본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

Biomechanical evaluations of the long-term stability of dental implant using finite element modeling method: a systematic review

Seyed Aref Hosseini-Faradonbeh|Hamid Reza Katoozian
대한치과보철학회 (The Korean Academy Of Prosthodontics)|2022.06|The Journal of Advanced of Prosthodontics|제14권 제3호|pp. 182-202|DOI https://doi.org/10.4047/jap.2022.14.3.182

2

조회

0

다운로드

0

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

ReliabilityFatigueOptimizationSensitivity analysisBone remodeling

초록

PURPOSE. The aim of this study is to summarize various biomechanical aspects in evaluating the long-term stability of dental implants based on finite element method (FEM). MATERIALS AND METHODS. A comprehensive search was performed among published studies over the last 20 years in three databases; PubMed, Scopus, and Google Scholar. The studies are arranged in a comparative table based on their publication date. Also, the variety of modeling is shown in the form of graphs and tables. Various aspects of the studies conducted were discussed here. RESULTS. By reviewing the titles and abstracts, 9 main categories were extracted and discussed as follows: implant materials, the focus of the study on bone or implant as well as the interface area, type of loading, element shape, parts of the model, boundary conditions, failure criteria, statistical analysis, and experimental tests performed to validate the results. It was found that most of the studied articles contain a model of the jaw bone (cortical and cancellous bone). The material properties were generally derived from the literature. Approximately 43% of the studies attempted to examine the implant and surrounding bone simultaneously. Almost 42% of the studies performed experimental tests to validate the modeling. CONCLUSION. Based on the results of the studies reviewed, there is no "optimal" design guideline, but more reliable design of implant is possible. This review study can be a starting point for more detailed investigations of dental implant longevity.

Abstract

PURPOSE. The aim of this study is to summarize various biomechanical aspects in evaluating the long-term stability of dental implants based on finite element method (FEM). MATERIALS AND METHODS. A comprehensive search was performed among published studies over the last 20 years in three databases; PubMed, Scopus, and Google Scholar. The studies are arranged in a comparative table based on their publication date. Also, the variety of modeling is shown in the form of graphs and tables. Various aspects of the studies conducted were discussed here. RESULTS. By reviewing the titles and abstracts, 9 main categories were extracted and discussed as follows: implant materials, the focus of the study on bone or implant as well as the interface area, type of loading, element shape, parts of the model, boundary conditions, failure criteria, statistical analysis, and experimental tests performed to validate the results. It was found that most of the studied articles contain a model of the jaw bone (cortical and cancellous bone). The material properties were generally derived from the literature. Approximately 43% of the studies attempted to examine the implant and surrounding bone simultaneously. Almost 42% of the studies performed experimental tests to validate the modeling. CONCLUSION. Based on the results of the studies reviewed, there is no "optimal" design guideline, but more reliable design of implant is possible. This review study can be a starting point for more detailed investigations of dental implant longevity.

참고문헌 (98)

  1. Chen LJ, "Finite element analysis of stress at the implant-bone interface of dental implants with different structures", Trans Nonferrous Met Soc Chin, 21, pp.1602~1610 (2011)
  2. Chang CL, "Finite element analysis of the dental implant using a topology optimization method", Med Eng Phys, 34, pp.999~1008 (2012)
  3. Chang HS, "Stress distribution of two commercial dental implant systems : a three-dimensional finite element analysis", J Dent Sci, 8, pp.261~271 (2013)
  4. Omori M, "A biomechanical investigation of mandibular molar implants : reproducibility and validity of a finite element analysis model", Int J Implant Dent, 1, pp.10~ (2015)
  5. Wu AY, "Biomechanical evaluation of one-piece and two-piece small-diameter dental implants : in-vitro experimental and three-dimensional finite element analyses", J Formos Med Assoc, 115, pp.794~800 (2016)
  6. Robling AG, "Mechanical signaling for bone modeling and remodeling", Crit Rev Eukaryot Gene Expr, 19, pp.319~338 (2009)
  7. Paracchini L, "Finite element analysis of a new dental implant design optimized for the desirable stress distribution in the surrounding bone region", Prosthesis, 2, pp.225~236 (2020)
  8. Ueda N, "Minimization of dental implant diameter and length according to bone quality determined by finite element analysis and optimized calculation", J Prosthodont Res, 61, pp.324~332 (2017)
  9. Mostafa Omran Hussein, "Stress-strain distribution at bone-implant interface of two splinted overdenture systems using 3D finite element analysis", The Journal of Advanced of Prosthodontics, 5(3), pp.333~340 (2013), 대한치과보철학회[DOI]
  10. Al-Zubaidi SM, "Improvements in clinical durability from functional biomimetic metallic dental implants", Front Mater, 7, pp.106~ (2020)
  11. Marcián P, "Micro finite element analysis of dental implants under different loading conditions", Comput Biol Med, 96, pp.157~165 (2018)
  12. Oliveira H, "Effect of different implant designs on strain and stress distribution under non-axial loading : a three-dimensional finite element analysis", Int J Environ Res Public Health, 17, pp.4738~ (2020)
  13. Kim T, "Orthopedic implants and devices for bone fractures and defects: Past, present and perspective", Eng Reg, 1, pp.6~18 (2020)
  14. Javed F, "The role of primary stability for successful immediate loading of dental implants. A literature review", J Dent, 38, pp.612~620 (2010)
  15. Hong HC, "The stability of implant-abutment complex with different implant-abutment connection designs, review of literature", J Oral Maxillofac Surg, 26, pp.262~286 (2015)
  16. Shemtov-Yona K, "Fatigue of dental implants:facts and fallacies", Dent J(Basel), 4, pp.16~ (2016)
  17. "ISO 14801. Dentistry-implants-dynamic fatigue test for end osseous dental implants", International Standards Organization (ISO), ~ (2007)
  18. Geng JP, "Application of finite element analysis in implant dentistry : a review of the literature", J Prosthet Dent, 85, pp.585~598 (2001)
  19. Steigenga JT, "Dental implant design and its relationship to long-term implant success", Implant Dent, 12, pp.306~317 (2003)
  20. Niroomand MR, "Effect of the dimensions of implant body and thread on bone resorption and stability in trapezoidal threaded dental implants : a sensitivity analysis and optimization", Comput Methods Biomech Biomed Engin, 23, pp.1005~1013 (2020)
  21. Jadhav L, "Design of experiments(DoE)based optimization of dental implants : a review", AIP Conf Proc, 2358, pp.1~13 (2021)
  22. Bandyopadhyay A, "Influence of porosity on mechanical properties and in vivo response of Ti6Al4V implants", Acta Biomater, 6, pp.1640~1648 (2010)
  23. Ji F, "Structure optimization of porous dental implant based on 3D printing", IOP Conf Ser Mater Sci Eng, 324, pp.012060~ (2018)
  24. Kunavisarut C, "Finite element analysis on dental implant-supported prostheses without passive fit", J Prosthodont, 11, pp.30~40 (2002)
  25. Perriard J, "Fatigue resistance of ITI implant-abutment connectors-a comparison of the standard cone with a novel internally keyed design", Clin Oral Implants Res, 13, pp.542~549 (2002)
  26. Genna F, "On the effects of cyclic transversal forces on osseointegrated dental implants : experimental and finite element shakedown analyses", Comput Methods Biomech Biomed Engin, 6, pp.141~152 (2003)
  27. Kayabasi O, "dynamic and fatigue behaviors of dental implant using finite element method", Adv Eng Softw, 37, pp.649~658 (2006)
  28. Wierszycki M, "Fatigue algorithm for dental implant", Found Civ Environ Eng, 7, pp.363~380 (2006)
  29. Yang J, "A three-dimensional finite element study on the biomechanical behavior of an FGBM dental implant in surrounding bone", J Biomech, 40, pp.2377~2385 (2007)
  30. Kong L, "Biomechanical optimization of implant diameter and length for immediate loading : a nonlinear finite element analysis", Int J Prosthodont, 22, pp.607~615 (2009)
  31. Hasan I, "Biomechanical finite element analysis of small diameter and short dental implant", Biomed Tech(Berl), 55, pp.341~350 (2010)
  32. Pérez M, "Life prediction of different commercial dental implants as influence by uncertainties in their fatigue material properties and loading conditions", Comput Methods Programs Biomed, 108, pp.1277~1286 (2012)
  33. Hasan I, "Influence of abutment design on the success of immediately loaded dental implants : experimental and numerical studies", Med Eng Phys, 34, pp.817~825 (2012)
  34. Tsai YT, "Fatigue life and reliability evaluation for dental implants based on computer simulation and limited test data", J Mech Eng Sci, 227, pp.554~564 (2012)
  35. Lee WT, "Stress shielding and fatigue limits of poly-ether-etherketone dental implants", J Biomed Mater Res B Appl Biomater, 100, pp.1044~1052 (2012)
  36. Ali B, "Effects of overloading in mastication on the mechanical behaviour of dental implants", Mater Des, 47, pp.210~217 (2013)
  37. Covani U, "An evaluation of new designs in implant-abutment connections : a finite element method assessment", Implant Dent, 22, pp.263~267 (2013)
  38. Geringer A, "Influence of superstructure geometry on the mechanical behavior of zirconia implant abutments: a finite element analysis", Biomed Tech(Berl), 59, pp.501~506 (2014)
  39. Ayllón JM, "Fatigue life estimation in dental implants", Eng Fract Mech, 123, pp.34~43 (2014)
  40. Bulaqi HA, "Effect of increased crown height on stress distribution in short dental implant components and their surrounding bone : A finite element analysis", J Prosthet Dent, 113, pp.548~557 (2015)
  41. Hernandez BA, "Fatigue analysis of dental prostheses by finite element method (FEM)", IMECE (2015)
  42. Hernandez-Rodriguez MAL, "Failure analysis in a dental implant", Eng Fail Anal, 57, pp.236~242 (2015)
  43. Prados-Privado M, "Dental implants fatigue as a possible failure of implantologic treatment : the importance of randomness in fatigue behaviour", Biomed Res Int, 2015, pp.825402~ (2015)
  44. Toyoshima Y, "Load limit of mini-implants with reduced abutment height based on fatigue fracture resistance : experimental and finite element study", Int J Oral Maxillofac Implants, 30, pp.e10~e16 (2015)
  45. Bicudo P, "Mechanical behaviour of dental implants", Procedia Struct Integr, 1, pp.26~33 (2016)
  46. Szajek K, "Numerical verification of two-component dental implant in the context of fatigue life for various load cases", Acta Bioeng Biomech, 18, pp.103~113 (2016)
  47. Bicudo P, "Performance evaluation of dental implants : An experimental and numerical simulation study", Theor Appl Fract Mech, 85, pp.74~83 (2016)
  48. Prados-Privado M, "A random fatigue of mechanize titanium abutment studied with Markoffchain and stochastic finite element formulation", Comput Methods Biomech Biomed Engin, 19, pp.1583~1591 (2016)
  49. Wu T, "Effect of lubricant on the reliability of dental implant abutment screw joint : An in vitro laboratory and three-dimension finite element analysis", Mater Sci Eng C Mater Biol Appl, 75, pp.297~304 (2017)
  50. Geramizadeh M, "Finite element analysis of dental implants with and without microthreads under static and dynamic loading", J Long Term EffMed Implants, 27, pp.25~35 (2017)
  51. Bordin D, "Fracture strength and probability of survival of narrow and extra-narrow dental implants after fatigue testing : In vitro and in silico analysis", J Mech Behav Biomed Mater, 71, pp.244~249 (2017)
  52. Prados-Privado M, "A new model to study fatigue in dental implants based on probabilistic finite elements and cumulative damage model", Appl Bionics Biomech, 2017, pp.3726361~ (2017)
  53. de la Rosa Castolo G, "Mechanical strength and fracture point of a dental implant under certification conditions : a numerical approach by finite element analysis", J Prosthet Dent, 119, pp.611~619 (2018)
  54. Yamaguchi S, "In vitro fatigue tests and in silico finite element analysis of dental implants with different fixture", abutment joint types using computer-aided design models, 2018, pp.62, 24~30
  55. Cinel S, "Experimental evaluation of stress distribution with narrow diameter implants : A finite element analysis", J Prosthet Dent, 119, pp.417~425 (2018)
  56. Cervino G, "FEM and von Mises analysis of OSSTEM ® dental implant structural components : evaluation of different direction dynamic loads", Open Dent J, 12, pp.219~229 (2018)
  57. Maryam Geramizadeh, "Three-dimensional optimization and sensitivity analysis of dental implant thread parameters using finite element analysis", 대한구강악안면외과학회지, 44(2), pp.59~65 (2018), 대한구강악안면외과학회
  58. Topkaya H, "Effect of dental implant dimensions on fatigue behaviour : a numerical approach", Uludağ Üniversitesi Mühendislik Fakültesi Dergisi, 23, pp.249~260 (2018)
  59. Abasolo M, "Influence of vertical misfit in screw fatigue behavior in dental implants : a three-dimensional finite element approach", Proc Inst Mech Eng H, 232, pp.1117~1128 (2018)
  60. Duan Y, "Fatigue lifetime prediction of a reduced-diameter dental implant system : numerical and experimental study", Dent Mater, 34, pp.1299~1309 (2018)
  61. Bayata F, "The mechanical behaviors of various dental implant materials under fatigue", Adv Mater Sci Eng, pp.5047319~ (2018)
  62. Prados-Privado M, "Complete mechanical characterization of an external hexagonal implant connection: in vitro study, 3D FEM and probabilistic fatigue", Med Biol Eng Comput, 56, pp.2233~2244 (2018)
  63. Lee H, "Biomechanical analysis of 4types of short dental implants in a resorbed mandible", J Prosthet Dent, 121, pp.659~670 (2019)
  64. Wang Y, "Studies on the performance of selective laser melting porous dental implant by finite element model simulation, fatigue testing and in vivo experiments", Proc Inst Mech Eng H, 233, pp.170~180 (2019)
  65. Bataineh K, "Effect of different biocompatible implant materials on the mechanical stability of dental implants under excessive oblique load", Clin Implant Dent Relat Res, 21, pp.1206~1217 (2019)
  66. Manea A, "New dental implant with 3d shock absorbers and tooth-like mobility-prototype development, finite element analysis(FEA), and mechanical testing", Materials(Basel), 12, pp.3444~ (2019)
  67. Prados-Privado M, "A finite element analysis of the fatigue behavior and risk of failure of immediate provisional implants", Metals, 9, pp.535~ (2019)
  68. Zhang X, "Study on statics and fatigue analysis of dental implants in the descending process of alveolar bone level", Proc Inst Mech Eng H, 234, pp.843~853 (2020)
  69. Sahin SC, "Static and dynamic stress analysis of standard-and narrow-diameter implants : a 3D finite element analysis", Int J Oral Maxillofac Implants, 35, pp.e58~e68 (2020)
  70. Nokar S, "Finite element analysis of stress in bone and abutment-implant interface under static and cyclic loadings", Front Dent, 17, pp.1~8 (2020)
  71. Armentia M, "Fatigue design of dental implant assemblies : a nominal stress approach", Metals, 10, pp.744~ (2020)
  72. Bayata F, "The effects of design parameters on mechanical failure of Ti-6Al-4V implants using finite element analysis", Eng Fail Anal, 110, pp.104445~ (2020)
  73. Lee H, "Biomechanical effects of dental implant diameter, connection type, and bone density on microgap formation and fatigue failure: A finite element analysis", Comput Methods Programs Biomed, 200, pp.105863~ (2021)
  74. Bergamo ETP, "Survival of implant-supported resin-matrix ceramic crowns : In silico and fatigue analyses", Dent Mater, 37, pp.523~533 (2021)
  75. Nicholson JW, "Titanium alloys for dental implants : a review", Prosthesis, 2, pp.100~116 (2020)
  76. Koike M, "Initial cytotoxicity of novel titanium alloys", J Biomed Mater Res B Appl Biomater, 83, pp.327~331 (2007)
  77. Liu X, "Binary titanium alloys as dental implant materials-a review", Regen Biomater, 4, pp.315~323 (2017)
  78. Saini M, "Implant biomaterials : a comprehensive review", World J Clin Cases, 3, pp.52~57 (2015)
  79. Augat P, "The role of cortical bone and its microstructure in bone strength", Age Ageing, 35, pp.27~31 (2006)
  80. Ovesy M, "A nonlinear homogenized finite element analysis of the primary stability of the bone-implant interface", Biomech Model Mechanobiol, 17, pp.1471~1480 (2018)
  81. Gao X, "Biomechanical behaviours of the bone-implant interface : a review", J R Soc Interface, 16, pp.20190259~ (2019)
  82. Gallucci GO, "Implant placement and loading protocols in partially edentulous patients : A systematic review", Clin Oral Implants Res, 29, pp.106~134 (2018)
  83. Gapski R, "Critical review of immediate implant loading", Clin Oral Implants Res, 14, pp.515~527 (2003)
  84. Colomina LE, "Immediate loading of implant-fixed mandibular prostheses : a prospective 18-month follow-up clinical study-preliminary report", Implant Dent, 10, pp.23~29 (2001)
  85. Horiuchi K, "Immediate loading of Brånemark system implants following placement in edentulous patients : a clinical report", Int J Oral Maxillofac Implants, 15, pp.824~830 (2000)
  86. Longva A, "Higher-order finite elements for embedded simulation", ACM Trans Graph, 39, pp.1~14 (2020)
  87. Lopez B, "Assessment of mesh dependency in the numerical simulation of compact tension tests for orthotropic materials", Composite Part C : Open Access, 1, pp.100006~ (2020)
  88. Flanagan D, "Osseous remodeling around dental implants", J Oral Implantol, 45, pp.239~246 (2019)
  89. Haase K, "Prediction of stress shielding around an orthopedic screw : using stress and strain energy density as mechanical stimuli", Comput Biol Med, 43, pp.1748~1757 (2013)
  90. Tortorelli DA, "Design sensitivity analysis : overview and review", Inverse Probl Sci Eng, 1, pp.71~105 (1994)
  91. Blázquez-Hinarejos M, "Influence of surface modified dental implant abutments on connective tissue attachment : a systematic review", Arch Oral Biol, 80, pp.185~192 (2017)
  92. Ding X, "Implant-bone interface stress distribution in immediately loaded implants of different diameters : a three-dimensional finite element analysis", J Prosthodont, 18, pp.393~402 (2009)
  93. Raffa ML, "Stress shielding at the bone-implant interface : Influence of surface roughness and of the bone-implant contact ratio", J Orthop Res, 39, pp.1174~1183 (2021)
  94. 김조은, "The three-dimensional microstructure of trabecular bone: Analysis of site-specific variation in the human jaw bone", Imaging Science in Dentistry, 43(4), pp.227~233 (2013), 대한영상치의학회
  95. De Martinis Massimo, "Gender Differences in Osteoporosis: A Single-Center Observational Study", The World Journal of Men's Health, 39(4), pp.750~759 (2021), 대한남성과학회[DOI]
  96. Carpenter RD, "Effect of porous orthopaedic implant material and structure on load sharing with simulated bone ingrowth : a finite element analysis comparing titanium and PEEK", J Mech Behav Biomed Mater, 80, pp.68~76 (2018)
  97. Aguilar C, "Influence of porosity on the elastic modulus of Ti-Zr-Ta-Nb foams with a low Nb content", Metals, 9, pp.176~ (2019)
  98. Abbasi N, "Porous scaffolds for bone regeneration", J Sci Adv Mater Dev, 5, pp.1~9 (2020)

관련 논문AI추천

Comparative finite element analysis of mandibular posterior single zirconia and titanium implants: a 3-dimensional finite element analysis이두형, 최성민, 최현석, 홍민호대한치과보철학회 · The Journal of Advanced of Prosthodontics2021 · 제13권 제6호Comparative evaluation of peri-implant stress distribution in implant protected occlusion and cuspally loaded occlusion on a 3 unit implant supported fixed partial denture: A 3D finite element analysis studyParamba Hitendrabhai Acharya, Sareen Subhash Duseja, Vilas Valjibhai Patel, Vishal Rajendrabhai Chauhan대한치과보철학회 · The Journal of Advanced of Prosthodontics2021 · 제13권 제2호The effects of bone density and crestal cortical bone thickness on micromotion and peri-implant bone strain distribution in an immediately loaded implant: a nonlinear finite element analysisKazuhiko Yamamoto, Kazuhiro Murakami, Sadami Tsutsumi, Satoshi Horita, Tadaaki Kirita, Tsutomu Sugiura대한치주과학회 · Journal of Periodontal & Implant Science2016 · 제46권 제3호Load response of the natural tooth and dental implant: A comparative biomechanics studyAndrea Gatti, Dale Robinson, David Ackland, Jaafar Abduo, Luis Aguilar, Peter Vee Sin Lee대한치과보철학회 · The Journal of Advanced of Prosthodontics2019 · 제11권 제3호Finite element study on the effect of abutment length and material on implant bone interface against dynamic loadingFumi Yoshioka, Manish Mishra, Shogo Ozawa, Tatsuhiko Masuda, Yoshinobu Tanaka대한치과보철학회 · The Journal of Advanced of Prosthodontics2011 · 제3권 제3호Effects of cementless fixation of implant prosthesis: A finite element study권긍록, 노건우, 박소연, 이현종대한치과보철학회 · The Journal of Advanced of Prosthodontics2019 · 제11권 제6호

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (5건)

Marginal bone level change during sequential loading periods of partial edentulous rehabilitation using immediately loaded self-tapping implants: a 6.5-year retrospective studyFeilong Deng, Zhengchuan Zhang, Jing Wangpp. 133-142Influence of dental implantation on bone mineral density distribution: a pilot studyDamian Jae-whan Lee, Jie Liu, Do-Gyoon Kim, Kenneth Stephen, Eun-sang Moonpp. 143-149Trueness of 3D printed partial denture frameworks; build orientations and support structure density parametersLamis Ahmed Hussein, Mostafa Omran Husseinpp. 150-161Effect of abutment neck taper and cement types on the amount of remnant cement in cement-retained implant restorations: an in vitro study박연희, 김경아, 이정진, 서재민, 권태민pp. 162-172Comparative analysis on intaglio surface trueness, wear volume loss of antagonist, and fracture resistance of full-contour monolithic zirconia crown for single-visit dentistry under simulated mastication김용규, 김대준, 한중석, 윤형인pp. 173-181
원문 보기