킹즐리와 뉴먼의 시에 나타난종교의 세속주의 갈등
A Conflict between Religion and Secularism through Kingsley’s and Newman’s Poems
0
조회
0
다운로드
1
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
This essay aims to analyze the reaction of religious camps to secularism as seen through the debate between Charles Kingsley and John Henry Newman, both of whom were well-known religious leaders in the Victorian age. First, a scientific and rational faith was observed in Kingsley’s claims attacking Newman’s faith. Kingsley denounced Newman’s faith as lacking historic evidences and scientific rationality. Kingsley believed newly discovered scientific knowledge should be incorporated into and bolster religious convictions. Kingsley’s vision for the progress of the world is exemplified by his poems, “Saint Maura: A. D. 304” and “The World’s Age.” On the other side, Newman responded to all critiques raised by Kingsley by elevating the value of the Church’s history and tradition. He recommended using imagination to understand the Church’s history, instead of scientifically deducing what happened. Newman’s two poems, “Hidden Saints” and “Warnings” reflected on how to oppose the tendency to analyze faith with new scientific knowledge. Newman’s vision for a traditional world was clearly in opposition to Kingsley’s progressive one, yet in their own way they were both suggesting a solution to the same problem; a way for religion to cope with the rapid spread of secularism.
Abstract
This essay aims to analyze the reaction of religious camps to secularism as seen through the debate between Charles Kingsley and John Henry Newman, both of whom were well-known religious leaders in the Victorian age. First, a scientific and rational faith was observed in Kingsley’s claims attacking Newman’s faith. Kingsley denounced Newman’s faith as lacking historic evidences and scientific rationality. Kingsley believed newly discovered scientific knowledge should be incorporated into and bolster religious convictions. Kingsley’s vision for the progress of the world is exemplified by his poems, “Saint Maura: A. D. 304” and “The World’s Age.” On the other side, Newman responded to all critiques raised by Kingsley by elevating the value of the Church’s history and tradition. He recommended using imagination to understand the Church’s history, instead of scientifically deducing what happened. Newman’s two poems, “Hidden Saints” and “Warnings” reflected on how to oppose the tendency to analyze faith with new scientific knowledge. Newman’s vision for a traditional world was clearly in opposition to Kingsley’s progressive one, yet in their own way they were both suggesting a solution to the same problem; a way for religion to cope with the rapid spread of secularism.
참고문헌 (23)
- 김연규, "『리라 아포스톨리카』를 통해서 본 존 헨리 뉴먼의 소책자시학", 영어영문학연구, 59(4), pp.89~114 (2017), 한국중앙영어영문학회[DOI]
- 김호경, "종교, 과학에 말을 걸다" (2005), 책세상
- 송은주, "녹색 유토피아: 페미니스트 유토피아 소설 『허랜드』와 『시간의 경계에 선 여자』의 생태주의적 비전과 과학기술", 영어영문학연구, 58(2), pp.89~118 (2016), 한국중앙영어영문학회[DOI]
- 차은정, "찰즈 킹즐리의 물의 아이들: 환상세계와의 소통과 정신적 진화", 동화와 번역, (12), pp.247~265 (2006), 동화와번역연구소
- Chadwick, Owen., "Charles Kingsley at Cambridge", The Historical Journal, 18(2), pp.303~332 (1975)
- Chitty, Susan., "The Beast and the Monk: A Life and Charles Kingsley" (1974), Hodder and Stoughta
- Fisher, Devon., "“On God and Godlike Men We Build Our Trust”:Canonization, Collective Memory, and the Victorian Quest for Origins", Doctoral, pp.2005
- Fisher, Devon., "Roman Catholic Saints and Early Victorian Literature:Consevativism, Liberalism, and the Emergence of Secular Culture" (2012), Ashgate
- Hutton, Arthur Wollaston., "Introduction. The Lives of the English Saints: Written by Various Hands at the Suggestion of John Henry Newman", pp.vii~xxx. (2015), FB &dLtd
- Kingsley, Charles., "Poems of Charles Kingsley" (1913), Oxford UP
- Kingsley, Charles., "Scientific Essays and Lectures" (2016), CreateSpace Independent Publishing Platform
- Kingsley, Charles., "The Water-Babies" (2011), Harper Press
- Kingsley, Charles., "Apologia pro Vita Sua", pp.375~410 (1994), Penguin Books
- Lightman, Bernard., "Victorian Sciences and Religion: Discordant Harmonies", Osiris, 16, pp.343~366 (2001)
- Manlove, Colin., "Christian Fantasy; From 1200 to the Present" (1992), U of Notre Dame P
- Newman, John Henry., "An Essay in Aid of a Grammar of Assent" (2015), Leopold Classic Library
- Newman, John Henry., "Apologia Pro Vita Sua" (1994), Penguin Books
- Newman, John Henry., "Lives of the English Saints" (2018), FB &dLtd
- Newman, John Henry., "Lyra Apostolica" (2015), Forgotten Books
- Newman, John Henry., "The Idea of a University Defined and Illustrated" (2016), Wentworth Press
- Norris. Thomas J., "Cardinal Newman for Today" (2010), The Columbia P
- "Our Souls with Literalism”: Reading Essays and Reviews"
- Turner, Frank M., "The Victorian Conflict between Science and Religion: A Professional Dimension", The History of Science Society, 69(3), pp.356~376 (1978)