문제바탕학습에서 튜터평가는 시험이 측정하는 것과는 다른 학습의 양상을 측정하고 있는가?
Does Tutor Evaluation in the PBL Course Assess Different Aspects of Learning from What Written Examination Assesses?
4
조회
0
다운로드
3
인용
0
참고문헌
초록
Abstract
Purpose: This study was aimed to examine whether tutor evaluation in the PBL course assesses different aspects of learning from what written examination assesses. Methods: 89 medical students were assessed by Self-Directed Learning Readiness Scale (SDLRS) and Learning Orientation Scale(LOS) in March 2004. Their tutor evaluation and written examination scores in the 1st semester of 2004 PBL units were collected in August 2004. Data analyses were conducted using t-test, correlation analysis, and linear regression. Results: SDLRS scores were significantly correlated with tutor evaluation scores, but not with written examination scores. Both schoolwork orientation and academic orientation scores on LOS were significantly associated with tutor evaluation and written examination scores. Tutor evaluation scores were explained significantly by all predictors, such as SDLRS, schoolwork orientation, and academic orientation scores. However, written examination scores were explained significantly by academic orientation only. Conclusions: Tutor evaluation in the PBL assessed student self-directed learning readiness and academic orientation, but written examination did not. The findings show a crucial possibility that tutor evaluation may overcome shortcomings of the written examination.
참고문헌 (29)
- "PBL 평가방안", pp.40~59 (2004), 가천의과대학교 교육개발연구센터.
- "문제중심학습에서 평가방법의 개선방향", 9, pp.73~85 (1997)
- "문제중심학습(Problem-based learning) 교육학적 명분과 우리나라에서의 실제", pp.79~94 (2004), 가천의과대학교 교육개발연구센터
- "학생반응으로 살펴본 문제바탕학습 교육과정의 질적 평가", 16, pp.179~194 (2004)
- "대학교육과 도덕판단력의 관계 연구" (2004)
- "계명대학교 의과대학에서의 문제중심학습 시행 경험", 12, pp.261~270 (2000)
- "문제중심학습 튜터 훈련 워크샵 자료집" (2004), 서울의대 의학교육연수원
- "PBL 교수 Workshop 자료집" (2003), 성균관대학교 의과대학
- "성인학습자의 자기주도성과 인구학적 및 사회심리학적 변인 연구" (1997)
- "인제의과대학에서 PBL교육의 경험과 자체 평가", 10, pp.351~362 (1998)
- "경북대학교 의과대학의 문제중심학습 시행과 그 평가", 13, pp.91~105 (2001)
- "충북대학교 의과대학에서의 문제중심학습의 실행 및 평가", 11, pp.285~295 (1999)
- "임상의학교육과정 내 기초학문 회귀교육과정개발 연구 Ⅰ: 본과 1학년생의 자기주도성 분석", 15, pp.221~ (2003)
- "교육심리학용어사전" (2000), 학지사
- "Effectiveness of Problem-based learning curricula: research and theory", 75, pp.259~266 (2000)
- "University of Minnesota" (1987)
- "Developing and evaluating the student assessment system in the preclinical problem-based curriculum at Sherbrooke", 71, pp.274~283 (1996)
- "Multiple approached to assessment reflections on use of tutor Teaching in Higher Education", 6, pp.229~246 (2001)
- "The effectiveness of PBL", 37, pp.1131~1132 (2003)
- "Effect of an undergraduate medical curriculum on students' self-directed learning", 78, pp.1259~1265 (2003)
- "Development and validation of an evaluation instrument for medical students in tutorials", 71, pp.488~494 (1996)
- "Moral development in the professions" (1994)
- "A lesson from the introduction of a problem-based the effects of different views of self-direction", 33, pp.801~807 (1999)
- "Measuring Inter-rater reliability of the sequenced performance inventory and reflective assessment of learning", 78, pp.844~850 (2003)
- "Handbook of moral behavior and development" (1991)
- "looking at outcomes with medical students", 34 (2002)
- "Interrater concordance for faculty grading of student performances in a problem-based learning course", 72, pp.150~151 (1997)
- "University of Minnesota" (1983), Unpublished doctoral dissertation
- "Assessment of student performance in problembased learning tutorial sessions", 33, pp.818~822 (1999)