본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

‘Grandfather Tree’: Ute Horror at the Killing of a Heritage Tree

1

조회

0

다운로드

0

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

초록

This paper illustrates that epistemological barriers can stand inthe way of communication about, and understanding of, naturalheritage resources. This common problem becomes explicit byusing the 2017 killing of a living Ute ‘Grandfather Tree’ in Delta,Colorado. The 260-year-old tree, which was recognised asculturally central to the three Ute Indian Tribes and the people ofthe State of Colorado, was cut down while still alive by the DeltaCounty Historical Society. Communication about this actionwas short, one-sided, and clouded by the contrasting beliefs ofthe two parties: i.e., to Euro-Americans the tree was just woodwithout rights, while to the Ute people the tree was a livinggrandfather with full rights to exist.

Abstract

This paper illustrates that epistemological barriers can stand inthe way of communication about, and understanding of, naturalheritage resources. This common problem becomes explicit byusing the 2017 killing of a living Ute ‘Grandfather Tree’ in Delta,Colorado. The 260-year-old tree, which was recognised asculturally central to the three Ute Indian Tribes and the people ofthe State of Colorado, was cut down while still alive by the DeltaCounty Historical Society. Communication about this actionwas short, one-sided, and clouded by the contrasting beliefs ofthe two parties: i.e., to Euro-Americans the tree was just woodwithout rights, while to the Ute people the tree was a livinggrandfather with full rights to exist.

참고문헌 (39)

  1. Adams, B., "Timescapes of Modernity: The Environmental & Invisible Hazards" (1998), Routledge
  2. Bonaiuto, M., "Feng Shui and Environmental Psychology: A Critical Comparison", Journal of Architectural and Planning Research, 27(1), pp.23~34 (2010)
  3. Barad, K., "Meeting the universe halfway: quantum physics and the entanglement of matter and meaning" (2007), Duke University Press
  4. Bond, A., "Sustainability Assessment: Pluralism, Practice, and Progress" (2013), Routledge
  5. Burkhead, J., "Smoking River Powwow Exceed Expectations", Herald Times: Serving Rio Blanco County Since (2008)
  6. Callaway, D., "Ute. Handbook of North American Indians, Great Basin, Vol 11" (1986), Smithsonian Institution
  7. Davis, T., "The Uncompahgre Valley" (2010), Arcadia Publishing
  8. Decker, P., "The Utes Must Go!: American Expansion and the Removal of a People" (2004), Fulcrum Publishing
  9. Denison, B., "Ute Land Religion in the American West, 1879-2009" (2017), University of Nebraska Press
  10. Fenn, E., "Pox Americana: The Great Smallpox Epidemic of 1775 to 1782" (2001), Hill and Wang
  11. Gahman, L., "White Settler Society as Monster: Rural Southeast Kansas, Ancestral Osage (Wah-Zha-Zhi) Territories, and the Violence of Forgetting", Antipode, 48(2), pp.314~335 (2016)
  12. Goldman, A., "Knowledge in a Social World" (1999), Oxford University Press
  13. Hansen, K., "Encounter On the Great Plains: Scandinavian Settlers and the Dispossession of the Dakota Indians, 1890-1930" (1930), Oxford University Press
  14. Hurwitz, L., "Got Land? Thank an Indian: Settler Colonialism and the White Settler in the Karuk Ancestral Territory", Humboldt Journal of Social Relations, 35, pp.59~76 (2014)
  15. Inwood, J. F., "Property and Whiteness: The Oregon Standoff and the Contradictions of the US Settler State", Space and Polity (2017)
  16. Inwood, J. F., "Confronting White Supremacy and a Militaristic Pedagogy in the US Settle Colonial State", Annals of the American Association of Geographers, 106(3), pp.521~529 (2016)
  17. Jacobs, G., "The Phantom Pathfinder: Juan Maria Antonio de Rivera and his Expedition", Utah Historical Quarterly, 60(3), pp.200~223 (1992)
  18. Pitblado, B., "Peak to Peak in Paleoindian Time: Occupation of Southwest Colorado", Plains Anthropologist, 43(166), pp.333~348 (1998)
  19. Sanchez, G., "Human (Clovis)—gomphothere (Cuvieronius sp.) association 13,390 ˜ calibrated yBP in Sonora, Mexico", Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 111(30), pp.10972~10977 (2014)
  20. Sanchez, S., "Tigua sculpture vandalized with red paint, ‘Columbus Day’ on cross", El Paso Times, ~ (2017)
  21. Slivka, K., "This is Part of our heritage: Centuries-old tree, revered by Ute tribe, dramatically cut back", The Daily Sentinel: Grand Junction (2017)
  22. Smith, A., "Ethnography of the Northern Utes" (1974), University of New Mexico Press
  23. Stewart, O., "Ute Indians: Before and After White Contact. Institute of Behavioral Sciences" (1966), University of Colorado
  24. Stewart, O., "Ethnohistorical Bibliography of the Ute Indians of Colorado" (1971), University of Colorado Press
  25. Stewart, O., "Peyote Religion: A History" (1987), University of Oklahoma Press
  26. Stoffle, R., "Collaborative Heritage Management. Tully, Gemma Tully and Ridges", pp.75~99 (2016), Gorgias Press
  27. Stoffle, R., "Resource Competition and Population Change: Kaibab Paiute Ethnohistorical Case", Ethnohistory, 23(2), pp.173~197 (1976)
  28. Stoffle, R., "Facing the Unimaginable: Hopi and Southern Paiute Respond to Massive Risk Events", The Applied Anthropologist, 35(1), pp.13~22 (2015)
  29. Stoffle, R., "Resilience at Risk, Epistemological and Social Construction Barriers to Risk Communication", Journal of Risk Research, 11(1&2), pp.55~68 (2008)
  30. Stoffle, R., "Ethnographic Overview and Assessment of Hovenweep National Park" (2018), School of Anthropology, University of Arizona
  31. Stoffle, R., "Sustainability Assessment: Pluralism, Practice and Progress", pp.51~67 (2013), Routledge
  32. Stoffle, R., "Ethnohistoric and Ethnographic Assessment of Contemporary Communities along the Old Spanish Trail. Prepared for the National Park Service, Trails Division" (2008), Bureau of Applied Research in Anthropology, University of Arizona
  33. Stoffle, R., "American Indians and the Old Spanish Trail. Prepared for the National Park Service, Trails Division" (2008), Bureau of Applied Research in Anthropology, University of Arizona
  34. Stoffle, R., "Facility Siting: Risk, Power and Identity in Land Use Planning", pp.127~144 (2004), Earthscan Publications Ltd
  35. Sutton, I., "Irredeemable America: Indians’ Estate and Land Claims" (1986), Olympic Marketing Corporation
  36. Toupal, T., "Prepared for the National Park Service Midwest Region Tucson" (2003), Bureau of Applied Research in Anthropology, The University of Arizona
  37. Van Vlack, K., "Ethnographic Evaluation of Effigy Mounds National Monument" (2015), Bureau of Applied Research in Anthropology, University of Arizona
  38. Veracini, L., "Introducing Settler Colonial Studies", Settler Colonial Studies, 1, pp.1~12 (2011)
  39. Wetzel, J., "A Spirit Returns: Delta County, Colorado: A Pictorial History" (2003), The Donning Company Publishers

관련 논문AI추천

'할아버지 나무': 유산목 벌목에 얽힌 유트 인디언의 참상아덴 나란조, 켈리 실브카, 리처드 스토플, 크리스 시틀러국립민속박물관 · International Journal of Intangible Heritage2018 · 제13호Living Universe or GeoFacts: stone arches in Utah National Parks - epistemological divides in heritage environmental communicationChristopher Sittler, Evelyn Pickering, Heather H. Lim, Kathleen Van Vlack, Richard W. Stoffle국립민속박물관 · International Journal of Intangible Heritage2020 · 제15호살아있는 우주인가? 또는 지질학적 유물(GeoFacts)인가?: 유타 국립공원의 석조아치 – 문화유산을 둘러싼 커뮤니케이션의 인식론적 분열리차드 W. 스토플국립민속박물관 · International Journal of Intangible Heritage2020 · 제15권 제2호Ghost of the Forest: the Tangible and Intangible in Natural and Cultural HeritageMarcel Robischon국립민속박물관 · International Journal of Intangible Heritage2015 · 제10호숲의 유령: 자연유산과 문화유산의 유•무형적 요소마르셀 로비숀국립민속박물관 · International Journal of Intangible Heritage2015 · 제10호Heritage value and touristisation of the Day of the Dead in Mixquic, Mexico: perspectives from local childrenBruna Galindo Moury Fernandes, Driselda P. Sánchez-Aguirre, Eric Orlando Jiménez Rosas, Ilia Alvarado-Sizzo국립민속박물관 · International Journal of Intangible Heritage2025 · 제1권 제20호

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (27건)