The application of augmented reality for improving clinical skills: a scoping review
2
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Augmented reality technology had developed rapidly in recent years and had been applied in many fields, including medical education. Augmented reality had potential to improve students’ knowledge and skills in medical education. This scoping review primarily aims to further elaborate the current studies on the implementation of augmented reality in advancing clinical skills. This study was conducted by utilizing electronic databases such as PubMed, Embase, and Web of Science in June 2022 for articles focusing on the use of augmented reality for improving clinical skills. The Rayyan website was used to screen the articles that met the inclusion criteria, which was the application of augmented reality as a learning method in medical education. Total of 37 articles met the inclusion criteria. These publications suggested that using augmented reality could improve clinical skills. The most researched topics explored were laparoscopic surgery skills and ophthalmology were the most studied topic. The research methods applied in the articles fall into two main categories: randomized control trial (RCT) (29.3%) and non-RCT (70.3%). Augmented reality has the potential to be integrated in medical education, particularly to boost clinical studies. Due to limited databases, however, any further studies on the implementation of augmented reality as a method to enhance skills in medical education need to be conducted.
Abstract
Augmented reality technology had developed rapidly in recent years and had been applied in many fields, including medical education. Augmented reality had potential to improve students’ knowledge and skills in medical education. This scoping review primarily aims to further elaborate the current studies on the implementation of augmented reality in advancing clinical skills. This study was conducted by utilizing electronic databases such as PubMed, Embase, and Web of Science in June 2022 for articles focusing on the use of augmented reality for improving clinical skills. The Rayyan website was used to screen the articles that met the inclusion criteria, which was the application of augmented reality as a learning method in medical education. Total of 37 articles met the inclusion criteria. These publications suggested that using augmented reality could improve clinical skills. The most researched topics explored were laparoscopic surgery skills and ophthalmology were the most studied topic. The research methods applied in the articles fall into two main categories: randomized control trial (RCT) (29.3%) and non-RCT (70.3%). Augmented reality has the potential to be integrated in medical education, particularly to boost clinical studies. Due to limited databases, however, any further studies on the implementation of augmented reality as a method to enhance skills in medical education need to be conducted.
참고문헌 (45)
- Tran B, "Educational experiences with traditional, online and hybrid learning environments", J Educ Soc Policy, 3(3), pp.60~63 (2016)
- Munzer BW, "Augmented reality in emergency medicine : a scoping review", J Med Internet Res, 21(4), pp.e12368~ (2019)
- Kurt Y, "The effect of mobile augmented reality application developed for injections on the knowledge and skill levels of nursing students : an experimental controlled study", Nurse Educ Today, 103, pp.104955~ (2021)
- Andersen DS, "Augmented reality future step visualization for robust surgical telementoring", Simul Healthc, 14(1), pp.59~66 (2019)
- Cecilio-Fernandes D, "The effects of expert and augmented feedback on learning a complex medical skill", Percept Mot Skills, 127(4), pp.766~784 (2020)
- Vera AM, "Augmented reality telementoring(ART)platform : a randomized controlled trial to assess the efficacy of a new surgical education technology", Surg Endosc, 28(12), pp.3467~3472 (2014)
- Chowriappa A, "Augmentedreality-based skills training for robot-assisted urethrovesical anastomosis : a multi-institutional randomised controlled trial", BJU Int, 115(2), pp.336~345 (2015)
- Rai AS, "Teaching binocular indirect ophthalmoscopy to novice residents using an augmented reality simulator", Can J Ophthalmol, 52(5), pp.430~434 (2017)
- Leitritz MA, "Critical evaluation of the usability of augmented reality ophthalmoscopy for the training of inexperienced examiners", Retina, 34(4), pp.785~791 (2014)
- Menozzi M, "Development of ophthalmic microsurgery training in augmented reality", Klin Monbl Augenheilkd, 237(4), pp.388~391 (2020)
- Mladenovic R, "Effectiveness of augmented reality mobile simulator in teaching local anesthesia of inferior alveolar nerve block", J Dent Educ, 83(4), pp.423~428 (2019)
- Sugand K, "Training and transfer effect of FluoroSim, an augmented reality fluoroscopic simulator for dynamic hip screw guidewire insertion : a single-blinded randomized controlled trial", J Bone Joint Surg Am, 101(17), pp.e88~ (2019)
- Wolf J, "Comparing the effectiveness of augmented reality-based and conventional instructions during single ECMO cannulation training", Int J Comput Assist Radiol Surg, 16(7), pp.1171~1180 (2021)
- Ienghong K, "Practical emergency ultrasound flashcards with augmented reality in teaching point-of-care ultrasound in ER", Open Access Maced J Med Sci, 9(E), pp.39~42 (2021)
- Yudkowsky R, "Practice on an augmented reality", haptic simulator and library of virtual brains improves residents’ ability to perform a ventriculostomy, 2013, pp.8(1), 25~31
- Volonté F, "Augmented reality and image overlay navigation with OsiriX in laparoscopic and robotic surgery : not only a matter of fashion", J Hepatobiliary Pancreat Sci, 18(4), pp.506~509 (2011)
- Ropelato S, "Augmented reality microsurgery : a tool for training micromanipulations in ophthalmic surgery using augmented reality", Simul Healthc, 15(2), pp.122~127 (2020)
- Yong M, "Application of augmented reality to surgical practice : a pilot study using the ODG R7 Smartglasses", Clin Otolaryngol, 45(1), pp.130~134 (2020)
- Broekema TH, "Laparoscopy instructional videos : the effect of preoperative compared with intraoperative use on learning curves", J Surg Educ, 74(1), pp.91~99 (2017)
- Heinrich F, "HoloPointer : a virtual augmented reality pointer for laparoscopic surgery training", Int J Comput Assist Radiol Surg, 16(1), pp.161~168 (2021)
- Botden SM, "Suturing training in augmented reality : gaining proficiency in suturing skills faster", Surg Endosc, 23(9), pp.2131~2137 (2009)
- Oostema JA, "Time-efficient laparoscopic skills assessment using an augmented-reality simulator", Surg Endosc, 22(12), pp.2621~2624 (2008)
- Nomura T, "Laparoscopic skill improvement after virtual reality simulator training in medical students as assessed by augmented reality simulator", Asian J Endosc Surg, 8(4), pp.408~412 (2015)
- Albrecht UV, "Effects of mobile augmented reality learning compared to textbook learning on medical students : randomized controlled pilot study", J Med Internet Res, 15(8), pp.e182~ (2013)
- Amiras D, "Augmented reality simulator for CT-guided interventions", Eur Radiol, 31(12), pp.8897~8902 (2021)
- Andersen D, "Medical telementoring using an augmented reality transparent display", Surgery, 159(6), pp.1646~1653 (2016)
- Nagayo Y, "A novel suture training system for open surgery replicating procedures performed by experts using augmented reality", J Med Syst, 45(5), pp.60~ (2021)
- Logishetty K, "Can an augmented reality headset improve accuracy of acetabular cup orientation in simulated THA? : a randomized trial", Clin Orthop Relat Res, 477(5), pp.1190~1199 (2019)
- Mu Y, "Augmented reality simulator for ultrasoundguided percutaneous renal access", Int J Comput Assist Radiol Surg, 15(5), pp.749~757 (2020)
- Müller M, "Mobile augmented reality for computer-assisted percutaneous nephrolithotomy", Int J Comput Assist Radiol Surg, 8(4), pp.663~675 (2013)
- Shakur SF, "Usefulness of a virtual reality percutaneous trigeminal rhizotomy simulator in neurosurgical training", Neurosurgery, 11(Suppl 3), pp.420~425 (2015)
- Glossop N, "Augmented reality laser projection device for surgery", Stud Health Technol Inform, 98, pp.104~110 (2004)
- Kollmann C, "A prototype of a handheld augmented reality application to get familiar with ultrasound equipment knobology", Med Ultrason, 23(4), pp.438~442 (2021)
- Kratzke IM, "Navigation improves tumor ablation performance : results from a novel liver tumor simulator study", Am Surg, 89(5), pp.1693~1700 (2023)
- Mendes HC, "PIÑATA : pinpoint insertion of intravenous needles via augmented reality training assistance", Comput Med Imaging Graph, 82, pp.101731~ (2020)
- Mladenovic R, "Effectiveness of technology-enhanced teaching methods of undergraduate dental skills for local anaesthesia administration during COVID-19 era : students’perception", BMC Oral Health, 22(1), pp.40~ (2022)
- Muangpoon T, "Augmented reality system for digital rectal examination training and assessment : system validation", J Med Internet Res, 22(8), pp.e18637~ (2020)
- Rochlen LR, "First-person point-ofview-augmented reality for central line insertion training : a usability and feasibility study", Simul Healthc, 12(1), pp.57~62 (2017)
- Wagner A, "Clinical experience with interactive teleconsultation and teleassistance in craniomaxillofacial surgical procedures", J Oral Maxillofac Surg, 57(12), pp.1413~1418 (1999)
- Zhao S, "An intelligent augmented reality training framework for neonatal endotracheal intubation", Int Symp Mix Augment Real, 2020, pp.672~681 (2020)
- Barcali E, "Augmented reality in surgery : a scoping review", Appl Sci, 12(14), pp.6890~ (2022)
- Park BJ, "Augmented reality improves procedural efficiency and reduces radiation dose for CT-guided lesion targeting : a phantom study using HoloLens 2", Sci Rep, 10(1), pp.18620~ (2020)
- Kovoor JG, "Validity and effectiveness of augmented reality in surgical education : a systematic review", Surgery, 170(1), pp.88~98 (2021)
- El-Sabawi B, "The evolution of surgical telementoring : current applications and future directions", Ann Transl Med, 4(20), pp.391~ (2016)
- Villagran-Vizcarra DC, "Applications analyses, challenges and development of augmented reality in education, industry, marketing, medicine, and entertainment", Appl Sci, 13(5), pp.2766~ (2023)