재판중계의 법적 쟁점 해소를 위한 방안 연구
A Study for Resolving Legal Issues of Trial Broadcasting
0
조회
0
다운로드
5
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
In accordance with the principle of public trial, trial broadcasting is required. There were various discussions and experiments with trial broadcasting in United States and other countries over the years. The following argument were found to be wrong; Trial broadcasting is violated defendant’s rights, and interfered with a fair trial, and undermined the authority of the court. This study is to examine the legal issues of the trial broadcasting, and to propose a resolution. first, the court should be owned and operated broadcasting system. Second, legal issues must be resolved in the video editing process. Third, TV channel for trial broadcasting should be made in court. As a result, trial broadcasting is expected to help realize public’s right to know and to restore the confidence of the court.
Abstract
In accordance with the principle of public trial, trial broadcasting is required. There were various discussions and experiments with trial broadcasting in United States and other countries over the years. The following argument were found to be wrong; Trial broadcasting is violated defendant’s rights, and interfered with a fair trial, and undermined the authority of the court. This study is to examine the legal issues of the trial broadcasting, and to propose a resolution. first, the court should be owned and operated broadcasting system. Second, legal issues must be resolved in the video editing process. Third, TV channel for trial broadcasting should be made in court. As a result, trial broadcasting is expected to help realize public’s right to know and to restore the confidence of the court.
참고문헌 (27)
- 강동욱, "형사재판에 대한 중계방송 제도도입의 문제점에 관한 고찰", 법과정책연구, 10(2), pp.613~629 (2010), 한국법정책학회
- 김일수, "재판공개의 원칙", 고시계, 29(4), pp.141~152 (1984)
- 김재윤, "독일과 한국의 공개주의와 그 제한에 관한 비교법적 고찰- 공개주의의 확대로서 TV공개주의에 관한 최근 독일의 논의를 중심으로 -", 형사법연구, (21), pp.297~332 (2004), 한국형사법학회
- 김철수, "학설판례 헌법학" (2009), 박영사
- 김태형, "재판에 대한 방송의 허용 여부에 관하여", 저스티스, (130), pp.128~164 (2012), 한국법학원[DOI]
- 박용철, "공개재판과 언론보도", 동양문화연구, 11, pp.213~230 (1984)
- 변종필, "공개주의와 공판의 의사소통구조", 형사정책연구, 9(4), pp.109~140 (1998)
- 손태규, "국민의 알권리와 법정 촬영 및 방송 ― 한국과 외국의 비교 연구 ―", 공법연구, 40(4), pp.29~62 (2012), 한국공법학회[DOI]
- 송희진, "형사재판에서의 공개주의", 연세법학연구, 7(2), pp.113~129 (2000)
- 이균룡, "법정에서의 사진촬영 ․ 녹음 ․ 방송 : 법원조직법 제59조의 합리적인 운용방안에 관한 시론", 법조, pp.82~115 (1999)
- 이진국, "개정 형사소송법상 심리비공개 제도의 문제점", 형사정책연구, 20(1), pp.565~584 (2009), 한국형사정책연구원
- 정선주, "민사소송절차에서 공개재판의 원칙과 비밀보호", 저스티스, 33(1), pp.54~72 (2001)
- 지성우, "헌법주석서 4" (2010), 법제처
- 차용석, "형사소송법" (2008), 21세기사
- 한동섭, "사법의 투명성과 개방성 확보를 위한 재판방송 실시방안에 관한 연구" (2012), 법원행정처
- Barber, S, "News cameras in the courtroom: A free press-fair trial debate" (1987), Ablex
- Carter, C. A, "Media in the Courts", National Center for State Courts, ~ (1981)
- Cohn, M., "Cameras in the courtroom: television and the pursuit of justice" (2011), McFarland
- "Committee to Study Extended Media Coverage, a Subcommittee of the Legislative Committee of the Maryland Judicial Conference", Report of the Committee to Study Extended Media Coverage of Criminal Trial Processing in Maryland (2008)
- Green, D. D, "Live! Broadcasting hith-profile appeals reignites cameras in the courtroom debate", The News Media & The Law, 35 (2011)
- Kozinski, A, "Of Cameras and Courtrooms. Fordham Intellectual, Property", Media &Entertainment Law Journal, 20 (2010)
- Lambert, P, "Eyeing the Supreme Court's Challenge: A Proposal to Use Eye Tracking th Determine the Effects of Television Courtroom Broadcasting", Reynolds Courts & Media Law Journal, 1(3), pp.277~306 (2011)
- Lassiter, C, "TV or Not TV-That is the Question", The Journal of Criminal Law & Criminology, 86(3), pp.928~1001 (1996)
- Lyman, C. M, "Courts Communications and Canon 35", American Bar Association Journal, 46, pp.1295~1299 (1960)
- Mason, P, "Court on Camera: Electronic Broadcast Coverage of the Legal Proceedings. Picturing Justice: The Online Journal of Law and Popular in West European broadcasting" (2001), Sage
- Rosenfeld, S, "Will Camera in the Courtroom Lead to More Law and Order?", A Case for Broadcast Access to Judicial Proceedings, 6 (2011), Criminal Law Brief
- Stepniak, D, "Audio-visual coverage of courts" (2008), Cambridge Univ. Press