Gender Frames of Women’s Movements in Korea : A Case Study of the Korea Women’s Hot Line between the 1970s and 1990s
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Framing theories have made a significant inroad into social movement literature; however, details on how collective action frames develop and change remains insufficient. This shortcoming comes from the tendency toward depreciating the structural conditions that facilitate and constrain a frame shift and limiting research to framing processes with a synchronic or short, temporal span. Since a frame is evolving, an integrative perspective is needed to investigate multiple structural conditions and identify their combined effects on a particular context in which a specific frame is appropriated and adapted. A case study of the efforts of Korean women’s movements to articulate and extend the gender frame suggests that three main conditions are needed for a frame change: (1) global influences, (2) state responses, and (3) interorganizational networks. Although not determinant, structural changes stimulate movement leaders to strive to modify extant frames to sustain or improve their mobilizing potency and policy effects.
Abstract
Framing theories have made a significant inroad into social movement literature; however, details on how collective action frames develop and change remains insufficient. This shortcoming comes from the tendency toward depreciating the structural conditions that facilitate and constrain a frame shift and limiting research to framing processes with a synchronic or short, temporal span. Since a frame is evolving, an integrative perspective is needed to investigate multiple structural conditions and identify their combined effects on a particular context in which a specific frame is appropriated and adapted. A case study of the efforts of Korean women’s movements to articulate and extend the gender frame suggests that three main conditions are needed for a frame change: (1) global influences, (2) state responses, and (3) interorganizational networks. Although not determinant, structural changes stimulate movement leaders to strive to modify extant frames to sustain or improve their mobilizing potency and policy effects.
참고문헌 (59)
- Benford, Robert D., "An Insider’s Critique of the Social Movement Framing Perspective", Sociological Inquiry, 67(4), pp.409~430 (1997)
- Benford, Robert D., "Framing Processes and Social Movements: An Overview and Assessment", Annual Review of Sociology, 26(1), pp.611~639 (2000)
- Bunch, Charlotte, "Organizing for Women’s Human Rights Globally, In Ours by Right: Women’s Rights as Human Rights", pp.141~49 (1993), Zed Books
- Bunch, Charlotte, "Violence Against Women, In Women in the Third World: An Encyclopedia of Contemporary Issues", pp.59~68 (1998), Routledge
- Gamson, William A., "Framing Political Opportunity, In Comparative Perspectives on Social Movements: Political Opportunities, Mobilizing Structures, and Cultural Framings", pp.275~90 (1996), Cambridge University Press
- Greenspan, Miriam, "A New Approach to Women & Therapy" (1983), Tab Books
- Heo, Min Sook, "Globally Agreed Upon, Locally Troubled: The Construction of Anti-Violence Legislation, Human Rights Discourse, and Domestic Violence in South Korea", 박사, pp.2008
- Hooks, Bell, "Feminism is for Everybody: Passionate Politics" (2000), South End Press
- Hull, Kathleen E., "The Political Limits of the Rights Frame: The Case of Same-Sex Marriage in Hawaii", Sociological Perspectives, 44(2), pp.207~232 (2001)
- 김경희, "A Frame Analysis of Women's Policies of Korean Government and Women's Movements in the 1980s and 1990s", Korea Journal, 42(2), pp.5~36 (2002), 유네스코한국위원회
- McAdam, Doug, "Comparative Perspectives on Social Movements: Political Opportunity Structures, Mobilizing Structures, and Cultural Framings" (1996), Cambridge University Press
- McCarthy, John D., "Resource Mobilization and Social Movements: A Partial Theory", American Journal of Sociology, 82(6), pp.1212~1241 (1977)
- Polletta, Francesca, "Frames and Their Consequences, In The Oxford Handbook of Contextual Political Analysis", pp.187~209 (2006), Oxford University Press
- Snow, David A., "Frame Alignment Processes, Micromobilization, and Movement Participation", American Sociological Review, 51(4), pp.464~481 (1986)
- Tarrow, Sidney, "Power in Movement: Social Movements, Collective Action and Politics" (1994), Cambridge University Press
- Tilly, Charles, "From Mobilization to Revolution" (1978), Addison-Wesley
- Worell, Judith, "Feminist Perspectives in Therapy: Empowering Diverse Women" (1996), Korean Works
- Cho, Chu-hyŏn, "Women’s Liberation and Politicization of Gender, In Women’s Liberation and Politicization of Gender", pp.165~244 (1996), Seoul National University Press
- Cho, Hŭi-yŏn, "Democracy and Social Movements in Korea" (1998), Tangdae
- Cho, Hŭi-yŏn, "Change and Characteristics of Social Movements after Democratic Uprising: Focusing on Four Aspects, In Korean Civil Society and NGOs", pp.35~65 (2004), Siminŭi Sinmun
- Cho, Hŭi-yŏn, "From Convergence into Large Movements to Differentiation into Movements with Difference, In From Big to Many in Differences: The Diversification of Social Movements in Korean Democratization", pp.25~137 (2010), Hanul Academy
- Chŏng, Ch’un-suk, "History of Feminist Counseling in Korea, In Feminist Counseling in Korea", pp.46~95 (2005), Hanul Academy
- Han, In-sŏp, "Women’s Movements and Law after the 1990s, In Issues and Prospects of Korean Women’s Policy", pp.127~168 (2005), Hamkke Iknŭn Ch’aek
- Hwang, Chŏng-mi, "Formation of Women’s Policy in Korea and Implication of Women’s Policy in the 1990s, In Issues and Prospects of Korean Women’s Policy", pp.33~68 (2005), Hamkke Iknŭn Ch’aek
- Kang, Wŏn-ryong, "Prospects for Future Society and Women’s Movements, In Challenge of Feminist Culture", pp.88~94 (1975), Samsung Publisher
- Kim, Chun-ho, "Attitude toward Violence in Korea" (1992), Korean Institute of Criminology
- Kim, Kŭn-nam, "A Study on the Cyclical Organizational Solidarity of Korean Women’s Movements: A Case Study of the Movement of ‘Family Law" (2004), Ewha Woman’s University
- Kim, Tong-ch’un, "Shadow of Modernity" (2000), Tangdae
- Min, Kyŏng-ja, "History of Anti-Prostitution Movements in Korea, In Korean Women’s Human Rights Movements", pp.239~299 (1999), Hanul Academy
- Nam, In-sun, "A Study of Effects of Women’s Organizations on the Legalization Process of the Law on the Prevention of Domestic Violence", 석사, pp.2002
- O, Yu-sŏk, "Change and Diversification of Women’s Movements, In From Big to Many in Differences: The Diversification of Social Movements in Korean Democratization", pp.245~288 (2010), Hanul Academy
- Pak, Chin-a, "A Study of the Feminist Therapy of Women Counseling Center", 석사, pp.2000
- Pak, Chin-suk, "A Comparative Study on the US and Korean Women’s Movements: A Preliminary Study", Women’s Studies Review, 18, pp.73~103 (2001)
- Pyŏn, Hwa-sun, "Impact of Patriarchal Militarism on Women in Korea", Women’s Status Change and Prospect after Liberation: Conference Commemorating the 50th Anniversary of Liberation, pp.131~164 (1995), Korean Women’s Development Institute
- Pyŏn, Hwa-sun, "50 Years of UN Commission on the Status of Women and 10-Year Activities in Korea" (1997), Korean Women’s Development Institute
- Sin, Hye-su, "The International Covenants for Human Rights on Women and Women’s Movements, In Korean Women’s Human Rights Movements", pp.452~502 (1999), Hanul Academy
- Sin, In-ryŏng, "Women’s Society and the Intermediate Class, In Polarization Era and the Intermediate Class", pp.307~325 (1975), Samsung Publisher
- Sin, Sang-suk, "Beyond the Dichotomy of Institutionalization vs. Autonomy: Building the Movements to End Violence Against Women in South Korea", 박사, pp.2007
- Yi, Hang-nyŏng, "Expansion of Unconsented Power, In Polarization Era and the Intermediate Class", pp.139~142 (1975), Samsung Publisher
- Yi, In-ho, "Women’s Movements are Human Rights Movements, In Challenge of Feminist Culture", pp.50~60 (1975), Samsung Publisher
- Yi, Sang-dŏk, "A Study in the Legislative Development of the ‘Punishment for Sexual Assault and Prevention Act’ in Korea", 석사, pp.1997
- Yi, Sin-haeng, "Social Movements and Political Change in Korea" (1998), Minŭmsa
- Yi, T’ae-yŏng, "Consciousness-Raising Movements of Korean Women and Their Prospect, In Diagnosis and Prospect of Korean Society", pp.269~288 (1975), Samsung Publisher
- 이동주, "한국 성매매 반대운동의 프레임 형성과 변화에 관한 연구 - 1970∼2005년 기간을 중심으로", 사회연구, 9(1), pp.9~39 (2008), 한국사회조사연구소
- Yun, Sun-dŏk, "Ideology and Direction of Korean Women’s Movements, In Challenge of Feminist Culture", pp.19~32 (1975), Samsung Publisher
- Women Leaders’ Consultative Meeting Report, "Christian Academy", ~ (1974)
- Christian Institute for the Study of Justice and Development(CISJD), "Democracy Movements and Christianity in the 1970s", ~ (1983)
- Korea Women’s Hot Line (KWHL), "Casebook of Feminist Counseling", ~ (1988)
- Report of Meeting with Politicians, "Korea Women’s Hot Line (KWHL)", ~ (1991)
- Professional Workshop Report for the Act on Prevention of Domestic Violence, "Korea Women’s Hot Line (KWHL)", ~ (1995)
- Sim, Yŏng-hŭi, "Women’s Human Rights and Marital Rape", Open Forum on Women’s Human Rights and Marital Rape (2000)
- Sin, Ŭn-hye, "A Case Study in the Second Half of 1983", Report Commemorating 1st Anniversary of Opening, Korea Women’s Hot Line (1984)
- Policy Report on Anti-VAW Movements, "Special Committee for Enactment of Special Act on Sexual Violence (SCESASV)", ~ (1992)
- Yi, Hyŏn-suk, "25-Year History of Korea Church Women United" (1992), Korea Church Women United
- Yun, Ho-mi, "Settlement of Womanhood in 1983", Women, 204 (1983)
- "Democratic Women of Korean Women’s Association United", ~
- "Loom of Korea Women’s Hot Line", ~
- "Women of Korea National Council of Women", ~
- "Korea Dialogue Academy"[URL]
