문제바탕학습에서 동료평가의 활용방안
Educational Implication of Peer Evaluation in Problem-based Learning
1
조회
0
다운로드
10
인용
0
참고문헌
초록
Abstract
Purpose: This study aimed to inquire into the educational implication of peer evaluation in PBL in relation to the evaluation system. Methods: 89 third and fourth-year medical students in PBL courses participated in this study. Descriptive statistics analysis and correlation analysis were performed. Results: Based on the results of the interviews with all the forth-year students, the feedback method of peer evaluation was modified and the peer evaluation sheet was revised. On the new peer evaluation system, the percentages of indiscriminant scores were significantly lower than those on the previous system. Peer evaluation on the new evaluation system was positively related to tutor evaluation, written examination, and quizzes. Correlations between the peer evaluation scores each units were higher than those of the tutor evaluation scores. All third-year students within the bottom ten percent on the peer evaluation score failed to successfully complete that year. Conclusion: The peer evaluation with feedback based on faculty counseling and a user- friendly evaluation sheet can be used as an effective method for assessing student performance in PBL and to screen for maladjusted students.
참고문헌 (13)
- "PBL의 평가", 40(59) (2004), 가천의과대학교 교육개발연구센터.
- "울산의대 PBL 운영현황" (2004), 서울의대 의학교육연수원.
- "문제바탕학습에서 튜터평가는 시험이 측정하는 것과는 다른 학습의 양상을 측정하고 있는가?", 17, pp.37~47 (2005)
- "PBL 동료평가 개선안" (2004)
- "고려대 의과대학 PBL" (2004), 서울의대 의학교육연수원.
- "인제의대 PBL 운영현황" (2005), 서울의대 의학교육연수원.
- "PBL에서의 평가", pp.89~102 (2002), 제12차 의학교육합동학술대회 추진위원회.
- "PBL 평가방안", pp.60~65 (2004), 가천의과대학교 교육개발연구센터.
- "문제중심학습에서 학생평가에 대한 신뢰도 및 타당도 연구" (2005)
- ". Strategies for student assessment. In David Boud . The challenge of problem based learning. New York" (1991), St. Martin's Press.
- ". Self and peer assessment in tutorials application of a relative-ranking model. Academic Medicine", 77, pp.1134~1139 (2002)
- ". Predicting academic success by behaviour in PBL. Medical Teacher", 25, pp.32~37 (2003)
- ". Peer and self assessment during problem-based tutorials. The American Journal of Surgery", 177, pp.266~269 (1999)