자살의 의미 －언어분석철학적 관점에서－
The Meaning of Suicide
0
조회
0
다운로드
2
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Every death is not always a suicide. But death of many people are suicides. Suicides appear in many forms. Suicides take forms of physician-assisted death or voluntary euthanasia besides stereo-typed suicides. Furthermore, somebody’s death is a indeterminate death that seems to be considered as suicide as well as murder. It is necessary to define the meaning of suicide in order to understand the physician-assisted death or the voluntary euthanasia. The result of the linguistic-analytical study on conceptual components of suicide can be summarized into five theses as follows: T.1 : A suicide requires the self-conflictedness of the suicidal. T.2 : A suicide requires the foreknowledge of the result of suicidal act. T.3 : A suicide requires the intention to die in the weak sense. T.4 : The motive of a suicide should not to be considered. T.5 : A suicide requires voluntariness of the suicidal. In sum, a suicide can be defined as a self-inflicted death resulted from the intentional act of a suicidal person having foreknowledge of the result of his own act regardless of the motive. It is very difficult to draw the boundary between suicide and euthanasia in the light of the above-mentioned definition of suicide. In reality, suicide and euthanasia can be overlapped in many cases. Furthermore, it is unnecessary to define a suicide as a exclusive concept in contrast with euthanasia.
Abstract
Every death is not always a suicide. But death of many people are suicides. Suicides appear in many forms. Suicides take forms of physician-assisted death or voluntary euthanasia besides stereo-typed suicides. Furthermore, somebody’s death is a indeterminate death that seems to be considered as suicide as well as murder. It is necessary to define the meaning of suicide in order to understand the physician-assisted death or the voluntary euthanasia. The result of the linguistic-analytical study on conceptual components of suicide can be summarized into five theses as follows: T.1 : A suicide requires the self-conflictedness of the suicidal. T.2 : A suicide requires the foreknowledge of the result of suicidal act. T.3 : A suicide requires the intention to die in the weak sense. T.4 : The motive of a suicide should not to be considered. T.5 : A suicide requires voluntariness of the suicidal. In sum, a suicide can be defined as a self-inflicted death resulted from the intentional act of a suicidal person having foreknowledge of the result of his own act regardless of the motive. It is very difficult to draw the boundary between suicide and euthanasia in the light of the above-mentioned definition of suicide. In reality, suicide and euthanasia can be overlapped in many cases. Furthermore, it is unnecessary to define a suicide as a exclusive concept in contrast with euthanasia.
참고문헌 (54)
- A. Alvarez, "자살의 연구" (1982), 청하
- A. Eser, "Suizid", Lexikon der Bioethik, Bd., 3 (2000), Gütersloher Verlagshaus
- A. Leenaars, "Suicidology: Essays in Honor of Edwin S. Schneidman" (1993), Jason Aronson
- B. Brody, "Suicide and Euthanasia: Historical and Contemporary Themes" (1989), Kluwer
- C. Varah, "Answers to Suicide" (1978), Constable
- D. Daube, "The linguistics of suicide", Philosophy and Public Affairs, 1 (1972)
- D. Wasserman, "Oxford Textbook of Suicidolody and Suicide Prevention" (2009), Oxford UP
- É. Durkheim, "자살론" (2008), 청아출판사
- E. Schneiderman, "Definition of Suicide" (1985), Wiley
- E. Schneidman, "Essays in Self Destruction" (1967), Science House
- E. Shneidman, "Suicide as Psychache", Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, 181 (1993)
- E. Shneidman, "Suicide, Lethality, and the Psychological Autopsy", International Psychiatry Clinics, 6 (1969)
- E. Shneidman, "Suicide", Encyclopaedia Britannica, 21 (1973), Encyclopaedia Britannica Inc
- G. Graber, "Mastering the Concept of Suicide, Suicide and Euthanasia: The Rights of Personhood", U. of Tennessee Press
- G. Graber, "Suicide: Right and Wrong, 2nd ed" (1998), Prometheus
- G. Minois, "Histoire du suicide: La société occidentale face à la mort volontaire" (1995), Fayard
- H. Ebeling, "Selbstmord", Historisches Wörterbuch der philosophie, Bd, 9 (1995), Schwabe & Co.
- I. Kant, "Vorlesungen über Moralphilosophie"
- I. Kant, "Lectures on Ethics" (1997), Cambridge UP
- J. Améry, "자유죽음" (2010), 산책자
- J. Cooper, "Greek Philosophers on Euthanasia and Suicide, Suicide and Euthanasia: Historical and Contemporary Themes" (1989), Kluwer
- J. Donnelly, "Introduction, Suicide: Right and Wrong, 2nd ed" (1998), Prometheus
- J. Kupfer, "Suicide: Its Nature and Moral Evaluation", Journal of Value Inquiry, 24 (1990)
- J. Kupfer, "Suicide: Right and Wrong, 2nd ed" (1998), Prometheus
- J. Margolis, "Negativities: The Limits of Life" (1975), Merrill
- J. Tubbs, "A Handbook of Bioethics Terms" (2009), Georgetown UP
- J.-P. Soubrier, "Definition of Suicide, Suicide: Essays in Honor of Edwin Shneidman" (1993), Aronson
- K. Baumann, "Selbstmord und Freitod im sprachlicher und geschichtlicher Beleuchtung" (1934), Triltsch
- M. Battin, "Suicide, Encyclopedia of Philosophy, 2nd ed" (2005), Macmillan
- M. Battin, "Suicidology and the Right to Die, Suicidology: Essays in Honor of Edwin S. Schneidman" (1993), Jason Aronson
- M. Battin, "Ethical Issues in Suicide" (1982), Prentice-Hall
- M. Cholbi, "‘Self-manslaughter’ and the Forensic Classification of Self-Inflicted Death", Journal of Medical Ethics, 33 (2007)
- "Suicide, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy"[URL]
- M. Halbwachs, "Les causes du suicide" (1930), Felix Alcan
- M. Monestier, "자살전서" (2008), 새움
- M. Smith, "Did Socrates Kill Himself Intentionally?", Philosophy, 55 (1980)
- M. Stingl, "The Price of Compassion: Assisted Suicide and Euthanasia" (2010), Broadview
- P. Foot, "The Problem of Abortion and the Doctrine of Double Effect", Oxford Review, 5 (1967)
- P. Windt, "The Concept of Suicide, Suicide: The Philosophical Issues" (1980), St.Martin’s Press
- R. Brandt, "The morality and Rationality of Suicide, A Handbook for the Understanding of Suicide" (1975), OUP
- R. Maris, "Comprehensive Textbook of Suicidolody" (2000), Guilford
- R.F. Holland, "Against Empiricism" (1980), Barnes and Noble
- R.G. Frey, "Did Socrates Commit Suicide", Philosophy, 53 (1978)
- R.G. Frey, "Suicide and Self-Inflicted Death", Philosophy, 56 (1981)
- R.G. Frey, "Suicide: Right and Wrong, 2nd ed" (1998), Prometheus
- S. Perlin, "A Handbook for the Understanding of Suicide" (1975), OUP
- S. Stern-Gillet, "The Rhetoric of Suicide", Philosophy and Rhetoric, 20 (1987)
- S. Stern-Gillet, "Suicide: Right and Wrong, 2nd ed" (1998), Prometheus
- T. Beauchamp, "Suicide, Matters of Life and Death" (1980), Temple UP
- T. Beauchamp, "What Is Suicide, Ethical Issues and Death and Dying" (1978), Prentice Hall
- T. O’Keeffe, "Suicide and Self-Starvation", Philosophy, 56 (1981)
- T. O’Keeffe, "Suicide: Right and Wrong, 2nd ed" (1998), Prometheus
- W. Tolhurst, "Suicide, Self-Sacrifice, and Coercion", The Southern Journal of Philosophy, 21 (1983)
- W. Tolhurst, "Suicide: Right and Wrong, 2nd ed" (1998), Prometheus