Cicero and the Age of Extremes
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
The title of this article is not only a direct allusion to the famous work by Eric J. Hobsbawm , The Age of Extremes : The Short Twentieth Century, published in 1994, but the article itself is also an evocation of the work of the late Emanuele Narducci who, in a short essay published in 2001, proposed an interesting way of looking at Cicero’s life: Cicerone nel « secolo brève » . Impressed by the political violence that marked Cicero’s century, Narducci borrowed from E. Hobsbawm the temporal concept of the « short century », transposing it to the first century B.C.. In both of these cases, the spirit of the century is that of war, violence and proscription. By drawing this ingenious parallel, Narducci suggested a new way to consider the reception of Cicero’s works. In this article we shall be looking at the parallel from the opposite side and examining the reception of Cicero’s works in the « century of extremes ».
Abstract
The title of this article is not only a direct allusion to the famous work by Eric J. Hobsbawm , The Age of Extremes : The Short Twentieth Century, published in 1994, but the article itself is also an evocation of the work of the late Emanuele Narducci who, in a short essay published in 2001, proposed an interesting way of looking at Cicero’s life: Cicerone nel « secolo brève » . Impressed by the political violence that marked Cicero’s century, Narducci borrowed from E. Hobsbawm the temporal concept of the « short century », transposing it to the first century B.C.. In both of these cases, the spirit of the century is that of war, violence and proscription. By drawing this ingenious parallel, Narducci suggested a new way to consider the reception of Cicero’s works. In this article we shall be looking at the parallel from the opposite side and examining the reception of Cicero’s works in the « century of extremes ».
참고문헌 (202)
- HOBSBAWM, Eric J., "The Age of Extremes: The Short Twentieth Century, 1914-1991", 640~ (1994)
- NARDUCCI, Emanuele, "Cicerone nel secolo breve", Cicerone prospettiva 2000, Atti del I Symposium Ciceronianum Arpinas, pp.3~15 (2001)
- MIDDLETON, Conyers, "The History of the life of Marcus Tullius Cicero", ~ (1910)
- ROLFE, John C., "Cicero and His Influence", pp.8~ (1923), Marshall Jones
- CANFORA, "Uomini come Cicerone, cosi trasparenti", ~
- Mario Emilio, "Petrarch’s Letters to Classical Authors", pp.6~ (1910), Chicago University Press
- Barthold Georg, "Romische Geschichte", 25~ (1844)
- Charles Secondat, "Discours sur Ciceron (ca 1709) in: OEuvres Completes", pp.34~ (1964), Seuil
- BOLGAR, R. R., "Classical Elements in the Social, Political, Educational Thoughts of Thomas and Matthew Arnold ., Classical Influences on Western Thought AD 1650-1870", pp.337~338 (1979), Cambridge Univ. Press
- MIDDLETON, "MONTESQUIEU, op.cit., Mes pensees (1720-1755)", 975~
- GRANT, Michael, "Cicero, Selected Works", pp.31~ (1960), Penguin classics
- FERRERO, G., "Greatness and Decline of Rome", 189~ (1909)
- FORSYTH, William, "The Life of Marcus Tullius Cicero", pp.115~ (1865), Charles Scribner
- Cleaveland, H. R., "Cicero", North American Review, 46, pp.51~ (1838)
- VOLTAIRE, "Examen de Milord Brolingbroke (1736) in: Melanges", 1058~
- ELVIRA, A. Ruiz de, "Memoria sobre Concepto, Fuentes y Metodo de la disciplina, parte leida ex professo", ~ (1955)
- BOYANCÉ, Pierre, "Les portraits de Ciceron", L’information Litteraire, 10, pp.21~28 (1958)
- LAMARTINE, Alphonse, "Les confidences", ~ (1849)
- FOX, Matthew, "Cicero's Philosophy of History", pp.285~ (2007), Harvard
- ROSNER, Mary, "Reflections on Cicero in Nineteenth-Century England and America", Rhetorica, 4(2), pp.153~182 (1986)
- LEO, Friedrich, "Miscella ciceroniana, Index scholarum Gottingae,", Ausgewahlte kleine Schriften, 1, pp.325~ (1960)
- SIHLER, Ernest, "A political and literary biography, being a contribution to the history of ancient civilization and a guide to the study of Cicero’s writings" (1914), Yale University press
- DRUMANN, Wilhelm Karl, "Geschichte Roms in seinem Ubergange von der republikanischen zur monarchischen Verfassung", Konisberg, 6 (1844)
- WILAMOWITZ-MOELLENDORFF, "History Of Classical Scholarship", pp.189~ (1921), The Johns Hopkins University Press
- MOMMSEN, Theodor, "Histoire Romaine", Robert Laffont, 2 (1985)
- LEVY, Carlos, "Ecole Francaise de Rome", 60~74 (1992)
- BUCHNER, Karl, "Cicero Grunzuge seines Wesens", Studien zur romischen Literatur, 2, pp.1~24 (1962)
- GOERLER, Woldemar, "Untersuchungen zu Ciceros Philosophie", pp.1~19 (1974), Carl Winter
- BOYANCÉ, Pierre, "Etudes sur l’humanisme ciceronien", Coll. Latomus, 121, pp.201~204 (1937)
- BRUWAENE, Martin van, "La theologie de Ciceron" (1937), Louvain
- DOUGLAS, Alan Edward, "Cicero, Greece & Rome : New Surveys in the Classics" (1968), Oxford
- HIRZEL, Rudolf, "Untersuchungen zu Cicero’s philosophischen Schriften" (1877), Leipzig
- THIAUCOURT, Camille, "Essai sur les traites philosophiques de Ciceron et leurs sources grecques", ~ (1885)
- SHOPENHAUER, Arthu, "L’Art d’avoir toujours raison, La dialectique eristique", Mille et un Nuits, ~ (1983)
- THUROT, Charles, "Etudes sur Aristote, politique, dialectique, rhetorique", 272~273 (1860)
- De Quincey, Thomas, "Cicero" (1842), Blackwood's
- FERRARA, Oreste, "Ciceron y Mirabeau : la moral de dos grandes oradores" (1949), La Nave
- BLOCH-CARCOPINO, "La Republique romaine de 133 a 44 av", pp.480~484 (1933), Presses universitaires de France
- GRIMAL, Pierre, "Jerome Carcopino, un historien au service de l’humanisme", pp.251~272 (1981), les Belles Lettres
- CARCOPINO, Jerome, "Les secrets de la correspondance de Ciceron" (1948), L'artisan du Livre
- PIGANIOL, Andre, "Un ennemi de Ciceron", Revue historique, 201, pp.59~78 (1949)
- CARCOPINO, J., "Un ami de la verite", Revue Historique, 202, pp.59~ (1949)
- BOYANCÉ, Pierre, "Ciceron contre Ciceron ?", Revue des Etudes anciennes, 19~ (1949)
- ALAIN, "Abreges pour les aveugles, Portraits et doctrines de philosophes anciens", pp.27~ (1943), Paul Hartman
- GAUTIER, A.F., "Ciceron et son siecle" (1842), Hachette
- Bernard Rudolf, "An account of the life and letters of Cicero" (1854), Longman
- TROLLOPE Anthony, "The Life of Cicero", ~ (1881)
- DAVIDSON, "Cicero and the Fall of the Roman Republic", ~ (1894)
- SABBADINI, Remigio, "Storia del ciceronianismo e di altre questione litterarie" (1886), Loescher
- ALY, Cicero, "Sein Leben und seine Schriften", ~ (1891)
- WEISSENFELS, "Cicero als Schulschriftsteller" (1892), Leipzig
- STRACHAN-DAVIDSON, "Cicero and the Fall of the Roman Republic", ~ (1894)
- ZIELINSKI, Taddeus, "Cicero im Wandel der Jahrhunderte" (1897), Leipzig
- HUBNER, Cicero, "Deutsche Rundschau for April", ~ (1899)
- SIHLER, Ernest, "A political and literary biography, being a contribution to the history of ancient civilization and a guide to the study of Cicero’s writings", pp.487~ (1914), Yale University press
- TAYLOR, Hannis, "Cicero: A Sketch of His Life and Works" (1916), A.C. McClurg
- PETERSSON, Torsten, "Cicero, a biography", pp.704~ (1920), University of California press
- ROLFE, John C., "Cicero and His Influence", ~ (1923)
- HELM, R, "Cicero, Rostock", Warkentiens, ~ (1922)
- DELAYEN, "Sous les Masques antiques" (1929), Marcelle Lesage
- PLASBERG, Otto, "Cicero in seinen werken und briefen" (1926), Leipzig
- EULENBERG, Herbert, "Ciceron", Payot, 254~ (1935)
- ARNALDI, Francesco, "Cicerone, Bari", Laterza, 193 (1929)
- FRANK, Tenney, "Cicero" (1932), Humphrey Milford
- LAURAND, Louis, "Ciceron" (1933), Belles lettres
- MAFFII, Maffio, "Cicerone e il suo dramma politico", pp.444~ (1933), Mondadori
- RICHARDS, G.C., "Cicero, A study", pp.208~ (1935), Chatto and Windus
- CIACERI, Emanuele, "Cicerone e i suoi tempi", Societa anonima editrice Dante Alighieri, 2 (1941)
- GELZER, Matthias, "Pauly's Real-Encyclopadie der Classischen Altertumswissenschaft", ~ (1939)
- "biographies of Forsyth", Helm, ~ (1922)
- LAURAND, Louis, "Ciceron est interessant", pp.69~ (1929), Les belles lettres
- MARROU, Henri-Irenee, "Defense de Ciceron", pp.52~73 (1936), Revue historique
- BOYANCÉ, Pierre, "Les methodes de l’histoire litteraire : Ciceron et son oeuvre philosophique", Revue des Etudes Latines, 14, pp.288~289 (1936)
- Selon LÉVY, "cet article constate le deces de la Quellenforschung", 109~ (1996)
- ALLEN, Walter, Jr, "Legendus est Cicero", The Classical Journal, 44(4), pp.260~263 (1949)
- BOISSIER, Gaston, "Ciceron et ses amis : etude sur la societe romaine du temps de Cesar" (1865), Hachette
- TREVES, P., "Ciceronianismo et Anticiceronianismo nella cultura italiana des sec", Rendiconti dell’Istituto Lombardo, 92, pp.403~464 (1958)
- ROSNER, Mary, "Reflections on Cicero in Nineteenth-Century England and America", Rhetorica, 4(2), pp.153~182 (1986)
- WILAMOWITZ-MOELLENDORFF, , 155~ (1921)
- BOISSIER, G., "Sur l’Histoire romaine de Mommsen", Revue des Deux Mondes, 13, pp.804~ (1872)
- STRACHAN-DAVIDSON, "Cicero and the Fall of the Roman Republic", ~ (1894)
- ZIELINSKI, Taddeus, "Cicero im Wandel der Jahrhunderte" (1897), Leipzig
- MICHEL Alain, "Y a t-il aujourd’hui une actualite de Ciceron" (1984), Les Belles Lettres
- MEILLET, "Esquisse d'une histoire de la langue latine", pp.207~208 (1928), Klincksieck
- D'OOGE, Benjamin L., , The Classical Journal, 2(6), pp.241~249 (1907)
- PIGANIOL A., "La conquete romaine", pp.382~387 (1927), Alcan
- FROUDE, James Anthony, "Caesar: A Sketch", pp.420~421 (1903), The Perkins Book Co.
- JACKSON, "Tullius Cicero of Rome and Tusculum", Journal of the Michigan Schoolmasters Club, pp.85~91 (1932)
- FERRERO, Guglielmo, "The Greatness and Decline of Rome", 228~ (1909)
- MARCHESI, Concetto, "Storia della letteratura latina" (1927), Principato
- YAVETZ, Z., "Cicero: A Man of Letters in Politics", pp.173~180 (2002), Oxford University Press
- DE JOUVENEL, Bertrand, "Theorie politique pure ., Revue francaise de science politique", 369~370 (1961)
- NARDUCCI, Emanuele, "Cicerone e i suoi interpreti", Studi sull'opera e la fortuna, ~ (2004)
- FLAUBERT, Gustave, "Lettre a sa niece Caroline, du 9 decembre 1876, citee par MATZNEFF, Gabriel", Maitres et complices, pp.220~ (1994)
- BLOY, Leon, "Belluaires et Porchers, Oeuvres completes", Mercure de France, 245~ (1954)
- FUNCK-BRENTANO, "L'affaire du collier", pp.310~ (1903), Hachette
- HUYSMANS, J.K., "A rebours", pp.38~ (1884), Charpentier
- FRANCE, Anatole, "Vie de Jeanne d'Arc", 129~ (1908)
- GOUMY, Edouard, "Les Latins : Plaute et Terence, Ciceron, Lucrece, Catulle, Cesar, Salluste, Virgile, Horace, Paris, Hachette", 110~ (1892)
- BALZAC, Honore, "Illusions perdues", ~ (1837)
- ROSNER, Mary, "Reflections on Cicero in Nineteenth-Century England and America", Rhetorica, 4(2), pp.153~182 (1986)
- ALAIN, Esquisses de l’homme, "Recueil de textes ecrits entre 1928 et 1936", pp.288~ (1938), Gallimard
- NARDUCCI, E., "A complete study of Gabba" (2003), La Galina Cicerone
- DUMAS, "Catilina" (1848), Levy Freres
- ORS, Alvaro d, "Defensa del poeta Arquias, anotada por Alvaro D'Ors", ~ (1970)
- BARTHES, Roland, "L’ancienne rhetorique in: L’aventure semiologique", pp.98~ (1985), Seuil
- BAUDELAIRE, Charles, "Oeuvres completes, oeuvres pothumes", Conard, 1, pp.233~ (1934)
- JANIN, Jules, "preface de DESCHAMPS" (1863), Essai bibliographique sur M.T. Ciceron
- Regardin Gambetta, "plaidoyers politiques" (1885), Charpentier
- ROUJOUN, H., "Discours de reception a l’Academie francaise", CXII, 168~169 (1912)
- BARTHÉLÉMY-MADAULE, "Bergson educateur", pp.9~ (1967), Madeleine
- BATAILLE, Michel, "Demain Jaures", 37~ (1977)
- LAURAND, L., "Ciceron : Questions diverses", 403~ (1935)
- ZÉVAÈS, Alexandre, "Un apotre du rapprochement franco-allemand", pp.41~ (1941), Jean Jaures
- TÉRY, Gustave, "Jaures, OEuvres", 269~ (1915)
- GUILLEMIN, Henri, "L'arriere-pensee de Jaures", 193~ (1966)
- BREDIN, Jean-Denis, "Convaincre. Dialogue sur l'eloquence", Odile Jacob, 31~ (2002)
- PROCHASSON, Christophe, "Sur l'environnement intellectuel de Georges Sorel : l'Ecole des hautes etudes sociales (1899-1911)", Cahiers Georges Sorel, 3(3), pp.28~ (1985)
- DRUMONT, Edouard, "La France juive : essai d'histoire contemporaine", ~ (1886)
- DRUMONT, "Les Juifs contre la France, Une nouvelle Pologne", Librairie antisemite, 21~
- CLADIS, Mark S., "A Communitarian Defense of Liberalism: Emile Durkheim and Contemporary Social theory", Stanford UP, 35~ (1992)
- "Cedant arma togae ., parue dans Psst… !" (1898)[URL]
- BARRÈS, Maurice, "OEuvres", 326~ (1965)
- BRASILLACH, Robert, "OEuvres completes" (1965), Club de l'honnete homme
- SHACKLETON-BAILEY, D.R., "Letters to Atticus: Books 1-2", pp.74~ (2004), Cambridge University Press
- MOMIGLIANO, Arnaldo, "Quarto contributo alla storia degli studi classici e del mondo antico", Storia e letterature, 115, pp.46~ (1969)
- ARON, Robert, "The Vichy Regime 1940-44 in Collaboration with Georgette Elgey", pp.277~278 (1944), The Macmillan Company
- CORCY-DEBRAY, Stephanie, "Jerome Carcopino et les lois d’exception", Revue d'histoire moderne et contemporaine, 91~100 (2002)
- CORCY-DEBRAY, Stephanie, "du triomphe a la roche Tarpeienne", Vingtieme Siecle, 58, pp.70~82 (1998)
- SAINT-DENIS, Eugene, "Essais sur le rire et le sourire des Latins", pp.304~ (1965), les Belles lettres
- ANDREAU, Jean, "Texte, politique, ideologie : Ciceron", Annales. Economies, Societes, Civilisations, 34(6), pp.1248~1252 (1979)
- DELAYEN, "Sous les Masques antiques" (1929), Marcelle Lesage
- HUGO, Victor, "OEuvre poetique", Bibliotheque de la Pleiade, pp.110~111 (1974)
- VIPPER, R.J., "les guerres civiles a Rome, in Le tourbillon de l’histoire", Moscou- Berlin, ~ (1923)
- RASKOLNIKOFF, Mouza, "Recherches sovietiques sur l’histoire economique et sociale de Rome ., Des anciens et des modernes" (1990), de la Sorbonne
- Marinus Antony, "historian in exile: Russian roots in an American context", pp.43~ (1990), Franz Steiner
- ROSTOVTZEFF, Michael Ivanovich, "Mystic Italy", pp.16~ (2003), Kessinger Publishing
- SHAULL, Daphne, "Cicero and Modern Problems", The Classical Journal, 26(4), pp.266~272 (1931)
- ULLMAN Berthold L., "Cicero and Modern Politics", The Classical Journal, 30(7), pp.385~402 (1935)
- CARR, Albert, "Juggernaut: The Path of Dictatorship", pp.509~ (1939), The Vikings press
- Hansen, Harry, "Cicero was Chamberlain of his day", pp.24~ (1940), The Pittsburgh Press
- RICHARDS, G.C., "Cicero, A study", pp.208~ (1935), Chatto and Windus
- MARROU, H.I., "Tristesse de l’historien", Esprit, 79, pp.21~ (1939)
- HASKELL, Henry Joseph, "This was Cicero. Modern politics in a Roman toga", pp.406~ (1942), Knopf
- FRISCH, Hartvig, "Cicero's fight for the republic : the Historical Background of the Philippics", pp.311~ (1946), Kobenhavn
- SYME, Ronald sir, "Roman Revolution" (1939), The Clarendon Press
- GALSTERER, H., "A Man, A Book and a Method, Sir Ronald Syme's Roman Revolution after Fifty Years", pp.3~ (1990), University California Press
- WILKIN, Robert N., "Eternal Lawyer : A Legal Biography of Cicero", pp.99~ (1947), Macmillan Co.
- WEIL, "Oeuvres completes", Tome II, 3, pp.204~ (1989)
- GRIFFIN, Miriam Tamara, "A companion to Julius Caesar", pp.512~ (2009), John Wiley and Sons
- JÜNGER, Ernst, "German writings before and after 1945", pp.21~ (2002), Jurgen Peters
- NEVIN, Thomas, "Ernst Junger and Germany: Into the Abyss, 1914-1945", pp.99~ (1996), Duke University Press
- ZWEIG, Stephan, "The head upon The Rostrum, Cicero's Death, The tide of fortune : twelve historical miniatures" (1940), Viking Press
- Magniez, Michel, "Stefan Zweig face a Ciceron, ou la biographie comme miroir de soi", De l’ethos biographique, 3(3), pp.43~53 (2008)
- STROH, Wilfried, "Le Latin est mort, vive le latin ! Petite histoire d'une grande langue", Les Belles Lettres, ~ (2008)
- BLOK, Alexander, "Katilina" (1919), Alkonost
- GLATZER ROSENTHAL, B., "A revolution of the spirit: crisis of value in Russia, 1890-1924", pp.293~321 (1990), Fordham Univ Press
- KALB, Judith E., "Russia's Rome: imperial visions, messianic dreams, 1890-1940", pp.106~129 (2008), Univ of Wisconsin Press
- COUMEL, Laurent, "Les appuis rhetoriques du pouvoir sovietique", Hypotheses, 1, pp.261~271 (2002)
- MASHKIN, N.A., "Eschatology and Messianism in the Final Period of the Roman Republic", Philosophy and Phenomenological Research, 10(2), pp.206~228 (1949)
- GRAHAM, Hugh F., "The Significant Role of the Study of Ancient History in the Soviet Union", The Classical World, 61(3), pp.85~97 (1967)
- Maffii, "Ciceron y su drama politico", Esclanes, 12~ (1942)
- LAROUSSE, Pierre, "Grand Dictionnaire universel du XIXe siecle", 251~ (1867)
- VEYNE, Paul, "L’inventaire des differences, Lecon inaugurale au College de France", pp.12~ (1976), Seuil
- MICHEL Alain, "Y a t-il aujourd’hui une actualite de Ciceron", Presence de Ciceron, 298~ (1984)
- Finley, Moses I., "Mythe, memoire, histoire", Flammarion, 152~ (1981)
- COMMITTEE OF CLASSICAL STUDIES, "Acta sessionis Ciceronianae diebus 3-5 m", Varsoviae, ~ (1960)
- KUMANIECKI, Kazimierz, "Twenty Years of Classical Philology in Poland (1945-1965)", Greece & Rome, 14(1), pp.61~75 (1967)
- CICERONIANA, "Atti dell’XII colloquium Tullianum (Salamanca)", ~ (2004)
- AROLDI, Edmondo, "Intervista a Giulio Andreotti", La lettura, ~ (1977)
- ANDREOTTI, G., "The USA Up Close: From the Atlantic Pact to Bush" (1993), New York University
- LINTOTT, A. W., "Review : Cicero: A Political Biography by David Stockton", The Classical Review, 24(1), pp.66~68 (1974)
- GRIMAL, Pierre, "Ciceron", pp.480~ (1986), Fayard
- MARROU, H.I., "Tristesse de l'historien", Esprit, 7, pp.11~47 (1939)
- ROSNER, Mary, "Reflections on Cicero in Nineteenth-Century England and America", Rhetorica, 4(2), pp.153~182 (1986)
- BIGORRA, Sebastian Mariner, "Ciceron, orador : una autocritiqua y una revision", Fundacion Pastor, 3, pp.123~124 (1961)
- VEYNE, Paul, "Le Pain et le cirque. Sociologie historique d'un pluralisme politique" (1976), Seuil
- Luciano, Cesar, "le dictateur democrate", pp.304~ (2001), Flammarion
- WISEMAN, T. P., "Remembering the Roman People, Essays on Late-Republican Politics and Literature", pp.3~ (2009), Oxford U. Press
- GOTOFF, Harold C., "Cicero’s caesarian speeches", U. North Carolina Press
- LINTOTT, Andrew, "Cicero as Evidence, A Historian's Companion", pp.3~ (2008), Oxford U. press
- DAVID, Jean-Michel, "Le patronat judiciaire au dernier siecle de la Republique romaine", BEFAR, 277 (1992)
- Levy, C, "As noted by FOX", 3~
- HANSON, Victor Davis, "Who Killed Homer?: The Demise of Classical Education and the Recovery of Greek Wisdom", Philosophy and Literature, 22(2), pp.516~518 (1998)
- MULLER, Philippe, "Ciceron, un philosophe pour notre temps", L'Age d'Homme, ~ (1990)
- CALDWELL, Taylor, "A Pillar of Iron" (1965), Doubleday & Company
- CALDWELL, T., "American Opinion", 71~72 (1965)
- EVERITT, Anthony, "Cicero: A Turbulent Life", pp.346~ (2001), John Murray
- BEARD, Mary, "Lucky City", London Review of Books, 23(16) (2001)
- BRENNAN, T. Corey, "Ancient Evenings", New York Times (2002)
- GREENFIELD, Jeff, "Low roads lead to Rome", Washington Monthly, 34(6), pp.48~ (2002)
- SIMMONS, Tracy Lee, "Man and monument", National Review, 54(20), pp.49~ (2002)
- HARRIS, Robert, "Imperium", Hutchinson, 305~ (2006)
- SHACKLETON BAILEY, D.R., "Cicero, Philippics", Loeb Classical Library, 189, pp.400~ (2010)
- LEPORE, Ettore, "Il princeps ciceroniano e gli ideali politici della tarda repubblica", ~ (1954)
- RAWSON, E., "Lucius Crassus and Cicero: the formation of a statesman", Proceedings of the Cambridge Philological Society, 통권 : 17, pp.75~ (1971)
- SMETHURST, S. E., "Cicero and Roman imperial Policy", Transactions of the American Philological Association, 84, pp.73~ (1953)
- BENARIO, Herbert W., "Cicero. Reipublicae amantissimus", The Classical Journal, 69(1), pp.12~20 (1973)
- STOCKTON, D., "Cicero, a political biography", pp.166~ (1970), Oxford
- SCHAIVONE, Aldo, "La storia spezzata Roma antica e Occidente moderno", Roma- Bari, ~ (2003)
- BOWERSOCK, G. W., "From Gibbon to Auden, Essays on the Classical Tradition", pp.135~ (2009), Oxford University Press
