Dual Purpose of Security Assistance and ROK’s Aerospace Capability Building: Analysis of America’s Security Assistance toward ROK in the 1970s and 1980s
0
조회
0
다운로드
1
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
America’s security assistance policies have played a pivotal role in achieving its defense and foreign policy objectives since the early Cold War era. Notwithstanding the extensive corpus on U.S. security aid, there remains a notable paucity of scholarly inquiry into the strategic underpinnings of military technology cooperation, particularly in the domain of aerospace technologies, with the weaker allies. This research endeavors to elucidate and critically assess the nexus between the United States’ security objectives within defense assistance frameworks and the evolving patterns of its security aid programs. To realize this aim, the research delves into the specific instances of America’s security support, including both conventional ways and technical assistance, toward the Republic of Korea throughout the decades of the 1970s and 1980s. This investigation particularly foregrounds the bilateral technical cooperation patterns in the acquisition of combat fighters, encompassing the F-4, F-5, and F-16 fighters, alongside surface-to-surface missile development cooperation, as case studies for empirical analysis.
Abstract
America’s security assistance policies have played a pivotal role in achieving its defense and foreign policy objectives since the early Cold War era. Notwithstanding the extensive corpus on U.S. security aid, there remains a notable paucity of scholarly inquiry into the strategic underpinnings of military technology cooperation, particularly in the domain of aerospace technologies, with the weaker allies. This research endeavors to elucidate and critically assess the nexus between the United States’ security objectives within defense assistance frameworks and the evolving patterns of its security aid programs. To realize this aim, the research delves into the specific instances of America’s security support, including both conventional ways and technical assistance, toward the Republic of Korea throughout the decades of the 1970s and 1980s. This investigation particularly foregrounds the bilateral technical cooperation patterns in the acquisition of combat fighters, encompassing the F-4, F-5, and F-16 fighters, alongside surface-to-surface missile development cooperation, as case studies for empirical analysis.
참고문헌 (122)
- Jonathan Masters, "How Much Aid Has the U.S. Sent Ukraine? Here Are Six Charts", Council on Foreign Relations, ~ (2023)
- Foreign Assistance: An Introduction to U.S. Programs and Policy, "Congressional Research Service", CRS, ~, pp.R40213 (2022)
- Building Partner Capacity: DOD and State Should Strengthen Planning for Train and Equip Projects, "U.S. GAO", United States General Accountability Office, ~, pp.GAO-23-105842 (2023)
- Rachel Tecott Metz, "The Cult of the Persuasive: Why U.S. Security Assistance Fail", International Security, 47(3), pp.95~135 (2023)
- Michael Beckley, "The Myth of Entangling Alliances: Reassessing the Security Risks of US Defense Pacts", International Security, 39(4), pp.7~48 (2015)
- "Advanced Sales in a Difficult Market Space: South Korea’s T/FA-50" (2023)[URL]
- Stephen M. Walt, "Who’s Afraid of a Balance of Power? The United States Is Ignoring the Most Basic Principle of International Relations, to Its Own Detriment", Foreign Policy, ~ (2017)
- John J. Mearsheimer, "The Tragedy of Great Power Politics" (2014), W. W. Norton & Company
- Victor D. Cha, "Powerplay: Origins of the US Alliance System in Asia", International Security, 34(3), pp.158~196 (2010)
- Benjamin O. Fordham, "Trade and Asymmetric Alliances", Journal of Peace Research, 47(6), pp.685~ (2010)
- Jack S. Levy, "Causes of War", pp.8~ (2010), Blackwell Pub
- Mark O. Yeisley, "Bipolarity, Proxy Wars, and the Rise of China", Strategic Studies Quarterly, 5(4), pp.77~ (2011)
- Double Containment and the Origins of the U.S.–Japan Alliance, "Timothy D. Temerson", Massachusetts Institute of Technology Japan Program, ~ (1992)
- , Japan and the U.S.,1960–1976, "Digital National Security Archive", 1972
- Michael T. Klare, "Restructuring the Empire: The Nixon Doctrine after Vietnam", Bulletin of Concerned Asian Scholars, 5(2), pp.57~61 (1973)
- Stephen M. Walt, "The Origins of Alliance" (1990), Cornell University Press
- Kunihiko Imai, "Dynamics of a Trilateral Game of Influence: Interactions between Major Powers’ Foreign Policy Instruments and the Behavior of Weaker States", International Interactions, 22(2), pp.189~ (1996)
- Saul B. Cohen, "Geography and Politics in a World Divided", pp.87~88 (1973), Oxford University Press
- Philip L. Kelly, "Escalation of Regional Conflict: Testing the Shatterbelt Concept", Political Geography Quarterly, 5(2), pp.161~180 (1986)
- Bruce E. Moon, "Consensus or Compliance? Foreign-Policy Change and External Dependence", International Organization, 39(2), pp.297~329 (1985)
- Eugene R. Wittkopf, "American Foreign Policy: Pattern and Process", pp.2008, Thomson
- Richard G. Stilwell, "Korea: The Implications of Withdrawal", Asian Affairs: An American Review, 4(5), pp.279~289 (1977)
- Committee on Armed Services, "The Global Posture Review of United States Military Forces Stationed Overseas (108th Congress)" (2004), U.S. Government Printing Office
- "U.S. Security Assistance to Ukraine" (2024)[URL]
- U.S. Military Aircraft Coproduction with Japan, "Joseph E. Kelley", United States General Accounting Office, ~, pp.T-NSIAD-89-6 (1989)
- John Andreas Olsen, "A History of Air Warfare" (2010), Potomac Books, Inc
- Roger F. Kropt, "Air and Space Power Theory and Doctrine", pp.113~128 (1997), American Heritage Custom Publishing
- Edward Coltrin Keefer, "Harold Brown: Offsetting the Soviet Military Challenge 1977–1981" (2017), U.S. Government Publishing Office
- U.S. GAO, "Coproduction Programs and Licensing Arrangements in Foreign Countries (ID-76-23)", United States General Accounting Office, 23~ (1975)
- U.S. GAO, "Sharing the Defense Burden: The Multinational F-16 Aircraft Program", U.S. General Accounting Office, ~ (1977)
- "System of Systems Integration Technology and Experimentation (SoSITE)" (2019)[URL]
- David W Tarr, "Military Technology and the Policy Process", The Western Political Quarterly, 18(1), pp.141~145 (1965)
- U.S. NSC, "PRM", NSC 13: Korea: Presidential Review, 1977
- James Everett Katz, "The Implication of Third World Military Industrialization: Sowing the Serpents’ Teeth", pp.4~9 (1986), Lexington Books
- "Announcement Concerning a Presidential Directive on United States Conventional Arms Transfer Policy", The Reagan Library, ~ (1981)
- "Schlesinger Chides Japan on Defense", The New York Times, ~ (1975)
- , Japan and the U.S., 1977–1992, "Digital National Security Archive Database", 1978
- Joseph S. Bermudez, "A History of Ballistic Missile Development in the DPRK" (1999), Center for Nonproliferation Studies
- , Korea, 1969–2000, "Digital National Security Archive", 1973
- James H. Buck, "The Role of Korea in Japanese Defense Policy", Asian Affairs, 4(4), pp.221~227 (1977)
- Richard A. Mobley, "Historical Crises in North Korea: Lessons from the USS Pueblo and EC-121 Incidents—1968 and 1969", Studies in Intelligence, 59(1), pp.1~10 (2015)
- U. Alexis Johnson, "The Right Hand of Power: The Memoirs of an American Diplomat", pp.523~524 (1984), Prentice-Hall, Inc
- The White House, "PD", NSC-12: U.S. Policy in Korea, 1977
- The White House, "Presidential Review Memorandum", NSC-10: Comprehensive Nest Assessment and Military Posture Review, 1977
- U.S. DOS, "Brown", Park Conversation Re Ground Forces Withdrawals and Compensatory Measure, 1977
- Norman D. Levin, "Korea in Postwar U.S. Security Policy", pp.27~ (1982), Rand Corporation
- ROK MND, "The Fifty Years History of ROK Military Force", pp.163~ (1998), ROK Ministry of National Defense
- , Korea, 1969–2000, "Digital National Security Archive", 1982
- "NSDM 227: Korean Force Modernization Plan" (1973)[URL]
- National Archives of Korea, "Translation of Overseas Collection Records: Records of the President Ford Library of the United States: Korea–U.S. Relations in the 1970s", National Archives of Korea, ~ (2008)
- , Acquisition of Aircraft (G-0040), "Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Frame no. 11", 2006
- American Embassy Seoul, "Joint Embassy", COMUSK Message: ROKG Fighter Aircraft Procurement, Electronic Telegrams, 1974, 1, pp.1973–12 (1974), 31[DOI]
- American Embassy Seoul, "F-16 for Korea", 1978SEOUL05492, Central Foreign Policy Files, created 7, 1973–12, pp.31, 1979, File no. D780264-0472, Access to Archival Databases[DOI]
- Jujin Park, "A Study on the Korean Air Power Building: A Comparative Analysis of Park Chung-hee and Chun Doo-hwan Administration’s Fighter Procurement", Ph.D., pp.2016
- American Embassy Seoul, "F-16’s for Korea", 1978SEOUL09189, Central Foreign Policy Files, created 7, 1973–12, pp.31, 1979, File no. D780420-0344, Access to Archival Databases[DOI]
- American Embassy Seoul, "US Assistance to ROK Defense Industries", Central Foreign Policy Files, Electronic Telegrams, 1978, ~ (1978)
- U.S. DOS, "F-16’s for Korea", 1978STATE015562, Central Foreign Policy Files, created 7, 1973–12, pp.31, 1979, File no. D780030-0435, Access to Archival Databases[DOI]
- Headquarters CINCPAC, "Commander in Chief Pacific Command History 1979" (1980), Pacific Commander History Branch
- CIA, "South Korea: Nuclear Development and Strategic Decisionmaking", Central Intelligence Agency, 8~ (1978)
- U.S. DOS, "Sale of Rocket Propulsion Technology to South Korea", Memorandum, National Security Adviser Presidential Country Files for East Asia and the Pacific, Box 9, Korea (3), Retrieved from History and Public Policy Program Digital Archive database. Gerald R. Ford Presidential Library, ~ (1975)
- U.S. NSC, "Development of US Policy toward South Korean Development of Nuclear Weapons", Memorandum, National Security Adviser Presidential Country Files for East Asia and the Pacific, History and Public Policy Program Digital Archive Database (Box 9, Korea (4)), Gerald R. Ford Presidential Library, ~ (1975)
- American Embassy Seoul, "ROKG Decision on Exocet, Submarines, and F5ES", Electronic Telegrams, 1974 (1974SEOUL08642, Central Foreign Policy Files, created 7, 1973–12, pp.31, 1979 Record Group 59, File no. D740377-0848), Access to Archival Database[DOI]
- Dinshaw Mistry, "Containing Missile Proliferation: Strategic Technology, Security Regimes, and International Cooperation in Arms Control" (2003), University of Washington Press
- "SIPRI Arms Transfers Database" (2019)[URL]
- American Embassy Seoul, "Missile Range Static and Flight Test Equipment", Electronic Telegramse, 1975 (1975STATE233992, Central Foreign Policy Files, created 7, 1973–12, pp.31, 1979, Record Group 59, File no. D750340-1021), Access to Archival Databases[DOI]
- American Embassy Seoul, "Missile Range Static and Flight Test Equipment", Electronic Telegrams, 1975 (1975SEOUL07966, Central Foreign Policy Files, created 7, 1973–12, pp.31, 1979, Record Group 59, File no. D750352-0832), Access to Archival Databases[DOI]
- American Embassy Seoul, "Missile Range Static and Flight Test Equipment", Electronic Telegrams, 1975 (1975SEOUL08145, Central Foreign Policy Files, created 7, 1973–12, pp.31, 1979, Record Group 59, File no. D750363-0260), Access to Archival Databases[DOI]
- American Embassy Seoul, "Propoesed Export of Vibration Test Equipment", Electronic Telegrams, 1975 (1975SEOUL01567, Central Foreign Policy Files, created 7, 1973–12, pp.31, 1979, Record Group 59, File no. D750083-0138), Access to Archival Databases[DOI]
- Headquarters CINCPAC, "Commander in Chief Pacific Command History 1975 (Volume I)", pp.433~ (1976), Pacific Commander History Branch
- American Embassy Seoul, "Pak Praises ROK Defense Industry", Electronic Telegrams, 1977, Access to Archival Databases, ~ (1977)
- "Database: North Korean Provocations" (2019)[URL]
- Don Oberdorfer, "The Two Koreas: A Contemporary History", pp.108~ (2001), Basic Books
- Gyu-hwa Seo, "A Research on Park’s Government Self-reliance Defense Policy Development Process", Ph.D., pp.2016
- "Digital National Security Archive", 1970
- U.S. DOS, "F-16’s for Korea", 1978STATE151842, Central Foreign Policy Files, created 7, 1973–12, pp.31, 1979, File no. D780249-0411, Access to Archival Databases[DOI]
- CIA, "Military Balance on the Korean Peninsula", Korea, 1969–2000, Digital National Security Archive database (Intelligence Memorandum), ~ (1978)
- "Korean Missile Forces" (2016)[URL]
- B.-j. Park, "Story on South Korea’s Weapons Development: The Case of Baekgom Guided Missile, a Signal of Military Self-Reliance", SegyeIlbo, ~ (2010)
- Ivo H. Daalder, "Rethinking the Unthinkable: New Directions for Nuclear Arms Control", pp.221~223 (1993), Routledge
- U.S. NSC, "PRM", NSC-45: U.S. Policy Toward Korea, 1979
- CIA, "Soviet Policy in East Asia (NIE 11", 40-84), 1984, pp.5~
- Military Presence: U.S. Personnel in NATO Europe, "U.S. GAO", United States General Accounting Office, 14~15, pp.NSIAD-90-4 (1989)
- , Korea, 1969–2000, Digital National Security Archive Database, "1983", ~
- , FOIA Collection, (0005569324), CIA Archives, "1987", 7~
- Kwak Tae–Hwan, "Military Capabilities of South and North Korea: A Comparative Study", Asian Perspective, 14(1), pp.113~ (1990)
- , General CIA Records, CIA Archives, "1985", ~
- Victor D. Cha, "Alignment Despite Antagonism: The United States–Korea–Japan Security Triangle", pp.174~ (1999), Stanford University Press
- Stephen P. Gibert, "U.S. Foreign Policy and Asian–Pacific Security: A Transregional Approach", pp.83~ (1982), Westview Press
- "President Chun Doo Hwan: A Brief Explanations on Foreign Policy"[URL]
- ROK MND, "The White Paper, 1994–95", pp.108~114 (1994), ROK Ministry of National Defense
- , Soviet–U.S. Relations, 1985–1991, Digital National Security Archive, "1988", ~
- Richard T. Detrio, "Strategic Partners: South Korea and the United States", pp.8~ (1989), National Defense University Press
- , Korea, 1969–2000, Digital National Security Archive Database, "1982", ~
- , 2007
- , Korea, 1969–2000, Digital National Security Archive, "1983", ~
- ROK MND, "The White Paper 1989" (1989), ROK Ministry of National Defense
- American Embassy Seoul, "Interagency Study of Arms Production and Implication", Central Foreign Policy Files, Electronic Telegrams, 1979, ~ (1979)
- Kim Jung Ik, "The Future of the US–Republic of Korea Military Relationship", pp.58~ (1996), St. Martin’s Press
- American Embassy Seoul, "Weekly Status Report: Korea", 1979STATE222033, Central Foreign Policy Files, created 7, 1973–12, pp.31, 1979 Record Group 59, File no. D790386-0116, Access to Archival Database[DOI]
- Two Coproduction Program: F-5E Aircraft in Taiwan and M-16 Rifle in the Philippines, "U.S. GAO", United States General Accounting Office, ~, pp.ID-76-84 (1977)
- , Korea, 1969–2000, Digital National Security Archive Database, "1979", ~
- Yu Kun Woo, "A Review of the R.O.K. Decision to Coassembly F-5E", F Aircraft (AFIT, SM,’soM-16), pp.master, U.S. Air University
- Headquarters CINCPAC, "Commander in Chief Pacific Command History 1981", pp.424~ (1982), Pacific Commander History Branch
- , China and the United States: From Hostility to Engagement, 1960–1998 Database (China, 1960–1998), "Digital National Security Archives", 1981
- William Bolles, "Security Assistance to South Korea: Assessment of Political, Economic and Military Issues from 1975–1979", master, pp.1979
- "U.S.–Korea Fighter Coproduction Program (T-NSIAD-90-29)" (1990)[URL]
- U.S.–Korea Fighter Coproduction Program: The F-16 Version, "U.S. GAO", U.S. General Accounting Office, ~, pp.T-NSIAD-91-53 (1991)
- Park Jub Bok, "The 40 Years Myth of Korean Missile: Self-defense and People who Achieve Dream", pp.60~70 (2011), Ilchikak
- Ahn Dong Man, "Baekgom (NH-K), the History of Challenges and Victory: The Story of South Korea’s First Surface to Surface Missile Development", pp.322~ (2016), Planet Media
- American Embassy Seoul, "(S) Korean Development of Surface-to-Surface Missile", Electronic Telegrams, 1979, (1979SEOUL14577, Central Foreign Policy Files, created 7, 1973–12, pp.31, 1979 Record Group 59, File no. D790436-1264), Access to Archival Database[DOI]
- Secretary of State, "Letter to ROK on SSMS", Electronic Telegrams, 1979 (1979STATE288570, Central Foreign Policy Files, created 7, 1973–12, pp.31, 1979 Record Group 59, File no. D790509-0069), Access to Archival Database[DOI]
- , NGA Records (Formerly NIMA), (CIARDP85T00060R000300020001-9), CIA Archive, "1984", ~
- , General CIA Records, (CIARDP88T00539R000600800002-5), CIA Archives, "1987", ~
- James Clay Moltz, "Asia’s Space Race: National Motivations, Regional Rivalries, and International Risks", pp.140~ (2012), Columbia University Press
- Secretary of State, "US Policy on ROK Surface-to-Surface Missile Development", Electronic Telegrams, 1979 (1979STATE288590, Central Foreign Policy Files, created 7, 1973–12, pp.31, 1979 Record Group 59, File no. D790509-0175), Access to Archival Database[DOI]
- Headquarters CINCPAC, "Commander in Chief Pacific Command History 1983" (1984), Pacific Commander History Branch
- ADD, "The History of Agency for Defence Development, Vol III, 1991–2005", pp.59~ (2007), Agency for Defence Development
- ROK MOST, "The 40 Years History of Science and Technology", pp.389~ (2008), Ministry of Science and Technology
- , Korea, 1969–2000, Digital National Security Archive, "1983", ~
- Technologies Underlying Weapons of Mass Destruction, "U.S. Congress", U.S. Government Printing Office, 212~, pp.OTA-BP-ISC-115 (1993)
- "Satellites, Summits and Succession in North Korea" (2024)[URL]
- U.S. Congress Senate, "S. Hrg. 116-513: The Proposal to Establish a United States Space Force (April 11, 2019)", U.S. Government Publishing Office, ~ (2019)
