An experimental study on Korean case stacking
2
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
This study aims to investigate whether case stacking is optionally permissible or obligatory in Korean through acceptability judgment testing. When presented without context, ‘case-stacked’ sentences consistently exhibit low acceptability scores (typically under 2 out of 5), and no instances have been observed where case stacking is necessary to rectify ill-formed sentences. Meanwhile, in ‘with context' conditions, case stacking has been more permissible than in ‘without context' conditions; nonetheless, the contextual effects are not robust enough to render the case-stacked sentences fully acceptable. Even in ‘with context' conditions, case-stacking is not as felicitous as non-stacking. These findings cast doubt on the widespread assumption of prior studies that report case stacking as generally acceptable in Korean; instead, we should focus on examining why case stacking is less acceptable or unacceptable and consider how it aligns with principles of economy and minimality.
Abstract
This study aims to investigate whether case stacking is optionally permissible or obligatory in Korean through acceptability judgment testing. When presented without context, ‘case-stacked’ sentences consistently exhibit low acceptability scores (typically under 2 out of 5), and no instances have been observed where case stacking is necessary to rectify ill-formed sentences. Meanwhile, in ‘with context' conditions, case stacking has been more permissible than in ‘without context' conditions; nonetheless, the contextual effects are not robust enough to render the case-stacked sentences fully acceptable. Even in ‘with context' conditions, case-stacking is not as felicitous as non-stacking. These findings cast doubt on the widespread assumption of prior studies that report case stacking as generally acceptable in Korean; instead, we should focus on examining why case stacking is less acceptable or unacceptable and consider how it aligns with principles of economy and minimality.
참고문헌 (27)
- 고길수, "문법격 조사는 격조사인가?", 언어연구, 24(1), pp.25~42 (2007), 언어정보연구소[DOI]
- 김영희, "사격표지와 후치사", 국어학, 34, pp.31~58 (1999)
- 김용하, "격과 조사", 國語學, (60), pp.233~263 (2011), 국어학회[DOI]
- 김용하, "한국어 조사의 분포와 통합체계" (2014), 경진출판
- 최기용, "한국어 격과 조사의 생성통사론" (2009), 한국문화사
- 조세연, "A Study on Case Stacking and Case Alternation in Korean: A Constraint-Based Approach", 현대문법연구, (43), pp.101~115 (2006), 현대문법학회
- Cho, Y. M. Y., "A lexical account of inflectional suffixes in Korean", Journal of East Asian Linguistics, 4, pp.119~174 (1995)
- 최현숙, "On the (stacked) markers -{ka", lul}, 2011, pp.(65), 115~143[DOI]
- Gerdts, D. B., "Korean psych constructions: Advancement or retreat?", Papers from the General Session at the... Regional Meeting, 24(1), pp.155~175 (1988)
- Gerdts, D., "Non-nominative subjects in Korean", Harvard Studies in Korean Linguistics, 3, pp.235~247 (1989)
- Gerdts, D., "Case stacking and focus in Korean", Harvard Studies in Korean Linguistics, 8, pp.325~339 (1999)
- Hong, K. S., "Argument selection and case marking in Korean" (1992), Stanford University Press
- Jung, Y. J., "Multiple case marking and its PF interpretation", Korean Journal of Linguistics, 26(2), pp.239~268 (2001)
- Levin, T., "Successive-cyclic case assignment : Korean nominative-nominative case-stacking", Natural Language & Linguistic Theory, 35, pp.447~498 (2017)
- Park, M. K., "Harvard studies in Korean linguistics Ⅱ", pp.381~393 (1991), Department of Linguistics, Harvard University
- Schütze, C. T., "Korean"case stacking"isn't : Unifying noncase uses of case particles", North East Linguistics Society, 26(1), pp.351~365 (1996)
- Schütze, C. T., "On Korean"Case stacking" : The varied functions of the particles ka and lul", The Linguistic Review, 18, pp.193~232 (2001)
- The distribution of topic-and nominative-marked phrases in Korean: The universality of IP structure, "Suh, S.", MIT, 207~221, pp.MIT Working Papers in Linguistics, 16 (1992)
- Yang, D. W., "Case features and case particles", Proceedings of the 18th WCCFL, pp.629~639 (1999)
- 양동휘, "Atypical Aspects of Korean Case: A Minimalist Perspective", 언어와 정보 사회, 1, pp.53~96 (2000), 언어정보연구소
- Yoon, J., "Ambiguity of government and the chain condition", Natural Language & Linguistic Theory, 14(1), pp.105~162 (1996)
- Yoon, J., "Non-nominative(major)subjects and case stacking in Korean", Typological Studies in Language, 61, pp.265~314 (2004)
- Yoon, J., "Chain condition, ambiguity of government and derivational grammars", North East Linguistics Society, 21(1), pp.415~429 (1991)
- Yoon, J. Y., "On the multiple ‘ka’and ‘lul’ constructions in Korean", Harvard Studies in Korean Linguistics, 3, pp.383~394 (1989)
- Youn, C, "A relational analysis of Korean multiple nominative constructions", pp.1990
- Youn, C., "A relational analysis of case stacking", Studies in Modern Grammar, 6, pp.121~147 (1995)
- Youn, C., "Case stacking revisited", Studies in Modern Grammar, 14, pp.125~149 (1998)