Identifying teaching competencies for medical residents using a modified Delphi method
1
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Purpose: This study aimed to identify the teaching competencies of medical residents.Methods: A modified Delphi study was conducted from January to March 2017. Twenty-four panelists (six medical educators, program directors, chief residents, and residents each) from various facilities in Japan participated in the study. The consensus criterion for this study was that more than 80% of the panelists gave a rating of 6 or higher on the 7-point Likert scale (“not at all important” to “extremely important”) without any comments. The modified Delphi approach resulted in a list of 27 resident teaching competencies after three rounds. These competencies were categorized based on Harden and Crosby’s 12 roles of medical teachers.Results: Our study revealed that, of the 12 roles, residents were primarily viewed as “clinical or practical teachers,” “teaching role models,” “on-the-job role models,” “learning facilitators,” and “student assessors.”Conclusion: The 27 resident teaching competencies indicate the importance of educational proximity for residents as teachers. It is expected that this finding will contribute to competency-based resident-as-teacher education.
Abstract
Purpose: This study aimed to identify the teaching competencies of medical residents.Methods: A modified Delphi study was conducted from January to March 2017. Twenty-four panelists (six medical educators, program directors, chief residents, and residents each) from various facilities in Japan participated in the study. The consensus criterion for this study was that more than 80% of the panelists gave a rating of 6 or higher on the 7-point Likert scale (“not at all important” to “extremely important”) without any comments. The modified Delphi approach resulted in a list of 27 resident teaching competencies after three rounds. These competencies were categorized based on Harden and Crosby’s 12 roles of medical teachers.Results: Our study revealed that, of the 12 roles, residents were primarily viewed as “clinical or practical teachers,” “teaching role models,” “on-the-job role models,” “learning facilitators,” and “student assessors.”Conclusion: The 27 resident teaching competencies indicate the importance of educational proximity for residents as teachers. It is expected that this finding will contribute to competency-based resident-as-teacher education.
참고문헌 (31)
- Harden RM, "AMEE Guide No 20 : the good teacher is more than a lecturer : the twelve roles of the teacher", Med Teach, 22(4), pp.334~347 (2000)
- Kikukawa M, "The characteristics of a good clinical teacher as perceived by resident physicians in Japan : a qualitative study", BMC Med Educ, 13, pp.100~ (2013)
- Ramani S, "Residents as teachers : near peer learning in clinical work settings : AMEE Guide No. 106", Med Teach, 38(7), pp.642~655 (2016)
- "Functions and structure of a medical school" (2020)[URL]
- "ACGME Common Program Requirements" (2023)[URL]
- "New Guideline of Japanese Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare for clinical teacher 2020 ver" (2020)[URL]
- Jewett LS, "Teaching residents how to teach : a one-year study", J Med Educ, 57(5), pp.361~366 (1982)
- Al Achkar M, "Changing trends in residents-as-teachers across graduate medical education", Adv Med Educ Pract, 8, pp.299~306 (2017)
- Ishak WW, "Burnout during residency training : a literature review", J Grad Med Educ, 1(2), pp.236~242 (2009)
- Fromme HB, "Pediatric residentas-teacher curricula : a national survey of existing programs and future needs", J Grad Med Educ, 3(2), pp.168~175 (2011)
- McKeon BA, "A consensus guideline to support resident-as-teacher programs and enhance the culture of teaching and learning", J Grad Med Educ, 11(3), pp.313~318 (2019)
- Hoffman LA, "A novel resident-as-teacher curriculum to improve residents’integration into the clinic", PRiMER, 3, pp.9~ (2019)
- Morrison EH, "A pilot randomized, controlled trial of a longitudinal residents-asteachers curriculum", Acad Med, 78(7), pp.722~729 (2003)
- Humphrey-Murto S, "Using consensus group methods such as Delphi and nominal group in medical education research", Med Teach, 39(1), pp.14~19 (2017)
- Srinivasan M, ""Teaching as a competency" : competencies for medical educators", Acad Med, 86(10), pp.1211~1220 (2011)
- Karani R, "How medical students learn from residents in the workplace : a qualitative study", Acad Med, 89(3), pp.490~496 (2014)
- Melvin L, "What makes a great resident teacher? : a multicenter survey of medical students attending an internal medicine conference", J Grad Med Educ, 6(4), pp.694~697 (2014)
- Veugelers R, "Improving design choices in Delphi studies in medicine : the case of an exemplary physician multi-round panel study with 100% response", BMC Med Res Methodol, 20(1), pp.156~ (2020)
- Bland CJ, "Characteristics of the successful researcher and implications for faculty development", J Med Educ, 61(1), pp.22~31 (1986)
- Harris DL, "Academic competencies for medical faculty", Fam Med, 39(5), pp.343~350 (2007)
- Bing-You RG, "Commentary : principle-based teaching competencies", J Grad Med Educ, 1(1), pp.100~103 (2009)
- Williams KF, "A textbook for today’s chief medical resident" (2013), Alliance for Academic Internal Medicine
- "Guideline of Japanese Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare regarding competencies of clinical teachers" (2018)[URL]
- Penciner R, "Using a Delphi process to establish consensus on emergency medicine clerkship competencies", Med Teach, 33(6), pp.e333~e339 (2011)
- Brink D, "Teaching competencies for community preceptors", Fam Med, 50(5), pp.359~363 (2018)
- Ten Cate O, "Peer teaching in medical education : twelve reasons to move from theory to practice", Med Teach, 29(6), pp.591~599 (2007)
- Lockspeiser TM, "Understanding the experience of being taught by peers : the value of social and cognitive congruence", Adv Health Sci Educ Theory Pract, 13(3), pp.361~372 (2008)
- Bulte C, "Student teaching : views of student near-peer teachers and learners", Med Teach, 29(6), pp.583~590 (2007)
- Miller GE, "The assessment of clinical skills", competence, Acad Med, pp.1990, 65(9 Suppl)[DOI]
- Maeno T, "Interprofessional education in medical schools in Japan", PLoS One, 14(1), pp.e0210912~ (2019)
- Hashimoto T, "Cross-sectional study of the educational roles of residents in the new medical specialty program", Med Educ, 53(1), pp.71~75 (2022)