瞻星臺 축조 의의 一考察: 동양의 禮制 문화 및 古典에서의 관련 기록 분석을 통해
A Study on the Significance of the Construction of Cheomseongdae(瞻星臺): Through the Analysis into the Oriental Lǐ(禮) Culture and Relevant Records in the Classics
0
조회
0
다운로드
3
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
There has been a controversy for a long time over whether Cheomseongdae(瞻星臺, Zhānxīngtái) in Gyeongju built in Silla(新羅) Dynasty was an observatory or not. In this paper, the purpose and significance of Cheomseongdae were examined through its aspect of lǐ(禮 : ruling, diplomatic and military norms expressed in ritual acts in oriental traditions) culture to realize Confucian wángdào(王道 : politics based on benevolence and virtues, and the political ideology regarded as ideal by Confucianism) and, in addition, through examples in the classics and ideographic aspect. The name, Cheomseong(瞻星), meaning 'looking at stars', is basically a part of divination to determine or judge a serious matter of a nation, and discussed in the concept of astrology. Cheomseongdae(瞻星臺) in Pyeongyang was the internal and external manifestation of self-esteem as a nation reigned over by a king as a ruller of majestic shèng(聖 : a supreme ruller with both wisdom and virtues), not as a nation of a lower rank serving cháo-jìn-lǐ(朝․覲禮 : a political and diplomatic ritual practiced in the hierarchical relationship of a king and a vassal) as a weak nation to a powerful nation. Based on which, the era of its construction seems to be able to be estimated. On the other hand, Cheomseongdae in Gyeongju is judged to have been built by the first queen of Silla, Queen Seondeok, as a tool for her to tangibly show her dignity as a queen to her political rivals. In addition, grounded on the fact that there was little chance of Silla producing a húntiānyí(渾天儀 : a precise apparatus measuring the movements and locations of the sun, the moon and five stars) by itself at that time, the following assumption has been made. Cheomseongdae in Gyeongju seems to have been an unfinished project to which a húntiānyí(渾天儀) model was installed on ‘the high, square-shaped head’(臺) ‘looking at stars’(瞻星), or to which it wasn't equipped yet. Accordingly, it can be said that Cheomseongdae in Gyeongju was built for the purpose of observing the sky(天), but actual observation of the sky wasn’t made with it, so it was ‘a kind of structure for display showing Queen Seondeok’s earnest wish who dreamed of strong sovereign power and omnipotence as a supreme ruller.
Abstract
There has been a controversy for a long time over whether Cheomseongdae(瞻星臺, Zhānxīngtái) in Gyeongju built in Silla(新羅) Dynasty was an observatory or not. In this paper, the purpose and significance of Cheomseongdae were examined through its aspect of lǐ(禮 : ruling, diplomatic and military norms expressed in ritual acts in oriental traditions) culture to realize Confucian wángdào(王道 : politics based on benevolence and virtues, and the political ideology regarded as ideal by Confucianism) and, in addition, through examples in the classics and ideographic aspect. The name, Cheomseong(瞻星), meaning 'looking at stars', is basically a part of divination to determine or judge a serious matter of a nation, and discussed in the concept of astrology. Cheomseongdae(瞻星臺) in Pyeongyang was the internal and external manifestation of self-esteem as a nation reigned over by a king as a ruller of majestic shèng(聖 : a supreme ruller with both wisdom and virtues), not as a nation of a lower rank serving cháo-jìn-lǐ(朝․覲禮 : a political and diplomatic ritual practiced in the hierarchical relationship of a king and a vassal) as a weak nation to a powerful nation. Based on which, the era of its construction seems to be able to be estimated. On the other hand, Cheomseongdae in Gyeongju is judged to have been built by the first queen of Silla, Queen Seondeok, as a tool for her to tangibly show her dignity as a queen to her political rivals. In addition, grounded on the fact that there was little chance of Silla producing a húntiānyí(渾天儀 : a precise apparatus measuring the movements and locations of the sun, the moon and five stars) by itself at that time, the following assumption has been made. Cheomseongdae in Gyeongju seems to have been an unfinished project to which a húntiānyí(渾天儀) model was installed on ‘the high, square-shaped head’(臺) ‘looking at stars’(瞻星), or to which it wasn't equipped yet. Accordingly, it can be said that Cheomseongdae in Gyeongju was built for the purpose of observing the sky(天), but actual observation of the sky wasn’t made with it, so it was ‘a kind of structure for display showing Queen Seondeok’s earnest wish who dreamed of strong sovereign power and omnipotence as a supreme ruller.
참고문헌 (44)
- 정연식, "첨성대의 기능과 형태에 관한 여러 학설 비판", 역사학보, (204), pp.357~403 (2009), 역사학회
- 서금석, "천문대로서의 첨성대 이설(異說)에 대한 재론(再論)", 한국고대사연구, (86), pp.149~194 (2017), 한국고대사학회[DOI]
- 이문규, "첨성대를 어떻게 볼 것인가 - 첨성대 해석의 역사와 신라시대의 천문관", 한국과학사학회지, 26(1), pp.3~28 (2004), 한국과학사학회
- 김일권, "첨성대의 靈臺적 독법과 신라 왕경의 三雍제도 관점", 신라사학보, (18), pp.5~31 (2010), 신라사학회
- "春秋左傳", ~ (1934)
- "焦氏易林 「頤之漸」 “藩屏燕齊, 周室以彊”", ~
- "韓策", ~
- "史記", ~
- "周禮注疏 卷41, 「冬官考工記 下」 <匠人建國>", ~
- 魏徵, "隋書 卷37, 「列傳 第2」 <李穆>", ~
- 王宏撰, "周易筮述 卷8, 「推騐 第15」", ~
- 杜光庭, "廣成集 卷10, 「莫庭乂九曜醮詞」", ~
- 서정화, "古代 中國의 28宿와 12次이론의 起源 ― 東洋 古典에 보이는 사례분석을 중심으로", 퇴계학논총, (20), pp.155~186 (2012), 사단법인 퇴계학부산연구원[DOI]
- "爾雅(戰國期~西漢) 「釋言」 “觀, 指, 示也.”", ~
- "說文解字 「見部」 “觀, 諦視也.”", ~
- "釋名(東漢) 「釋姿容」 “觀, 翰也, 望之延頸翰翰也.”", ~
- "世宗實錄", ~
- 酈道元, "水經注 卷14, 「濕餘水」", ~
- "晉書 「天文志 上」", ~
- "後漢書 「光武帝紀 下」", ~
- "東觀漢記 「紀", 世祖光武皇帝」
- 樂史, "太平寰宇記 卷10, 「河南道", 陳州」
- "欽定大淸一統志 卷170, 陳州府(在河南省治東南三百里‧‧)", ~
- "南頓"[URL]
- 서정화, "廟數 규정 제도의 始原에 대한 一考 ― 漢代와 戰國期의 廟數制 관련 논의를 중심으로", 대동문화연구, (102), pp.159~184 (2018), 대동문화연구원[DOI]
- "한국철학논집 57", ~
- "유교사상문화연구 72", ~
- 서정화, "주나라의 宮, 宗廟와 明堂" (2017), 한국학술정보
- "後漢書 「光武帝紀 上」", ~
- 정연식, "평양 첨성대의 서사구조와 연개소문의 탄생", 역사와 현실, (79), pp.231~269 (2011), 한국역사연구회
- "春秋穀梁傳", ~
- "漢書", ~
- "禮記", ~
- "孔子家語", ~
- 金容天, "??石渠禮論??의 分析과 前漢시대 禮治 理念", 동방학지, (137), pp.213~281 (2007), 국학연구원
- 金容天, "前漢 元帝期 韋玄成의 宗廟制論", 동양사학연구, (95), pp.1~38 (2006), 동양사학회
- 서정화, "周代의 明堂과 辟雍에 대한 小考", 동양철학연구, (87), pp.161~190 (2016), 동양철학연구회[DOI]
- 서정화, "『春秋』王曆① - 宋代 이후 春秋曆數의 改月⋅改時 논의에 대한 小考", 동양고전연구, (67), pp.345~378 (2017), 동양고전학회[DOI]
- 서정화, "『春秋』王曆② - 周代의 曆法 一考察", 동양철학, (47), pp.191~227 (2017), 한국동양철학회[DOI]
- 서정화, "『춘추』 왕력(王曆)③ - 주력(周曆)에서 하력(夏曆)으로, 그리고 공자의 “행하지시(行夏之時)”", 한국철학논집, (54), pp.153~184 (2017), 한국철학사연구회[DOI]
- "한국사DB"[URL]
- 장활식, "첨성대 옛 기록의 분석", 신라문화, (39), pp.117~158 (2012), 신라문화연구소
- "新增東國輿地勝覽 箋 卷21, 慶尙道", 慶州府 <古跡>
- 서정화, "漢代 이전에 형성된 天體曆 紀年 원리 고찰의 필요성에 대한 小論", 동양고전연구, (72), pp.365~400 (2018), 동양고전학회[DOI]
