Evaluation of Healthy City Project Using SPIRIT Checklist: Wonju City Case
1
조회
0
다운로드
5
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
The purpose of this study was to evaluate Wonju Healthy City project and identify its problems, and seeking a way for its improvement based on the Healthy City project philosophy and strategies. We used the SPIRIT Checklist that was a process evaluation tool and developed by Alliance for Healthy Cities for the study. We analyzed 39 related materials and gathered opinions on the evaluation result with Healthy City Team staffs, related department staffs and the advisory committee. Finally, a joint meeting with AFHC SPIRIT evaluation expert verified the result of the analysis. The evaluation of Wonju Healthy City project confirmed that Wonju city is equipped with the resources, such as mid-term plan,infrastructure, cooperative organizations, and the Healthy City network to enable the consistent implementation of the Healthy City project based on strong political commitment. However, the necessity of additional complementary processes as well as the application of further improvements to assist health promotion strategies was evident. The SPIRIT Checklist contains items to evaluate the progress of the Healthy City projects. However, we propose that the checklist should develop quantitative methods based on a qualitative checklist for comparison among members of the Alliance for Healthy Cities.
Abstract
The purpose of this study was to evaluate Wonju Healthy City project and identify its problems, and seeking a way for its improvement based on the Healthy City project philosophy and strategies. We used the SPIRIT Checklist that was a process evaluation tool and developed by Alliance for Healthy Cities for the study. We analyzed 39 related materials and gathered opinions on the evaluation result with Healthy City Team staffs, related department staffs and the advisory committee. Finally, a joint meeting with AFHC SPIRIT evaluation expert verified the result of the analysis. The evaluation of Wonju Healthy City project confirmed that Wonju city is equipped with the resources, such as mid-term plan,infrastructure, cooperative organizations, and the Healthy City network to enable the consistent implementation of the Healthy City project based on strong political commitment. However, the necessity of additional complementary processes as well as the application of further improvements to assist health promotion strategies was evident. The SPIRIT Checklist contains items to evaluate the progress of the Healthy City projects. However, we propose that the checklist should develop quantitative methods based on a qualitative checklist for comparison among members of the Alliance for Healthy Cities.
참고문헌 (33)
- Ashton,J, "Healthy Cities" (1992), Open University Press
- Baum, F, "Healthy City Australia: The evaluation of the pilot project in Noarlunga", Health Promotion International, 8(1), pp.31~40 (1992)
- Baum,F, "Healthy Cities and change: Social movement of bureaucratic tool?", Health Promotion International, 8(1), pp.181~193 (1993)
- Bae,S.S, "Planning for Health program planning" (2008), Gye Chuk Mun Wha Sa
- Boonekamp, G.M.M, "Healthy Cities Evaluation: the co-ordinators perspective", Health Promotion International, 14(2), pp.103~110 (1999)
- Chiba,M, "Community reinvigorate over 1%" (2007), The Hope Institute
- Donchin, M, "Implementation of the Healthy Cities’ Principles and Strategies:An evaluation of the Israel Healthy Cities Network", Health Promotion International, 21(4), pp.266~273 (2006)
- Harpham, T, "Healthy City projects in developing countries: the first evaluation", Health Promotion International, 16(2), pp.111~125 (2001)
- Kickbush, I, "Helathy Cities: a working project and a growing movement", Health Promotion, 4, pp.77~82 (1989)
- Lee, A, "Evaluating Health Promoting Schools in Hong Kong: The Development of a Framework", Health Promotion International, 20(2), pp.177~186 (2005)
- Lee,M.C, "Application for the Award to "Climate Change and Health in Cities": Clean and Cool City, Wonju Plan, Economy Environment Bureau, Environment Protection Division of Wonju city, Climate Protection Research Institute, Wonju ECO Environmental Technology Center of Yonsei University", Healthy City Research Center, of Yonsei University, ~ (2008)
- Leeuw,E.D, "Sense and Nonsense in Healthy City Evaluation. Paper presented at the International Conference on Healthy Cities, Athens", WHO Collaborating Centre for Research on Healthy Cities, University of Maastrcicht, ~ (1998)
- Moderation in Drink Club of Yonsei University at Wonju, "2007 Moderation in Drink at School in Gangwon region" (2007), Healthy City Research Center of Yonsei University
- Moderation in Drink Club of Yonsei University at Wonju, "2008 Moderation in Drink at School in Gangwon region" (2008), Healthy City Research Center of Yonsei University
- Naidoo,J, "Foundations for health promotion" (2000), Bailliere Tindall
- Nam,E.W, "Collaboration program between Healthy City project and Health Promotion program", Healthy City Wonju Forum (2005), Wonju City
- Nam, E.W, "AFHC awards for Healthy Cities 2008:Application for the Award for Progress of Healthy Cities", Healthy City Project Team, Health, Sports and Knowledge Industry division of Wonju city, Healthy City Research Center of Yonsei University, ~ (2008)
- Nam, E.W, "Using Tobacco Comsumption Tax for Sustainable Resourcing of the Healthy City of Wonju, Republic of Korea", Health Promotion International, ~ (2010)
- Nunez, A, "The Valencian Community Healthy Cities Network: Assessment of the implementation process", Health Promotion International, 9(3), pp.189~198 (1994)
- Nutbeam,D, "Evaluation health promotion", Health Promotion International, 13, pp.27~44 (1998)
- Werna, E, "Cox’s Bazar Healthy Town Programme, Bangladesh- review of progress", Consultancy Report for WHO, ~ (1996)
- WHO, "Ottawa Charter for Health Promotion. An international Conference on Health Promotion", An international Conference on Health Promotion, pp.17~21 (1986)
- WHO, "Regional Guidelines for developing a Healthy Cities Project", WHO Regional Office for the Western Pacific, ~ (2000)
- WHO, "Healthy Cities Initiatives: approaches and experiences in the African Region", WHO Regional Office for Africa, ~ (2002)
- Wonju City, "Wonju City Health Profiles" (2004), Wonju City
- Wonju City, "Construction of a database of the Wonju Healthy City" (2006), Wonju City, Healthy City Research Center
- Wonju City, "Construction of a homepage of the Wonju Healthy City" (2006), Wonju City, Healthy City Research Center
- Wonju City, "Application for the Award to Financing of Health Promotion Activities –How to Finance Healthy City Project: The Health City Project in Wonju Financed with Tobacco Tax-" (2006), Wonju city, Healthy City Research Center
- Wonju City, "Healthy City Five-year Project" (2006), Wonju City, Healthy City Research Center
- Wonju Public Health Center, "WHO Healthy City Wonju Community Survey and Report on Health Promotion Program" (2007), Wonju City, Healthy City Research Center
- Wonju City, "Wonju City Health Education for Wonju Citizen in 2007" (2007), Wonju City, Healthy City Research Center
- Wonju City, "Wonju City Health Education for Wonju Citizen in 2008" (2008), Wonju City, Healthy City Research Center
- Wonju City, "the 2007 Evaluation Report, 2008" (2008), Wonju City