‘체제전환’과 법치(法治) -중국의 경험을 중심으로-
‘System Transition’ and Rule of Law -the Chinese Experience-
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Abstract
It is obvious that the transition process of the former socialist system can’t be sustained without the support of appropriate legal institutions. In the article, I trace the development of the PRC’s legal and judicial system since the beginning of its “reform and opening” policy. First, I characterize the Chinese model as “gradual” change of legal institutions, and compare it with the German model. Then, I research various statutes in each legal area classified as constitutional and administrative laws, civil and commercial laws, criminal and socio-economic laws, and the judicial system. And I find out below “macro-dynamic” tendencies. 1. The change of legal institutions generally comes after economic reform. 2. The legislative act(the general rule) comes after long-term accumulation of administrative orders(legal experiments). 3. The change of legal institutions sometimes comes later/earlier than expected, and it makes gaps between law and markets. 4. The change of legal institutions is sometimes not accompanied with the proper supply of the related mental resources, especially in judicial system. The Chinese “gradual” development model is a reflection of its national “size and complexity”, so it can’t be literally applied to the Korean situation. But the Chinese model can afford “buffer” stages to the people, and such merit should not be underestimated.
참고문헌 (42)
- 마 광, "중국의 사법고시제도", 법제, (598) (2007)
- 쉬션지앤, "중국 형사소송 현대화의 역사적 고찰(當代中國刑事訴訟現代化的歷史考察)", 법사학연구, (35), pp.295~328 (2007), 한국법사학회
- 신우철, "중국 인민법원의 현실적 기능분석 및 그 제도개혁 논의 : 법관전문화 엘리트화를 위한 인사시스템의 혁신", 법과사회, 34(29), pp.177~207 (2005), 법과사회이론학회
- 申宇澈, "중국 인민법원의 현실적 기능분석 및 그 제도개혁 논의 ―사법개혁의 방법론 문제를 중심으로―", 공법연구, 34(1), pp.301~318 (2005), 한국공법학회
- 신우철, "중화인민공화국 국가체제에 관한 헌법학적 연구", 법학, pp.1996
- 신우철, "체제전환’과 국가: 독일통일·중국개혁의 비교헌법론" (2003), 영남대학교 출판부
- 신우철, "체제전환과 사법개혁: 중국 인민법원의 문제점 분석을 중심으로", 통일문제연구, 44(2), pp.5~23 (2005), 평화문제연구소
- 정이근, "중국공법학연구" (2007), 오름
- 진강, "중국사법구제제도" (2005), 세종출판사
- Srubar, Ilja, "Eliten, politische Kultur und Privatisierung in Ostdeutschland, Tschechienund Mittelosteuropa" (1998), UVK Soziologie
- 姜明安, "行政訴訟法" (2007), 法律出版社
- 姜明安, "行政程序硏究" (2006), 北京大學出版社
- 景漢朝, "中國司法改革策論" (2002), 中國檢察出版社
- 高銘暄, "中國刑法立法文獻資料精選" (2007), 法律出版社
- 顧培東, "從經濟改革到司法改革" (2003), 法律出版社
- 國務院新聞辦公室, "中國的人權狀況" (1991), 中央文獻出版社
- 梁慧星, "合同法的成功與不足(上·下)", 中外法学 (1999)
- 馬嶺, "中國靑年政治學院法律係學生關于‘良性違憲’問題的一次討論", 2003年中國立法硏究報告 (2003), 中國民主法制出版社
- 苗連營, "民法帝國主義’的虛幻與憲法學的迷思－第三只眼看‘根據憲法, 制定本法’的爭論" (2008), 哲社版
- "中國法官冗员—一個令人叫屈的僞命题"[URL]
- 蘇力, "送法下鄕: 中國基層司法制度硏究" (2002), 中國政法大學出版社
- 孫謙, "司法改革報告: 檢察改革·檢察理論與實踐專家對話錄" (2002), 法律出版社
- 信春鷹, "依法治國與司法改革" (1999), 中國法制出版社
- "中國物權法的制定"[URL]
- "關于我國民法典的體系的再思考"[URL]
- 王利明, "21世紀法學系列敎材: 民法" (2007), 中國人民出版社
- 王琳, "司法改革的路徑選擇" (2002), 中國法制出版社
- 王玉明, "毛澤東法律思想庫" (1993), 中國政法大學出版社
- 王作富, "21世紀法學系列敎材: 刑法" (2007), 中國人民出版社
- 劉作翔, "法理學視野中的司法問題" (2003), 上海人民出版社
- 殷嘯虎, "論我國現行‘政策性修憲’模式的局限性", ~ (1999)
- 應松年, "走向法治政府: 依法行政理論硏究與實證調査" (2001), 法律出版社
- 張文顯, "司法改革報告: 法律職業共同體硏究" (2002), 法律出版社
- 張 越, "行政復議法學" (2007), 中國法制出版社
- 鄭顯華, "合同法·擔保法理論與實務" (2006), 人民法院出版社
- 朱力宇, "依法治國論" (2004), 中國人民大學出版社
- 中國人民大學憲政與行政法治硏究中心, "憲政與行政法治發展報告(2003年－2004年卷)" (2005), 中國人民大學出版社
- 陳信勇, "中韓商法比較硏究" (1997), 杭州大學出版社
- 蔡定劍, "監督與司法公正－硏究與案例報告" (2005), 法律出版社
- 畢玉謙, "司法審判動態與硏究(第7集)" (2005), 法律出版社
- 賀日開, "司法權威的憲政分析" (2004), 人民法院出版社
- 胡夏冰, "司法權:性質與構成的分析" (2003), 人民法院出版社