화가 이중섭과 반 고흐간의 사회문화 배경과 정신질환에 관한 비교 고찰
The Comparing Analysis of Sociocultural Background and Mental Illness between Painter Lee Jungseop and Vincent Van Gogh
0
조회
0
다운로드
1
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
The authors have investigated the life, family, premorbid personality, historical background, writings, and dysfunctional behaviors of Vincent van Gogh and Jungseop Lee before hospitalization. Psychiatric symptoms at the time of hospital admission, physical and mental illness, psychodynamic approach, treatment, and artistic creativity were evaluated. The two artists showed characteristics of bipolar disorder and substance use disorder including alcoholism. Van Gogh showed possibilities of bipolar schizoaffective disorder, while Lee had signs of bipolar II disorder. The two artists showed high creative urges in hypomanic states and low creative urges in depressive states. Van Gogh was amenable to psychiatric treatment from the start. Lee, although showed resistance to treatment at first, improved with progressive treatment and continued his artistic endeavors. Artists who are diagnosed with bipolar disorder and individuals close to them require ongoing psychiatric supervision to prevent mood swings, substance abuse, and suicide and continue their artistic work. Also, any discussion related to the artist’s creativity and psychiatric disorders should not belittle the artistic achievements by overinterpreting the artist’s physical or psychiatric illness or underestimating and ignoring them altogether. The two artists’ lives represent a struggle to manifest artistic creativity and goals in life alongside the fight against psychiatric illness and hardship.
Abstract
The authors have investigated the life, family, premorbid personality, historical background, writings, and dysfunctional behaviors of Vincent van Gogh and Jungseop Lee before hospitalization. Psychiatric symptoms at the time of hospital admission, physical and mental illness, psychodynamic approach, treatment, and artistic creativity were evaluated. The two artists showed characteristics of bipolar disorder and substance use disorder including alcoholism. Van Gogh showed possibilities of bipolar schizoaffective disorder, while Lee had signs of bipolar II disorder. The two artists showed high creative urges in hypomanic states and low creative urges in depressive states. Van Gogh was amenable to psychiatric treatment from the start. Lee, although showed resistance to treatment at first, improved with progressive treatment and continued his artistic endeavors. Artists who are diagnosed with bipolar disorder and individuals close to them require ongoing psychiatric supervision to prevent mood swings, substance abuse, and suicide and continue their artistic work. Also, any discussion related to the artist’s creativity and psychiatric disorders should not belittle the artistic achievements by overinterpreting the artist’s physical or psychiatric illness or underestimating and ignoring them altogether. The two artists’ lives represent a struggle to manifest artistic creativity and goals in life alongside the fight against psychiatric illness and hardship.
참고문헌 (50)
- American Psychiatric Association, "Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders" (2013), American Psychiatric Publishing
- Andreasen NJ, "The creative writer : psychiatric symptoms and family history", Compr Psychiatry, 15, pp.123~131 (1974)
- Arenberg IK, "Van Gogh had Menière’s disease and not epilepsy", JAMA, 264, pp.491~493 (1990)
- Arnold WN, "Vincent van Gogh : chemicals, crises, and creativity" (1992), Birkhäuser
- Blum HP, "Van Gogh’s fantasies of replacement : being a double and a twin", J Am Psychoanal Assoc, 57, pp.1311~1326 (2009)
- Blumer D, "The illness of Vincent van Gogh", Am J Psychiatry, 159, pp.519~526 (2002)
- Cain AC, "On replacing a child", J Am Acad Child Psychiatry, 3, pp.443~456 (1964)
- Choi Y, "A critical biography on Jungseop Lee" (2014), Dolbegae
- EBS Knowledge Channel e Creative Team, "EBS children’s knowledge e. 7" (2015), Jisik Plus
- Garrett G, "Vincent van Gogh and glaucoma", JAMA, 218, pp.595~596 (1971)
- Gastaut H, "Vincent van Gogh’s disease seen in the light of new concepts of psychomotor epilepsy", Ann Med Psychol(Paris), 114, pp.196~238 (1956)
- Go E, "이중섭 그 예술과 생애" (1973), Mineumsa
- Go E, "이중섭 평전" (2004), Hyangyeon
- "화가 이중섭 정신질환 있었다|한국임상예술학회 토론회분석" (1993)[URL]
- Jamison KR, "Mood disorders and patterns of creativity in British writers and artists", Psychiatry, 52, pp.125~134 (1989)
- Jaspers K, "Strindberg und van Gogh", Annalen der Philosophie Und Philosophischen Kritik, 5, pp.220~ (1926)
- Jo JJ, "Life and art of Jungseop Lee", master, pp.1971
- Kang WH, "천재화가 이중섭과 아이들" (1999), Yearimdang
- Kim GL, "나의 이중섭 체험" (1977), Yuwon
- Kwack Y, "이중섭 회화의 상징성", Korean Bulletin of Clinical Art, 1, pp.50~65 (1985)
- "역시 단원·혜원… 디지털 미술관서도 시선 집중" (2014)[URL]
- Lee BY, "이중섭의 회화에서 본 그리움의 의미-위기와 창조성과의 관련에서", 표현정신병리 국제심포지움 및 미술치료법워크샵, pp.46~63 (1994)
- Lee H, "이중섭(李仲燮)의 사랑과 예술" (1981), Baikmisa
- Lee J, "이중섭, 그대에게 가는 길" (2000), Davinci
- Lee J, "이중섭 편지" (2015), Hyunsilbook
- Lee JG, "정신신경과영역의 최신치료경향", 한국의약, 2, pp.31~34 (1959)
- Lee MS, "Psychoanalytic study on the life of Vincent Van Gogh", Psychoanal, 8, pp.146~162 (1997)
- Lee TC, "Van Gogh’s vision. Digitalis intoxication?", JAMA, 245, pp.727~729 (1981)
- 이영식, "현대 정신의학에서 바라본 반 고흐의 정신세계와 정신질환에 대한 고찰", 신경정신의학, 60(2), pp.97~119 (2021), 대한신경정신의학회[DOI]
- Lewis B, "A deep ethics for mental difference and disability : the ‘case’ of Vincent van Gogh", Med Humanit, 43, pp.172~176 (2017)
- Lombroso C, "Genio e follia, in rapporto alla medicina legale, alla critica ed alla storia", Giuseppe Chiusi, ~ (1864)
- Lombroso C, "L’uomo di genio in rapporto alla psichiatria, alla storia ed all’estetica (Vol. 4)", Fratelli Bocca, ~ (1888)
- Mehlum L, "Suicidal process and suicidal motives. Suicide illustrated by the art, life and illness of Vincent van Gogh", Tidsskr Nor Laegeforen, 116, pp.1095~1101 (1996)
- Meissner WW, "The theme of the double and creativity in Vincent van Gogh", Contemp Psychoanal, 30, pp.323~347 (1994)
- Min GH, "빈센트 반 고흐, 내 영혼의 자서전" (2000), Hakgojae
- Moreau JJ, "La psychologie morbide dans ses rapports avec la philosophie de l’histoire: ou, de l’influence des névropathies sur le dynamisme intellectuel", Masson, ~ (1859)
- Moreno C, "National trends in the outpatient diagnosis and treatment of bipolar disorder in youth", Arch Gen Psychiatry, 64, pp.1032~1039 (2007)
- 나경세, "심리부검 : 우리나라에서 향후 방향에 대한 검토 및 고찰", 신경정신의학, 54(1), pp.40~48 (2015), 대한신경정신의학회[DOI]
- Nomura A, "고흐, 37년의 고독" (2004), Kungul
- Park HK, "내친구 빈센트" (1999), Sonamoo
- Post F, "Creativity and psychopathology. A study of 291 world-famous men", Br J Psychiatry, 165, pp.22~34 (1994)
- Schou M, "Artistic productivity and lithium prophylaxis in manic-depressive illness", Br J Psychiatry, 135, pp.97~103 (1979)
- Sohn S, "Psychological Autopsy of Lee Jung Sup’s Death", Association of Biographical Art History in Korea, 12, pp.185~329 (2016)
- Sund J, "Van Gogh" (2004), Hangilart
- van Meekeren E, "Starry starry night: life and psychiatric history of Vincent van Gogh" (2003), Benecke NI
- Weissman E, "Vincent van Gogh(1853-90) : the plumbic artist", J Med Biogr, 16, pp.109~117 (2008)
- Youn BM, "A study on Lee, Joong-Seob’s painting", Dongak Art History, 5, pp.191~204 (2004)
- Gu S, "이중섭(李仲燮)의 발병(發病)전후 : ‘성당부근(聖堂附近)’에 대하여", 문학사상, 23, pp.342~ (1974)
- "초중고 학생 76%가 미술학원 “과외경험”" (1988)[URL]
- "故 李仲燮화백「鬪病그림」전시" (1973)[URL]