클로드 베르나르의 실험 의학 : 19세기 프랑스 문학에 나타난 자연주의와 근대성의 기원 연구
Claude Bernard’s Experimental Medicine: One of the Origins of Modernity and Naturalism of French Literature in the 19th Century
0
조회
0
다운로드
7
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Authors studied how Claude Bernard, the first founder of experimental medicine, contributed significantly to establishment of modernism and influenced European modern culture. Authors first studied his views on modernity, comparing with Descartes and Magendie, and on the similarity between “Experimental medicine” and the European literature in the 19th century. Bernard was not exclusively against vitalism, but the dogmatic misuse of vitalism. His objective thinking could be a useful model for the authors,who considered science to be an origin of modernity in literature of naturalism. Especially, Emile Zola was strongly influenced by Bernard’s “An introduction to the study of Experimental medicine” and published ”Experimental novel,“ a manifesto of naturalism. Although Bernard’s experimental methodology and determinism deeply influenced modern European culture, the relationship between his Experimental medicine and modernism have not been fully investigated yet. His experimental medicine also needs to be discussed from the ecological viewpoints. His anthropo-centrism was unique since he emphasized any human theory could not surpass the principle of nature. Conventional anthropo-centrism claims that human beings are superior enough to own and govern the nature. And Bernard’s the necessary determinism contains the ecological principle that all life forms and inanimate objects are organically related and intertwined to each other, irrespectively of their usefulness for the human beings. Although there were some ethical debates related to his medical experiments on living bodies of animal, his strict principle to perform experiments only after animal or human body died was worth considering as an effort to sustain ecological viewpoints. He was also unique in terms of being realistic and candid about his situation which was limited by the 19th century’s scientific and medical development. In conclusion, the significance of convergence of literature and medical science in Experimental medicine and the importance of Bernard’s ecological viewpoints, need to be further studied in the field of medical history.
Abstract
Authors studied how Claude Bernard, the first founder of experimental medicine, contributed significantly to establishment of modernism and influenced European modern culture. Authors first studied his views on modernity, comparing with Descartes and Magendie, and on the similarity between “Experimental medicine” and the European literature in the 19th century. Bernard was not exclusively against vitalism, but the dogmatic misuse of vitalism. His objective thinking could be a useful model for the authors,who considered science to be an origin of modernity in literature of naturalism. Especially, Emile Zola was strongly influenced by Bernard’s “An introduction to the study of Experimental medicine” and published ”Experimental novel,“ a manifesto of naturalism. Although Bernard’s experimental methodology and determinism deeply influenced modern European culture, the relationship between his Experimental medicine and modernism have not been fully investigated yet. His experimental medicine also needs to be discussed from the ecological viewpoints. His anthropo-centrism was unique since he emphasized any human theory could not surpass the principle of nature. Conventional anthropo-centrism claims that human beings are superior enough to own and govern the nature. And Bernard’s the necessary determinism contains the ecological principle that all life forms and inanimate objects are organically related and intertwined to each other, irrespectively of their usefulness for the human beings. Although there were some ethical debates related to his medical experiments on living bodies of animal, his strict principle to perform experiments only after animal or human body died was worth considering as an effort to sustain ecological viewpoints. He was also unique in terms of being realistic and candid about his situation which was limited by the 19th century’s scientific and medical development. In conclusion, the significance of convergence of literature and medical science in Experimental medicine and the importance of Bernard’s ecological viewpoints, need to be further studied in the field of medical history.
참고문헌 (45)
- Bernard, Claude, "De la physiologie générale" (1965), Culture et Civilisation
- Bernard, Claude, "L’introduction à l ’étude de la médecine expérimentale" (1966), Garnier-Flammarion
- Bernard, Claude, "Leçons sur les phénomènes de la vie communs aux animaux et aux végétaux" (2011), Nabu Press
- Magendie, François, "Précis élémentaire de physiologie" (2012), Ulan Press
- Zola, Emile, "Le roman expérimental" (2006), Garnier-Flammarion
- Zola, Emile, "Mes Haines" (1979), Slatkine
- Zola, Emile, "Thérèse Raquin", pp.2001, Gallimard
- 신동원, "의학 오디세이 인간의 몸, 과학을 만나다" (2007), 역사비평사
- 김옥주, "문학과 의학 : 현대 임상학에서의 의미", 가정의학회지, 22(11) (2001)
- 김옥주, "생명과학연구자" (2007), 서울대학교출판부
- 남경희, "생태주의 인문학 서설, In 생태주의와 기호학" (2001), 문학과 지성사
- 유기환, "에밀 졸라" (1996), 건국대학교 출판부
- 이찬규, "가스통 바슐라르와 펠릭스 가타리 :생태학적 상생의 문화를 위하여", 한국프랑스학논집, 62, pp.141~162 (2008), 한국프랑스학회
- 장은주, "생존에서 존엄으로" (2007), 나남
- 정명환, "졸라와 자연주의" (1982), 민음사
- 한희진, "폴‐조제프 바르테즈(1734∼1806)의 생기론", 의사학, 19(1), pp.157~188 (2010), 대한의사학회
- Basilio, Kelly, "Le mécanique et le vivant: La métonymie chez Zola" (1993), Droz
- Becker, George, "Documents of Modern Literary Realism" (1963), Princeton University Press
- Benjamin, Andrew, "Experimentation as a Defence of Literature: Zola’s Roman Expérimental", Australian Journal of French Studies, 45 (2009), Monash University
- Bornecque, J.H., "Réalisme et naturalisme" (1958), Hachette
- Capra, Fritjof, "The Web of Life" (1997), HarperCollins Publishers
- Clarke, Robert, "Claude Bernard" (1961), Seghers
- Dachez, Roger, "Histoire de la médecine" (2012), Tallandrier
- Debray-Ritzen, Pierre, "Claude Bernard : ou un nouvel état de l’humaine raison" (1992), Albin Michel
- Debru, Claude, "L’art du physiologiste et l’interprétation des faits, In La nécessité de Claude Bernard" (2001), L’harmattan
- Delsol, Michel, "Le concept de réductionnisme chez les spécialistes de la théorie synthétique, In La nécessité de ClaudeBernard" (2001), L’harmattan
- Dorst, Jean, "La nature dé-naturée" (1965), Delanchaux et Niestlé
- Fauvet, Jean, "Histoire de la médecine" (1957), PUF
- Favre, Robert, "La littérature française: Histoire & perspectives" (1990), PUL
- Ferroul, Yves, "Médecin et médecine: Manuel de l’introduction à l’étude de l’histoire de la médecine" (2005), Honoré Champion
- Ferry, Luc, "Le nouvel ordre écologique" (1992), Grasset
- Gillespie, Charles C., "Dictionary of Scientific Biography" (1973), Scribner’s
- Grmek, Mirko D., "Raisonnement expérimental et recherches toxicologiques chez Claude Bernard" (1973), Droz
- Hauser, Arnold, "The Social History of Art" (1958), Vintage Books
- Holmes, Frederic L., "Claude Bernard and Animal Chemistry : The Emergence of a Scientist" (1974), Harvard Unversity Press
- Lambrichs, Louise L., "Présentation, In La nécessité de Claude Bernard" (2001), L’harmattan
- Lesch, John E., "Science and Medicine in France: The Emergence of Expérimental Physiology, 1790-1855" (1984), Harvard University Press
- Marguénaud, Jean Pierre, "L’expérimentation animale: Entre droit et liberté" (2011), Quae
- Mazliak, Pierre, "François Magendie: Bouillant créateur de la physiologie expérimental au XIXe siècle" (2012), Hermann
- Merleau-Ponty, "Phénoménologie de la perception" (1945), Gallimard
- Mitterand, Henri, "Le naturalisme" (2000), Nathan
- Prochiantz, Alain, "Claude Bernard: la force du vivant, In La nécessité de Claude Bernard" (2001), L’harmattan
- Py, Gilbert, "L’indispensable de la culture générale: Le XVIII siècle" (2002), Studyrama
- Schiller, Joseph, "Claude Bernard et les problèmes scientifiques de son temps" (1967), Cedre
- Sylvie, Thorel-Cailleteau, "Réalisme et naturalisme" (1998), Hachette