경‧검 수사권의 합리적인 조정에 관한 연구
Study on Reasonable Adjustments of Police and Prosecutors' Investigations
0
조회
0
다운로드
20
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Police law enforcement authority in the country's symbol, the police system to keep the democratic rule of law principles is the nation's basic institutions. This phase of the police in determining the level of democracy in that country can be considered an important indicator. In this study, investigations of police and prosecutors to exercise a reasonable independence from Japan after adjusting for the investigations and take a look at the history of the debate concerning, prosecutors argued that the problems of monopoly investigations. And Germany. France. United States. England. Japan and investigations were reviewed. September 2, 2004 the Attorney General to adjust discretionary power to investigate as the council was composed of police and prosecutors, Sept. 10, police and prosecutors' investigations adjustments consultative body that has established December 16, the police investigation in progress meetings ensure the independence of the opening of the 19 agreed to. However, despite these efforts did not get the expected results. Modern society, human rights interpretation and application of the law and society is at the center of international exchange. Currently the national police and the prosecution of human rights is of utmost importance. The number of lawyers will increase very much. Growth of a lawyer for the crime, including the various social phenomena will lead to legal judgments and legal support. Recent investigations relating to coordination and the efforts of the National Assembly hope to bear fruit. And emphasizing the rights of police and prosecutors to cases of reasonable adjustments is expected to be a reality.
Abstract
Police law enforcement authority in the country's symbol, the police system to keep the democratic rule of law principles is the nation's basic institutions. This phase of the police in determining the level of democracy in that country can be considered an important indicator. In this study, investigations of police and prosecutors to exercise a reasonable independence from Japan after adjusting for the investigations and take a look at the history of the debate concerning, prosecutors argued that the problems of monopoly investigations. And Germany. France. United States. England. Japan and investigations were reviewed. September 2, 2004 the Attorney General to adjust discretionary power to investigate as the council was composed of police and prosecutors, Sept. 10, police and prosecutors' investigations adjustments consultative body that has established December 16, the police investigation in progress meetings ensure the independence of the opening of the 19 agreed to. However, despite these efforts did not get the expected results. Modern society, human rights interpretation and application of the law and society is at the center of international exchange. Currently the national police and the prosecution of human rights is of utmost importance. The number of lawyers will increase very much. Growth of a lawyer for the crime, including the various social phenomena will lead to legal judgments and legal support. Recent investigations relating to coordination and the efforts of the National Assembly hope to bear fruit. And emphasizing the rights of police and prosecutors to cases of reasonable adjustments is expected to be a reality.
참고문헌 (39)
- 서보학, "헌법상 검사독점적 영장청구권 문제의 실증적‧처방적 연구", 선진 수사제도연구 학술세미나 자료집 (2010), 경찰청‧선진수사제도연구회
- 사법경찰의 수사권 독립에 관한 연구. in: 경찰 수사권 체제의 합리화 방안, "김경희", 치안연구소, ~ (2000)
- 차용석, "완전독립보다 일정형벌 이하 범죄에 수사권부여 바람직", 수사연구 (1992)
- 정웅석, "사법통제 없는 수사권 독립은 문제, 국회보, 2003. 2", ~ (2003)
- 표창원, "수사제도 개선의 당위성", 시민과 변호사 (2003)
- 송강호, "주체적 수사권을 향하여", 경찰법연구, 2(1)통권 : 2 (2003)
- 김창윤, "한국과 일본의 미군정기 치안정책 비교 연구", 경찰학연구, 9(2), pp.39~72 (2009), 경찰대학
- 신동운, "형사소송법제정자료집", pp.190~ (1990), 한국형사정책연구원
- 허남오, "한국경찰제도사", pp.339~342 (1998), 동도원
- 안미영, "우리 헌법상 검사의 영장신청권 조항의 의의", 형사법의 신동향, (24), pp.1~45 (2010), 대검찰청
- 독일‧오스트리아‧스위스의 형사법 개정추이 연구-특히 수사체계에서 검사의 지위와 역할을 중심으로-, "김일수", 법무부, 4~16 (2006)
- "경향신문, 2010. 4. 21", ~ (2010)
- "매달 두 번 촌지‧룸살롱 술판 … 성접대도(경향신문, 2010. 4. 22)", ~ (2010)
- "사상최대 ‘스폰서 스캔들’ … 검, 사활 건 조사(동아일보, 2010. 4. 22)", ~ (2010)
- "게이트 때마다 판‧검사 스폰서 논란(중앙일보, 2010. 4. 22)", ~ (2010)
- "검찰 스폰서 문화도 토착비리의 한 축이다(중앙일보, 2010. 4. 23)", ~ (2010)
- "검사의 옷을 벗긴다 한들 …, 진상규명위 위에 검찰조사단 … 시작부터 ‘삐걱’, 옷 벗으면 그만 … 검찰 징계는 ‘솜방망이 역사’ (경향신문, 2010. 4. 26)", ~ (2010)
- "‘스폰서 검사’ 진상규명 용두사미 우려(경향신문, 2010. 4. 27)", ~ (2010)
- 천진호, "합리적 수사권 조정 원리에 관한 연구", 경찰학연구, (9), pp.9~44 (2005), 경찰대학
- 박노섭, "수사기소분리에 대한 경‧검 상호관계에 관한 연구", 선진 수사제도연구 학술세미나 자료집, pp.124~125 (2010), 경찰청‧선진수사제도연구회
- 이관희, "경찰수사권의 독자성 확보방안", 수사연구, pp.23~ (1992)
- 이웅혁, "형사사법시스템 분석 : 경찰공무원의 검사 수사지휘에 대한 조직공정성 인식을 중심으로", 경찰법연구, 6(1), pp.95~118 (2008), 한국경찰법학회
- 이헌, "수사권 독립논의에 앞선 당면과제", 수사연구 (1992)
- Wolfgan Wohlers, "Entstehung und Funktion der Staatsanwaltschaft", pp.70~ (1994)
- 형사사법체계상에서 경찰의 수사권 현실화 방안. in: 경찰 수사권 체제의 합리화 방안, "이상원", 치안연구소, ~ (2000)
- 정진환, "비교경찰제도론", pp.120~ (1991), 대정
- 박창호, "비교수사제도론-한국 수사구조의 개혁을 향한 기초연구-", pp.354~ (2004), 박영사
- 이완규, "독일에서의 경찰독자수사권 논쟁과 결과", 형사정책연구, 14(1), pp.349~360 (2003), 한국형사정책연구원
- James S. Kakalik, "Private Police in the United States (Finding and Recommendation)", pp.11~ (1971), Rand Corporation
- 표성수, "미국의 검찰과 한국의 검찰", pp.58~ (2000), 육법사
- Alec Samuels, "Non-Crown Prosecutions: Prosecutions by Non-Police Agencies and by Private Individuals", Criminal Law Review (1986)
- A Sanders, "Prosecution Decisions and the Attorney- General's Guidelines", Criminal Law Review, pp.5~ (1985)
- Andrew Sanders, "Criminal Justice, 2d ed.", pp.347~ (2000)
- 野村護, "刑事警察50年のあゆみ", 警察學論集, 52(1) (1999)
- 國松孝次, "刑事警察の歷史と今後のあり方. in: 講座 日本の警察(第2卷 刑事警察)", pp.7~ (1993), 立花書房
- 三井誠, "刑事手續法(1)", pp.76~77 (1997), 有斐閣
- 박정섭, "경찰수사의 선진화를 위한 수사권 독립에 관현 연구", 수사연구 (1992)
- 경찰청, "합리적인 수사권 조정방향", pp.17~ (2006), 경찰청
- 한인섭, "정의의 법 양심의 법 인권의 법", pp.142~152 (2004), 박영사