본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

오스카 피스토리우스의 비장애인스포츠 참여 논쟁에 관한 텍스트 분석

Textual Analysis on the Issues Related to Oscar Pistorius' Eligibility of Participation in an Able-bodied Sporting Event

이원일|이경준
한국특수체육학회 (Korean Society Of Adapted Physical Activity)|2011.12|한국특수체육학회지 (Korean Journal of Adapted Physical Activity)|제19권 제4호|pp. 77-93|DOI 10.17006/kjapa.2011.19.4.77

0

조회

0

다운로드

6

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

텍스트분석오스카 피스토리우스Oscar PistoriusTextual Analysis(비)장애인스포츠Disability Sports/Able-bodied Sports

초록

본 연구의 목적은 오스카 피스토리우스의 비장애인스포츠 참여와 관련하여 촉발된 논쟁들을 분석하는 것이었다. 따라서 Keats(2009)의 다양한 텍스트분석방법(multiple text analysis)을 사용하여 오스카 피스토리우스의 장애인스포츠 참여 논쟁과 관련된 문서, 시각, 구술 텍스트를 분석하였다. 이를 통하여 첫째, 공정한 경쟁, 둘째, 기술의 힘 vs. 인간 고유의 능력, 셋째, 모호한 기준의 세 가지 주제가 도출되었으며, 도출된 주제는 Richardson과 St. Pierre(2005)가 제안한 창조적분석과정기술법(creative analytic processes ethnography)을 통하여 기술하였다. 마지막으로 본 연구에서 도출된 논쟁의 핵심은 향후 특수체육 연구에 어떠한 시사점을 제공하고 있는지를 논의하였다.

Abstract

The purpose of this study was to examine the issues related to Oscar Pistorius' eligibility of participation in an able-bodied sporting event. Multiple text analysis (Keats, 2009) was utilized for analyzing written, visual, and spoken texts about Oscar Pistorius' eligibility issues. Three themes were emerged: (a) fairness of the competition, (b) use of the technology, and (c) aftermath of the decision. The themes were represented through 'creative analytic processes ethnography' (Richardson & St.Pierre, 2005). Finally, future research agendas of the field of adapted physical activity were discussed based on the emerged themes.

참고문헌 (59)

  1. 구교만, "특수체육 미래를 위한 교류와 협력 - ‘특수체육학’ 학제 간 연구의 새로운 시작 -", 한국특수체육학회지, 17(2), pp.63~76 (2009), 한국특수체육학회
  2. 노형규, "신문보도에 투영된 전국장애인체육대회의 의미와 특징", 한국특수체육학회지, 14(3), pp.21~36 (2006), 한국특수체육학회
  3. 오광진, "특수체육학의 정체성 탐색", 한국특수체육학회지, 16(2), pp.75~100 (2008), 한국특수체육학회
  4. 오광진, "정상화 원리에 기반한 일반학교 통합체육문화의 문제점과 장애학생의 실존성 탐색", 한국특수체육학회지, 18(2), pp.63~80 (2010), 한국특수체육학회
  5. 이경준, "특수체육 질적연구 패러다임들의 기여와 한계", 한국특수체육학회지, 19(1), pp.83~101 (2011), 한국특수체육학회
  6. Armstrong, D., "A new history of identity: A sociology of medical knowledge" (2002), Palgrave
  7. Camporesi, S., "Oscar Pistorius, enhancement and post-humans", Journal of Medical Ethics, 34, pp.639~ (2008)
  8. Charlish, P., "Should Oscar run? Fordham Intellectual Property", Media and Entertainment Law Journal, 18, pp.929~957 (2008)
  9. Cole, C. L., "Oscar Pistorius‘s aftermath", Journal of Sport and Social Issues, 1, pp.3~4 (2009)
  10. Corrigan, T. F., "Discourse of the "Too abled": Contested body hierarchies and the Oscar Pistorius case", International Journal of Sport Communication, 3, pp.288~307 (2010)
  11. DePauw, K. P., "Social-cultural context of disability: Implications for scientific inquiry and professional preparation", Quest, 52, pp.358~368 (2000)
  12. Dyer, B., "The fair use of lower-limb running prostheses: A delphi study", Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 28, pp.16~26 (2011)
  13. Edwards, D., "Discourse and cognition" (1997), Sage
  14. Edwards, S. D., "Should Oscar Pistorius be excluded from the 2008 Olympic Games?", Sport, Ethics and Philosophy, 2, pp.112~125 (2008)
  15. Fairclough, N., "Media discourse" (1995), Edward Arnold
  16. Goodwin, D. L., "Inadequate bodies or inadequate contexts: Reactions to the metaphors of disability", Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 21, pp.379~398 (2004)
  17. Goosey-Tolfrey, V., "Supporting the Paralympic athlete: Focus on wheeled sports", Disability and Rehabilitation, 32, pp.2237~2243 (2010)
  18. Greimas, A. J., "Semantique structurale" (1966), Larousse
  19. Grenier, A. M., "The contextual and social locations of older women's experiences of disability and decline", Journal of Aging Studies, 19, pp.131~146 (2005)
  20. Grenier, M., "A social constructionist perspective of teaching and learning in inclusive physical education", Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 23, pp.245~260 (2006)
  21. Grenier, M., "Inclusion in physical education: From the medical model to social constructionism", Quest, 59, pp.298~310 (2007)
  22. Hood, M., "Running against the wind (sports prosthetics)", IEEE Spectrum, 42, pp.13~14 (2005)
  23. Hutzler, Y., "Ethical consideration in adapted physical activity practices", Sport, Ethics and Philosophy, 2, pp.158~171 (2008)
  24. Jespersen, E., "Philosophy, adapted physical education and dis", ability, 2008, pp.2, 87~96
  25. Jones, C., "Defining advantage and athletic performance: The case of Oscar Pistorius", European Journal of Sport Science, 9, pp.125~131 (2009)
  26. Keats, P. A., "Multiple text analysis in narrative research: Visual, written, and spoken stories of experience", Qualitative Research, 9, pp.181~195 (2009)
  27. Kram, R., "Counterpoint: Artificial legs do not make artificially fast running speeds possible", Journal of Applied Physiology, 108, pp.1012~1014 (2010)
  28. Lechler, K., "Lower extremity leg amputation: An advantage in running?", Sports Technology, 1, pp.229~234 (2008)
  29. Lippi, G., "Pistorius ineligible for the Olympic Games: The right decision", British Journal of Sport Medicine, 42, pp.160~161 (2008)
  30. Markula, P., "Sport and the personal narrative, In Qualitative methods in sport studies", pp.165~184 (2005), Guilford
  31. Markula, P., "Qualitative research and aging and physical activity", Journal of Aging and Physical Activity, 9, pp.245~264 (2001)
  32. McArdle, D., "Just one of the challenges of 21st century life: Oscar Pistorius in the Court of Arbitration for Sport", SCRIPTed, 5, pp.404~413 (2008)
  33. McKee, A., "Textual analysis: A beginner's guide" (2003), Sage
  34. Natalia, M., "Game efficiency of wheelchair rugby athletes at the 2008 Paralympic Games with regard to player classification", Human Movement, 11, pp.29~36 (2010)
  35. Oberle, K., "Ethics in Canadian nursing practice: Navigating the journey" (2009), Prentice Hall
  36. Perakyla, A., "Analyzing talk and text, In Handbook of qualitative research (3rd ed.)", pp.869~886 (2005), Sage
  37. Pistorius, O., "Blade runner" (2009), Virgin Books
  38. Propp, V. I., "Morphology of the folk tale" (1968), University of Texas Press
  39. Reid, G., "Future directions of inquiry in adapted physical activity", Quest, 52, pp.369~381 (2000)
  40. Richardson, L., "Writing: A method of inquiry, In Handbook of qualitative research (3rd ed.)", pp.959~978 (2005), Sage
  41. Sacks, H., "On the analysability of stories by children, In Ethnomethodology", pp.216~232 (1974), Penguin
  42. Sacks, H., "Lectures on conversation" (1992), Basil Blackwell
  43. Shephard, R. J., "Assumptions inherent in biological research", Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 15, pp.222~235 (1998)
  44. Shephard, R. J., "Postmodernism and adapted physical activity: A new gnostic heresy?", Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 16, pp.331~343 (1999)
  45. Shephard, R. J., "The scientific method, modernism, and postmodernism revisited: A response to Bouffard (1999)", Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 18, pp.235~239 (1999)
  46. Shogan, D., "The social construction of disability: The impact of statistics and technology", Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 15, pp.269~277 (1998)
  47. Silverman, D., "Interpreting qualitative data: Methods for analyzing talk, text, and interaction (2nd ed.)" (2001), Sage
  48. Slife, B. D., "Raising the consciousness of researchers: Hidden assumptions in the behavioral sciences", Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 15, pp.208~221 (1998)
  49. Slife, B. D., "What’s behind the research? Discovering hidden assumption in the behavioral sciences" (1995), Sage
  50. Sparkes, A. C., "Telling tales in sport and physical activity: A qualitative journey" (2002), Human Kinetics
  51. Standal, O. F., "Celebrating the insecure practitioner. A critique of evidence-based practice in adapted physical activity", Sport, Ethics and Philosophy, 2, pp.200~215 (2008)
  52. Sullivan, M., "Subjective bodies: Paraplegia, rehabilitation, and the politics of movement, In Foucault and the government of disability", pp.27~44 (2005), The University of Michigan Press
  53. Swartz, L., "Cyborg anxiety: Oscar Pistorius and the boundaries of what it means to be human", Disability and Society, 23, pp.187~190 (2008)
  54. Tracy, S. J., "Qualitative quality: Eight "Big-tent" criteria for excellent qualitative research", Qualitative Inquiry, 16, pp.837~851 (2010)
  55. van Hilvoorde, I., "Enhancing disabilities: Transhumanism under the veil of inclusion?", Disability and Rehabilitation, 32, pp.2222~2227 (2010)
  56. van Hilvoorde, I., "Disability of extraordinary talent: Francesco Lentini (three legs) versus Oscar Pistorius (no legs)", Sport, Ethics and Philosophy, 2, pp.97~111 (2008)
  57. Vanlandewijck, Y., "Sport science in the Paralympic movement", Journal of Rehabilitation Research and Development, 43, pp.17~26 (2006)
  58. Weyand, P. G., "The fastest runner on artificial legs: Different limbs, similar function?", Journal of Applied Physiology, 107, pp.903~911 (2009)
  59. Wolbring, G., "Oscar Pistorius and the future nature of Olympic, Paralympic and other sports", SCRIPTed, 5, pp.139~160 (2008)

관련 논문AI추천

장애인 스포츠에서의 편의 제공과 공정의 딜레마 - 스포츠중재재판소(CAS)의 의족 스프린터 올림픽 출전 여부 판단에 대한 법적 분석을 중심으로윤태영한국스포츠엔터테인먼트법학회 · 스포츠엔터테인먼트와 법2025 · 제28권 제1호장애인 스포츠를 향한 차별과 구별에 관한 담론김지태, 정태린한국특수체육학회 · 한국특수체육학회지2018 · 제26권 제3호장애인 엘리트선수들이 지각하는 지원체계 문제점의 내용분석김지태, 서은철한국특수체육학회 · 한국특수체육학회지2015 · 제23권 제3호스포츠에서 과학의 개입한도와 기준 문제이승훈스포츠윤리연구소 · 스포츠와 윤리2025 · 제5권 제1호장애인스포츠 등급분류의 병폐에 따른 윤리적 쟁점김민창, 안재찬한국체육철학회 · 움직임의 철학 : 한국체육철학회지2018 · 제26권 제4호장애인스포츠 인권침해현황과 과제안재찬한국체육철학회 · 움직임의 철학 : 한국체육철학회지2022 · 제30권 제4호

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (14건)

특수학급 학생들의 여가 활동 실태에 관한 연구이철환, 박병도, 박지민pp. 1-17지체장애인의 좌식배구 참여여부가 사회성 발달에 미치는 영향홍양자, 김혜영, 김옥자pp. 18-33예비특수체육교사 모의체육수업의 신체활동 수준, 수업 내용 및 수업 행동 분석한동기pp. 34-49장애인 국가대표 선수의 운동 상해 유형허정석, 홍대석, 박승재, 장명재, 이준희, 남혜주pp. 50-62비만분류에 따른 지적장애학생의 유산소운동이 운동일탈 및 신체형태변화에 미치는 영향오봉근, 전혜자pp. 63-76
원문 보기