화평법에 따른 급성 수생독성 예측을 위한 QSAR 모델의 활용 가능성 연구
Applicability of QSAR Models for Acute Aquatic Toxicity under the Act on Registration, Evaluation, etc. of Chemicals in the Republic of Korea
2
조회
0
다운로드
1
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Background: A quantitative structure-activity relationship (QSAR) model was adopted in the Registration, Evaluation, Authorization, and Restriction of Chemicals (REACH, EU) regulations as well as the Act on Registration, Evaluation, etc. of Chemicals (AREC, Republic of Korea). It has been previously used in the registration of chemicals. Objectives: In this study, we investigated the correlation between the predicted data provided by three prediction programs using a QSAR model and actual experimental results (acute fish, daphnia magna toxicity). Through this approach, we aimed to effectively conjecture on the performance and determine the most applicable programs when designating toxic substances through the AREC. Methods: Chemicals that had been registered and evaluated in the Toxic Chemicals Control Act (TCCA, Republic of Korea) were selected for this study. Two prediction programs developed and operated by the U.S. EPA – the Ecological Structure-Activity Relationship (ECOSAR) and Toxicity Estimation Software Tool (T.E.S.T.) models – were utilized along with the TOPKAT (Toxicity Prediction by Komputer Assisted Technology) commercial program. The applicability of these three programs was evaluated according to three parameters: accuracy, sensitivity, and specificity. Results: The prediction analysis on fish and daphnia magna in the three programs showed that the TOPKAT program had better sensitivity than the others. Conclusions: Although the predictive performance of the TOPKAT program when using a single predictive program was found to perform well in toxic substance designation, using a single program involves many restrictions. It is necessary to validate the reliability of predictions by utilizing multiple methods when applying the prediction program to the regulation of chemicals.
Abstract
Background: A quantitative structure-activity relationship (QSAR) model was adopted in the Registration, Evaluation, Authorization, and Restriction of Chemicals (REACH, EU) regulations as well as the Act on Registration, Evaluation, etc. of Chemicals (AREC, Republic of Korea). It has been previously used in the registration of chemicals. Objectives: In this study, we investigated the correlation between the predicted data provided by three prediction programs using a QSAR model and actual experimental results (acute fish, daphnia magna toxicity). Through this approach, we aimed to effectively conjecture on the performance and determine the most applicable programs when designating toxic substances through the AREC. Methods: Chemicals that had been registered and evaluated in the Toxic Chemicals Control Act (TCCA, Republic of Korea) were selected for this study. Two prediction programs developed and operated by the U.S. EPA – the Ecological Structure-Activity Relationship (ECOSAR) and Toxicity Estimation Software Tool (T.E.S.T.) models – were utilized along with the TOPKAT (Toxicity Prediction by Komputer Assisted Technology) commercial program. The applicability of these three programs was evaluated according to three parameters: accuracy, sensitivity, and specificity. Results: The prediction analysis on fish and daphnia magna in the three programs showed that the TOPKAT program had better sensitivity than the others. Conclusions: Although the predictive performance of the TOPKAT program when using a single predictive program was found to perform well in toxic substance designation, using a single program involves many restrictions. It is necessary to validate the reliability of predictions by utilizing multiple methods when applying the prediction program to the regulation of chemicals.
참고문헌 (41)
- Toxic Chemicals Control Act, Rep, "Ministry of Environment", Ministry of Environment, ~ (2012)
- Ministry of Environment, "Act on Registration, Evaluation, ETC. of Chemicals" (2018), Ministry of Environment
- Pizzo F, "In silico models for predicting ready biodegradability under REACH: a comparative study", Sci Total Environ, 463-464, pp.161~168 (2013)
- Dearden J, "Prediction of environmental toxicity and fate using quantitative structure-activity relationships (QSARs)", J Braz Chem Soc, 13(6), pp.754~762 (2002)
- 옥환석, "정량적 구조 활성관계(QSAR) 모델개발 동향과 농약", 농약과학회지, 15(1), pp.68~85 (2011), 한국농약과학회
- Lozano S, "Prediction of acute toxicity in fish by using QSAR methods and chemical modes of action", J Enzyme Inhib Med Chem, 25(2), pp.195~203 (2010)
- 김정곤, "OECD QSAR Application Toolbox를 이용한 화학물질의 건강유해성 및 생태독성 예측", 한국환경보건학회지, 39(2), pp.130~137 (2013), 한국환경보건학회[DOI]
- de Roode D, "QSARs in ecotoxicological risk assessment", Regul Toxicol Pharmacol, 45(1), pp.24~35 (2006)
- Khan K, "QSAR modeling of Daphnia magna and fish toxicities of biocides using 2D descriptors", Chemosphere, 229, pp.8~17 (2019)
- Khan K, "QSAR modeling of Daphnia magna and fish toxicities of biocides using 2D descriptors", Erratum in: Chemosphere, 237, pp.124397~ (2019)
- "Ecological Structure-Activity Relationships Program (ECOSAR) Methodology Document v2.0"[URL]
- Melnikov F, "Assessment of predictive models for estimating the acute aquatic toxicity of organic chemicals", Green Chem, 18, pp.4432~4445 (2016)
- Golbamaki A, "Comparison of in silico models for prediction of Daphnia magna acute toxicity", SAR QSAR Environ Res, 25(8), pp.673~694 (2014)
- Kim HK, "A Study on Structural Alerts and Application of (Q)SARs for Mutagenicity Screening" (2011), National Institute of Environmental Research
- 이진욱, "TOPKAT®, Derek®, OECD toolbox를 활용한 화학물질 독성 예측 연구", 한국환경보건학회지, 45(5), pp.457~464 (2019), 한국환경보건학회[DOI]
- "Predictive Toxicology in Discovery Studio"[URL]
- Netzeva T, Worth A, "Classification of Phthalates According to Their (Q)SAR Predicted Acute Toxicity to Fish: A Case Study" (2007), European Commission Directorate General Joint Research Centre
- Rorije E, "Evaluation and application of models for the prediction of ready biodegradability in the MITI-I test", Chemosphere, 38(6), pp.1409~1417 (1999)
- Sung CH, "Study on the Improvement of Genotoxicity Prediction Using QSARs Models" (2017), National Institute of Environmental Research
- Tunkel J, "Practical considerations on the use of predictive models for regulatory purposes", Environ Sci Technol, 39(7), pp.2188~2199 (2005)
- "User’s Guide for T.E.S.T. 2016, Ver.4.2"[URL]
- Moore DR, "A comparison of model performance for six quantitative structure-activity relationship packages that predict acute toxicity to fish", Environ Toxicol Chem, 22(8), pp.1799~1809 (2003)
- Cappelli CI, "Assessment of in silico models for acute aquatic toxicity towards fish under REACH regulation", SAR QSAR Environ Res, 26(12), pp.977~999 (2015)
- Burden N, "The utility of QSARs in predicting acute fish toxicity of pesticide metabolites: a retrospective validation approach", Regul Toxicol Pharmacol, 80, pp.241~246 (2016)
- Talapatra SN, "Predictive acute toxicity comparison in Daphnia magna for common organic chemicals present in cosmetics by using two QSAR modeling softwares", World Sci News, 42, pp.101~118 (2016)
- Schüürmann G, "Quantitative read-across for predicting the acute fish toxicity of organic compounds", Environ Sci Technol, 45(10), pp.4616~4622 (2011)
- Sheffield TY, "Ensemble QSAR modeling to predict multispecies fish toxicity lethal concentrations and points of departure", Environ Sci Technol, 53(21), pp.12793~12802 (2019)
- Ferrari T, "QSARpy: a new flexible algorithm to generate QSAR models based on dissimilarities", The log Kow case study. Sci Total Environ, 637-638, pp.1158~1165 (2018)
- Zuriaga E, "QSAR modelling for predicting the toxic effects of traditional and derived biomass solvents on a Danio rerio biomodel", Chemosphere, 227, pp.480~488 (2019)
- Di Marzio W, "Quantitative structure-activity relationship for aromatic hydrocarbons on freshwater fish", Ecotoxicol Environ Saf, 59(2), pp.256~262 (2004)
- Schultz TW, "Relative toxicity of para-substituted phenols: log KOW and pKa-dependent structure-activity relationships", Bull Environ Contam Toxicol, 38(6), pp.994~999 (1987)
- Reuschenbach P, "ECOSAR model performance with a large test set of industrial chemicals", Chemosphere, 8(71), pp.1986~1995 (2008)
- Hrovat M, "Variability of in vivo fish acute toxicity data", Regul Toxicol Pharmacol, 54(3), pp.294~300 (2009)
- Devillers J, "Structural alerts for estimating the carcinogenicity of pesticides and biocides", SAR QSAR Environ Res, 22(1-2), pp.89~106 (2011)
- Cronin MT, "(Q)SARs to predict environmental toxicities: current status and future needs", Environ Sci Process Impacts, 19(3), pp.213~220 (2017)
- Pradeep P, "An ensemble model of QSAR tools for regulatory risk assessment", J Cheminform, 8, pp.48~ (2016)
- 김광연, "Assessment of quantitative structure-activity relationship of toxicity prediction models for Korean chemical substance control legislation", 환경독성보건학회지, 30, pp.1~10 (2015), 환경독성보건학회
- Kim HK, "Study on the Best Application of (Q)SARs to Predict Aquatic Toxicity of Organic Chemicals" (2010), National Institute of Environmental Research
- Sung CH, "Study on the Improvement of Mutagenicity Prediction Using QSAR Models" (2016), National Institute of Environmental Research
- Sung CH, "A Study for the Improvement of a Prediction Using QSAR Models to Find Out Hazardous Substances(I)" (2018), National Institute of Environmental Research
- 김지영, "전자산업에서 사용하는 화학물질의 독성예측을 위한 QSAR 접근법", 한국환경보건학회지, 40(2), pp.105~113 (2014), 한국환경보건학회[DOI]
