How Can Russia Contribute to Peace in Korea?
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
This article examines what contribution, if any, Russia can make to peace on the Korean Peninsula. It begins by assessing Russia’s relatively marginal standing in the current Korean negotiations and proceeds from there to analyze Russia’s interests and stake in a Korean peace process. While in fact Moscow’s standing here is marginal, its interests in peace in Korea and overall in Northeast Asia and in being included in any such process are considerable. The main contribution it can make is in the provision of energy and trade infrastructures such as its long- standing advocacy of a trans–Siberian, trans–Korean railroad and an analogous gas pipeline. We argue that matters have reached a stage where Russia depends on at least one if not both Korean states to allow it into this process and make these kinds of contributions. But beyond the two Korean states, one of the other major participants, i.e. the United States and/or China must also permit such Russian involvement. Yet our reading of their interests strongly suggests that they are opposed to giving Russia precedence over their own interests in Korea. While there are real possibilities for one or both Korean states to invite Moscow into this process, Russia now depends upon “the kindness of strangers” to play the role it wants to have in Korea.
Abstract
This article examines what contribution, if any, Russia can make to peace on the Korean Peninsula. It begins by assessing Russia’s relatively marginal standing in the current Korean negotiations and proceeds from there to analyze Russia’s interests and stake in a Korean peace process. While in fact Moscow’s standing here is marginal, its interests in peace in Korea and overall in Northeast Asia and in being included in any such process are considerable. The main contribution it can make is in the provision of energy and trade infrastructures such as its long- standing advocacy of a trans–Siberian, trans–Korean railroad and an analogous gas pipeline. We argue that matters have reached a stage where Russia depends on at least one if not both Korean states to allow it into this process and make these kinds of contributions. But beyond the two Korean states, one of the other major participants, i.e. the United States and/or China must also permit such Russian involvement. Yet our reading of their interests strongly suggests that they are opposed to giving Russia precedence over their own interests in Korea. While there are real possibilities for one or both Korean states to invite Moscow into this process, Russia now depends upon “the kindness of strangers” to play the role it wants to have in Korea.
참고문헌 (120)
- "Low-Key Kim–Xi Summit, Vital to Both Sides" (2019)[URL]
- Shannon Tiezzi, "Xi’s North Korea Visit: All Style, No Substance?", The Diplomat, ~ (2019)
- Christopher Bodeen, "China’s Xi Pushes Economic Reform at North Korea Summit", AP News, ~ (2019)
- Yun Sun, "The Real Agenda of Xi Jinping’s First Trip to North Korea", 38 North, ~ (2019)
- Robert Carlin, "North Korea: The Pot Still Boiling", 38 North, ~ (2019)
- "North Korea Solidifies Kim Jong Un’s ‘Monolithic’ Power" (2019)[URL]
- Atsuhito Isozaki, "North Korea Revamps Its Constitution", The Diplomat, ~ (2019)
- Ankit Panda, "Report: China, Russia Have Draft UN Security Council Resolution Proposing Sanctions Relief for North Korea", The Diplomat, ~ (2019)
- Michelle Nichols, "China, Russia Propose Lifting Some U.N. Sanctions on North Korea, U.S. Says Not the Time", Reuters, ~ (2019)
- John Hudson, "Russia Secretly Offered North Korea a Nuclear Power Plant, Officials Say", Washington Post, ~ (2019)
- "Proposed Oil, Gas Pipelines from Russia to China via Mongolia" (2018)[URL]
- "Putin Orders Construction of Second Gas Pipeline to China" (2019)[URL]
- Colin Zwirko, "Russia, North Korea Agree to Work on ‘Trilateral Projects’ in Pyongyang Meeting: Moscow", NK News, ~ (2019)
- "Economic Relations between Russia and South Korea in the New Northern Policy" (2019)[URL]
- "North Korea’s Kim Not Ready to Denuclearize: U.S. Intelligence Agency Chief", Reuters, ~ (2019)
- "North Made at Least 10 More Nukes Last Year", Korea Joongang Daily, ~ (2019)
- "North Korea May Be Building Submarine Capable of Launching Nuclear Missiles" (2019)[URL]
- "North Korea Tests Submarine-Launched Missile: Seoul" (2019)[URL]
- "N. Korea Can Miniaturize Nuclear Warheads, Japan Claims" (2019)[URL]
- Report of the Panel of Experts Established Pursuant to Resolution 1874 (2009), "United Nations Security Council", ~, pp.S2019 (2019), 691
- "North Korea Building a Nuclear-Capable Submarine, Experts Say" (2019)[URL]
- "N. Korea ‘Could Have 30–40 Nukes Next Year’" (2019)[URL]
- Geoff Brumfiel, "North Korea’s Newest Missile Appears Similar to Advanced Russia Design", NPR, ~ (2019)
- "ZATO Ony Delayut Rakety" (2017)[URL]
- "Flashback to the Past: North Korea’s “New” Extended-Range Scud" (2016)[URL]
- Andrei Lankov, "Russia, Two Korea, and Unification Prospects", Korean Unification and a New East Asian Order: KINU Unification Forum, pp.115~ (2012), Korea Institute for National Unification
- "Why Russia Is Still Playing Second Fiddle in Korean Geopolitics" (2018)[URL]
- "On North Korea, Trump Has Putin Playing Second Fiddle", Moscow Times, ~ (2018)
- Artyom Lukin, "Russia and the United States in the Asia Pacific: A Perspective of the English School", Asian Perspective, 42(3), pp.307~331 (2018), 극동문제연구소
- "Russia Detains Two N. Korean Vessels after Attack—TASS" (2019)[URL]
- "Russia Detains 161 Suspected Poachers after Attack, Some Wounded- RIA" (2019)[URL]
- "No Korean Nuclear Progress without Russia, Minister Says", BBC Monitoring, ~ (2018)
- "Why Russia Is Standing Aloof on the Korean Peninsula" (2019)[URL]
- "Russia ‘Ready to Mediate’ between North Korea and the U.S", Deutsche Welle, ~ (2018)
- "U.S. Warns Russia, China and Others on Enforcing North Korea Sanctions" (2018)[URL]
- "Russia, China Block UN from Saying North Korea Violated Sanctions" (2019)[URL]
- "Vladimir Putin Addressed the Final Plenary Session of the 16th Meeting of the Valdai International Discussion Club" (2019)[URL]
- "Russia, China Coordinate New Plan on Settlement on Korean Peninsula", The Diplomat, ~ (2019)
- Artyom Lukin, "Does the Russia–China Military Alliance Begin in the Pacific", Valdai Discussion Club, ~ (2019)
- Franz-Stefan Gady, "Japan, South Korea Scramble Fighter Jets against 2 Russian Strategic Bombers", The Diplomat, ~ (2019)
- "Russia ‘Has Repeatedly Supplied Fuel to North Korea in Violation of Sanctions,’" (2017)[URL]
- Pavel Felgenhauer, "Russia Stays Mute on North Korean Launch of Apparent Iskander-Type Missiles", Eurasia Daily Monitor, ~ (2019)
- Mercy A. Kuo, "China, Russia, and U.S. Sanctions on North Korea", The Diplomat, ~ (2018)
- Vladimir Snosyrev, "The Foreign Ministers of the Russian Federation and the PRC Agreed on the Promotion of the Korean Initiative", Nezavisimaya Gazeta, ~ (2018)
- Russia’s Game on the Korean Peninsula: Accepting China’s Rise to Regional Hegemony?, in The China–Russia Entente and the Korean Peninsula, "Artem Lukin", NBR, 21~30, pp.Special Report no. 78 (2019)
- "Russia’s ‘Turn to Asia’ Has Yet to Bring Prosperity to the Far East" (2019)[URL]
- "China Promises Kremlin $2.6 Billion to Accelerate Russian Economy" (2019)[URL]
- "India Gives $1 Billion Line of Credit to Russia Far East" (2019)[URL]
- "North and South Korea on the Brink of War, Russian Diplomat Warns" (2010)[URL]
- "Russia Says Situation in Korean Peninsula Could Escalate in 2020: RIA", Reuters, ~ (2019)
- Stephen Blank, "Russia and the Two Koreas in the Context of Moscow’s Asian Policy, Academic Paper Series" (2015), Korean Economic Institute of America
- M. Nikolaev, "The Asia–Pacific Region and Russia’s National Security", International Affairs (Moscow), 56(3), pp.68~69 (2010)
- "What We’re Watching at the U.N. General Assembly" (2018)[URL]
- "China and Russia Train for War with U.S. If Trump Invades North Korea" (2017)[URL]
- "Vostok-2018:Political and Military Significance" (2018)[URL]
- Damien Sharikov, "Russia Is Preparing for North Korea War as Tensions Rise, Says Putin’s Top Security Adviser", Newsweek, ~ (2017)
- Luke Chambers, "Authoritarianism and Foreign Policy: The Twin Pillars of Resurgent Russia", Caucasian Review of International Affairs, 4(2), pp.119~120 (2010)
- Vitaly Kozyrev, "Russia’s Security Policy in Asia in Times of Economic Uncertainty", paper Presented to the Annual Meeting of the American Political Science Association, pp.21~ (2010)
- "Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov’s Remarks at the 73rd Session of the UN General Assembly, New York, September 28, 2018"[URL]
- "North Korea’s Place in Sino–Russian Relations and Identities" (2015)[URL]
- Yuri Morozov, "Russia, China, and the North Korean Nuclear Problem", Far Eastern Affairs, 46(3), pp.38~53 (2018)
- Stephen Blank, "Joint U.S.-Korea Academic Studies—The East Asian Whirlpool: Kim Jong-Un’s Diplomatic Shake-Up, China’s Sharp Power, and Trump’s Trade Wars", pp.36~59 (2019), Korean Economic Institute of America
- "Russian Writers on the Decline of Russia in the Far East and the Rise of China" (2016)[URL]
- Jacob Kipp, "From Strategic Partnership to De Facto Military Alliance: Sino–Soviet Mil–Mil Contacts in the Modern Era, 1945–2018", presented to the NPEC Conference (2018)
- "On the Verge of an Alliance: Contemporary China–Russia Military Cooperation" (2018)[URL]
- China–Russia Military-to-Military Relations: Moving toward a Higher Level of Cooperation, "Ethan Meick", U.S.-China Economic and Security Review Commission, ~ (2017)
- "The Authoritarian Entente: Sino–Russian Security Cooperation" (2019)[URL]
- "Valdai 2019: The Dawn of the East and the World Political Order" (2019)[URL]
- "We Are at Serious Risk, So We Trust China" (2019)[URL]
- "Russia–China Bomber Patrol Shows Stronger Alignment between the Two" (2019)[URL]
- "Joint Bomber Patrol over the Pacific: The Russo–Chinese Military Alliance in Action" (2019)[URL]
- Robert Farley, "The United States Tests a New GLCM: What Next?", The Diplomat, ~ (2019)
- "Esper: U.S. to Soon Put Intermediate Range Missile in Asia" (2019)[URL]
- "Defense Secretary Esper: China ‘Has Studied Us,’ Expanding Military to ‘Push U.S. Out’ of the Region" (2019)[URL]
- "China ‘Will Not Participate’ in Trump’s Proposed Three-Way Nuclear Talks" (2019)[URL]
- "China Vows to Counter U.S. Deployment of Midrange Arms in Asia" (2019)[URL]
- "Russia Says No Plans to Install New Missiles Unless U.S. Deploys Them", Reuters, ~ (2019)
- "Putin Says North Korea Needs More Encouragement", Radio Free Europe Radio Liberty, ~ (2018)
- "Putin Says North Korea Doing a Lot to Disarm But Washington Not Responding", Reuters, ~ (2018)
- "In the LOOP: U.S. Crude Exports to South Korea Soar" (2018)[URL]
- "U.S. Liquefied Natural Gas Exports Quadrupled in 2017" (2018)[URL]
- Melissa De Witte, "Economic Prosperity in North Korea Is Part of U.S. Diplomatic Vision, Says U.S. Special Representative for North Korea at Stanford Event", Stanford News, ~ (2019)
- "Multi-Million Dollar Projects Can Boost North Korea–U.S. Nuclear Talks: South Korea Minister" (2019)[URL]
- Hyung-Jin Kim, "North Korea Urges South to Stop Mediating between North, U.S", AP News, ~ (2019)
- Adam Schreck, "South Korea’s President: 3rd Trump-Kim Summit under Discussion", The Diplomat, ~ (2019)
- "China’s Russia Problem on North Korea" (2017)[URL]
- "The North Korean Nuclear Problem" (2017)[URL]
- "Russia’s Pivot to Asia: The Multilateral Dimension" (2017)[URL]
- "Kim Jong Un’s New Year’s Day Speech: Understanding ‘Sovereignty’ Is the Key" (2019)[URL]
- "Kim Jong-un Leaves China with ‘Backing for Second Trump Summit", BBC, ~ (2019)
- "China’s Xi Arrives in North Korea to Hold Talks with Kim Jong Un before G-20 Summit" (2019)[URL]
- "Chinese President Xi Jinping Gives North Korean Leader Kim Jong-un His Full Support" (2019)[URL]
- "Secret Document Reveals China Covertly Offering Missiles, Increased Aid to North Korea" (2018)[URL]
- "Donald Trump Blames China for North Korea’s Failure to Denuclearize, Beijing Slams President’s ‘Irresponsible and Absurd Logic,’" (2018)[URL]
- "Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov’s Remarks at the UN Security Council Ministerial Meeting on North Korea Settlement Efforts, New York, September 27, 2018"[URL]
- "Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov’s Statement and Answers to Media Questions at a Joint News Conference by BRICS Foreign Ministers Following Their Meeting, Pretoria" (2018)[URL]
- "Russian Diplomacy: Rather a Bad Peace than a Good Quarrel" (2019)[URL]
- "Vladimir Putin’s Interview in the Financial times, Transcript: ‘All This Fuss about Spies ... It Is Not Worth Serious Interstate Relations,’" (2019)[URL]
- Stephen Blank, "On Korea 2019: Academic Paper Studies", pp.83~96 (2019), Korean Economic Institute of America
- Nodari A. Simoniia, "TKR–TSR Linkage and Its Impact on ROK–DPRK–Russia Relationship", The Journal of East Asian Affairs, 15(2), pp.180~202 (2001)
- Stephen Blank, "The End of Russian Power in Asia?", Orbis, (Spring), pp.249~266 (2012)
- "U.S. Now Supplying LNG to Korea" (2017)[URL]
- "N. Korea Looking to Increase Exports to Russia–Report", Mainichi Shimbun, ~ (2019)
- 홍석훈, "North Korea’s Transition of Its Economic Development Strategy: Its Signicance and the Political Environment Surrounding the Korean Peninsula", The Korean Journal of Defense Analysis, 30(4), pp.493~512 (2018), 한국국방연구원[DOI]
- "N. Korea, Russia Agree to Bolster ‘High-Level Contact’ Cooperation in Various Areas", Korea Herald, ~ (2019)
- Sandip Kumar Mishra, "North Korea: Seeking New Friends?", Institute of Peace and Conflict Studies, ~ (2014)
- Liudmila Zakharova, "Economic cooperation between Russia and North Korea: New goals and new approaches", Journal of Eurasian Studies, 7(2), pp.151~161 (2016), 아태지역연구센터
- "North Korea: Kim Jong UN to Meet Putin in Russia on April 25" (2019)[URL]
- "Japan Says North Korea Developing Warheads to Penetrate Missile Defenses", Reuters, ~ (2019)
- "Lambasting Pompeo, North Korea Says Hopes for U.S. Talks Are ‘Fading,’" (2019)[URL]
- "Experts Warn North Korea Missile Crisis Could Trigger Arms Race" (2017)[URL]
- Ankit Panda, "North Korea: No Talks with South Korea until Seoul Gives ‘Plausible Excuse’for Joint Exercises", The Diplomat, ~ (2019)
- "ZATO Ony Delayut Rakety”; and Markus Schiller and Robert Schmucker, “Flashback to the Past: North Korea’s ‘New’ Extended-Range Scud" (2016)[URL]
- "‘Door Is Wide Open’ for Negotiations with North Korea U.S. Envoy Says" (2019)[URL]
- "U.S. Ready for Talks with N.K. to Make ‘Simultaneous and Parallel’ Progress: Nuke Envoy" (2019)[URL]
- "North Korea Says It Will Resume Nuclear Talks with U.S. This Weekend" (2019)[URL]
