CalTOX 모델에 의한 휘발성유기화합물의 대기 중 예측 농도와 실측 농도간의 타당성 분석에 관한 연구
A Study on Analyzing the Validity between the Predicted and Measured Concentrations of VOCs in the Atmosphere Using the CalTOX Model
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Objectives: This study calculated local residents exposures to VOCs (Volatile Organic Compounds) released into the atmosphere using the CalTOX model and carried out uncertainty analysis and sensitivity analysis. The model validity was analyzed by comparing the predicted and the actual atmospheric concentrations. Methods: Uncertainty was parsed by conducting a Monte Carlo simulation. Sensitivity was dissected with the regression (coefficients) method. The model validity was analyzed by applying r2 (coefficient of determination), RMSE (root mean square error), and the Nash-Sutcliffe EI (efficiency index) formula. Results: Among the concentrations in the atmosphere in this study, benzene was the highest and the lifetime average daily dose of benzene and the average daily dose of xylene were high. In terms of the sensitivity analysis outcome, the source term to air, exposure time, indoors resting (ETri), exposure time, outdoors at home (ETao), yearly average wind speed (v_w), contaminated area in m2 (Area), active breathing rate (BRa), resting breathing rate (BRr), exposure time, and active indoors (ETai) were elicited as input variables having great influence upon this model. In consequence of inspecting the validity of the model, r2 appeared to be a value close to 1 and RMSE appeared to be a value close to 0, but EI indicated unacceptable model efficiency. To supplement this value, the regression formula was derived for benzene with y=0.002+15.48x, ethylbenzene with y ≡ 0.001+57.240x, styrene with y=0.000+42.249x, toluene with y=0.004+91.588x, and xylene with y=0.000+ 0.007x. Conclusions: In consequence of inspecting the validity of the model, r2 appeared to be a value close to 1 and RMSE appeared to be a value close to 0, but EI indicated unacceptable model efficiency. This will be able to be used as base data for securing the accuracy and reliability of the model.
Abstract
Objectives: This study calculated local residents exposures to VOCs (Volatile Organic Compounds) released into the atmosphere using the CalTOX model and carried out uncertainty analysis and sensitivity analysis. The model validity was analyzed by comparing the predicted and the actual atmospheric concentrations. Methods: Uncertainty was parsed by conducting a Monte Carlo simulation. Sensitivity was dissected with the regression (coefficients) method. The model validity was analyzed by applying r2 (coefficient of determination), RMSE (root mean square error), and the Nash-Sutcliffe EI (efficiency index) formula. Results: Among the concentrations in the atmosphere in this study, benzene was the highest and the lifetime average daily dose of benzene and the average daily dose of xylene were high. In terms of the sensitivity analysis outcome, the source term to air, exposure time, indoors resting (ETri), exposure time, outdoors at home (ETao), yearly average wind speed (v_w), contaminated area in m2 (Area), active breathing rate (BRa), resting breathing rate (BRr), exposure time, and active indoors (ETai) were elicited as input variables having great influence upon this model. In consequence of inspecting the validity of the model, r2 appeared to be a value close to 1 and RMSE appeared to be a value close to 0, but EI indicated unacceptable model efficiency. To supplement this value, the regression formula was derived for benzene with y=0.002+15.48x, ethylbenzene with y ≡ 0.001+57.240x, styrene with y=0.000+42.249x, toluene with y=0.004+91.588x, and xylene with y=0.000+ 0.007x. Conclusions: In consequence of inspecting the validity of the model, r2 appeared to be a value close to 1 and RMSE appeared to be a value close to 0, but EI indicated unacceptable model efficiency. This will be able to be used as base data for securing the accuracy and reliability of the model.
참고문헌 (49)
- "Korea Industrial Complex Corporation"[URL]
- 이병준, "산업단지 및 일반생활 지역의 공기 중 톨루엔에 대한 개인노출 및 생체시료의 상관성 분석", 한국환경보건학회지, 43(4), pp.324~333 (2017), 한국환경보건학회
- Lopez-Aparicio S, "Assessment of discrepancies between bottom-up and regional emission inventories in norwegian urban areas", Atmos Environ, 154, pp.285~296 (2017)
- Phetxumphou K, "Subtleties of human exposure and response to chemical mixtures from spills", Environ Pollut, 214, pp.618~626 (2016)
- 김현지, "주요 산업단지의 화학물질 배출량 특성에 관한 연구", 한국환경보건학회지, 44(6), pp.515~523 (2018), 한국환경보건학회
- 박지훈, "흡입 노출 모델 알고리즘의 구성과 시나리오 노출량 비교", 한국산업보건학회지, 29(3), pp.358~367 (2019), 한국산업보건학회[DOI]
- US NRC, "Frontiers in assessing human exposures to environmental toxicants" (1991), National Academy Press
- "WHO" (2000)[URL]
- WHO, "Harmonization project strategic plan: harmonization of approaches to the assessment of risk from exposure to chemicals", ~ (2012)
- Robert G. Sargent, "Verification and validation of simulation models", Proceedings of the 30th Conference on Winter Simulation Conference (1998)
- Thomas E. McKone, "Tracking multiple pathways of human exposure to persistent multimedia pollutants: regional, continental, and global-scale models", Annu. Rev. Environ. Resour, 28, pp.463~492 (2003)
- US NRC, "Models in environmental regulatory decision making" (2007), The National Academies Press
- US EPA, "Guidance on the development, evaluation, and application of environmental models", Office of the Science Advisor. Council for Regulatory Environmental Modeling, ~ (2009)
- US EPA, "Guidelines for human exposure assessment", Risk Assessment Forum, ~ (1992)
- Schlesinger S, "Terminology for model credibility", Simulation, 32(3), pp.103~104 (1979)
- US EPA, "Framework for human health risk assessment to inform decision making", Office of the Science Advisor. Risk Assessment Forum, ~ (2014)
- Beven JK, "Rainfall-runoff modelling-the primer" (2001), John Wiley & Sons Ltd
- 양지연, "다매체", 다경로 모델을 이용한 도시지역에서의 다이옥신 인체노출량 예측 연구, 연세대학교 대학원, pp.보건학, 2001
- 문지영, "다매체", 다경로 노출을 고려한 benzo(a)pyrene의 총 인체 노출량 예측, 2003, pp.18(4), 255~269[DOI]
- Kim O, "A multimedia & multiple pathway estimating human exposure of benzo(a)pyrene by using CalTOX model, focused on the fuel combustion in Seosan area", pp.2017
- 김옥, "CalTOX 모델을 이용한 벤젠 종합위해성평가의 불확실성 분석과 민감도 분석", 한국환경보건학회지, 46(2), pp.136~149 (2020), 한국환경보건학회[DOI]
- Song YH, "Assessment of integrated human risk of heavy metals emitted from coal-fired power plant using 3MRA model", pp.2018
- "Ministry of environment"[URL]
- 김옥, "기상변수들의 확률밀도함수(PDF)에 따른 CalTOX모델을 이용한 BTEX 인체노출량 및 인체위해성 평가 연구", 한국환경보건학회지, 45(5), pp.497~510 (2019), 한국환경보건학회[DOI]
- Nash JE, "River flow forecasting through conceptual models part I-A discussion of principles", Journal of Hydrology, 10(3), pp.282~290 (1970)
- Xiaohui Zhong, "Engaging Nash-Sutcliffe efficiency and model efficiency factor indicators in selecting and validating effective light rail system operation and maintenance cost models", Journal of Traffic and Transportation Engineering, 3, pp.255~265 (2015)
- Krause P, "Comparison of different efficiency criteria for hydrological model assessment", Adv. Geosci, 5, pp.89~97 (2005)
- Lee SB, "Comparative evaluation of runoff and water quality using HSPF and SWMM", Water Sci Technol, 62(6), pp.1401~1409 (2010)
- Legates DR, "Evaluating the use of ‘Goodness-of-Fit’ measures in hydrologic and hydroclimatic model validation", Water Resources Research, 35(1), pp.233~241 (1999)
- ASCE, "Criteria for evaluation of watershed models", J Irrig Drain Eng, 119(3), pp.429~442 (1993)
- Moriasi DN, "Model evaluation guidelines for systematic qualification of accuracy in watershed simulations", American Society of Agricultural and Biological engineers, 50(3), pp.885~900 (2007)
- Servat E, "Selection of calibration objective functions in the context of rainfall-runoff modeling in a sudanese savannah area", Hydrological Science Journal, 36(4), pp.307~330 (1991)
- US EPA, "Risk assessment guidance for superfund volume I: human health evaluation manual (Part F, supplemental guidance for inhalation risk assessment)", Office of Superfund Remediation and Technology Innovation, ~ (2009)
- The ConsExpo spray model-Modelling and experimental validation of the inhalation exposure of consumers to aerosols from spray cans and trigger sprays, "Delmaar JE", RIVM, ~ (2009)
- Delmaar J, "First tier modeling of consumer dermal exposure to substances in consumer articles under reach : A quantitative evaluation of the ECETOC TRA for consumers tool", Regul Toxicol Pharm, 65(1), pp.79~86 (2013)
- Riedmann R, "Sensitivity analysis, dominant factors, and robustness of the ECETOC TRA v3, Stoffenmanager 4.5, and ART 1.5occupational exposure models", Risk Anal, 35(2), pp.211~225 (2015)
- CalTOX, A Multimedia Total Exposure Model for Hazardous-Waste Sites Part I: Executive Summary, "McKone TE", California Environmental Protection Agency DTSC, ~ (1993)
- Davis PA, "Approaches for the validation of models used for performance assessment of high-level nuclear waste repositories", ~ (1991)
- 박진현, "Monte-Carlo 모의실험을 통한 부분 인구집단별 벤젠 및 PM10의 노출 및 위해성 평가", 한국환경보건학회지, 45(3), pp.247~257 (2019), 한국환경보건학회[DOI]
- 류현수, "한국 학생들의 시간활동 양상 평가", 한국환경보건학회지, 44(2), pp.143~152 (2018), 한국환경보건학회
- 이보람, "대기오염물질 개인노출 평가를 위한 시간", 장소 조사방법의 고찰, 2016, pp.42(5), 314~323[DOI]
- Annual Report of Quality in Korea 2018, "National Institute of Environmetal Research", National Institute of Environmetal Research, ~ (2019)
- National Institute of Environmental Research, "National air pollutant emission calculation method manual (III)", National Institute of Environmental Research, ~ (2013)
- 황문영, "주거환경 및 개인 생활습관에 따른 화학물질 노출수준 차이 - 국민환경보건기초조사", 한국환경보건학회지, 45(2), pp.142~153 (2019), 한국환경보건학회[DOI]
- "ASOS"[URL]
- "Korea Ststistical Information Service"[URL]
- National Institute of Environmental Research, "Korean exposure factors handbook", ~ (2019)
- CalTOX, A multimedia total-exposure model for hazardous-waste sites Part III : The multiple-pathway exposure model, "McKone TE", ~ (1992)
- National Institute of Environmental Research, "Korean exposure factors handbook for children", ~ (2019)