임상시험 법률관계에서 미성년자 동의능력의 문제
Legal Issues Concerning the Competence of Minors in Clinical Investigation
0
조회
0
다운로드
11
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
This article examines some of the legal issues associated with consent and the competence of minors. A study was designed to evaluate the self-decisions of competent minors who are regarded as vulnerable subjects. The study begins with the Grimes Case (Grimes versus Kennedy Krieger Institute, Inc., 2001), which has established some special relationship between research institutes and human subjects. Since minors do not have the legal competence to complete a contract without the consent of their parents there is a conflict between the consent of parents as guardians and that of minors as self-decision makers. This article argues that the self-decisions of competent minors should take precedence over parental rights and that the authority of parents should be restricted. The article discusses the role of IRBs in protecting the consent of the competent minors.
Abstract
This article examines some of the legal issues associated with consent and the competence of minors. A study was designed to evaluate the self-decisions of competent minors who are regarded as vulnerable subjects. The study begins with the Grimes Case (Grimes versus Kennedy Krieger Institute, Inc., 2001), which has established some special relationship between research institutes and human subjects. Since minors do not have the legal competence to complete a contract without the consent of their parents there is a conflict between the consent of parents as guardians and that of minors as self-decision makers. This article argues that the self-decisions of competent minors should take precedence over parental rights and that the authority of parents should be restricted. The article discusses the role of IRBs in protecting the consent of the competent minors.
참고문헌 (16)
- "의료기기안전정책과 문의결과", 식약청[URL]
- 연합뉴스, "연합뉴스 2006. 11. 22. 신문기사", ~ (2006)
- 연합뉴스, "연합뉴스 2007. 4. 6. 신문기사.", ~ (2007)
- 서울행정법원, "서울행정법원 2002 12. 4. 선고 2002구합10926 판결.", ~
- 연합뉴스, "연합뉴스 2004. 6. 17. 신문기사.", ~ (2004)
- Dolgin J, "Bioethics and the law", pp.434~435 (2005), Aspen
- 지원림, "민법특강", pp.168~ (2007), 홍문사
- 유택형, "의료사고에 대한 법적 보장문제<6> 법률신문, 1974. 11. 18.", ~ (1974)
- 중앙일보, "중앙일보 1998. 5. 15. 신문기사.", ~ (1998)
- 유네스코한국위원회, "과학연구윤리", pp.86~ (2001), 당대
- 김천수, "인체에 대한 생체의학적 연구(인체실험)에 관한 법적 고찰", 법정논총, 5, pp.32~33 (1990)
- 홍경남, "과학기술과 사회윤리", pp.224~225 (2007), 철학과 현실사
- 앤드류 솔로몬, "한낮의 우울" (2004), 민음사
- Habermann E, "Therapeutische Prüfungen an Nicht-Einwilligungsfähigen im Einfall -ethisch geboten und rechtlich zulässig", NJW, pp.3389~3395 (2000)
- 이선규, "동의능력이 있는 미성년자의 치료의사결정", 연세학술논집, 통권 : 38, pp.195~197 (2003)
- Wolk, "Der minderjahrige Patent", MedR, pp.974~ (2001)