從愛憎由己到知人論世：重評李商隱之政治認識
Re-evaluation on Li Shangyin in a Political View
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
The different attitudes towards the poems of Li Shangyin (c.813-c.858), a prominent poet in late Tang Dynasty (618-907), have led to various evaluations on his personality. On one hand, the opposites of Li’s poems often criticize the personality of Li. On the other hand, the supporters of Li’s poems praise almost all aspects of him. This resulted in serious bias all over the studies on Li. Focusing on the historical context of the Tang Dynasty, this article analyses the limitations of the viewpoints of both the Li’s supporters and opposites, and points out that discussing the personality of Li is indeed not an appropriate way in knowing this historical figure. Since the Tang scholars were highly enthusiastic in obtaining political success, this article chooses to re-evaluate Li through the view of politics. Based on Li’s commentaries on the past historical events and current affairs and his performances in dealing with other officials, the article illustrates the weaknesses of Li and tries to provide an objective new understanding of this important poet.
Abstract
The different attitudes towards the poems of Li Shangyin (c.813-c.858), a prominent poet in late Tang Dynasty (618-907), have led to various evaluations on his personality. On one hand, the opposites of Li’s poems often criticize the personality of Li. On the other hand, the supporters of Li’s poems praise almost all aspects of him. This resulted in serious bias all over the studies on Li. Focusing on the historical context of the Tang Dynasty, this article analyses the limitations of the viewpoints of both the Li’s supporters and opposites, and points out that discussing the personality of Li is indeed not an appropriate way in knowing this historical figure. Since the Tang scholars were highly enthusiastic in obtaining political success, this article chooses to re-evaluate Li through the view of politics. Based on Li’s commentaries on the past historical events and current affairs and his performances in dealing with other officials, the article illustrates the weaknesses of Li and tries to provide an objective new understanding of this important poet.
참고문헌 (77)
- 肖妮妮, "唐人選擇廬山隱居的功利化傾向", 華南師範大學學報（社會科學版）, 3, pp.75~78 (2007)
- 張黎輝, "論李德裕與唐宣宗──兼談牛李黨爭與皇權之關係", 周口師範學院學報, 24(1), pp.69~72 (2007)
- 傅劍平, "李商隱與令狐綯關係要論", 華南師範大學學報（社會科學版）, 4, pp.34~38 (2006)
- 宋寧娜, "蘇州大學學報（哲學社會科學版）", 蘇州大學學報（哲學社會科學版), 3, pp.59~65 (2006)
- 袁行霈, "在沉淪中演進──晚唐詩歌創作趨向 In 唐詩風神及其他", pp.103~123 (2005), 香港城市大學出版社
- 韓大強, "清代李商隱研究綜述", 信陽師範學院學報（哲學社會科學版）, 25(5), pp.78~82 (2005)
- 余金龍, "有關徐復觀《環繞李義山錦瑟詩的諸問題》之探討", 通識研究集刊, 6, pp.115~174 (2004)
- 方堅銘, "李商隱對甘露之變的態度及其經驗模式的形成", 中南大學學報（社會科學版）, 9(5), pp.695~699 (2003)
- 尹占華, "李商隱得罪令狐綯原因新探", 甘肅廣播電視大學學報, 13(1), pp.1~6 (2003)
- 石雲濤, "唐後期方鎮使府賓主關係與牛李黨爭", 許昌學院學報, 1, pp.89~93 (2003)
- 武榮強, "李商隱與牛李黨爭新論", 唐山師範學院學報, 24(6), pp.9~12 (2002)
- 趙木蘭, "李商隱政治詩中的「甘露之變」", 山西煤炭管理干部學院學報, 2, pp.65~66 (2001)
- 朱易安, "「詩家」並非「總愛西崑好」", 文學遺產, 2, pp.42~52 (2000)
- 王壽南, "李訓與甘露之變 In 唐代人物與政治", pp.212~235 (1999), 文津出版社
- 陳伯海, "略論李商隱的政治詩 In 李商隱研究論集", pp.87~102 (1998), 廣西師範大學出版社
- 徐朔方, "論李商隱的無題詩", 李商隱研究論集, pp.116~130 (1997)
- 陳貽焮, "李商隱戀愛事迹考辨", 李商隱研究論集, pp.131~165 (1997)
- 陳伯海, "怎樣看待李商隱的《無題》詩", 李商隱研究論集, pp.177~189 (1997)
- 董乃斌, "李商隱悲劇初探", 李商隱研究論集, pp.230~246 (1997)
- 傅璇琮, "李商隱研究中的一些問題", 李商隱研究論集, pp.297~315 (1997)
- 周建國, "試論李商隱與牛李黨爭", 李商隱研究論集, pp.382~399 (1997)
- 毛水清, "論李商隱與鄭亞", 李商隱研究論集, pp.702~716 (1997)
- 雷巧玲, "「甘露之變」發微", 陝西師大學報（哲學社會科學版), 24(3), pp.68~73 (1995)
- 劉詠聰, "唐宋以來「尤物禍國敗家」思想的發展 In 女性與歷史──中國傳統觀念新探", pp.29~48 (1993), 香港教育圖書公司
- 馬良懷, "唐代宦官考述", 廈門大學學報（哲社版）, 4, pp.37~43 (1989)
- 馬良懷, "唐代宦官與皇帝關係考論", 華中師範大學學報（哲社版）, 5, pp.61~67 (1987)
- 劉智亭, "李商隱與牛李黨爭", 陝西師範大學學報（哲學社會科學版）, 4, pp.67~73 (1985)
- 蘇雪林, "詩謎專家李商隱", 李商隱詩研究論文集, pp.13~21 (1984), 天工書局
- 黃永武, "李商隱的遠隔心態", 李商隱詩研究論文集, pp.58~71
- 曾克耑, "李商隱之詩及其風節", 李商隱詩研究論文集, pp.199~214
- 高越天, "李義山政治詩摘箋", 李商隱詩研究論文集, pp.372~380
- 方瑜, "李商隱的詠史詩", 李商隱詩研究論文集, pp.407~448
- 董乃斌, "唐人看甘露之變", 中華文史論叢, 1, pp.105~106 (1981)
- 傅樂成, "唐人的生活 In 漢唐史論集", pp.117~141 (1977), 聯經出版事業股份有限公司
- 湯承業, "論李訓所以敗於仇士良", 食貨月刊, 3(7), pp.325~330 (1973)
- 陳貽焮, "談李商隱的詠史詩和詠物詩", 文學評論, 6, pp.97~109 (1962)
- 陳貽焮, "關於李商隱", 北京大學學報, 2, pp.55~63 (1962)
- 黃勝雄, "李商隱與令狐氏關係考──兼論相關詩文及史事", 석사, pp.2005
- 楊儀君, "論牛李黨爭與李商隱政治詩的關係", 석사, pp.2005
- 龔鵬程, "唐代思潮" (2007), 商務印書館
- 楊伯峻, "論語譯注" (2007), 中華書局
- 葛兆光, "晚唐風韻" (2004), 中華書局
- 李商隱, "李商隱全集" (2002), 珠海出版社
- 劉學鍇, "李商隱文編年校注" (2002), 中華書局
- 張豈之, "中國歷史．隋唐遼宋金卷" (2001), 高等教育出版社
- 黃山市黟縣旅遊局, "古黟楹聯" (2001), 黃山市黟縣旅遊局
- 劉學鍇, "李商隱詩歌研究" (1998), 安徽大學出版社
- 楊柳, "李商隱評傳" (1997), 當代中國出版社
- 陸龜蒙, "甫里先生文集" (1996), 河南大學出版社
- 裴庭裕, "東觀奏記" (1994), 中華書局
- 李宗吾, "厚黑學" (1994), 傳文文化事業有限公司
- 董乃斌, "李商隱的心靈世界" (1992), 上海古籍出版社
- 郁賢皓, "李商隱" (1992), 群玉堂出版事業股份有限公司
- 顏崑陽, "李商隱詩箋釋方法論" (1991), 台灣學生書局
- 李長慶, "李商隱及其作品" (1989), 時代文藝出版社
- 韓非, "韓非子" (1989), 上海古籍出版社
- 劉安等, "上海古籍出版社" (1989), 上海古籍出版社
- 劉學鍇, "李商隱詩歌集解" (1988), 中華書局
- 丁福保輯, "歷代詩話續編" (1988), 木鐸出版社
- 清聖祖敕, "全唐詩" (1987), 文史哲出版社
- 王壽南, "隋唐史" (1986), 三民書局股份有限公司
- 李涪, "刊誤 In 景印文淵閣四庫全書" (1985), 商務印書館
- 何焯, "義門讀書記", 景印文淵閣四庫全書
- 孫光憲, "北夢瑣言, In 景印文淵閣四庫全書"
- 張采田, "玉谿生年譜會箋（外一種）" (1983), 上海古籍出版社
- 李商隱, "李義山詩集" (1979), 台灣學生書局
- 劉維崇, "李商隱評傳" (1978), 黎明文化事業股份有限公司
- 丁仲祜, "清詩話" (1977), 藝文印書館
- 劉昫等, "舊唐書" (1975), 中華書局
- 歐陽修, "新唐書" (1975), 中華書局
- 王夫之, "讀通鑑論" (1975), 中華書局
- 李肇, "新校唐國史補 In 世界書局新校" (1968), 世界書局
- 王定保, "唐摭言" (1967), 世界書局
- 司馬光, "資治通鑑" (1956), 中華書局
- 詹滿江, "李商隱研究" (2005), 汲古書院
- 桐島薰子, "晚唐詩人考：李商隱．溫庭筠．杜牧の比較と考察" (1998), 中國書店
- 小川環樹, "唐代の詩人：その傳記" (1975), 大修館書店