본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

Hyper-Constitutionalization of Civil Cases in Korea - Focusing on Property Law Cases -

김영희
법학연구소 (The Institute of Legal Studies Konkuk University)|2015.06|법학논집|제19권 제4호|pp. 173-207

0

조회

0

다운로드

0

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

대법원헌법재판소헌법헌법소원민법한국KoreaConstitutional CourtConstitutionSupreme CourtConstitutional ComplaintCivil CodeHyper-Constitutionalization과잉 헌법사건화 현상

초록

The constitutional court of Korea is the specialized highest court which has overall authority for constitutional issues. The supreme court of Korea as the general highest court also plays certain role in reviewing the constitutionality of laws and lower laws. This dual constitutionality review system has caused severe conflicts between the two highest courts, and brought considerable legal instability in Korea. Indeed, the hyper-constitutionalization phenomenon is an example of the abusing constitutional lawsuits by people under favor of the conflicts. As a solution, the author suggests the merger of the supreme court and the constitutional court into one big multi-supreme court.

Abstract

The constitutional court of Korea is the specialized highest court which has overall authority for constitutional issues. The supreme court of Korea as the general highest court also plays certain role in reviewing the constitutionality of laws and lower laws. This dual constitutionality review system has caused severe conflicts between the two highest courts, and brought considerable legal instability in Korea. Indeed, the hyper-constitutionalization phenomenon is an example of the abusing constitutional lawsuits by people under favor of the conflicts. As a solution, the author suggests the merger of the supreme court and the constitutional court into one big multi-supreme court.

참고문헌 (67)

  1. The Constitutional Court of Korea, "Constitutional Justice and Social Integration", International Symposium Commemoration the 3rd Congress of the World Conference on Constitution Justice (2014), The Constitutional Court of Korea
  2. The Constitutional Court of Korea, "Twenty Years of the The Constitutional Court of Korea" (2008)
  3. The Constitutional Court of Korea, "The First Ten Years of The Korean Constitutional Court", The Constitutional Court of Korea, ~ (2001)
  4. The Constitutional Court of Korea, "헌법재판소 창립 25주년 기념 국제학술심포지엄 자료집 (International Symposium Commemorating the 25 Years of the The Constitutional Court of Korea)" (2013), Constitutional Court of Korea
  5. The Constitutional Court of Korea, "창립 25주년 기념 학술대회 자료집(Conference Commemorating the 25 Years of the The Constitutional Court of Korea)" (2013), The Constitutional Court of Korea
  6. The Constitutional Court of Korea, "헌법재판의 회고와 전망 : 헌법재판소 창립 10주년기념 학술대회 자료집 (Seminar Commemorating the 10 Years of the The Constitutional Court of Korea)" (1998), The Constitutional Court of Korea
  7. 피터 길레스, "민사소송과 헌법-독일의 관점에서의 고찰-", 민사소송, 9(1), pp.11~39 (2005), 한국민사소송법학회
  8. 한충수, "2014년 상고법원 설치 논의에 대한 批判的 省察과 새로운 대법원 제도에 대한 試論的 考察", 법학논총, 31(4), pp.381~409 (2014), 법학연구소
  9. HAN Su-Ung, "Heonbeobjaepansogyeoljeonghaeseoljip 2003", pp.131~160 (2003), The Constitutional Court of Korea
  10. HEO Young, "헌법재판소와 법원의 권한갈등을 어떻게 풀 것인가? (How to Resolve the Friction between the Constitutional Court and the Ordinary Courts?)", Gongbeobyeongu, 24(1), pp.27~42 (1996), Hangukgongbeobyeonguhakhoe
  11. HWANG Chi-Yeon, "Hanguk Heonbeopagui Hyeonhwanggwa Gwaje (KIM Cheol-Su Gyosu Jeongnyeon Ginyeom Nonmunjip)", pp.990~1017 (1998), Pakyoungsa
  12. HWANG Chi-Yeon, "헌법재판소 결정의 효력과 대법원의 판결 (The Effects of the Decisions of Constitutional Court and Supreme Court Rulings)", Ingwongwajeongui, (255), pp.29~43 (1997), Korean Bar Association
  13. HWANG Do-Su, "Jaepanui Han Gil (KIM Yong-Jun Heonbeopjaepansojang Hwagap Ginyeom Nonmunjip)", pp.261~282 (1998), Pakyoungsa
  14. HWANG Do-Su, "헌법재판소와 대법원의 관계 (Relationship between the Constitutional Court and the Supreme Court)", Gosigye, 42(5), pp.81~97 (1997), Gosigyesa
  15. HWANG U-Yeo, "한국의 헌법재판과 일반재판 (Constitutional Court Cases and Ordinary Court Cases in Korea)", Gongbeobyeongu, 24(1), pp.101~116 (1996), Hangukgongbeobyeonguhakhoe
  16. IHM Sahng-Hyeog, "Sabeobgaehyeokgwa Segyeui Sabeobjedo (II)", pp.618~629 (2004), Hanguksabeobhaengjeonghakhoe
  17. 임상혁, "조선전기 민사소송과 소송이론의 전개", 박사, 민사소송법, pp.2000
  18. 任相爀, "高麗의 裁判에 관한 考察", 석사, 법학, pp.1993
  19. 장석조, "민사재판과 헌법적 판단", 법조, 56(7), pp.5~65 (2007), 법조협회
  20. JEON Gwang-Seok, "Heonbeopjaepanjedoui Baljeon (｢Heonbeopjaepanjaryo 5｣)", pp.47~62 (1992), The Constitutional Court of Korea
  21. 정혜영, "헌법재판소의 판례를 통해 본 재산권보장의 문제점", 인권과 정의, (357), pp.48~69 (2006), 대한변호사협회
  22. JEONG Jae-Hwang, "헌법재판소의 권한과 일반소송 (The Authority and Jurisdiction of the Constitutional Court and the Ordinary Courts’ Trials)", Gongbeobyeongu, 24(1), pp.147~178 (1996), Hangukgongbeobyeonguhakhoe
  23. JEONG Yeon-Ju, "Heonbeobpanryeyeongu 1", pp.363~389, Pakyoungsa
  24. Hak, "Heonbeobgyubeomgwa Heonbeobhyeonsil (KWON Yeong-Seoung Gyosu Jeongnyeon Ginyeom Nonmunjip)", pp.460~482 (2000), Bobmunsa
  25. KIM Hyeon-Cheol, "헌법소원의 적법요건 (Legal Requirement of Constitutional Complaint)", Heonbeobnonchong 9, pp.765~812 (1998), The Constitutional Court of Korea
  26. 김일환, "독일의 사법구조에서 본 한국의 헌법재판 운영실태", 공법학연구, 10(1), pp.191~220 (2009), 한국비교공법학회
  27. KIM Il-Hwan, "Sabeopgaehyeokgwa Segyeui Sabeopjedo (Ⅲ)", pp.315~352 (2006), Hanguksabeobhaengjeonghakhoe
  28. KIM Mun-Hyeon, "Heonbeopjaepanui Irongwa Silje (KIM Cheol-Su Gyosu Hwagap Ginyeom Nonmunjip)", pp.79~107 (1993), Pakyoungsa
  29. KIM Myeong-Su, "Heonbeobmunjewa Jaepan (Sang) (｢Jaepanjaryo 75｣)" (1997), The Supreme Court Library of Korea
  30. KIM Seon-Taek, "사법질서에 있어서 기본권의 효력 (Effects of the Constitutional Rights on the Private Law Order)", Goryeobeobhak, (39), pp.153~180 (2002), The Legal Research Institute of Korea University
  31. KIM Young-Hee, "Introduction to Korean Legal Materials", Journal of Korean Law, 2(1), pp.125~166 (2002), Seoul National University Law Research Institute
  32. KLEIN Hans, "독일 헌법재판과 일반재판의 관계 (Relationship between Constitutional Cases and Ordinary Cases in Germany)", Gongbeobyeongu, 24(1), pp.81~100 (1996), Hangukgongbeobyeonguhakhoe
  33. KWAK Yun-Jik, "민법총칙 (General Provisions of Civil Law)" (2002), Pakyoungsa
  34. KWON Yeong-Seong, "헌법학원론 (Introduction to Constitutional Theory)" (2006), Bobmunsa
  35. 이부하, "헌법재판에 있어서 사법적 자제 ―입법자와 헌법재판소간의 권한획정과 관련하여―", 공법연구, 33(3), pp.253~272 (2005), 한국공법학회
  36. 이부하, "법원의 재판에 대한 헌법소원-헌법상 원리에 의한 검토를 중심으로-", 법조, 53(6), pp.99~122 (2004), 법조협회
  37. LEE Jong-Su, "Sabeobgaehyeokgwa Segyeui Sabeobjedo (Ⅲ)", pp.13~46 (2006), Hanguksabeobhaengjeonghakhoe
  38. 이명웅, "미국과 한국의 위헌심사제 비교 - 헌법적 근거, 심사기준, 결정의 효력을 중심으로", 인권과 정의, (357), pp.29~47 (2006), 대한변호사협회
  39. LEE Seon-Jun, "판결의 기판력과 위헌법률심판의 재판전제성 (Effect of Excluding Further Litigation of Ordinary Lawsuit and Prerequisite of Constitutional Lawsuit)", Beobjeongnonchong, (34), pp.19~29 (1999), The Institute of Legal Research of Chung-Ang University
  40. 이영록, "제1공화국 헌법위원회제도의 형성 - 사법제도 형성의 한 단면 -", 헌법학연구, 11(2), pp.307~336 (2005), 한국헌법학회
  41. 南福鉉, "헌법재판소와 대법원의 관할문제", 공법연구, 32(1), pp.4~4 (2003), 한국공법학회
  42. NAM Bok-Hyeon, "Hangukheonbeobhakui Hyeonhwangwa Gwaje (KIM Cheol-Su Gyosu Jeongnyeon Ginyeom Nonmunjip)", pp.896~932 (1998), Pakyoungsa
  43. NAM Bok-Hyeon, "헌법재판소에 의한 헌법재판이 우리 사회에 미친 영향(Influence of Constitutional Lawsuit by Constitutional Court On Our Society)", Jeongchaekgaebalyeongu, 1 (2010), The Constitutional Court of Korea
  44. PARK Hong-U, "Heonbeobjaepanui Hoegowa Jeonmang", pp.267~279 (1998), The Constitutional Court of Korea
  45. PARK In-Su, "주요 국가별 헌법재판제도의 비교분석과 시사점 (Comparative Study and its Implication on Constitutional Review System in Major Countries)", Heonbeopjaepanyeongu, (21) (2010), The Constitutional Court of Korea
  46. 朴炅澈, "우리 헌법질서에서 裁判訴願禁止의 違憲性", 공법연구, 30(3), pp.155~182 (2002), 한국공법학회
  47. 명령 규칙에 대한 위헌심사권 (Jurisdiction over Unconstitutionality of Orders and Regulations), "SEO Bo-Guk", The Constitutional Research Institute, ~, pp.v.2011-A-2 (2011)
  48. SO Sun-Mu, "Heonbeobmunjewa Jaepan (Sang) (｢Jaepanjaryo 75｣)", pp.535~620 (1997), The Supreme Court Library of Korea
  49. YANG Chang-Soo, "민법입문 (Introduction to Civil Law)" (2008), Pakyoungsa
  50. 미국 연방대법원의 지위 및 기능 (The Position and Function of U.S. Supreme Court), "YU Eun-Jeong", The Constitutional Research Institute, ~, pp.2011-B-1 (2011)
  51. YU Nam-Seok, "Heonbeobmunjewa Jaepan (Sang) (｢Jaepanjaryo 75｣)", pp.281~339 (1997), The Supreme Court Library of Korea
  52. YUN Jin-Su, "Heonbeobjaepanjedoui Baljeon (｢Heonbeopjaepanjaryo 5｣)" (1992), The Constitutional Court of Korea

관련 논문AI추천

韓國憲法裁判制度의 改善方向김철수법학연구소 · 법학논집1999 · 제4권 제1호헌법소원제도의 공과(功過)- 사법정책적 개선방안을 중심으로 -도회근법학연구원 · 법학논총2013 · 제30권 제4호Constitutional Review and Its Procedures임지봉법학연구원 · 법학논총2010 · 제23권 제1호Korea’s Judicial Interpretation and Application of International Law정명현한국법제연구원 · Korea Legislation Research Institute Journal of Law and Legislation2020 · 제10권 제1호The Constitutional Court as a Political Crisis Manager차동욱(사)위기관리이론과실천 · Journal of Safety and Crisis Management2023 · 제13권 제1호The Effect of Constitutional Review on the Legislature and the Executive branch for last 25 years in Korea전종익아시아태평양법연구소 · Journal of Korean Law2015 · 제14권 제2호

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (15건)

日本における民営化と規整改革板垣 勝彦pp. 1-44台灣對管制規範的改革—以對電子媒體核發臨時執照的運用為核心吳 志 光pp. 45-79Gewährleistungsstaat und Regulierungsreform in Deutschland: From deregulation to smart regulationJanZiekowpp. 81-124법학 50년 <민법학>송덕수pp. 125-171한국의 정치자금법제 개선방안 - 법인, 단체의 정치자금 기부허용과 사후 투명성강화를 중심으로 -성중탁pp. 209-239
원문 보기