본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

카이도의 최후 激戰地 연구

A Study on Qaidu’s Last Ferocious Battlefield

류병재
한국몽골학회 (KAMS)|2018.11|몽골학 (Mongolian Studies)|제55호|pp. 75-100|DOI 10.17292/kams.2018..55.004

0

조회

0

다운로드

3

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

카이도테메르잔-바바한델룬산하르 하드오르트
주제분류기타동양어문학

초록

The purpose of this study is to historically research into where the combat branch was exactly between Qaidu(海都) and Da Yuan(大元) Ulus military, which took place at the Altai Mountains in the eighth lunar month in 1301. This researcher tried to generally reconstruct a historical situation in those days through a documentary research and an on-site survey in addition to where the last ferocious battlefield of Qaidu is located at Altai Mountains through the primary exploration in July 2013 and the secondary local field survey of Altai in Mongolia in July 2016. It directly performed a field survey on place names, which were confirmed through a documentary historical-source research, exactly examined many terrain features and locations in those places, and then strived to historically investigate correctly into whether all of “region(地域)ㆍhistorical source(史料)ㆍhistorical fact(史實)” are consistent. These primary and secondary field surveys were performed an investigation into the locally place names and terrain features of which he informed, in addition to the evidence of a native old villager of Kazakh named ‘Temerzan Babakhan’. Synthetically analyzing through this, its historical region is comparatively determined as the whole area of Delüün Sum in Bayan-ölgii Aimag of the current Mongolian country. In other words, based on the center of Delüün Sum, it is consistent in “鐵堅古ㆍ迭怯里古ㆍ帖堅古 = Tegelkū” with Delüün uul(Дэлүүн уул; in Mongolian), “合剌合塔ㆍ哈剌答 = Qarāltū” with Qar qad(Хар хад; in Mongolian), and “兀兒禿 = Urtu” with Urt salaa(Урт салаа; in Mongolian) region.

Abstract

The purpose of this study is to historically research into where the combat branch was exactly between Qaidu(海都) and Da Yuan(大元) Ulus military, which took place at the Altai Mountains in the eighth lunar month in 1301. This researcher tried to generally reconstruct a historical situation in those days through a documentary research and an on-site survey in addition to where the last ferocious battlefield of Qaidu is located at Altai Mountains through the primary exploration in July 2013 and the secondary local field survey of Altai in Mongolia in July 2016. It directly performed a field survey on place names, which were confirmed through a documentary historical-source research, exactly examined many terrain features and locations in those places, and then strived to historically investigate correctly into whether all of “region(地域)ㆍhistorical source(史料)ㆍhistorical fact(史實)” are consistent. These primary and secondary field surveys were performed an investigation into the locally place names and terrain features of which he informed, in addition to the evidence of a native old villager of Kazakh named ‘Temerzan Babakhan’. Synthetically analyzing through this, its historical region is comparatively determined as the whole area of Delüün Sum in Bayan-ölgii Aimag of the current Mongolian country. In other words, based on the center of Delüün Sum, it is consistent in “鐵堅古ㆍ迭怯里古ㆍ帖堅古 = Tegelkū” with Delüün uul(Дэлүүн уул; in Mongolian), “合剌合塔ㆍ哈剌答 = Qarāltū” with Qar qad(Хар хад; in Mongolian), and “兀兒禿 = Urtu” with Urt salaa(Урт салаа; in Mongolian) region.

참고문헌 (62)

  1. "元史" (1976), 中華書局
  2. "元朝名臣史略" (1996), 中華書局
  3. 虞集, "道園學古錄 , 四部叢刊初編" (1926), 据商务印书馆
  4. 李修生, "全元文" (2004), 鳳凰出版社(原江蘇古籍出版社)
  5. Rashīd ad-Dīn, "이스탄불 톱카프 도서관 소장본 : Revan Köşkü 1518", ~
  6. 라시드 앗 딘, "부족지 2002, 칭기스칸기 2003, 칸의 후예들 2005", 사계절
  7. Hammer-Purgstall, "Geschichte Wassaf's, persisch herausgegeben und deutsch übersetzt, Band.Ⅰ" (1856), Wien
  8. Khvāndamir, Wheeler M, "Habibu's-siyar, Mass. : Dept. of Near Eastern Languages and Civilizations" (1994), Harvard University
  9. 마르코 폴로, "동방견문록" (2000), 사계절
  10. Jamāl Qarshī, "賈瑪爾․喀爾施和他的 蘇拉赫詞典補編", 元史及北方民族史研究集刊, (11) (1987)
  11. 邱樹森, "元史辭典" (2002), 山東敎育出版社
  12. 譚其驤, "中國歷史地圖集 元·明時期, 第七冊" (1982), 中國社會科學院
  13. 楊耐思, "中原音韵音系" (1981), 中国社会科学出版社
  14. 魏嵩山, "中國歷史地名大辭典" (1995), 廣東敎育出版社
  15. "皇輿全覽圖"[URL]
  16. 賈叢江, "海都與窩闊台汗國的創建", 西域硏究, (4) (1999)
  17. 邱轶皓, "合失生母小考", 中国史研究, (3) (2012)
  18. 김장구, "쿠빌라이칸 正權과 몽골帝國의 발전", 동국사학, 41 (2005)
  19. 김호동, "元代의 漢文實錄과 蒙文實錄 ― 『元史』 「本紀」의 中國中心的 一面性의 解明을 위하여 ―", 동양사학연구, (109), pp.141~189 (2009), 동양사학회
  20. 김호동, "쿠빌라이 카안의 大臣들 ― 『五支派(Shu‛ab-i panjgāna)』에 수록된 쿠빌라이 카안의 大臣(amīr) 名單 분석 ―", 동양사학연구, (125), pp.219~249 (2013), 동양사학회
  21. 김호동, "몽골제국과 고려– 쿠빌라이 정권의 탄생과 고려의 정치적 위상-" (2007), 서울대학교 출판부
  22. 김호동, "아틀라스 중앙유라시아사" (2016), 사계절
  23. 黨寶海, "元代火州之戰年代辯正", 歐亞學刊, 3 (2002)
  24. 류병재, "카이두 올로스 성립에 있어 탈라스 코릴타의 역할", 몽골학, (18), pp.169~199 (2005), 한국몽골학회
  25. 류병재, "“탈라스 코릴타이” 성립배경 연구", 백산학보, (97), pp.237~267 (2013), 백산학회
  26. 류병재, "동·서 올로스 반란에 대한 쿠빌라이의 대응 ― 나얀과 카이도의 난을 중심으로 ―", 몽골학, (34), pp.133~179 (2013), 한국몽골학회[DOI]
  27. 류병재, "카이도 휘하의 제왕(諸王)과 대신(大臣)", 몽골학, (39), pp.65~113 (2014), 한국몽골학회[DOI]
  28. 류병재, "카이도의 가계(家系)와 초기 성장과정 연구", 몽골학, (48), pp.47~75 (2017), 한국몽골학회[DOI]
  29. 劉迎勝, "論塔剌思會議", 元史論叢, 4 (1992)
  30. 劉迎勝, "從北平王到北安王—那木罕二三題—", 元史及民族與邊疆研究集刊, 21 (2009)
  31. 劉迎勝, "察合台汗國史硏究" (2006), 上海古籍出版社
  32. 刘晓, "也谈合失", 中国史研究, (2) (2006)
  33. 刘晓, "合失卒年小考", 中国史研究, (2) (2007)
  34. 本田實信, "モンゴル時代史硏究" (1991), 東京大學出版會
  35. 杉山正明, "モンゴル帝國と大元ウルス" (2004), 京都大學學術出版會
  36. 徐黎麗, "海都與窩闊台汗國的興衰", 西北師大學報, (4) (2000)
  37. 설배환, "蒙·元제국 쿠릴타이(Quriltai)연구", 박사, pp.2016
  38. 松田孝一, "ユブグル等の元朝投降", 立命館史學, 4 (1984)
  39. 松田孝一, "カイシャンの西北モンゴリア出鎮", 東方学, (64) (1982)
  40. 愛宕松男, "紀元二千六百年記念史學論文集" (1941), 內外出版印刷
  41. 王晓欣, "合失身份及相关问题再考", 元史论丛, 10 (2005)
  42. 任崇嶽, "從兩通元代碑文看“ 海都之亂”的性質", 中州學刊, (5) (1996)
  43. 箭內 亘, "海都の叛いた年次", 蒙古史硏究 (1930)
  44. 田村實造, "中國征服王朝の硏究 中" (1968), 東洋史硏究會
  45. 周淸澍, "元蒙史札" (2001), 內蒙古大學出版社
  46. 陳得芝, "蒙文史研究叢稿" (2005), 人民出版社
  47. 村岡 倫, "オゴデ=ウルスの分立", 東洋史苑, 39 (1992)
  48. 村岡 倫, "オルダウルスと大元ウルス-<カイドゥの亂>․<シリギの亂>をめぐって-", 東洋史苑, 52․53 (1999)
  49. 村岡 倫, "カイドゥと中央アジア-タラスのクリルタイをめぐって-", 東洋史苑, 30․31 (1988)
  50. 村岡 倫, "シリギの亂-元初モンゴリアの爭亂-", 東洋史苑, 24․25 (1985)
  51. 村岡 倫, "海都與突兒斯坦 ; 再論塔剌思忽里台大會", papers Contributed to the Symphosium for the History of the Yuan Dynasty, pp.189~192 (1986)
  52. 叢海平, "‘黑城出土文書’所見海都之亂時期亦集乃路的軍糧供給", 雲南師範大學學報(哲學社會科學版), (4) (2009)
  53. 惠谷後之, "田村博士頌壽 東洋史論叢" (1968), 同朋舍
  54. George Lane, "Early Mongol rule in thirteenth century Iran : A Persian renaissance" (2003), RoutledgeCurzon
  55. d’Osson, Constantine M., "Histoire des Mongols, depuis Tchiguiz-Khan jusqu’a Timour bey ou Tamerlan, 4 Vols" (1834), Amsterdam
  56. Henry H. Howorth, "History of the Mongols from 9th to the 19th century, The Mongols Proper and Kalmuks" (1876), Longmans, Green, and Co.
  57. Hodong Kim, "The Unity of the Mongol Empire and Continental Exchanges over Eurasia", Journal of Central Eurasian Studies, 1 (2009)
  58. J.W. Dardess, "From Mongol Empire to Yüan Dynasty", Monumenta Serica, 30 (1972)
  59. Michal Biran, "Warfare in Inner Asian History" (2002), Brill Leiden Boston Köln
  60. Michal Biran, "Qaidu and the Rise of the Independent Mongol State in Central Asia" (1997), Curzon Press
  61. Paul Pelliot, "Notes on Marco Polo, 3 Vols" (1959), Imprimerie nationale
  62. V.V. Barthold, "Four Studies on the History of Central Asia, vol. Ⅰ" (1956), E. J. Brill

관련 논문AI추천

카이도 휘하의 제왕(諸王)과 대신(大臣)류병재한국몽골학회 · 몽골학2014 · 제39호동·서 올로스 반란에 대한 쿠빌라이의 대응 ― 나얀과 카이도의 난을 중심으로 ―류병재한국몽골학회 · 몽골학2013 · 제34호카이도의 가계(家系)와 초기 성장과정 연구류병재한국몽골학회 · 몽골학2017 · 제48호카단(Qadan)의 고려 침입 전후(前後) 상황과 고려․대원올로스 연합군의 대응류병재한국몽골학회 · 몽골학2021 · 제64호몽골 제국 붕괴 이후 쿠빌라이계의 활동과 그 한계김성수한국몽골학회 · 몽골학2014 · 제39호《海都太子令旨碑》를 통해 본 청년기 카이도의 상황류병재한국몽골학회 · 몽골학2020 · 제62호

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (8건)

고조선어와 몽골어의 비교연구 시론이성규pp. 1-27契丹语动词“适”考백원명pp. 29-421686년 쿠룬·벨치르 회맹을 통해 본 17세기 내륙아시아의 會盟禮김성수pp. 43-73Өмнөговь аймгийн “Чингисийн далан”, түүний түүхэн цаг хугацааг нягтлах нь에르덴적토, 바트볼드pp. 101-112訛答剌事件始末研究강원pp. 113-131
원문 보기