본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

건강도시 평가의 원칙

Principles for Evaluating Healthy Cities

김진희
한국보건교육건강증진학회 (Korean Society for Health Education and Promotion)|2012.10|보건교육건강증진학회지 (KOREAN JOURNAL OF HEALTH EDUCATION AND PROMOTION)|제29권 제4호|pp. 67-81

2

조회

0

다운로드

11

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

Healthy cities evaluationParticipatory evaluationUtility-based evaluation
주제분류예방의학/직업환경의학

초록

Objectives: This article examines the diversity of healthy cities evaluation in practice and discusses the major conflicting issues in evaluating healthy cities to offer implications to academics and cities for application in their field. Methods: The author discusses issues on major topics that arose from a review of literature on selected articles from peer-reviewed journals, books and gray literature. The recently developed Korean Healthy Cities evaluation framework is used as a main source of reference. Results: Evaluating healthy cities is in itself a political process and requires multiple methodologies and diverse sources of data. Details of the evaluation process depend on the purposes and goals predetermined by the stakeholders. The Korean Healthy Cities evaluation framework applies these principles and suggests a participatory approach to evaluation, selection of indicators that provide evidence on the process of change and to use mixed evaluation methods. The involvement of stakeholders in the evaluation process can also be a useful tool to further strengthen partnerships and strategies for healthy cities. Conclusion: Cities need to engage more in evaluation activities and develop necessary skills and capacity to produce utility-driven evidence.

Abstract

Objectives: This article examines the diversity of healthy cities evaluation in practice and discusses the major conflicting issues in evaluating healthy cities to offer implications to academics and cities for application in their field. Methods: The author discusses issues on major topics that arose from a review of literature on selected articles from peer-reviewed journals, books and gray literature. The recently developed Korean Healthy Cities evaluation framework is used as a main source of reference. Results: Evaluating healthy cities is in itself a political process and requires multiple methodologies and diverse sources of data. Details of the evaluation process depend on the purposes and goals predetermined by the stakeholders. The Korean Healthy Cities evaluation framework applies these principles and suggests a participatory approach to evaluation, selection of indicators that provide evidence on the process of change and to use mixed evaluation methods. The involvement of stakeholders in the evaluation process can also be a useful tool to further strengthen partnerships and strategies for healthy cities. Conclusion: Cities need to engage more in evaluation activities and develop necessary skills and capacity to produce utility-driven evidence.

참고문헌 (75)

  1. Allegrante, J., "Domains of core competency, standards, and quality assurance for building global capacity in health promotion: The Galway Consensus Conference Statement", Health Education & Behavior, 36(3), pp.476~482 (2009)
  3. Araya, R., "Perceptions of social capital and the built environment and mental health", Social Science & Medicine, 62(12), pp.3072~3083 (2006)
  4. Aronson, R., "Achieving a "broad view of health": findings from the California healthy cities and communities evaluation", Health Education & Behavior, 34(3), pp.441~452 (2007)
  5. Ashton, J., "Healthy cities -- WHO's new public health initiative", Health Promotion International, 1(3), pp.319~324 (1986)
  6. Baum, F., "Researching public health: Behind the qualitative-quantitative methodological debate", Social Science & Medicine, 40(4), pp.459~468 (1995)
  7. Baum, F., "What makes for sustainable Healthy Cities initiatives? - a review of the evidence from Noarlunga, Australia after 18 years", Health Promotion International, 21(4), pp.259~265 (2006)
  8. Birckmayer, J., "Theory-Based Evaluation in practice: What do we learn?", Evaluation Review, 24(4), pp.407~431 (2000)
  9. Boonekamp, G., "Healthy Cities Evaluation: the co-ordinators perspective", Health Promotion International, 14(2), pp.103~110 (1999)
  10. Cho, B. H, "The sociology of disease and medicine" (2006), Jipmundang
  11. Costongs, C, "Towards a framework for the evaluation of health-related policies in cities", Evaluation, 3(3), pp.345~362 (1997)
  12. Curtice, L, "Chapter 14. Evaluation in urban settings: the challenge of Healthy Cities, In Evaluation in health promotion: Principles and perspectives" (2001), WHO Regional Publications
  13. Davies, J, "Healthy cities: research and practice" (1993), Routledge
  14. de Leeuw, E, "Global and local (glocal) health: the WHO healthy cities programme", Global Change and Human Health, 2(1), pp.34~45 (2001)
  15. de Leeuw, E, "Nurturing Healthy Cities", Healthy cities and urban policy research, 138 (2003)
  16. de Leeuw, E, "Evidence for Healthy Cities: reflections on practice, method and theory", Health Promotion International, 24(suppl_1), pp.i19~i36 (2009)
  17. de Leeuw, E, "Mixing urban health research methods for best fit", Journal of Urban Health, 87(1), pp.1~4 (2009)
  18. de Leeuw, E, "Do Healthy Cities work? A logic of method for assessing impact and outcome of Healthy Cities", Journal of Urban Health, 89(2), pp.217~231 (2012)
  19. de Leeuw, E, "Utility-driven evidence for healthy cities: problems with evidence generation and application", Social Science & Medicine, 61(6), pp.1331~1341 (2005)
  20. "The CompHP core competencies framework for health promotion handbook" (2011)[URL]
  21. Donchin, M., "Implementation of the Healthy Cities' principles and strategies: an evaluation of the Israel Healthy Cities Network", Health Promotion International, 21(4), pp.266~273 (2006)
  22. Dooris, M., "Healthy settings: challenges to generating evidence of effectiveness", Health Promotion International, 21(1), pp.55~65 (2006)
  23. Draper, R., "WHO Healthy Cities Project: review of the first five years (1987-1992): A working tool and reference framework for evaluating the project" (1993), WHO Regional Office for Europe
  24. Duhl, L., "Conditions for healthy cities; diversity, game boards and social entrepreneurs", Environment and Urbanization, 5(2), pp.112~124 (1993)
  25. Engelhardt, K, "Inventory of designation criteria for Healthy Cities", Paper presented at the Consultation Meeting for National Accreditation System for Healthy Cities (2012)
  26. Flynn, B., "Healthy Cities: The Indiana model of community development in public health", Health Education & Behavior, 18(3), pp.331~347 (1991)
  27. Fryer, P., "A healthy city strategy three years on--the case of Oxford City Council", Health Promotion International, 3(2), pp.213~217 (1988)
  28. Goumans, M., "What about healthy networks? An analysis of the national networks of healthy cities in Europe", Health Promotion International, 7(4), pp.273~281 (1992)
  29. Goumans, M, "Innovations in a fuzzy domain. Healthy Cities and (health) policy development in the Netherlands and the United Kingdom", 박사, pp.1998
  30. Goumans, M., "From projects to policy: 'healthy cities' as a mechanism for policy change for health?", Health Promotion International, 12(4), pp.311~322 (1997)
  31. Green, L, "Health promotion planning: an educational and ecological approach (3rd ed)" (1999), Mayfield Publishing Company
  32. Greene, J, "Qualitative program evaluation, In Handbook of qualitative research", pp.531~534 (1994), Sage Publications
  33. Hall, C., "Health in the urban environment: A qualitative review of the Brighton and Hove WHO Healthy City Program", Journal of Urban Health, 87(1), pp.8~28 (2009)
  34. Hancock, T., "The evolution, impact and significance of the healthy cities", healthy communities movement, 1993, pp.14(1), 5~18
  35. 정길호, "국내 건강도시 프로젝트 담당자를 대상으로 한 건강도시 관련 특성 조사", 농촌의학.지역보건, 34(2), pp.155~167 (2009), 한국농촌의학.지역보건학회
  36. Kegler, M., "Achieving organizational change: findings from case studies of 20 California healthy cities and communities coalitions", Health Promotion International, 23(2), pp.109~118 (2008)
  37. Kegler, M., "Assessing community change at multiple levels: the genesis of an evaluation framework for the California Healthy Cities Project", Health Education & Behavior, 27(6), pp.760~779 (2000)
  38. Kickbusch, I., "Healthy Cities: a working project and a growing movement", Health Promotion International, 4(2), pp.77~82 (1989)
  39. 김정희, "건강도시에 대한 비판적 고찰: 열린 담론을 기대하며", 보건과 사회과학, 21(21), pp.141~160 (2007), 한국보건사회학회
  40. 김정민, "건강도시사업추진을 위한 개인, 조직, 환경역량의 평가", 보건교육건강증진학회지, 26(2), pp.121~135 (2009), 한국보건교육건강증진학회
  42. Lawrence, R, "Building healthy cities : The World Health Organization perspective, In Handbook of Urban Health" (2005), Springer Science+Media, Inc
  43. Leyden, K, "Social capital and the built environment: the importance of walkable neighborhoods", American Journal of Public Health, 93(9), pp.1546~1551 (2003)
  44. Lincoln, Y, "Fourth Generation Evaluation" (1989), SAGE Publications
  45. Milio, N, "Healthy Cities: the new public health and supportive research", Health Promotion International, 5(4), pp.291~297 (1990)
  46. Ministry of Health and Welfare, "Healthy city : current status and policy development", Paper presented at the Consultation meeting for National Accreditation System for Healthy Cities (2012)
  47. Naidoo, J, "Foundations for health promotion" (2009), Elsevier
  48. 남은우, "Health promotion capacity mapping: The Korean situation", HEALTH PROMOTION INTERNATIONAL, 22(2), pp.155~162
  49. 남은우, "Evaluation of Healthy City Project Using SPIRIT Checklist: Wonju City Case", 보건교육건강증진학회지, 27(5), pp.15~25 (2010), 한국보건교육건강증진학회
  50. Nunez, A., "The Valencian community healthy cities network: assessment of the implementation process", Health Promotion International, 9(3), pp.189~198 (1994)
  51. Nutbeam, D, "Evaluating health promotion - progress, problems and solutions", Health Promotion International, 13(1), pp.27~44 (1998)
  52. O'Neill, M, "Choosing indicators to evaluate Healthy Cities projects: a political task?", Health Promotion International, 21(2), pp.145~152 (2006)
  53. 오유미, "대한민국 건강도시 평가(2008-2010)", 보건교육건강증진학회지, 28(3), pp.99~111 (2011), 한국보건교육건강증진학회
  54. Park, Y. H., "Development of standard guideline and evaluation system for healthy cities" (2011), Sooncheonhyang University, Korea Health Promotion Foundation
  55. Poland, B., "Knowledge development and evaluation in, of and for Healthy Community initiatives. Part I: guiding principles", Health Promotion International, 11(3), pp.237~247 (1996)
  56. Plümer, K., "Evaluating the implementation of the WHO Healthy Cities Programme across Germany (1999–2002)", Health Promotion International, 25(3), pp.342~354 (2010)
  57. Saelens, B., "Built environment correlates of walking: a review", Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise, 40(Suppl), pp.S550~ (2008)
  58. Springett, J, "Chapter 4 Participatory approaches to evaluation in health promotion, In Evaluation in health promotion. Principles and perspectives" (2001), WHO Regional Publications
  59. Springett, J, "Quality measures and evaluation of Healthy City policy initiatives: The Liverpool experience, In Quality, Evidence and Effectiveness in Health Promotion: Striving for Uncertainties" (2001), Routledge
  60. Stern, R., "Boundary workers and the management of frustration: a case study of two Healthy City partnerships", Health Promotion International, 20(3), pp.269~276 (2005)
  61. Stevenson, H., "Bureaucratic logic in new social movement clothing: the limits of health promotion research", Health Promotion International, 6(4), pp.281~289 (1991)
  62. Stufflebeam, D, "Chapter 1. Overview of the evaluation field, In Evaluation Theory, Models, and Applications" (2007), Jossey-Bass
  63. Takano, T., "An analysis of health levels and various indicators of urban environments for Healthy Cities projects", Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health, 55(4), pp.263~270 (2001)
  64. Tsouros, A, "The WHO Healthy Cities Project: state of the art and future plans", Health Promotion International, 10(2), pp.133~141 (1995)
  65. Tsouros, A, "Urban health and healthy cities: WHO's plans for the future", Eurohealth, 4(2), pp.27~29 (1998)
  66. Tsouros, A, "City leadership for health and sustainable development: The World Health Organization European Healthy Cities Network", Health Promotion International, 24(suppl 1), pp.i4~i10 (2009)
  67. Tsouros, A., "Health Promotion International: special supplement on European Healthy Cities", Health Promotion International, 24(suppl_1), pp.i1~i3 (2009)
  68. Vlahov, D., "Urban as a determinant of health", Journal of Urban Health, 84, pp.16~26 (2007)
  69. Webster, P, "Review of the "City Health Profiles" produced by WHO Healthy Cities - Do they present information on health and its determinants and what are their perceived benefits?", Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health, 53(2), pp.125~127 (1999)
  70. Webster, P., "The evolution of the WHO city health profiles: a content review", Health Promotion International, 24(suppl_1), pp.i56~i63 (2009)
  71. Weich, S., "Mental health and the built environment: cross-sectional survey of individual and contextual risk factors for depression", British Journal of Psychiatry, 180(5), pp.428~433 (2002)
  72. Werna, E., "The evaluation of healthy city projects in developing countries", Habitat International, 19(4), pp.629~641 (1995)
  73. Werna, E., "The implementation of the Healthy Cities Project in developing countries: Lessons from Chittagong", Habitat International, 20(2), pp.221~228 (1996)
  74. WHO, "City Leadership for Health", pp.2008, WHO
  75. WHO, "Regional Guidelines for Developing a Healthy Cities Project", pp.2000, WHO

관련 논문AI추천

대한민국 건강도시 평가(2008-2010)김혜정, 오유미, 홍경수한국보건교육건강증진학회 · 보건교육건강증진학회지2011 · 제28권 제3호영국과 한국의 건강도시 사업 평가방법 비교 연구: 리버풀과 원주시를 중심으로강신희, 남은우, 문지영한국보건교육건강증진학회 · 보건교육건강증진학회지2013 · 제30권 제2호건강도시프로젝트에서의 도시건강프로파일 개발사례고광욱, 김희숙, 신용현, 임백빈한국보건교육건강증진학회 · 보건교육건강증진학회지2014 · 제31권 제3호건강도시와 건강증진의 관계 정립 및 국민건강증진법 개정 방향강은정, 김광기, 유승현한국보건교육건강증진학회 · 보건교육건강증진학회지2019 · 제36권 제5호유럽건강도시 발전과 국내적 함의고광욱, 송정국, 임요환한국보건교육건강증진학회 · 보건교육건강증진학회지2021 · 제38권 제1호Evaluation of Healthy City Project Using SPIRIT Checklist: Wonju City Case남은우, 문지영, Albert Lee한국보건교육건강증진학회 · 보건교육건강증진학회지2010 · 제27권 제5호

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (6건)

최근 보건교육건강증진학회지 게재논문 동향 (2009-2011년)권은주, 김혜경pp. 1-13건강증진 연구의 방향과 과제: 한국건강증진재단 연구과제(2005-2011년)를 중심으로안지영, 함승우, 제갈정, 김광기, 박정은pp. 15-28공공부문 건강증진사업의 발전방향이주열pp. 29-38민간부문의 건강증진 사업과 연구 현황, 발전방향과 과제 - 한국건강관리협회의 건강증진 사업과 연구를 중심으로 -조한익pp. 40-56지역사회건강증진을 위한 참여: 이해와 적용유승현pp. 57-66
원문 보기