임진왜란과 영국-스페인 전쟁의 개전과정에 관한 비교 연구
A Comparative Study on the Process of Outbreak of Imjin War and England-Spain War
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
From the late 16th century to the middle 17th century, both East Asia and Europe could not be ceased from a similar continuation of conflicts and wars. When designing this study, it was deeply motivated to us by the facts that Japanese maritime invasion to Joseon Dynasty in 1592 and Spanish maritime invasion to United Kingdom in 1588, it is called England-Spain War, by mobilizing an invincible fleet (Armada), were similar types of outbreaks in the same era, but the war outcomes were quite different one another. The Joseon Dynasty predicted the possibility of a Japanese invasion and took its own countermeasures for the prevention and outbreak of war, but failed to defend the Japanese invading force from the sea, as results, the entire country was violated for about 7 years. United Kingdom predicted the possibility of a Spanish invasion and succeeded in defending the Spanish invading force from the sea by taking measures to prevent war and to prepare for the outbreak of war. By winning the war, he emerged as a strongest maritime power. Therefore, this study examined the differences between the Korean and England warfare preparedness measures, and why Joseon suffered the tragedy of being violated for 7 years without defending the Japanese invading force from the sea in the first war and the United Kingdom defeated the Spanish invading force from the sea. And also, we compared and analyzed the essential causes of the United Kingdom preserving the territory and establishing the foundation for growing up a strongest maritime power. As a methodology for this study, Stuart A. Bremer's team's Theory of the Process of War and Kahneman and Tversky's Prospect Theory were applied. Through the analysis of the war process, the factors of the outbreak of the war were derived. In addition, Seonjo, King of the Joseon Dynasty chose a risk-aversion strategy, which brought to fail for defending Japanese troops from the sea, resulting in a prolonged war, however, Queen Elizabeth of the United Kingdom chose a risk-acceptance strategy to conquer the Spanish army from the sea, resulting in an early ended war. Results of the study show many implications for today's international relations and modern wars, so further case studies are to be continued in the future.
Abstract
From the late 16th century to the middle 17th century, both East Asia and Europe could not be ceased from a similar continuation of conflicts and wars. When designing this study, it was deeply motivated to us by the facts that Japanese maritime invasion to Joseon Dynasty in 1592 and Spanish maritime invasion to United Kingdom in 1588, it is called England-Spain War, by mobilizing an invincible fleet (Armada), were similar types of outbreaks in the same era, but the war outcomes were quite different one another. The Joseon Dynasty predicted the possibility of a Japanese invasion and took its own countermeasures for the prevention and outbreak of war, but failed to defend the Japanese invading force from the sea, as results, the entire country was violated for about 7 years. United Kingdom predicted the possibility of a Spanish invasion and succeeded in defending the Spanish invading force from the sea by taking measures to prevent war and to prepare for the outbreak of war. By winning the war, he emerged as a strongest maritime power. Therefore, this study examined the differences between the Korean and England warfare preparedness measures, and why Joseon suffered the tragedy of being violated for 7 years without defending the Japanese invading force from the sea in the first war and the United Kingdom defeated the Spanish invading force from the sea. And also, we compared and analyzed the essential causes of the United Kingdom preserving the territory and establishing the foundation for growing up a strongest maritime power. As a methodology for this study, Stuart A. Bremer's team's Theory of the Process of War and Kahneman and Tversky's Prospect Theory were applied. Through the analysis of the war process, the factors of the outbreak of the war were derived. In addition, Seonjo, King of the Joseon Dynasty chose a risk-aversion strategy, which brought to fail for defending Japanese troops from the sea, resulting in a prolonged war, however, Queen Elizabeth of the United Kingdom chose a risk-acceptance strategy to conquer the Spanish army from the sea, resulting in an early ended war. Results of the study show many implications for today's international relations and modern wars, so further case studies are to be continued in the future.
참고문헌 (38)
- 강진아, "동아시아의 지역질서" (2005), 창비
- 개릿 매팅리, "아르마다" (2012), 천일문화사
- 김명준, "임진왜란과 김성일" (2006), 백산서당
- 김영환, "군사작전 비교연구", 박사, pp.2017
- 김준배, "아리마 세이호(有馬成甫)의 『조선역 수군사(朝鮮役水軍史)』(1942)에 보이는 이순신 비판론", 군사, (114), pp.243~280 (2020), 국방부군사편찬연구소[DOI]
- 김원중, "근세초 스페인 제국의 흥기와 몰락", 이베로아메리카 연구, (12) (2001)
- 기타지마 만지, "도요토미 히데요시의 조선 침략" (2008), 경인문화사
- 박지향, "제국의 품격" (2018), (주)북이십일 21세기북스
- 박희봉, "교과서가 말하지 않은 임진왜란 이야기" (2016), 논형
- 반윤홍, "조선시대 비변사 연구" (2003), 경인문화사
- 서희석, "유럽의 첫 번째 태양, 스페인" (2015), 을유문화사
- 시오노 나나미, "레판토 해전" (1998), 도서출판 한길사
- 신동준, "조선의 왕과 신하, 부국강병을 논하다" (2007), (주)살림출판사
- 신윤호, "임진왜란 시기 3도 수군 연구", 박사, pp.2019
- 이민웅, "임진왜란 해전사" (2004), 한영문화사
- 이승영, "영국의 종교개혁의 논의에 관한 일고", 역사와 사회, (18) (1994)
- 육군군사연구소, "한국 군사사 제7권" (2012), 경인문화사
- 장학근, "壬辰倭亂期 朝·日·明 三國의 水軍 運用策", 군사, (85), pp.89~126 (2012), 국방부군사편찬연구소[DOI]
- 장학근, "임진왜란기 관군의 활약" (1992), 국사편찬위원회
- 정완희, "임진왜란 한ㆍ일 함선 전투력 지수 연구", 군사, (92), pp.139~165 (2014), 국방부군사편찬연구소[DOI]
- 조덕현, "영국-스페인전쟁, 해전에 관한 연구", 해양안보논총, (31) (2018)
- 조성식, "영국 장인법의 제정에 관한 연구", 박사, 사학, pp.2003
- 조원래, "명군의 출병과 임진전국의 추이" (1992), 국사편찬위원회
- 타임라이프 북스, "엘리자베스 여왕의 왕국" (2004), 가람기획
- 최영수, "포르투갈과 스페인의 식민지정책에 관한 비교연구", 이베로 아메리카연구, (1) (1990)
- 해군대학, "한국 해전사" (2007), 해군인쇄창
- Alison Weir, "엘리자베스 1세" (2007), 루비박스
- C.V.Wedgewood, "30년 전쟁" (2011), (주)휴머니스트 출판그룹
- G.J.마이어, "튜더스" (2011), 도서출판 말글빛냄
- Michael Klare, "자원의 지배" (2002), 세종연구원
- Henry Kamen, "Spain 1469~1714" (1983), A Society of Conflict
- Jack S. Levy,, "An Introduction to Prospect Theory", Political Psychology, 13 (1992)
- Kahneman, Daniel, "Prospect Theory : An Analysis of Decision under Risk", Econometrica, 47 (1979)
- R.B.Wernham, "The Making of Elizabethan Foreign Policy, 1558~1603" (1980), University of Calfornia Press
- "『宣祖實錄』선조 22년 8월, 丙子", ~
- "『宣祖修正實錄』선조 24년 3월, 丁酉", ~
- "『宣祖修正實錄』선조 24년 7월, 丙子", ~
- "『宣祖修正實錄』선조 24년 8월, 癸巳", ~
