본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

동아시아공동체에 대한 일본과 중국의 시각과 이해: 민간의 논의를 중심으로

Japanese and Chinese Views on the East Asian Community

이한우
한국동남아학회|2007.08|동남아시아연구 (The Southeast Asian Review)|제17권 제2호|pp. 65-100|DOI 10.21652/kaseas.17.2.200708.65

0

조회

0

다운로드

10

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

일본중국JapanChinaASEANEast Asian Community지역통합regional integrationEast Asia Summit동아시아공동체동아시아정상회의
주제분류지역학

초록

This paper aims to explore and analyze various Japanese and Chinese views on the East Asian Community and regional integration in a comparative perspective. When the first East Asia Sumit was held in Kuala Lumpur on December 2005, someone viewed it a big step to a community building in East Asia, while someone understood it a clearing bubles. On the way to the Summit it was acelerated by the competition betwen Japan and China to get an initiative in the comunity building in the region.There have ben various perspectives on the regional community building in Japan, spanning from positive ones to negative ones, while almost unanimous views have existed in China. On the comunity building, Japanese have been on the realist or liberal views, while Chinese tend to be based on the social constructivism as well as realism, as China is offensive to change the status quo and Japan is defensive to kep it in East Asia. To build the community, almost Japanese tend to focus on the functional approach through economic integration into a community, while many Chinese argue to build the integral economic entity and multilateral security institution simultaneously and then integrate them into one regional community. In Japanese and Chinese views, the nature of the East Asian Community is still formalizing rather than embodied.

Abstract

This paper aims to explore and analyze various Japanese and Chinese views on the East Asian Community and regional integration in a comparative perspective. When the first East Asia Sumit was held in Kuala Lumpur on December 2005, someone viewed it a big step to a community building in East Asia, while someone understood it a clearing bubles. On the way to the Summit it was acelerated by the competition betwen Japan and China to get an initiative in the comunity building in the region.There have ben various perspectives on the regional community building in Japan, spanning from positive ones to negative ones, while almost unanimous views have existed in China. On the comunity building, Japanese have been on the realist or liberal views, while Chinese tend to be based on the social constructivism as well as realism, as China is offensive to change the status quo and Japan is defensive to kep it in East Asia. To build the community, almost Japanese tend to focus on the functional approach through economic integration into a community, while many Chinese argue to build the integral economic entity and multilateral security institution simultaneously and then integrate them into one regional community. In Japanese and Chinese views, the nature of the East Asian Community is still formalizing rather than embodied.

참고문헌 (90)

  1. "동아시아 지역주의와 일본 대외경제정책의 딜레마", 11, pp.4~ (2005)
  2. "일본의 동아시아 지역주의전략 :ASEAN+3 EAS 그리고 동아시아 공동체", 13, pp.1~ (2007)
  3. "중국의 동아시아 정책", 9, pp.4~ (2003)
  4. "일본의 동아시아 지역주의 정책: 동아시아공동체(East Asian Community)를 중심으로", 1, pp.4~ (2006)
  5. "동아시아 공동체" (2007), 서울: 울력
  6. "동아시아의 새로운 모색" (2006), 서울: 이매진
  7. "동아시아 공동체의 발전과정: ASEAN+3 협력체제를 중심으로" (2005)
  8. "동아시아 공동체 비전과 전망" (2005), 서울: 한양대학교 출판부
  9. "동아시아 공동체에 대한 이론적 검토" (2005)
  10. "Multilateralism in China's ASEAN Policy: Its Evolution, Characteristics, and Aspiration", 27, pp.1~ (2005)
  11. "Southeast Asia and China: Balancing or Bandwagoning?", 27, pp.2~ (2005)
  12. "The Nature of East Asian Regionalism: A Chinese Perspective" (2005), Trend and Response. Beijing: World Affairs Press
  13. "Japan, ASEAN, and the Construction of an East Asian Community", 28, pp.2~ (2006)
  14. "The Rise of China and Community Building in East Asia" (2006), Seoul: KINU
  15. "Emerging New East Asian Regionalism", 12, pp.1~ (2005)
  16. "安全保障からみた東アジア共同體の可能性" (2006)
  17. "？|ⅱⅨⅱ？？菱ㅞ漣撈돨？y북ㆂ" (2006)
  18. "域內不戰｣の共同體を-東アジア市民連帶の法文化形成" (2006)
  19. "？？？A？W？A？？？？？？-？S？Z？？？？？？？？？？？？？？？？？{" (2004), ？？？？: ？？？g？？？X
  20. "？？？@？I？A？W？A？O？？？？？？？？？？？？？？？？？？？？" (2006)
  21. "各썹ㅞㅚㄻㅞ？|ⅱⅨⅱ" (2006), ？|쑴: ？c？ちx賠댕？W？|ⅱⅨⅱ？x씩杰
  22. "？n？？ ？？？？？？？？？？？A？W？A", (538) (2005)
  23. "？？？A？W？A？？？？？？:？？？？？？？`？？？？？？" (2005)
  24. "？？？A？W？A？？？？？？？？？{？？？？？K？v？？？？？？" (2006), ？？？？ ？k？？？？
  25. "東アジアの地域經濟協力と中國の戰略" (2006)
  26. "六カ國協議ワク組みとASEANとの連携可能性" (2006)
  27. "？？？z？？？？？？？？？？？？？？？？？n？？？{"
  28. "東アジア共同體｣の危うさ" (2006), 東京: 勁草書房
  29. "パクスㆍシニカ｣にアジアが屈する日" (2006)
  30. "？A？W？A？？？？？？？？？？？{？？？？？？？？？O？？？Q？[？？" (2004)
  31. "東アジアに｢共同體｣はできるか" (2006), 東京 社會評論社
  32. "？？？A？W？A？？？？？？？？？？？？" (2006), ？？？？ ？？？？？？？{？o？？？？
  33. "東アジア共同體構想の背景と課題" (2006)
  34. "東アジア共同體と中國の地域外交" (2005), 東京:早稻田大學出版部
  35. "？？？A？W？A？？？？？？？？？？？？", (551) (2006)
  36. "東アジア共同體の構築は可能か-日米同盟との兩立を探る" (2006)
  37. "共に步み共に進む｣眞の地域主義の設立" (2005)
  38. "東アジア共同體の構築と日本の戰略" (2006)
  39. "東アジア共同體の構築" (2006), 東京: ミナルヴァ書房
  40. "日本外交から見た東アジア" (2006)
  41. "？|ⅱⅨⅱ묾谿？w-퓻댕뺏ㅉㅻ櫓？捌훑欄쑈？？措？" (2005), ？|쑴 휑굶？？？革u？？？？
  42. "東アジア共同體論議にどう關わるか" (2007)
  43. "東アジア共同體｣構想の行方と中國外交", (123) (2005)
  44. "？A？W？A？n？？？？？？？？？？？鉉？？W", (540) (2005)
  45. "和解-日本外交の課題<上> <下>" (2006)
  46. "東アジア共同體と日本の針路" (2005), 東京 NHK出版
  47. "21？？？I？？？{？O？？？？？D？？？I？？？？" (2005)
  48. "東アジア｣という新地域形成の試み - ASEAN+3の展開" (2003), 東京大學出版會
  49. "？|ⅱⅨⅱ묾谿？w？？拳ㅘ휑굶", 52(3) (2006)
  50. "？？？A？W？A？逡I？？？k？？？？？？？？？？？飜？？W", 54(4) (2006)
  51. "？？？？？？？？ASEAN？？？W？？？A？？？？？J", (559) (2007)
  52. "東アジア共同體の可能性-日中關係の再檢討" (2006), 東京: 御茶の水書房
  53. "？？？A？W？A<？？？？>？？？？？？" (2006), 嫌？？: ？？？D？？？[
  54. "？？？A？W？A？？？？？？？？？？？？？m？？？n？o" (2003), ？？？？？？？{？o？？？？
  55. "？？？A？W？A？？？？？？？？？？？？？？？z" (2006), ？？？s ？i？J？j？V？？？o？？
  56. "？？？A？W？A？？？？？？？？？？？？？？？？？？？？" (2007), ？？？？ ？}？？？？？[
  57. "東アジア共同體を設計する" (2006), 東京 日本經濟評論社
  58. "中國ㆍアジアㆍ日本-大國化する｢巨龍｣は威脅か" (2006), 東京 筑摩書房
  59. "東アジア共同體の可能性-日本外交の視點から" (2006)
  60. "？？？？？？？？？？？絅？？？？？？？？w？？？？" (2005)
  61. "？？？A？W？A？？？？？？？？？？？？？I？？？？" (2005)
  62. "？？？A？W？A？？？？？？？\？z？？？？？？？？？？？" (2005)
  63. "東アジア共同體｣構築の隘路と進路" (2006)
  64. "？？？A？W？A？？？？？？？？？？？z？？？？？？？？" (2005)
  65. "？A？W？A？n？？？？？？？？ASEAN？？？？？D" (2005), ？？？？:？？？？？？？X
  66. "？？？A？W？A？？？？？？？？ASEAN" (2006)
  67. "亞洲發展與區域合作的互動", 3 (2006)
  68. "多邊主義與東亞合作" (2006), 北京: 當代世界出版社
  69. "中國的地區戰略", (6) (2004)
  70. "？？？？？@？㏛o？？？？？I？D？？？I？？", (2) (2001)
  71. "？？？？？a？？？？？N？I？？？？？D？？？y？？", (6) (2004)
  72. "？\？？？？？？？？？D？？？I？y？？" (2005), ？k？？: ？k？？？？？{？o？？？？
  73. "櫓？便？？？碌？措？-？`삶돨뜩？？寮？x", (10) (2001)
  74. "뒈？^뺏, 뒈？^昑？c뒈？^寮？x-？？？|？？뒈？^寮？x", (11) (2003)
  75. "亞洲區域合作路線圖" (2006), 北京: 時事出版社
  76. "東亞安全合作" (2004), 北京: 北京大學出版社
  77. "亞洲區域化: 從理性主義走向社會建構主義", (5) (2003)
  78. "？？？？？n？？？？？`？I？？？\？？？`？阻？", (12) (2005)
  79. "關于建立東亞安全共同體的戰略設想", (7) (2004)
  80. "東亞共同體問題初探", (2) (2007)
  81. "地區認同與東亞地區主義", (5) (2004)
  82. "新東亞區域主義的興起", 3 (2006)
  83. "安全共同體理論和東盟的實踐", (5) (2004)
  84. "？|？？묾谿？w’毒쒼돨？？뼙昑驕？？", (4) (2007)
  85. "？？？？？I？？？？？？？C？o？n？？？？？`？D？？", (1) (2003)
  86. "？？？？？？？？？？,-？v？？？\？？？？？Z", (10) (2004)
  87. "櫓？？？？？|촉漣꿉？x씩？窄？", (10) (2004)
  88. "中國:東亞一體化新戰略" (2005), 杭州: 浙江人民出版社
  89. "대외경제정책연구원 동서남아팀장, 전화 인터뷰" (2007)
  90. "경상대학교 정치행정학부 교수, 전화 인터뷰" (2007), 교수

관련 논문AI추천

East Asian Way to a Community Building: Beyond the Barrier of Theoretical Perception이동윤, 이재현한국세계지역학회 · 세계지역연구논총2010 · 제28권 제2호일본의 동아시아 공동체 구상과 지역 인식 ─아시아에 대한 인식의 변화─최운도일본연구소 · 일본연구2012 · 제51호아세안공동체와 동아시아공동체박사명한국동남아학회 · 동남아시아연구2014 · 제24권 제3호일본의 동아시아 지역공동체 構想 - 대동아공영권과 동아시아 공동체 비교를 중심으로 -조정원동북아시아문화학회 · 동북아 문화연구2009 · 제1권 제20호동북아경제공동체: 쟁점과 주요국 시각박제훈한국비교경제학회 · 비교경제연구2004 · 제11권 제2호Regional Institution and Institutional Balancing: The Case of the East Asian Summit유현석신아시아연구소 · 신아세아2010 · 제17권 제2호

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (6건)

시장에서 광장으로: 동아시아의 발전주의적 경쟁을 넘어서박사명pp. 1-31마하티르와 김대중의 동아시아지역협력 구상 비교 연구이재현pp. 33-64동남아의 참여적 지역주의와 ‘동아시아공동체’전제성pp. 101-130최근 필리핀의 선거정치와 사회적 변화: 변화와 지속성의 혼재박승우pp. 131-172타이 남부문제와 시민사회의 대응: 인권의 관점박은홍pp. 173-205
원문 보기