헤바 서판과 트리부스민회에 비추어본 켄투리아민회의 개편
The Reform of the Centuriate Assembly in the Light of the Tabula Hebana and the Tribal Assembly
0
조회
0
다운로드
1
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
This paper aims to reconsider the reform of the centuriate assembly(Comitia Centuriata) in the light of the Tabula Hebana and the tribal assembly(Comitia Tributa). My main points are as follows. First, it seems certain that Augustus's resolve to cling to and to revive Republican forms extended to his plans for procedure in the select assembly(comitia) responsible for destinatio in the Tabula Hebana. Second, I suggest that voting method by which the senators and equites voted into the fifteen large urns each in the Tabula Hebana would be same as that by which the 280 junior centuries(iuniores) and senior centuries(seniores) of the five classes voted into the 170 urns(voting centuries) each in the reformed centuriate assembly. If my suggestion is right, the voting procedure in the tribal assembly would be introduced for the voting of five classes in the reformed centuriate assembly. As any one tribe among 35 tribes for voting of five classes each was drawn by lot, iuniores in each class from that tribe would approach their urn and cast their vote; when they have cast their vote in this way and returned, then seniores in each class from same tribe would approach the same urn or other urn and cast their vote. This voting method in reformed centuriate assembly is the voting by the tribes that Appian remarked in the his Bellum Civilium, I. 59. Third, I suggest that the second class had 35 centuries; the third and fourth classes had 20 centuries each; the fifth class had 25 centuries. In conclusion, I suggest that as compared with the voting by the centuries in Servian centuriate assembly, the voting in the reformed centuriate assembly would be by the tribes.
Abstract
This paper aims to reconsider the reform of the centuriate assembly(Comitia Centuriata) in the light of the Tabula Hebana and the tribal assembly(Comitia Tributa). My main points are as follows. First, it seems certain that Augustus's resolve to cling to and to revive Republican forms extended to his plans for procedure in the select assembly(comitia) responsible for destinatio in the Tabula Hebana. Second, I suggest that voting method by which the senators and equites voted into the fifteen large urns each in the Tabula Hebana would be same as that by which the 280 junior centuries(iuniores) and senior centuries(seniores) of the five classes voted into the 170 urns(voting centuries) each in the reformed centuriate assembly. If my suggestion is right, the voting procedure in the tribal assembly would be introduced for the voting of five classes in the reformed centuriate assembly. As any one tribe among 35 tribes for voting of five classes each was drawn by lot, iuniores in each class from that tribe would approach their urn and cast their vote; when they have cast their vote in this way and returned, then seniores in each class from same tribe would approach the same urn or other urn and cast their vote. This voting method in reformed centuriate assembly is the voting by the tribes that Appian remarked in the his Bellum Civilium, I. 59. Third, I suggest that the second class had 35 centuries; the third and fourth classes had 20 centuries each; the fifth class had 25 centuries. In conclusion, I suggest that as compared with the voting by the centuries in Servian centuriate assembly, the voting in the reformed centuriate assembly would be by the tribes.
참고문헌 (25)
- 김경현, "기원전 3세기 Comitia Centuriata(켄투리아회)의 개혁", 서양고대사연구, 8, pp.21~37 (2000)
- 김덕수, "<헤바 서판>(Tabula Hebana)과 켄투리아회", 서양사연구, 30, pp.1~28 (2003)
- 허승일, "켄투리아회 개편, in 증보 로마 공화정 연구", pp.24~41 (1995), 서울대 출판부
- Brunt, P. A., "The Lex Valeria Cornelia", The Journal of Roman Studies, 51, pp.71~83 (1961)
- Crawford M. H., "Roman Statutes" (1996)
- De Sanctis, G., "Storia dei Romani" (1917)
- Fraccaro, P., "Opuscula" (1957)
- Gallo, F., "La riforma dei comizi centuriati", Studia et Documenta Historiae et Iuris, 18, pp.127~157 (1952)
- Oliver J. H., "Text of the Tabula Hebana", American Journal of Philology, 75, pp.225~249 (1954)
- Dell'Oro, A., "Rogatio e riforma dei comizi centuriati alla luce della Tabula Hebana", LaParola del Passato, 5, pp.132~150 (1950)
- Develin, R., "The Third Reform of the Comitia Centuriata", Athenaeum, 56, pp.346~377 (1978)
- Gabba, E., "Appiani Bellorum Civilium Liber Primus" (1957)
- Grieve, L. J., "The Reform of the Comitia Centuriata", Historia, 34, pp.278~309 (1985)
- Lintott, A., "The Constitution of the Roman Republic" (1999)
- Momigliano, A., "Studi sugli ordinamenti centuriati", Studia et Documenta Historiae et Iuris, 4, pp.509~520 (1938)
- Mommsen, Th., "Römische Staatsrecht, Band III" (1887)
- Nicholls, J. J., "The Reform of the Comitia Centuriata", American Journal of Philology, 77, pp.225~254 (1956)
- Rosenberg, A., "Untersuchungen zur römischen Zenturienverfassung" (1911)
- Schönbauer, E., "Die römische CenturienVerfassung in neuer Quellenschau", Historia, 2, pp.21~49 (1953)
- Staveley, E. S., "The Reform of the Comitia Centuriata", American Journal of Philology, 74, pp.1~33 (1953)
- Staveley, E. S., "Greek and Roman Voting and Elections" (1972)
- Taylor, L. R., "The Centuriate Assembly before and after the Reform", American Journal of Philology, 78, pp.337~354 (1957)
- Taylor, L. R., "Roman Voting Assemblies" (1966)
- Tibiletti, G., "Il funzionamento dei comizi centuriata alla luce della Tavola Hebana", Athenaeum, 27, pp.210~245 (1949)
- Yakobson, A., "Dionysius of Halicarssus on a Democratic Change in the Centuriate Assembly", Scripta Classica Israelica, 12, pp.139~155 (1993)