본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

탈근대와 지방사 연구:프랑스와 영국의 경우

Local History in Postmodern Methods:On Cases of France and England

장세룡
대구사학회 (Daegu Sahakhoe)|2008.11|대구사학 (DAEGUSAHAK)|제93권 |pp. 277-308

0

조회

0

다운로드

6

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

Landscape풍경아날학파Annales SchoolLocal HistoryNational History국가사지방사레스터학파Leicester Scool
주제분류역사학

초록

This article intend to compare the tendencies of methods and epistemologies of ‘Local History’ which aims to study local and locality in contemporary France and England. At first, French Local History was continually mobiled or attracted by republican national history. It was proved by ‘Annales School’ which started by local history studies of Lucien Febvre and Marc Bloch before World war II. But its culminate period of dominated by French national and European history such as represented Emmanuel Le Ladurie and Fernand Braudel. In Contrast, England local history which started by William G. Hoskins and H. P. R. Finberg in middle of 20th century was developed and called Leicester School. In late 20th century, ‘Local History’ was related, especially in England, to the current of postmodernism in epistemology by its relativity of local scale and its process to criticize the national history. It resulted in to question the possibility of existence of local history as a discipline of history. Nowadays the study of ‘local history’ is in crisis one dimensional by threaten of computer technology and the other much absorptional attractive force of national history. But grope for the alternative is now attempting in search of the ‘history of memory’ in France or ‘community history’ in England which purpose to realize democratic society.

Abstract

This article intend to compare the tendencies of methods and epistemologies of ‘Local History’ which aims to study local and locality in contemporary France and England. At first, French Local History was continually mobiled or attracted by republican national history. It was proved by ‘Annales School’ which started by local history studies of Lucien Febvre and Marc Bloch before World war II. But its culminate period of dominated by French national and European history such as represented Emmanuel Le Ladurie and Fernand Braudel. In Contrast, England local history which started by William G. Hoskins and H. P. R. Finberg in middle of 20th century was developed and called Leicester School. In late 20th century, ‘Local History’ was related, especially in England, to the current of postmodernism in epistemology by its relativity of local scale and its process to criticize the national history. It resulted in to question the possibility of existence of local history as a discipline of history. Nowadays the study of ‘local history’ is in crisis one dimensional by threaten of computer technology and the other much absorptional attractive force of national history. But grope for the alternative is now attempting in search of the ‘history of memory’ in France or ‘community history’ in England which purpose to realize democratic society.

참고문헌 (103)

  1. Carol Kammen, "On Doing Local History" (1986), AltaMira Press
  2. Marc Bloch, "Apologie pour l’histoire, ou metier d’historien" (1949), Arman Colin
  3. 정남기, "역사가를 위한 변명" (1979), 한길사
  4. Lewis Mumford, "The Pursuit of Local History: Reading on Theory and Practice" (1996), AltaMira Press
  5. Paul Leuilliot, "A Manifesto: The Defense and Illustration of Local History in : Rural Society in France: Selections from the Annales Economies, Societes, Civilisations" (1977), The John Hopkins U. P
  6. Guy Thuillier, "Aspects de l’economie nivernaise au XIe siecle" (1966), Paris
  7. Lawrence Stone, "English and United States Local History", Daedalus, 100(1) (1971)
  8. "Alain Croix and Didier Guyvarc’h, Guide de l’Histoire locale. Fasions notre histoire" (1990), Seuil
  9. Carol Kammen, "Encyclopedia of local History" (2000), AltaMira Press
  10. 이학수, "탈근대와 프랑스 지방사 연구" (2008), 로컬리티의 인문학 연구단 2008년 제1회 기획 콜로키움
  11. Georges Lefebvre, "Les paysans du Nord pendant la Revolution fran?ise" (1972), Arman Colin
  12. G. Lefebvre, "La Grande Peur de" (2002), 까치글방
  13. 최갑수, "혁명사가 조르쥬 르페브르의 삶과 학문", 프랑스혁명사 연구, pp.314~5 (2004), 부산대학교 출판부
  14. 김응종, "아날학파의 역사세계" (2001), 아르케
  15. Lucien Febvre, "Phelippe II et la Franche-Comt?" (1970), Flammarion
  16. Pierre Goubert, "L’Ancien Regime, 2vols", Armand Colin
  17. 주식, "앙시앙 레짐" (1999), 아르케
  18. Pierre de Saint-Jacob, "Les paysans de la Bourgogne du Nord au dernier siecle de l’Ancien Regime" (1960), Les Belles-Lettres
  19. Jean Delumeau, "L’Alun de Rome, XVe-XIXe siecle" (1962), S.E.V.P.E.N
  20. Abel Poitrineau, "La vie rurale en Basse-Auvergne au XVIIIe si?le" (1965), PUF
  21. 2tomes, "Pierre Deyon, Amiens capitale provinciale, ?ude sur soci??urbaine au XVIIe si?le" (1967), Mouton
  22. Maurice Gardin, "Lyon et les Lyonnais au XVIIIe si?le" (1970), Les Belles-Lettres
  23. Jean Jacqart, "La soci??rurale dans le Sud de la r?ion parisienne du milieu du XVIe au milieu du XVIIe si?le" (1974), Arman Colin
  24. Pierre Goubert, "Beauvais et le Beauvaisis de 1600 a 1730, contribution a l’histoiresociales de la France du siecle" (1993), S.E.V.P.E.N
  25. Emmanuel Le Roy Ladurie, "Les paysan du Languedoc" (1969), S.E.V.P.E,N
  26. 유희수, "몽타이유: 중세말 남프랑스 어느 마을 사람들의 삶" (2006), 길
  27. Francois Dosse, "L’histoire en miette: Des Annales a la nouvelle histoire" (1987), La Decouverte
  28. 김복래, "조각난 역사" (1997), 푸른역사
  29. "http:", index17html[DOI]
  30. Alan Crosby, "The Amateur Historian and The Local Historian: some thoughts after fifty years", The Local Historian, 32(3) (2002)
  31. Asa Briggs, "The Leicester School" (1958), New Statesman
  32. Joan Thirsk, "English Peasant Farming: The Agrarian History of Llincolnshire from Tudor to Recent Times" (1957), Routledge
  33. "England’s Agricultural Regions and Agrarian History" (1987), Macmillan
  34. Maurice Bresford, "The Lost Villages of England" (1954), Lutterworth Press
  35. W. E. Tate, "The English Village Community and the Enclosure Movements" (1967), Gollancz
  36. William George Hoskins, "The Making of the English Landscape" (1955), Hodder Stoughton
  37. 이영석, "잉글랜드 풍경의 형성" (2007), 한길사
  38. The Midland Peasant, "The Economic & Social History of Leicestershire Village" (1957), Longman
  39. "Local History in England" (1959), Longman
  40. H. P. R. Finberg, "The Local Historian and his Theme" (1952), Leicester
  41. Finberg, "How Not to Write Local History" (1967), David and Charles
  42. 강성호, "포스트모던 역사학과 지방사", 전남사학, 23 (2004)
  43. Margaret Spufford, "Contrasting Communities, English Villagers in the Sixteenth and Seventeenth Centuries" (2000), Rreprint
  44. "The Scope of Local History, and the Potential of the Hearth Tax Returns", The Local Historian, 30(4) (2000)
  45. Charles Phytian-Adams, "Re-Thinking English Local History" (1988), Leicester
  46. Angus J., "Parish, Township and Tithing: landscapes of local administration in England before the nineteenth century", The Local Historian, 27(1) (1997)
  47. V. Skipp, "Local History: a new definition and its implication", The Local Historian, 14(4) (1981)
  48. K. Schurer, "The furture for local history: boom or recession", The Local Historian, 21(2) (1991)
  49. Edward Royle, "Local history in context: twenty years of the Conference of Regional and Local Historians", The Local Historian, 28(3) (1998)
  50. Pat Hudson, "A new history from below: computer and the maturing of local and regional history", The Local Historian, 25(3) (1995)
  51. ate Tiller, "English Local History: An Introduction" (1992), Alan Suttun
  52. Lawrence Stone, "History and Post-modernism", Past and Present, 131 (1991)
  53. Patric Joyce, "History and Post-modernism I", Past and Present, 133 (1991)
  54. L. Stone, "History and Post-modernism III" (1992), Past and Present 135
  55. Joyce Appleby, "Lynn Hunt and Margaret Jacob, Telling the Truth about History" (1994), W. W. Norton
  56. J. D. Marshall, "The Tyranny of Discrete: a Discussion of the Problems of Local History in England" (1997), Scolar Press
  57. 노서경, "알제리 전쟁에 대한 프랑스인들의 ‘과거’ 성찰-폭력의 문제를 중심으로", 프랑스사 연구, (12) (2005)
  58. 이재원, "기억의 전유와 기억의 투쟁-알제리전쟁 기념 문제에 대한 비판적 고찰", 프랑스사 연구, (19) (2008)
  59. Pierre Nora dir, "Les lieux de m?oire" (1997), Gallimard
  60. Philippe Joutard, "La legends des Camisards. Une sensibilit?au pass" (2001), Gallimard
  61. Les Camisards, "Patrick Cabanal and Philippe Joutard ?s., Le camisards et leur m?oire 1702-4" (2002), Biblioth?ue Camisarde
  62. "http:", Nouveaute-fr, pp.htm
  63. Jean-Cl?ent Martin, "La Vend? et la France 1789-1799" (1987), Seuil
  64. Paul Bois, "Paysans de l’Ouest : des structure economics et sociales aux options politiques dupuis l’epoque revolutionnaire dans la Sarthe" (1971), Flammarion
  65. Marcel Faucheux, "L’Insurrection vendeene de 1793, Aspects economiques et sociaux" (1964), Imperimerie Nationale
  66. Charles Tilly, "The Vend?" (1967), Science Edition
  67. Claude Petifrere, "Les Blancs et Bleus d’Anjou 1789-1793" (1979), Lille
  68. Peter Jones, "Parish, Seigneurie and the Community of Inhabitants in Southern Central France During the Eighteenth and Nighteenth Centuries" (1981), Past and Present
  69. Timothy Takett, "The West in France in 1789: The Religious Factor in the Origins of the Counter- Revolution", Journal of Modern History, 54 (1982)
  70. Colin Lucas, "Resistances populaires a la Revolution dans le Sud-Est in : Mouvements populaires et conscience sociale xvie-xixe siecles" (1985), Maloine
  71. Clarke Garett, "Myth of the Counterrevolution in 1789", French Historical Studies, 18(3) (1994)
  72. Reynald Secher, "Le g?ocide franco-fran?is, la Vend?-Veng?" (1986), PUF
  73. Timothy Tackett, "Interpreting the terror", French Historical Studies, 24(4) (2001)
  74. Jean-Cl?ent Martin, "La Vend? en 30 questions (La Cr?he: Geste ?ition, 1996); Contre- R?olution, R?olution et Nation en France 1789-1799" (1998), Seuil
  75. Violence, "Essai sur la naissance d'un mythe national" (2006), Seuil
  76. Jean-Cl?ent Martin, "La Vend? et M?oire 1800-1980" (1988), Seuil
  77. La Vend, "Accepter la m?oire pour ?rire l'histoire" (2007), Perrin
  78. Philppe de Villiers, "L’aventure du Puy du Fou" (1997), Albin Michel
  79. Charles Suaud, "Jean-Clement Martin, Le Puy du Fou en Vendee: histoire mise en scene" (1996), L’Harmattan
  80. 주섭일, "프랑스의 대숙청: 드골의 나치 협력 반역자 처단 진상" (1999), 중심
  81. 이용우, "프랑스의 과거사 청산" (2008), 역사비평사
  82. 박지현, "전쟁문화와 여성-비시 프랑스의 여성성을 중심으로", 역사와 문화, (9) (2004)
  83. 이학수, "임시수도 비시와 비시의 주민들 1940-1944", 역사와 경계, 63 (2007)
  84. Henry Rousso, "Le syndrome de Vichy de 1944 a nos jour" (1987), Seuil
  85. "비시 정권의 여성 동원", 대구사학, 93 (2008)
  86. 고 원, "제2차 세계대전시기 독일 점령하의 프랑스와 여성들", 대구사학, 92 (2008)
  87. Alain Brossat, "Les Tondues" (1993), Manya
  88. 전진성, "역사가 기억을 말하다: 이론과 실천을 위한 기억의 문화사" (2005), 휴머니스트
  89. Spencer Jordan, "History and Information Technology: some implications for the Local Historian", The Local Historian, 31(2) (2001)
  90. Margaret Procter, "The end of (local) history’: will twenty-first century sources survive?", The Local Historian, 36(4) (2006)
  91. Jacquelene Filmore, "Local history internetsites; a handlist", The Local Historian, 37(3) (2007)
  92. Shelton Stromquist, "Sense of Place: A Historian Advocates Conceptual Approaches to Community History" (1983), History News
  93. George, "Discourses in Local History", Rethinking History, 2(1) (1988)
  94. "Reconstructing Local History", The Local Historian, 29(4) (1999)
  95. Kate Tiller, "Local history brought up to date", The Local Historian, 36(3) (2006)
  96. Dennis Mills, "What is Community History in : Getting into Community History" (1995), Local Population Studies Society
  97. W. G. Hoskins, "Provincial England" (1965), Macmillan
  98. Nigel Goose, "Local Population Studies: history, demography and locality", The Local Historian, 34(1) (2004)
  99. Dennis Mills, "Defining community: a critical review of community", Family and Community History, 7(1) (2004)
  100. B. Deacon, "In search of community history", Family and Community History, 7(1) (2004)
  101. Kate Tiller, "Local History at the Crossroads", The Local Historian, 37(4) (2007)
  102. J. D. Marshall, "A cooperative local history project and some lessons learned from it", The Local Historian, 31(2) (2001)
  103. Richard Jones, "Medieval Village in an English Landscape: Beginnings and Ends" (2006), Windgather Press

관련 논문AI추천

지역학 연구의 방향과 방법론이윤갑동방한문학회 · 동방한문학2004 · 제26권 세계화와 역사교육의 탈근대적 전환김미경대구사학회 · 대구사학2013 · 제113권 지방사 연구의 대상과 방법-『한국향토문화전자대전』 사례를 중심으로-이정자인문과학연구소 · 인문과학연구2010 · 제13호역사탐구체험으로서의 영국의지역사교육박주현한국역사교육학회 · 역사교육연구2011 · 제14호지방사를 넘어, 지역사로의 전환 －한국 근대 지역사 연구의 현황과 새로운 모색－허영란역사문화학회 · 지방사와 지방문화2017 · 제20권 제2호서양사학사 최근 경향에 대한 검토와 전망조한욱호서사학회 · 역사와 담론2008 · 제49호

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (9건)

신라 中古期 儒學 사상의 수용과 확산노중국pp. 1-28삼국시대 낙동강 수로를 둘러싼 신라와 가야세력의 동향 - 낙동강 중류지역을 중심으로 -전덕재pp. 29-81運河 建設 努力을 通해 본 中國의 河運 - 元代 以後 山東 地域을 中心으로 -김종건pp. 83-113민족사의 터전에서 유럽 속의 지역으로 -라인지방사(地方史) 서술에 나타나는 지역 정체성 인식의 변화 -박용희pp. 115-1481848년 인민 헌장 운동과 퍼거스 오코너남철호pp. 149-172
원문 보기