본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

『제인 에어』: 페미니스트적 열망과 제국주의적 기획

Feminist Desire and Imperialistic Planning in Jane Eyre

1

조회

0

다운로드

3

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

주제분류영어와문학

초록

The imperialistic planning of mid-Victorian era skillfully appropriated ‘sexual politics.’ At that time, the British Empire idealized the women who gave up physical pleasure and were dedicated to imperialism for its own sake. Externally, the empire justified territorial expansion and economic exploitation in the name of civilization by suppressing the subjugated. Internally, on the basis of patriarchal ideology, the empire suppressed women’s subjectivity. In short, at that time, imperialism and patriarchal system were the basis of the British Empire, and therefore women came to fall a victim to them. In Jane Eyre, not only imperialism but also colonialism was a dynamic force of the main plot. As the romance of Jane and Rochester was the core of the plot, the novel seems to have nothing to do with imperialism and colonialism any more. But what puts the romance of Jane and Rochester to an ultimate success was the death of Bertha and a large fortune left to Jane by her uncle, which made Jane and Rochester equal on a economical level and a social position class. Since the fortune was presumed to come from a colony, imperialism and colonialism were the fundamentals of Jane Eyre. The literary success of Jane Eyre can be attributed to acutely demonstrating how closely imperialism is related to everyday life of the British. Bertha stands for ‘brutality’ and ‘sense of guilty’, which arise from the colonialization of the West Indies by England. In addition, the psychological viewpoints of ‘conquest’ and ‘civilization,’ which were two pivotal parts of colonialization, were vividly represented by male characters in Jane Eyre. Also, Brontë sharply criticized the repressive attitudes of colonialists. Jane’s feminist desire points out the combination of the imperial planning with gender ideology. As we saw in the relationship between Jane and St. John, Jane completely rejected the role as an assistant of a missionary required by the imperialism. Therefore, the suppression that Jane felt in the relationship between sexes/genders was projected on to women of other ethnicities. Especially, Jane’s desire, fear, and anger were the same as those of Bertha. Brontë indicated the problems of the imperialism by illustrating discrimination against women and suppression of women. But she did not criticize the intrinsic problems of the imperialism. Instead, Brontë/ Jane did expose her potential desire for the imperialism. Although Jane’s desire for the imperialism was limited in a small society of family, she never gave up her desire for it. As we all know, Jane’s individual achievement desire is closely associated to an expansionist policy of the imperialism. But it is not easy to predicate that Brontë/Jane is imperialistic on the grounds: Bertha was eliminated from the plot of Jane Eyre, and the civilization of St. John internalized the imperialism. Namely, although Brontë/Jane’s feminist desire appropriates the imperialist discourses, she creates a crack in the imperialist discourses by rejecting the image of women required by patriarchal ideology of Victorian era. In conclusion, when we pay attention to the points of intersection between ‘imperialism’ and ‘feminism,’ it is likely to be easier for us to grasp the subversive forces and their meanings of individual feminism in Jane Eyre.

Abstract

The imperialistic planning of mid-Victorian era skillfully appropriated ‘sexual politics.’ At that time, the British Empire idealized the women who gave up physical pleasure and were dedicated to imperialism for its own sake. Externally, the empire justified territorial expansion and economic exploitation in the name of civilization by suppressing the subjugated. Internally, on the basis of patriarchal ideology, the empire suppressed women’s subjectivity. In short, at that time, imperialism and patriarchal system were the basis of the British Empire, and therefore women came to fall a victim to them. In Jane Eyre, not only imperialism but also colonialism was a dynamic force of the main plot. As the romance of Jane and Rochester was the core of the plot, the novel seems to have nothing to do with imperialism and colonialism any more. But what puts the romance of Jane and Rochester to an ultimate success was the death of Bertha and a large fortune left to Jane by her uncle, which made Jane and Rochester equal on a economical level and a social position class. Since the fortune was presumed to come from a colony, imperialism and colonialism were the fundamentals of Jane Eyre. The literary success of Jane Eyre can be attributed to acutely demonstrating how closely imperialism is related to everyday life of the British. Bertha stands for ‘brutality’ and ‘sense of guilty’, which arise from the colonialization of the West Indies by England. In addition, the psychological viewpoints of ‘conquest’ and ‘civilization,’ which were two pivotal parts of colonialization, were vividly represented by male characters in Jane Eyre. Also, Brontë sharply criticized the repressive attitudes of colonialists. Jane’s feminist desire points out the combination of the imperial planning with gender ideology. As we saw in the relationship between Jane and St. John, Jane completely rejected the role as an assistant of a missionary required by the imperialism. Therefore, the suppression that Jane felt in the relationship between sexes/genders was projected on to women of other ethnicities. Especially, Jane’s desire, fear, and anger were the same as those of Bertha. Brontë indicated the problems of the imperialism by illustrating discrimination against women and suppression of women. But she did not criticize the intrinsic problems of the imperialism. Instead, Brontë/ Jane did expose her potential desire for the imperialism. Although Jane’s desire for the imperialism was limited in a small society of family, she never gave up her desire for it. As we all know, Jane’s individual achievement desire is closely associated to an expansionist policy of the imperialism. But it is not easy to predicate that Brontë/Jane is imperialistic on the grounds: Bertha was eliminated from the plot of Jane Eyre, and the civilization of St. John internalized the imperialism. Namely, although Brontë/Jane’s feminist desire appropriates the imperialist discourses, she creates a crack in the imperialist discourses by rejecting the image of women required by patriarchal ideology of Victorian era. In conclusion, when we pay attention to the points of intersection between ‘imperialism’ and ‘feminism,’ it is likely to be easier for us to grasp the subversive forces and their meanings of individual feminism in Jane Eyre.

참고문헌 (29)

  1. 김경숙, "포도주, 광기 그리고 나쁜 피 —『제인 에어』속 제국주의 다시 읽기", 영어영문학, 57(2), pp.339~365 (2011), 한국영어영문학회
  2. 김경순, "『폭풍의 언덕』과 『제인 에어』에 나타난 빅토리아시대의 인종차별주의와 식민지 논리", 비교문학, 61(61), pp.163~188 (2013), 한국비교문학회
  3. 류승희, ""드넓은 사가소 바다"(Wide Sargasso Sea)에 나타난 탈식민주의 페미니즘", 건국대학교 대학원 학술논문집, 51, pp.21~56 (2000)
  4. 박연옥, "가정소설과 정전의 문제: '제인 에어'와 '넓고 넓은 세상' 비교", 신영어영문학, 16, pp.157~174 (2000)
  5. 애쉬크로프트, 빌, "포스트 콜로니얼 문학이론" (1996), 민음사
  6. 영, 로버트, "포스트식민주의 또는 트리컨티넨탈리즘" (2005), 박종철출판사
  7. 장정희, "샬롯 브론테와 여성 몸의 문제", 근대영미소설, 5(2), pp.221~240 (1998)
  8. 정미경, "'제인 에어'에 나타난 빅토리아조의 성", 계급 이데올로기, 2000, pp.46(1), 159~176
  9. 조애리, "제국주의와 '제인 에어'", 근대영미소설, 6(2), pp.185~200 (1999)
  10. 태혜숙, "트리컨티넨탈리즘과 '제인 에어' 다시 읽기", 마르크스주의 연구, 8(4), pp.226~254 (2011), 사회과학연구원
  11. Azim, Firdous, "The Colonial Rise of the Novel" (1993), Routledge
  12. Baym, Nina, "Women’s Fiction: A Guide to Novels by and about Women in America 1820-1870" (1978), Cornell UP
  13. Boumelha, Penny, "Charlotte Brontë" (1990), Indiana UP
  14. Brontë, Charlotte, "Jane Eyre" (2000), Oxford UP
  15. DeLamotte, Eugenia C, "Perils of Nights: A Feminist Study of Nineteenth-Century Gothic" (1990), Oxford UP
  16. Eagleton, Terry, "Myths of Power : A Marxist Study of the Brontës" (1975), Macmillan
  17. Gilbert, Sandra, "Jane Eyre", pp.475~501 (1996), St. Martin’s
  18. Gilman, Sandra L, "Difference and Pathology: Stereotypes of Sexuality, Race and Madness" (1985), Cornell UP
  19. Kaplan, Cora, "Sea Changes : Essays on Culture and Feminism" (1986), Verso
  20. Maynard, John, "Charlotte Brontë and Sexuality" (1984), Cambridge UP
  21. Meyer, Susan, "Imperialism at Home : Race and Victorian Women’s Fiction" (1996), Cornell UP
  22. Michie, Elsie, "Jane Eyre", pp.584~598 (1996), St. Martin’s
  23. Rhys, Jean, "Wide Sargasso Sea" (2000), Penguin Books
  24. Rich, Adrienne, "On Lies, Secrets, and Silence: Selected Prose, 1966-1978" (1979), Norton
  25. Senf, Carol A., "Jane Eyre: The Prison House of Victorian Marriage", Journal of Women’s Studies in Literature, 1(4), pp.353~359 (1968)
  26. Sharpe, Jenny, "Allegories of Empire : The Figure of the Woman in the Colonial Text" (1993), U of Minnesota P
  27. Showalter, Elaine. A Literature of Their own : British Women Novelists form Bronte to Lessing, "A Literature of Their own: British Women Novelists form Bronte to Lessing" (1977), Princeton UP
  28. Spivak, Gayatri C, "Three Women’s Texts and a Critique of Imperialism", Critical Inquiry, 12(1), pp.243~261 (1985)
  29. Tholfsen, Trygve R, "Working Class Radicalism in Mid-Victorian England" (1977), Columbia UP

관련 논문AI추천

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (28건)