한의학교육평가원 2주기, 세계의학교육연합회(WFME)의 의학기본교육, WHO 서태평양 지역지부(WHO/WPRO) 인증 기준 간의 비교 연구
A Comparative study among 2nd cycle of Evaluation and Accreditation system on Korean Medicine Education, Global Standards of WFME for Basic Medical Education and WHO guidelines for quality assurance of Traditional Medicine Education in the Western Pacific Region
1
조회
0
다운로드
7
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Objective : The purpose of our study is to compare and analyze the standards for the 2nd cycle of Evaluation and Accreditation system on institute of Korean Medicine Education & Evaluation (2nd IKMEE standards) and WHO guidelines for quality assurance of Traditional Medicine Education in the Western Pacific Region (WHO/WPRO guidelines) around the global standards of World Federation for Medical Education for basic medical education (WFME standard) to identify the shortcomings and improvements of 2nd IKMEE standards. Method : Each article of 2015 revised WFME standard was translated and summarized with focus on its core content. The next step was to review and analyze the corresponding contents of 2nd IKMEE standards in 2016 and the WHO/WPRO guidelines in 2005 for each item, focusing on the WFME standards. Results : All items in the fields of 3. assessment of students and 7. program evaluation in the WFME domain were absent from the 2nd IKMEE standards, and almost none of the WHO/WPRO guidelines. Most items in 1. the mission and outcomes domain, except for some items in the 1.1 mission field, the items of 2.6~2.8 fields in 2. education program domain, the items of 4. student domain except for the items of 4.3 student counseling and support field, and almost all items about quality development in WFME standards did not have a corresponding item in both the 2nd IKMEE standards and the WHO/WPRO standards. Conclusion : 1. The WFME standards are applicable to the criteria development of IKMEE standards. Several items of the WFME standards may need to be modified to apply the educational characteristics of Korean medicine, but consensus or further study is required. 2. Both the 2nd IKMEE standards and the WHO/WPRO standards are very insufficient to meet the WFME standards. In particular, 3. assessment of students and 7. program evaluation in the WFME domain were not in the 2nd IKMEE standards. This standard needs to be supplemented.
Abstract
Objective : The purpose of our study is to compare and analyze the standards for the 2nd cycle of Evaluation and Accreditation system on institute of Korean Medicine Education & Evaluation (2nd IKMEE standards) and WHO guidelines for quality assurance of Traditional Medicine Education in the Western Pacific Region (WHO/WPRO guidelines) around the global standards of World Federation for Medical Education for basic medical education (WFME standard) to identify the shortcomings and improvements of 2nd IKMEE standards. Method : Each article of 2015 revised WFME standard was translated and summarized with focus on its core content. The next step was to review and analyze the corresponding contents of 2nd IKMEE standards in 2016 and the WHO/WPRO guidelines in 2005 for each item, focusing on the WFME standards. Results : All items in the fields of 3. assessment of students and 7. program evaluation in the WFME domain were absent from the 2nd IKMEE standards, and almost none of the WHO/WPRO guidelines. Most items in 1. the mission and outcomes domain, except for some items in the 1.1 mission field, the items of 2.6~2.8 fields in 2. education program domain, the items of 4. student domain except for the items of 4.3 student counseling and support field, and almost all items about quality development in WFME standards did not have a corresponding item in both the 2nd IKMEE standards and the WHO/WPRO standards. Conclusion : 1. The WFME standards are applicable to the criteria development of IKMEE standards. Several items of the WFME standards may need to be modified to apply the educational characteristics of Korean medicine, but consensus or further study is required. 2. Both the 2nd IKMEE standards and the WHO/WPRO standards are very insufficient to meet the WFME standards. In particular, 3. assessment of students and 7. program evaluation in the WFME domain were not in the 2nd IKMEE standards. This standard needs to be supplemented.
참고문헌 (18)
- 이정혁, "World Federation Medical Education Global Standards의 교육과정 표준에 따른 한의학 교육 연구", 대한한의학회지, 39(3), pp.28~40 (2018), 대한한의학회[DOI]
- Ahn DS, "Current Status and Direction of Improvements in Accreditation of Medical Schools", Research Institute for Healthcare Policy Korean Medical Association, 13(2), pp.38~44 (2015)
- "The updated second edition of the WFME Global Standards for Quality Improvement: Basic Medical Education" (2015)[URL]
- "the 2nd cycle of Evaluation and Accreditation system on institute of Korean Medicine Education & Evaluation" (2016)[URL]
- "WHO guidelines for quality assurance of traditional medicine education in the Western Pacific Region" (2005)[URL]
- "The history of Korean Institute of Medical Education and Evaluation"[URL]
- "Accreditation Standards of KIMEE 2019 (ASK2019)" (2018)[URL]
- Seo DJ, "Comparison between Accreditation Board for Medical Education in Korea and Accreditation Board for Engineering Education of Korea", Korean Medical Education Review, 2(1), pp.57~69 (2000)
- Improvement Measures of Medical Education Accreditation System, "Im KY", Korean Medical Association, 1~166 (2011)
- Development of Outcome Measurement Toolkits in Basic Medical Education Program Evaluation and Accreditation, "Lee YM", Korean Medical Association, 1~185 (2018)
- 신상우, "국제적인 의학교육 역량체계 비교를 통한 한의학교육에의 시사점 연구", 동의생리병리학회지, 31(1), pp.36~45 (2017), 한의병리학회[DOI]
- Frank JR, "Toward a definition of competency-based education in medicine:a systematic review of published definitions", Medical teacher, 32(8), pp.631~637 (2010)
- Frank JR, "Competencybased medical education: theory to practice", Medical teacher, 32(8), pp.638~645 (2010)
- 이병두, "기본의학교육 학습성과 개발과 활용", 의학교육논단, 18(3), pp.119~124 (2016), 연세대학교 의과대학
- Brown TC, "A competency-based educational approach to reproductive biology", American journal of obstetrics and gynecology, 116(7), pp.1036~1042 (1973)
- McGaghie WC, "Competency-based curriculum development on medical education: an introduction", Public health papers, (68), pp.11~91 (1978)
- Dent JA, "A Practical Guide for Medical Teachers" (2013), Elsevier
- "Basic Medical Education: Japanese Specifications WFME Global Standards for Quality Improvement. (ver 2.31)" (2019)[URL]