자유와 평등의 이율배반성에 대한 분석적 성찰
A Psychoanalytic Note on the Antinomic Freedom and Equality
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
The ideology of freedom and equality has been very long-standing hot issue and a difficult problem to solve. Many persons have been sacrificed for their freedom and equality. But freedom and equality really seem to have peaceful coexistence in any structure of a society because guaranteed freedom is likely to lead to the inequality, on the other hand, guaranteed equality is likely to lead to the restricted freedom. To speak figuratively, it looks like a wooden iron, in other words, they are antinomic. Human-being has been trapped in this trial and error repetitively. I trace this problem in terms of psychoanalytic theory, and then proceed to discuss the issues of basic deficit and conflict. Surely we are accustomed to Freudian psychic determinism, but many philosophers insist the existence of human free will, and do not agree to the unconscious. Nevertheless psychoanalytic theory presents many evidences for the unfree and unequal inner conditions intrapsychically or interpsychically. All neurotics are unfree and unequal from their unconscious power, so far as in their free associations. Even so they are unfree from various deficit and conflict, or psychologic trauma. Hence we have need for the insightful understanding of the basic inner deficit and conflict as the contradictory roots of freedom and equality, accordingly we can expect the desirable mature and insane society based on the proper compromise and concession, mutual respect and common sense. I believe those societies as the real democracy.
Abstract
The ideology of freedom and equality has been very long-standing hot issue and a difficult problem to solve. Many persons have been sacrificed for their freedom and equality. But freedom and equality really seem to have peaceful coexistence in any structure of a society because guaranteed freedom is likely to lead to the inequality, on the other hand, guaranteed equality is likely to lead to the restricted freedom. To speak figuratively, it looks like a wooden iron, in other words, they are antinomic. Human-being has been trapped in this trial and error repetitively. I trace this problem in terms of psychoanalytic theory, and then proceed to discuss the issues of basic deficit and conflict. Surely we are accustomed to Freudian psychic determinism, but many philosophers insist the existence of human free will, and do not agree to the unconscious. Nevertheless psychoanalytic theory presents many evidences for the unfree and unequal inner conditions intrapsychically or interpsychically. All neurotics are unfree and unequal from their unconscious power, so far as in their free associations. Even so they are unfree from various deficit and conflict, or psychologic trauma. Hence we have need for the insightful understanding of the basic inner deficit and conflict as the contradictory roots of freedom and equality, accordingly we can expect the desirable mature and insane society based on the proper compromise and concession, mutual respect and common sense. I believe those societies as the real democracy.
참고문헌 (44)
- Andress D., "The Terror: The Merciless War for Freedom in Revolutionary France" (2006), Farrar, Straus and Giroux
- Basch MF, "Psychic determinism and freedom of will", Int Rev Psychoanal, 5, pp.257~264 (1978)
- Bion WR, "Differentiation of the psychotic from the non-psychotic personalities", Int J Psychoanal, 38, pp.266~275 (1957)
- Blos P., "On Adolescence" (1962), Free Press
- Brenner C, "The Mind in Conflict" (1982), Int Univ Press
- Colarusso CA., "Separation-individuation phenomena in adulthood: general concepts and the fifth individuation", J Am Psychoanal Assoc, 48, pp.1467~1489 (2000)
- Dewey J., "Freedom and Culture" (1989), Prometheus Books
- Dunayevskaya R, "Marxism and Freedom: From 1776 Until Today" (2000), Humanity Books
- Epstein RA, "Skepticism and Freedom: A Modern Case for Classical Liberalism" (2003), Univ Chicago Press
- Fenichel O., "Psychoanalytic remarks on Fromm’s book “Escape from Freedom”", Psychoanal Rev, 31, pp.133~152 (1944)
- Freud S., "Civilization and Its Discontents. SE 21", pp.57~146 (1930), Hogarth Press
- Freud S., "New Introductory Lectures on Psychoanalysis. SE Vol 22", pp.1~182 (1933), Hogarth Press
- Freud S., "The Psychopathology of Everyday Life. SE 7", pp.1~290 (1901), Hogarth Press
- Freud S., "The ‘Uncanny’. SE 17", pp.217~252 (1919), Hogarth Press
- Fromm E., "Escape from Freedom" (1941), Farrar and Rinehart
- Fromm E., "Escape from Freedom" (1969), Henry Holt & Co
- Fromm E., "Marx’s Conception of Man" (1961), Frederick Ungar
- Fromm E., "The Sane Society" (1955), Rinehart
- Fromm E., "To Have or To Be?" (1976), Harper and Row
- Hartmann H., "Ego Psychology and the Problem of Adaptation" (1939), Int Univ Press
- Ingram D., "Group Rights: Reconciling Equality and Difference" (2000), Univ Press Kansas
- Karasu TB, "Conflict and deficit: toward an integrative vision of the self", Am J Psychoanal, 55, pp.279~288 (1995)
- Kaufmann W, "Discovering the Mind" (1980), Mc-Graw-Hill
- Kennedy DM, "Freedom from Fear: The American People in Depression and War, 1929-1945" (1999), Oxford Univ Press
- Kernberg O, "Ideology, Conflict, and Leadership in Groups and Organizations" (1998), Yale Univ Press
- Klein M., "Notes on some schizoid mechanisms", Int J Psychoanal, 27(Pt 3-4), pp.99~110 (1946)
- Lee BW, "Dystopia of Orwell and Huxley: Focusing on 1984 and Brave New World", Psychoanalysis, 19, pp.139~149 (2008)
- Lee BW, "Freudo-Marxism", J Korean Psychoanalytic Society, 14, pp.91~104 (2003)
- Macfarlane A., "The Riddle of the Modern World: Of Liberty, Wealth and Equality" (2002), Palgrave
- Mahler MS, "The Psychological Birth of the Infant:Symbiosis and Individuation" (1975), Basic Books
- May R., "Freedom and Destiny" (1981), WW Norton & Co
- Osborn R, "Marxism and Psychoanalysis" (1965), Delta
- Phillips M, "Freud, psychic determinism and freedom", Int Rev Psychoanal, 8, pp.449~455 (1981)
- Proctor CE., "Women, Equality, and the French Revolution" (1990), Greenwood Press
- Raaflaub K., "The Discovery of Freedom in Ancient Greece" (2004), Univ Chicago Press
- Reich W., "The Mass Psychology of Fascism" (1980), Noonday Press
- Rousseau JJ, "Discours sur l’origine et les fondements de l’inégalité parmi les hommes", Marc-Michel Rey
- Skinner BF, "Beyond Freedom and Dignity" (1972), Vintage Books
- Smith JH., "The psychoanalytic understanding of human freedom: freedom from and freedom for", J Am Psychoanal Assoc, 26, pp.87~107 (1978)
- Stivers R., "The Illusion of Freedom and Equality" (2008), State Univ New York Press
- Sullivan WF, "The Impossibility of Religious Freedom" (2005), Princeton Univ Press
- Tiatorio A., "Freedom and Equality: The Human Ethical Enigma" (2005), Trafford Publishing
- Winnicott D, "The Maturational Process and the Facilitating Environment" (1965), Int Univ Press
- Zinoviev A., "The Reality of Communism" (1984), Schocken Books