본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

복지국가 보건의료 정책의 정치경제학: 1979년부터 2010년까지 영국의 보수당 정부와 신 노동당정부의 National Health Service 개혁을 중심으로

The Political Economy of Healthcare Policy of the Welfare State: National Health Service Reform by the Conservative and New Labour Governments from 1979 to 2010

0

조회

0

다운로드

0

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

주제분류정책학

초록

본 논문의 목적은 1979년부터 2010년까지 영국의 보수당과 신 노동당 정부의 NHS 개혁정책 분석을 통해 복지국가 보건의료 정책의 정치경제적 역동성을 고찰하고, 복지정치의 이분법적 논리 재고의 필요성을 밝히기 위한 것이다. 두 정부가 발행한 백서 등 정책 보고서, 전당대회 원고, 법안 등을 분석한 결과, 보수당 정부는 NHS 행정 조직 및 권력 구조를 분권화하고, 기업 경영 원리와 내부 시장 도입을 통해 운영 방식을 개혁하였으며, 신 노동당 정부는 NHS 행정 조직 및 권력 구조의 분권화를 확대하고, 기업 경영 원리와 내부 시장 확대를 통해 운영 방식을 개혁하였다. 두 정부가 상이한 정치 이데올로기에 기반 하여 복지 정책에 대한 시각이 상반됨에도 불구하고, NHS를 유사하게 개혁했다는 분석 결과는 상반되는 두 정치 세력의 복지정치에 대한 기존의 이분법적 접근이 보다 다양한 스펙트럼을 수용할 수 있는 시각으로 수정되어야 함을 시사한다.

Abstract

This research aims not only to examine the political economic dynamics of healthcare policy in the welfare state but also to argue to reconsider the dichotomous perspective of the welfare politics. The research focuses on the issue by analysing the NHS reform carried by the Conservative and New Labour Governments from May 1979 to April 2010. Content analysis shows that the Conservative Government decentralized both the organization of administration and the structure of the power in administration. In addition, the government renewed the way of management by introducing both managerialism and internal market. The New Labour Government extended the decentralization and strengthened both managerialism and internal market. The fact that both governments reformed the NHS by using a homogeneous preference despite adhering to different political ideologies suggests that the dichotomous perspective of welfare politics should be reconsidered.

참고문헌 (113)

  1. Allan, JP., "Political partisanship and welfare state reform in advanced industrial societies", American Journal of Political Science, 48(3), pp.496~512 (2004)
  2. The private finance initiative, "Allen, G.", House of Commons Library, ~, pp.House of Commons Library Economic Policy and Statistics Section Research Paper No.117 (2001)
  3. Audit Commission, "What the doctor ordered" (1996), HMSO
  4. Bartels, LM., "Unequal Democracy" (2008), Princeton University Press
  5. Bevan, G., "The interplay between economic and political logics", Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law, 30, pp.53~78 (2005)
  6. Beveridge, WH., "Social insurance and allied services" (1942), HMSO
  7. Blair, T., "Manuscript for Labour Party conference(December)" (1997), Labour Party
  8. Blair, T., "Manuscript for Labour Party Conference(March)" (2001), Labour Party
  9. Blair, T., "Manuscript for Labour Party conference(October)" (2001), Labour Party
  10. Blair, T., "Manuscript for Labour Party conference(March)" (2003), Labour Party
  11. Boaden, N., "Primary Care" (1997), Open University Press
  12. Bonoli, G., "The Politics of Pension Reform" (2000), Cambridge University Press
  13. Boyle, S., "A Healthy Partnership", pp.6~34 (2000), IPPR
  14. Brown, G., "State and market", Political Quarterly, 74(3), pp.266~284 (2003)
  15. Butcher, T., "Delivering Welfare" (1995), Open University Press
  16. Butler, J., "Patients, Policies and Politics" (1992), Open University Press
  17. Crosland, A., "The Future of Socialism" (2006), Constable
  18. Dawson, D., "The private finance initiative", Health Economics, 10(6), pp.479~486 (2001)
  19. Dean, H., "Social Policy" (2006), Polity Press
  20. DHSS, "National Health Service management inquiry" (1983), DHSS
  21. Dixon, J., "Payment by results", British Medical Journal, 328, pp.969~970 (2004)
  22. DoH, "Promoting better health" (1987), HMSO
  23. DoH, "Working for patients" (1989), HMSO
  24. DoH, "National Health Service and Community Care Act" (1990), HMSO
  25. DoH, "The new NHS: modern, dependable" (1997), The Stationery Office
  26. DoH, "The new NHS" (1998), The Stationery Office
  27. DoH, "Care Standards Act 2000", Department of Health, ~ (2000)
  28. DoH, "National Care Standards Commission(Registration) Regulations", Department of Health, ~ (2001)
  29. DoH, "Primary Care Trusts" (2002), Department of Health
  30. DoH, "NHS performance ratings" (2002), Department of Health
  31. DoH, "NHS foundation trusts. eligibility criteria and time table" (2002), Department of Health
  32. DoH, "Reforming NHS financial flows" (2002), Department of Health
  33. DoH, "NHS financial flows" (2002), Department of Health
  34. DoH, "Choose and book" (2004), Department of Health
  35. DoH, "Department of Health business plan, 2009-2011" (2009), Department of Health
  36. Report on the national patient choice survey, "DoH", Department of Health, ~ (2009)
  37. Driver, S., "Understanding British Party Politics" (2011), Polity Press
  38. Dryzek, JS., "Theories of the Democratic State" (2009), Palgrave Macmillan
  39. Easton, D., "A Framework for Political Analysis" (1965), Prentice-Hall
  40. Easton, D., "A Systems Analysis of Political Life" (1965), John Wiley & Sons
  41. Economou, A., "Economic fluctuations and political self-placement", The Journal of Socio-Economics, 46, pp.57~65 (2013)
  42. Enthoven, A., "Health Plan" (1980), Addison-Wesley Publishing Company
  43. Enthoven, A., "Theory and Practice of Managed Competition in Health Care Finance" (1988), Elsevier
  44. Garrett, G., "Partisan Politics in the Global Economy" (1999), Cambridge University Press
  45. Giddens, A., "The Third Way" (2008), Polity Press
  46. Glennerster, H., "British Social Policy since 1945" (1945), Blackwell
  47. Glennerster, H., "The development of quasi-markets in welfare provision in the United Kingdom", International Journal of Health Services, 25(2), pp.203~218 (1995)
  48. Glennerster, H., "Implementing GP Fundholding" (1994), Open University Press
  49. Greener, I., "Understanding NHS reform", Governance, 15(2), pp.161~183 (2002)
  50. Greener, I., "The three moments of New Labour’s health policy discourse", Policy and Politics, 32(3), pp.303~316 (2004)
  51. Griggs, E., "The politics of health care reform in Britain", Political Quarterly, 62(4), pp.419~430 (1991)
  52. Grindey, S., "Losing sight of blindness" (1997), Royal National Institute for the Blind
  53. Guardian, "The National Care Standards Commission", The Guardian, ~ (2002)
  54. Ham, C., "The politics of NHS reform 1988-1997" (1997), King's Fund
  55. Hambleton, R., "Health planning", Policy and Politics, 11(2), pp.198~201 (1983)
  56. Hay, C., "The Political Economy of New Labour" (1999), Manchester University Press
  57. Hibbs, DA., "Political parties and macroeconomic theory", American Political Science Review, 71(4), pp.1467~1487 (1977)
  58. Hibbs, DA., "The American Political Economy" (1989), Harvard University Press
  59. HM Treasury, "The government's expenditure plans 1980-1981" (1981), HMSO
  60. HM Treasury, "Public private partnerships" (2000), The Stationery Office
  61. Hood, C., "Explaining Economic Policy Reversals" (1994), Open University Press
  62. Huber, E., "Development and Crisis of the Welfare State" (2001), The University of Chicago Press
  63. IPPR, "Building better partnership" (2001), IPPR
  64. Jones, O., "The Establishment" (2015), Penguin Books
  65. Kastner, SL., "Partisanship and the path to financial openness", Comparative Political Studies, 38(5), pp.484~506 (2005)
  66. Keech, W., "Economic Politics in the United States" (2013), Cambridge University Press
  67. King's Fund, "Health and ten years of Labour government" (2007), King's Fund
  68. Klein, R., "The New Politics of the National Health Service" (2001), Prentice Hall
  69. Kwon, HY., "Globalization, labour power and partisan politics revisited", Socio-Economic Review, 8(2), pp.251~281 (2010)
  70. Labour Party, "New Labour" (1997), Labour Party Online Library
  71. Lawson, N., "The View from No. 11" (1993), Corgi
  72. Le Grand, J., "Further tales from the British National Health Service", Health Affairs, 21(3), pp.116~128 (2002)
  73. Le Grand, J., "The Other Invisible Hand" (2007), Princeton University Press
  74. Le Grand, J., "Learning from the NHS Internal Market" (1998), King's Fund
  75. Leach, R., "British Politics" (2011), Palgrave Macmillan
  76. Lewis, R., "Health Care UK, 1999-2000", pp.9~14 (2000), King's Fund
  77. Major, J., "The Autobiography" (2000), Harper Collins
  78. Promoting better health, "Marks, L.", King's Fund, ~, pp.Briefing Paper No.7 (1988)
  79. Mayhew, K., "European Social Models from Crisis to Crisis", pp.144~176 (2017), Oxford University Press
  80. Mays, N., "The Purchasing of Health Care by Primary Care Organizations" (2001), Open University Press
  81. Mcauley, J., "An Introduction to Politics, State and Society" (2003), Sage
  82. NHS Executive, "Public private partnerships in the National Health Service" (2007), Department of Health
  83. Pierson, C., "The Oxford Handbook of The Welfare State", pp.32~44 (2010), Oxford University Press
  84. Pierson, P., "Dismantling the Welfare State? Reagan, Thatcher, and the Politics of Retrenchment" (1994), Cambridge University Press
  85. Pierson, P., "The new politics of the welfare state", World Politics, 48(2), pp.143~179 (1996)
  86. Powell, M., "New Labour and the third way in the British welfare state", Critical Social Policy, 20(1), pp.39~60 (2000)
  87. Powell, M., "Equal access to health care and the British National Health Service", Policy Studies, 24(1), pp.51~64 (2003)
  88. Powell, M., "Framing privatisation in the English National Health Service", Journal of Social Policy, 43(3), pp.575~594 (2014)
  89. Przeworski, A., "Capitalism and Social Democracy" (1997), Cambridge University Press
  90. Richard, V., "Thatcher's Britain" (2009), Simon and Schuster
  91. Roberts, HR., "The use of family health services authority registers as a sampling frame in the UK", Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health, 49(4), pp.344~347 (1995)
  92. Robinson, R., "NHS foundation trusts", British Medical Journal, 325(7), pp.506~507 (2002)
  93. “Three at the top.” Preliminary Report for the NHS Executive Leadership Programme, "Robinson, R.", LSE, ~ (2001)
  94. Roskin, MG., "Political Science" (2017), Pearson
  95. Savas, ES., "Privatization" (1987), Chatham House Publishers
  96. Shelley, F., "National evaluation of payment by results" (2007), Health Economics Research Unit. University of Aberdeen
  97. Siciliani, L., "Tackling excessive waiting times for elective surgery", Health Policy, 72(2), pp.201~215 (2005)
  98. Smith, PC., "Performance management in British health care", Health Affairs, 21(3), pp.103~115 (2002)
  99. Social and Community Planning Research, "British Social Attitudes Survey 1997" (1997), Inter-University Consortium for Political and Social Research
  100. Spicker, P., "Arguments for Welfare" (2017), Rowman and Littlefield
  101. Stevens, S., "Reform strategies for the English NHS", Health Affairs, 23(3), pp.37~44 (2004)
  102. Strom, K., "A behavioral theory of competitive political parties", American Journal of Political Science, 34(2), pp.565~598 (1990)
  103. Stryker, R., "Globalization and the welfare state", International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy, 18(2, pp.3 (1998), 4)[DOI]
  104. Sussex, J., "The economics of the private finance initiative in the NHS" (2001), Office of Health Economics
  105. Taylor, R., "The Blair Effect 2001-5", pp.184~206 (2005), Cambridge University Press
  106. Telegraph, "The NHS", The Telegraph, ~ (2010)
  107. Thatcher, M., "The Downing Street Years" (1993), Harper Press
  108. Thorlby, R., "Health and ten years of Labour Government" (2007), King's Fund
  109. Timmins, N., "The Five Giants" (1995), HarperCollins
  110. Report of the inquiry into London's health service, "Tomlinson, N.", HMSO, ~ (1992)
  111. Webster, C., "The National Health Service" (2002), Oxford University Press
  112. Wilson, S., "After New Labour", Policy Studies, 37(5), pp.408~425 (2016)
  113. Wright, EO., "Understanding Class" (2015), Verso

관련 논문AI추천

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (13건)