹, "我国双层股权结构的制度构造", 吉林大学社会科学学报, (61) (2021)
  7. 李理, "公司治理之下的双层股权结构:正当性基础与本土化实施路径", 河北法学, (4) (2021)
  8. 李鸿渐, "双层股权制度下的中小投资者利益保护研究", 会计之友, (2) (2021)
  9. 吴尚轩, "论中国双层股权上市的规制", 法学论坛, (6) (2020)
  10. 冯果, "股东异质化视角下的双层股权结构", 政法论坛, (4) (2016)
  11. 樊纪伟, "中小企业双层股权结构:让人欢喜让人忧", 人民法治 (2019)
  12. 丁娜, "科创板双层股权结构制度探究", 甘肃金融, (1) (2020)
  13. 刘立燕, "科创板引入双层股权结构的制度保障研究", 武汉商学院学报, (4) (2019)
  14. 潘颖, "特别表决权制度在科创板的实践——兼评《科创板股票上市规则》‘表决权差异安排’", 吉林金融研究, (6) (2019)
  15. 李曜, "上市公司的双层资本结构--加拿大的经验及对我国的启示", 证券市场导报, (6) (2003)
  16. 李尚桦, "双层股权结构之法律评析——兼论其在我国之适用性", 金陵法律评论, (2) (2014)
  17. 程即正, "我国引入双层股权结构的挑战与对策研究——以公司治理为视角", 南方金融, (10) (2020)
  18. 刘胜军, "新经济下的双层股权结构:理论证成、 实践经验与中国有效治理路径", 法学杂志, (1) (2020)
  19. 王灏文, "美国类别股法律制度探源:背景、 进程及内在逻辑", 证券法苑, (2) (2018)
  20. Amoako-Adu, B, "Dual class firms: Capitalization, ownership structure and recapitalization back into single class", Journal of Banking & finance, 25(6), pp.1083~1111 (2001)
  21. Hossain, A. T., "Dual-class firms and governance: An acquisition perspective", Managerial Fiance, 41(11), pp.1221~1235 (2015)

관련 논문AI추천

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (15건)