본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

생시몽(Saint-Simon) 그리고 동양 ― ‘정신 진보’의 거대서사와 동양의 부재 ―

Saint-Simon and the Orient

1

조회

0

다운로드

1

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

주제분류역사학

초록

The objective of this paper is to analyze the orientalist discourse of Saint Simon on the base of the analyzes of the modern orientalism by Edward W. Said that criticize the understanding of the Other which, based on the notion of exteriority, tends to fix the identity and the nature of the Other in various categories formed in his own culture. Firstly, in order to understand the problematic of Saint-Simon, convinced of the progress of the human spirit, this paper tries to regard the ideas of Saint-Simon as the one of the social transition that could not be limited in the French society. In the second part of this work, it is important to examine his discourse which is part of a eurocentric perspective on the history of civilizations. Finally, the paper tries to understand Saint-Simon’s discourse about the civilization in order to prepare future work for the analyze of the visions of the Saint-Simonians such as the ‘civilizing mission’ and the ‘association of the Orient and the Occident’. In short, this work intends to show that the discourse of Saint-Simon on the Orient is related more to his doctrine than to the Orientals considering that the Orient is generally excluded from their discourse on the Orient.

Abstract

The objective of this paper is to analyze the orientalist discourse of Saint Simon on the base of the analyzes of the modern orientalism by Edward W. Said that criticize the understanding of the Other which, based on the notion of exteriority, tends to fix the identity and the nature of the Other in various categories formed in his own culture. Firstly, in order to understand the problematic of Saint-Simon, convinced of the progress of the human spirit, this paper tries to regard the ideas of Saint-Simon as the one of the social transition that could not be limited in the French society. In the second part of this work, it is important to examine his discourse which is part of a eurocentric perspective on the history of civilizations. Finally, the paper tries to understand Saint-Simon’s discourse about the civilization in order to prepare future work for the analyze of the visions of the Saint-Simonians such as the ‘civilizing mission’ and the ‘association of the Orient and the Occident’. In short, this work intends to show that the discourse of Saint-Simon on the Orient is related more to his doctrine than to the Orientals considering that the Orient is generally excluded from their discourse on the Orient.

참고문헌 (14)

  1. OEuvres de Claude-Henri de Saint-Simon, "생시몽전집, 총 6권" (1966)
  2. OEuvres de Claude-Henri de Saint-Simon, "생시몽과 앙팡땡 전집, 총 47권" (1865), E. Dentu
  3. Konrad Engelbert OELSNER, "1809년 7월 7일 프랑스 협회 수상 논문", F. Schoell (1810)
  4. Pierre ANSART, "Sociologie de Saint-Simon" (1970), PUF
  5. Nathalie COILLY, "Le siècle des saint-simoniens : du Nouveau christianisme au canal de Suez" (2006), BNF
  6. Jean-René DERRÉ, "Regards sur le saint-simonisme et les saint-simoniens" (1986), Presses Université de Lyon
  7. Jehan D’IVRAY, "L’aventure Saint-Simonienne et les femmes" (1928), Félix Alcan
  8. Émile DURKHEIM, "Le socialisme, sa définition, ses débuts ; la doctrine saint-simonienne" (1928), F. Alcan
  9. Juliette GRANGE, "Saint-Simon" (2005), Ellipses
  10. Maxime LEROY, "Le socialisme des producteurs : Henri de Saint-Simon" (1924), M. Rivière
  11. Magali MORSY, "Les saint-simoniens et l’Orient : Vers la modernité" (1989), Édisud
  12. Antoine PICON, "Les saint-simoniens. Raison, imaginaire et utopie" (2002), Belin
  13. Marie-France PIGUET, "“L’Europe des Européens chez le comte de Saint-Simon”, Mots", Les langages du politique, 34 (1993)
  14. Philippe RÉGNIER, "Études saint-simoniennes" (2002), Presses Universitaires de Lyon

관련 논문AI추천

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (9건)