선박 검사원 처벌주의 입법의 정당성에 관한 탐색적 고찰
Exploratory Research on the Legitimacy of the Legislation Tilting toward Punishing an Individual Ship Surveyor
0
조회
0
다운로드
4
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Ship inspection does not guarantee the safety and seaworthiness of ships as the results of the inspection, and the act features a collective evaluation. However, since the Sewol accident, the possibility of criminal punishment for individual ship surveyors has drastically increased, and the problem has deepened. This is a very unusual phenomenon that contradicts the concept, characteristics and nature of ship inspection. To the contrary, in foreign countries, protectionist legislation is found that exempts ship surveyors, who performed the inspection in good faith, from any liability. The current Ship Safety Act stipulates government accountability, but the responsibility of the inspection rests with the natural persons of civil society. This is not only against the public interest of ship inspection, but also causes the rigidity of ship inspection. In the present era, the ship surveyors, natural persons, are placed in a blind spot away from any protection. This paper aims at presenting this problem.
Abstract
Ship inspection does not guarantee the safety and seaworthiness of ships as the results of the inspection, and the act features a collective evaluation. However, since the Sewol accident, the possibility of criminal punishment for individual ship surveyors has drastically increased, and the problem has deepened. This is a very unusual phenomenon that contradicts the concept, characteristics and nature of ship inspection. To the contrary, in foreign countries, protectionist legislation is found that exempts ship surveyors, who performed the inspection in good faith, from any liability. The current Ship Safety Act stipulates government accountability, but the responsibility of the inspection rests with the natural persons of civil society. This is not only against the public interest of ship inspection, but also causes the rigidity of ship inspection. In the present era, the ship surveyors, natural persons, are placed in a blind spot away from any protection. This paper aims at presenting this problem.
참고문헌 (27)
- 현대 리스크 사회에서의 안전법제에 관한 연구, "권대우", 한양대학교, ~ (2008)
- 김남진, "행정법 I 제21판" (2017), 법문사
- 박균성, "행정법강의 제7판" (2010), 박영사
- 박수진, "세월호 허위검사 검사원, 재판 다섯 번 만에 유죄확정", 전남일보, ~ (2019)
- 박현규, "묵암 박현규 이사장 회고록 묵암제해록" (2017), 한국해사문제연구소
- 양천수, "객관적 귀속 재검토", 성균관법학, 30(4), pp.319~346 (2018), 법학연구원[DOI]
- 유진호, "전문 평가·인증기관의 불법행위책임에 관한 연구 -과학기술 적합성 평가기관을 중심으로", 박사, pp.2017
- 유진호, "주요 국제협약상 정부의 선박검사권의 성질과 공인선박검사기관(RO) 위탁제도 일고찰", 해사법연구, 29(1), pp.69~118 (2017), 한국해사법학회
- 이윤철, "선박검사의 법적 책임에 관한 연구", 해사법연구, 23(2), pp.25~54 (2011), 한국해사법학회
- 윤영석, "자율주행자동차 운행으로 인해 발생한 형사책임의 귀속주체", 홍익법학, 20(1), pp.515~542 (2019), 법학연구소[DOI]
- 이윤철, "港灣國統制의 法的 根據와 國內施行上의 問題", 국제법학회논총, 50(1), pp.105~138 (2005), 대한국제법학회
- 이정원, "선급협회의 계약상 책임에 관한 연구", 동아법학, (65), pp.471~497 (2014), 법학연구소
- 이상일, "선박안전법상 정부검사 대행제도의 법적 성격과 민간위탁제도로의 편입", 해사법연구, 29(2), pp.173~212 (2017), 한국해사법학회[DOI]
- Jan De Bruyne, "Contractual Liability of Classification Societies in Belgium: Dune Case", International Transport Law Review, 1(1) (2016)
- IMO, "RO Code Part 2, section 1.3", ~
- IACS, "Classification Societies–What, Why and How", ~
- "IACS Charter 3. MEMBERSHIP OF IACS 3.1 IACS' Membership Criteria (ix) Independence from ship-owning, ship-building and other commercial interests which could undermine the Classification Society’'s impartiality", ~
- Jürgen Basedow, "Third-Party Liability of Classification Societies: A Comparative Perspective" (2006), Springer
- "Caparo Plc v Dickman. 1990. 2 AC 605", ~ (1990)
- Commerce and Industry Insurance Co. v. Grinnell Corp, "No. Civ. A. 97-803, 97-775, 1999 WL 508357", ~ (1999)
- Great American Ins. Co. v. Bureau Veritas, "338 F.Supp. 999 (S.D.N.Y. 1972), aff'd, 478 F.2d 235 (2d Cir)", ~ (1973)
- "Marc Rich and Co. Ag and Others v Bishop Rock Marine Co. Ltd. and Others. 1995. UKHL 4", ~
- Meyers v. Donnatacci, "531 A.2d 398 (N.J. Super. Ct. Law Div.)", ~ (1987)
- Sundance Cruises Corp. v. American Bureau of Shipping, "7 F.3d. 1077 (2d Cir.)", ~ (1993)
- Ricci v. Quality Bakers of Am. Co-Op. Inc, "556 F. Supp. 716, 721 (D. Del.)", ~ (1983)
- Renn, O, "Coping with complexity, uncertainty and ambiguity in risk governance: A synthesis", Ambio, 40(2) (2011)
- Ulich Beck, "World Risk Society" (1999), Polity Press