리더와 구성원의 리더십 이중주: 팀에서 리더의 변혁적 리더십과 구성원의 변혁적 리더십의 상호작용
A Duet of Leadership by Leader and Member: The Synergy Effects of Leader Transformational Leadership and Transformational Leadership Shared by Members on Team Effectiveness
0
조회
0
다운로드
19
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
The present study examines the effects of transformational leadership exercised by team leader and transformational leadership shared by team members on team creativity and team performance at the team level. A growing body on leadership research highlights the role of team leadership in work organizations. In team settings, studies have focused exclusively on individual leaders who occupy formal leadership positions and exercise vertical influence over team members. In contrast to this traditional approach, shared leadership highlights a horizontal influence process where leadership is collectively carried out by team members. In this shared form of leadership, members actively participate in the leadership process and horizontally influence other team members. This mutual influence among team members constitutes a critical condition for the success of team-based organizations. The ability of team members to work together as a team is the key to the overall functioning of the team organization. To verify the effect of two leadership styles, we analyze the effect of a leader’s transformational leadership and members’ shared transformational leadership on team creativity and team performance for the same team. This study also predicts that the transformational leadership shared by members will moderate the effects of leader transformational leadership on team performance and creativity. Our findings show that both leaderships have a positive effect on team performance. However, the main effect of a leader’s transformational leadership on team creativity is not significant when members’ transformational leadership is employed into the model. With the effect of leader transformational leadership controlled for, the main effects of the transformational leadership shared by members on team creativity and performance are significant. In addition, we also found the significant moderation effects of member transformational leadership by leader transformational leadership on team creativity. Based on these findings, we strongly recommend that team based organizations shift the leadership focus from the leader focused leadership model to the shared leadership model. We also discuss managerial implications of our findings in details.
Abstract
The present study examines the effects of transformational leadership exercised by team leader and transformational leadership shared by team members on team creativity and team performance at the team level. A growing body on leadership research highlights the role of team leadership in work organizations. In team settings, studies have focused exclusively on individual leaders who occupy formal leadership positions and exercise vertical influence over team members. In contrast to this traditional approach, shared leadership highlights a horizontal influence process where leadership is collectively carried out by team members. In this shared form of leadership, members actively participate in the leadership process and horizontally influence other team members. This mutual influence among team members constitutes a critical condition for the success of team-based organizations. The ability of team members to work together as a team is the key to the overall functioning of the team organization. To verify the effect of two leadership styles, we analyze the effect of a leader’s transformational leadership and members’ shared transformational leadership on team creativity and team performance for the same team. This study also predicts that the transformational leadership shared by members will moderate the effects of leader transformational leadership on team performance and creativity. Our findings show that both leaderships have a positive effect on team performance. However, the main effect of a leader’s transformational leadership on team creativity is not significant when members’ transformational leadership is employed into the model. With the effect of leader transformational leadership controlled for, the main effects of the transformational leadership shared by members on team creativity and performance are significant. In addition, we also found the significant moderation effects of member transformational leadership by leader transformational leadership on team creativity. Based on these findings, we strongly recommend that team based organizations shift the leadership focus from the leader focused leadership model to the shared leadership model. We also discuss managerial implications of our findings in details.
참고문헌 (111)
- 김보영, "동료의 과업관련 도움요청과 이들의 특징이 지식공유에 미치는 영향에 관한 연구", 지식경영연구, 13(4), pp.101~116 (2012), 한국지식경영학회
- 방호진, "공유리더십의 효과에대한 연구 과업상호의존성과 리더십의존성의 조절효과를 중심으로", 한국인사관리학회 추계학술대회발표논문집 (2008)
- 양동민, "프로젝트 팀 내 공유리더십(Shared Leadership)이 팀 효능감과 팀 몰입에 미치는 영향 -과업조정 및 업무분담의 매개효과 검증 -", 기업경영연구, 19(2), pp.127~147 (2012), 한국기업경영학회
- 이건창, "가상공동체에서 리더십 스타일과 팀 성과에 관한 실증연구", 지식경영연구, 9(4), pp.127~142 (2008), 한국지식경영학회
- 임준철, "부하에 의해 인지된 상사의변혁적 및 거래적 리더십이 부하의 혁신성향에 미치는 영향:자기권능감의 매개역할을 중심으로", 인사조직연구, 7(1), pp.1~42 (1999)
- 지철규, "지식근로자의 직무특성이 조직 몰입도에 미치는 영향 -공유리더십을 조절 변수로", 한국산학기술학회논문지, 13(12), pp.5786~5799 (2012), 한국산학기술학회[DOI]
- 한주희, "변혁적 리더십과 팀 유효성에 관한 연구:자율욕구의 조절효과를 중심으로", 조직과 인사관리 연구, 24(2), pp.145~166 (2001)
- 허문구, "인적자원관리가 지식공유에 미치는 영향 : 공유비전과 코드의 매개효과를 중심으로", 지식경영연구, 11(2), pp.57~73 (2010), 한국지식경영학회
- Amabile, T. M., "How tokill creativity", HarvardBusinessReview, 76(5), pp.76~87 (1998)
- Amabile, T. M., "Creativity in context" (1996), Westview
- Amabile, T. M., "From individualcreativitto organizationalinnovation, In Achievementand motivation:Asocial-developmental perspective" (1988), CambridgeUniversityPress
- Amabile, T. M., "Assessing the workenvironment for creativity", Academy ofManagementJournal, 39(5), pp.1154~1184 (1996)
- Amabile, T. M., "The work preferenceinventory: Assessing intrinsic and extrinsicmotivational orientations", Journal of PersonalityandSocialPsychology, 66(5), pp.950~967 (1994)
- Andriopoulos, C., "Determinants oforganisational creativity: A literature review", ManagementDecision, 39(10), pp.834~840 (2001)
- Avolio, B. J., "Re-examining the components of transformationaland transactionalleadership using theMultifactorLeadershipQuestionnaire", JournalofOrganizationalandOccupationalPsychology, 72, pp.441~462 (1999)
- Avolio, B. J., "Individualconsiderationviewedatmultiplelevelofanalysis:A multi-level framework for examining thediffusionoftransformationalleadership", LeadershipQuarterly, 6, pp.199~218 (1995)
- Avolio, B. J., "Building highlydeveloped teams:Focusing in shared leadershipprocess,efficacy,trust,andperformance, In Advances in interdisciplinarystudies of work teams", pp.173~209 (1996), JAIPress
- Avolio, B. J., "Assessingshared leadership: Development and preliminaryvalidation of a team multifactor leadershipquestionnaire, In Shared leadership: Reframing thehows and whys of leadership", pp.143~172 (2003), Sage
- Bartol, K. M., "Womenandmenintaskgroups, In The socialpsychology offemale-malerelations:A criticalanalysisofcentralconcepts", pp.259~310 (1986), AcademicPress
- Bartko, J. J., "On various intraclasscorrelation reliability coefficients", PsychologicalBulletin, 83(5), pp.762~765 (1976)
- Bass, B. M., "Bass& Stogdill'shandbookofleadership" (1990), FreePress
- Bass, B. M., "Leadership and performancebeyondexpectations" (1985), FreePress
- Bass, B. M., "Improvingorganizationaleffectivenessthroughtransformationalleadership" (1994), SagePublications
- Transformationalleadership,charisma,andbeyond, "Bass, B. M.", StateUniversityofNew York, ~ (1985)
- Becker, B. E., "The HR scorecard: Linking people,strategy, and performance" (2001), Harvard BusinessSchoolPress
- Bligh, M. C., "The importance of self- and sharedleadership in team based knowledge work: Ameso-levelmodelof leadershipdynamics", JournalofManagerialPsychology, 21(4), pp.296~318 (2006)
- Bowers, D. G., "Predicting organizational effectiveness with afour-factor theory of leadership", AdministrativeScienceQuarterly, 11, pp.238~263 (1966)
- Burns, J. M., "Leadership, New" (1978), Harper& Row
- Campbell, J. P., "Contributionresearchcanmake in understanding organization effectiveness, In OrganizationalEffectiveness" (1976), Kent,tateUnivPress
- Carson, J. B., "Shared leadership in teams: Aninvestigation of antecedent conditions andperformance", AcademyofManagementJournal, 50, pp.1217~1234 (2007)
- Conger, J. A., "landscapeofopportunities, In Sharedleadership:Reframingthehowsand whys of leadership" (2003), Sage
- Cox, J. F., "Towardamodelofsharedleadership anddistributedinfluenceintheinnovationprocess, In Sharedleadership:Reframing the hows and whys of leadership" (2003), Sage
- Dalton, D. R., "Organization structureand performance:A criticalreview", Academy ofManagementReview, 5(1), pp.49~64 (1980)
- Day, D., "Leadership in team-based organization: On thethresholdofanew era", LeadershipQuarterly, 17, pp.211~216 (2006)
- Day, D., "Leadership capacity in teams", LeadershipQuarterly, 15(6), pp.857~880 (2004)
- Deci, E. L., "Intrinsicmotivation and self-determination in humanbehavior" (1985), Plenum
- Dionne, S., "Transformationalleadershipand team performance", JournalofOrganizationalChangeManagement, 17, pp.177~193 (2004)
- Drath, W., "Thedeepbluesea:Rethinkingthe source of leadership" (2001), Jossey-Bass
- Ensley, M. D., "Theimportanceofverticalandsharedleadership within new venture top managementteams: Implications for the performance ofstartups", LeadershipQuarterly, 17, pp.217~231 (2006)
- Ensley, M. D., "Top management team process, sharedleadership, and new venture performance: Atheoretical model and research agenda", HumanResourceManagementReview, 13(2), pp.329~346 (2003)
- Evans, C. R., "GroupCohesion and performance: A Meta Analysis", SmallGroupResearch, 22(7), pp.175~186 (1991)
- Epitropaki, O., "Themoderating role of individualdifference in therelation between transformational", transactionalleadership perceptions and organizationalidentification, 2005, pp.16, 569~589
- Friedrich, T. L., "Aframework forunderstanding collectiveleadership:The selective utilization ofleaderand teamexpertise within networks", Leadership Quarterly, 20, pp.933~958 (2009)
- Gibb, C. A., "Leadership, In Handbook of social psychology", pp.877~917 (1954), Addison-Wesley
- Gockel, C., "Measuringandmodeling shared leadership: Traditionalapproachesand new ideas", JournalofPersonnelPsychology, 9(4), pp.172~180 (2010)
- Gronn, P., "Distributedleadershipasaunitofanalysis", LeadershipQuarterly, 13, pp.423~451 (2002)
- Gumusluoglu, L., "Transformational leadership, creativity, andorganizational innovation", Journal of BusinessResearch, 62, pp.461~473 (2009)
- Gupta, V. K., "Social capital, collective transformationalleadership, and performance: A resource-basedview of self-managed teams", Journal ofManagerialIssues, 23(1), pp.31~45 (2011)
- Guzzo, R. A., "Teamsin organizations:Recentresearch on performanceand effectiveness", AnnualReview ofPsychology, 47, pp.307~338 (1996)
- Hackman, J. R., "WorkRedesign" (1980), AddisonWesley
- Hair, J. F. Jr., "MultivariateDataAnalysis" (2006), Pearson-PrenticeHall
- Harter, J. J., "Superiors'evaluation and subordinates perception oftransformational and transactional leadership", JournalofAppliedPsychology, 73, pp.695~702 (1988)
- Hiller, N. J., "Collective enactmentofleadership rolesandteam effectiveness:A fieldstudy", LeadershipQuarterly, 17(4), pp.387~397 (2006)
- Hinds, P. J., "Understandingconflictingeographicallydistributedteams:Themoderating effectsofshared identity,shared context,and spontaneous communication", OrganizationScience, 16(3), pp.290~307 (2005)
- Hollander, E. P., "Process ofLeadershipEmergence", Journal of Contemporary Business, 3(4), pp.19~33 (1974)
- Hooker, C., "Flow,creativity,and shared leadership, In Shared leadership:Reframing the hows and whys of leadership" (2003), Sage
- Howell, J. M., "Transformationalleadership,transactionalleadership,locusofcontrolandsupportforinnovation:Keypredictorsofconsolidated-business-unitperformance", JournalofAppliedPsychology, 78, pp.891~902 (1993)
- Ishikawa, J., "Leadership and performancein Japanese R&D teams", Asia Pacific BusinessReview, 18(2), pp.241~258 (2012)
- Jung, D. I., "Therole oftransformationalleadership in enhancingorganizational innovation: Hypotheses and somepreliminary findings", Leadership Quarterly, 14, pp.525~544 (2003)
- Effectsofleadershipstyle,anonymityandrewards in an electronic meeting systemenvironment, "Kahai, S. S.", Center forLeadershipStudies,BinghantonUniversity, ~ (2000)
- Katz, D., "The socialpsychology of organisations" (1978), John Wiley
- Keller, R. T., "Transformationalleadership,initiatingstructureandsubstitutesforleadership:Alongitudinalstudy of research and developmentproject team performance", Journal of AppliedPsychology, 91(1), pp.202~210 (2006)
- Kerr, N. L., "Illusions of efficacy:Theeffects of group size on perceived efficacy insocial dilemmas", Journal of Experimental andSocialPsychology, 25, pp.374~403 (1989)
- Experiencesof innovation at work, "King, N.", UniversityofSheffield, ~, pp.SAPU Memp No.772 (1985)
- Kuhnert, K. W., "Transactionaland transformational leadership:Aconstructive", developmentalanalysis, 1987, pp.12(4), 648~657
- Lee, K. C., "Effects of shared leadership on team creativitythrough knowledge-sharing in an e-learningenvironment", Proceedingsofthe5th InternationalConferenceonUbiquitousInformationManagementand Communication, ICUIMC 2011, pp.81~ (2011)
- Levine, J. M., "Progress in small group research, In AnnualReviewofPsychology(Vol.41)", pp.585~634 (1990), AnnualReviews
- Lowe, K. B., "Effectivenesscorrelates of transformational and transactionalleadership:A meta-analytic review ofthe MLQliterature", LeadershipQuarterly, 7, pp.385~425 (1996)
- Manz, C. C., "Sustainable performance withvalues-basedsharedleadership:A casestudyofavirtuous organization", Canadian Journal ofAdministrativeSciences, 28, pp.284~296 (2011)
- Manz, C. C., "Businesses without bosses: How self-managingteams are building high performance companies" (1993), Wiley
- Marks, M. A., "A temporally based framework andtaxonomy of team processes", Academy ofManagementReview, 26(3), pp.356~376 (2001)
- Mehra, A., "Distributed leadership in teams:Thenetwork of leadership perceptions and teamperformance", LeadershipQuarterly, 17, pp.232~245 (2006)
- Nahapiet, J., "Socialcapital,intellectualcapital,andthe organizationaladvantage", Academy ofManagementReview, 23, pp.242~266 (1998)
- Nunnally, J. C., "Psychometric theory" (1994), McGraw Hill
- Oldham, G. R., "Employee creativity: Personal and contextualfactorsatwork", AcademyofManagementJournal, 39(3), pp.607~634 (1996)
- Ostroff, C., "Substantive and operational issues ofresponse bias across levels of analysis: Anexample of climate- satisfaction relationships", JournalofAppliedPsychology, 87(2), pp.355~368 (2002)
- O'Toole, J., "When leadership is anorganizational trait, In Thefutureof leadership", pp.158~175 (2001), Jossey-Bass
- Pearce, C. L., "The future ofleadership:Combining vertical and shared leadership totransform knowledge work", Academy ofManagementExecutive, 18, pp.47~57 (2004)
- Pearce, C. L., "Theoretical and practitioner letters-Sharedleadership theory", Leadership Quarterly, 18, pp.281~283 (2007)
- Pearce, C. L., "Sharedleadership: Reframing the hows and whys ofleadership" (2003), Sage
- Pearce, C. L., "Theoreticalandpractitioner letters-Sharedleadership theory", Leadership Quarterly, 19, pp.622~628 (2008)
- Pearce, C. L., "New formsof management:Sharedanddistributedleadershipinorganizations", JournalofPersonnelPsychology, 9(4), pp.151~153 (2010)
- Pearce, C. L., "Theimportance of self- and shared leadership inknowledgework", OrganizationalDynamics, 34(2), pp.130~140 (2005)
- Pearce, C., "Sharedleadership", ExecutiveExcellence, 21(7), pp.6~8 (2004)
- Pearce, C. L., "Sharedleadership:RelationshipmanagementtoimproveNPO effectiveness, In The nonprofit handbook: Management", pp.624~641 (2001), Wiley
- Pearce, C. L., "Verticalversusshared leadership aspredictorsoftheeffectivenessofchangemanagementteams:Anexamination of aversive, directive, transactional,transformational,andempoweringleaderbehaviors", GroupDynamics:Theory,Research,andPractice, 6(2), pp.172~197 (2002)
- Pearce, C. L., "Sharedleadership: Toward a multi-level theory ofleadership, In Advancesininterdisciplinarystudies of work teams", pp.115~139 (2000), JAIPress
- Pearce, C. L., "Leadership,socialwork and virtualteams:Therelativeinfluenceofverticalvs.sharedleadershipin thenonprofitsection, In Nonprofit Leadership" (2004), Jossey-Bass
- Pelled, L. H., "Exploring theback box:An analysisofwork group diversity,conflict,and performance", AdministrativeScienceQuarterly, 44, pp.1~28 (1999)
- Podsakoff, P. M., "Common methodbiasesin behavioralresearch:A criticalreviewsoftheliterature and recommended remedies", JournalofAppliedPsychology, 88(5), pp.879~903 (2003)
- Prahalad, C. K., "Thedominantlogic:A new linkagebetween diversityand performance", Strategic ManagementJournal, 7, pp.485~501 (1986)
- Quinn, R. E., "A spatialmodelofeffectivecriteria:Towardsacompetingvalues approach to organizational analysis", ManagementScience, 29(3), pp.363~377 (1983)
- Redmond, M., "Putting creativity to work: Effects ofleader behavior on subordinate creativity", Organizational Behavior and Human DecisionProcesses, 55(1), pp.120~151 (1993)
- Scott, S. G., "Determinantsof innovative behavior: A path model ofindividualinnovation in the workplace", AcademyofManagementJournal, 37, pp.580~607 (1994)
- Shamir. B, "The motivational effects of charismaticleadership:A selfconceptbasedtheory", OrganizationScience, 4, pp.77~94 (1993)
- Shin, S. J., "Transformationalleadership,conservation and creativity:Evidencefrom Korea", Academy of Management Journal, 46(6), pp.703~714 (2003)
- Simons, T., "Taskconflict and relationship conflict in topmanagementteams:Thepivotalroleofintragrouptrust", Journal of Applied Psychology, 85(1), pp.102~111 (2000)
- Sivasubramaniam, N., "A longitudinalmodelof the effects of team leadership and grouppotency on group performance", Group &OrganizationManagement, 27, pp.66~96 (2002)
- Sosik, J. J., "Inspiring group creativity", SmallGroupResearch, 29(1), pp.3~31 (1998)
- Steers, R. M., "OrganizationaleffectivenessA behavioralview" (1977), GoodyearPublishingCompany
- Stein, R. T., "Anempiricalanalysis of the correlation between leadershipstatus and participation rates reported in theliterature", Journal of Personality and SocialPsychology, 37, pp.1993~2002 (1979)
- Tierney, P., "An examination of leadership andemployee creativity:The relevance oftraitsandrelationships", PersonnelPsychology, 52, pp.591~620 (1999)
- Vandewaerde, M., "Board teamleadershiprevisited:A conceptualmodelofsharedleadership in theboardroom", JournalofBusinessEthics, 104, pp.403~420 (2011)
- Wang, Y. S., "Therelationship of transformational leadership withgroup cohesiveness and emotional intelligence", SocialBehaviorandPersonality:AnInternationalJournal, 37(3), pp.379~392 (2009)
- Weick, K. E., "Leadership as thelegitimation of doubt, In Thefutureofleadership" (2001), Jossey-Bass
- Yammarino, F. J., "Group leadership:Amultiplelevelsofanalysisperspective, In The Handbook of Work GroupPsychology", pp.189~224 (1996), Wiley
- Yeatts, D., "High-PerformingSelf-managed Work Teams: A comparison ofTheory" (1998), Sage
- Yukl, G., "Leadershipinorganizations(7thEds)" (2006), PearsonEducation
- Zhang, X., "Linking transformational leadership and teamperformance: A conflict management approach", Journal of Management Studies, 48(7), pp.1586~1611 (2011)
- Zhou, J., "When jobdissatisfactionleadstocreativity:Encouragingtheexpression of voice", Academy of ManagementJournal, 44(4), pp.682~696 (2001)
