부정수표단속법상 과실범 처벌의 정당성 - 과실범 처벌규정의 입법취지를 중심으로 -
Legitimacy of Criminalizing Negligence in Dishonoured Cheques Act
0
조회
0
다운로드
2
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
The healthy circulation of check is largely depend on the trust in capitalistic society. For instance in case the originator issues his payment instruction by check, it is common practice for the bank of beneficiary, which is the payee, to enter a provisional credit in the beneficiary's account as soon as hi pays in the check to his bank. Thus it is necessary for modern society to protect the function of check in many ways, especially by laws. Some critics have argued that the regulation of criminalizing negligence in Dishonoured Cheques Act cannot be justifiable in that this Act imposes penalty on those who draw a dishonoured check not only with intention but also with negligence, which is against modern legal principle that intentional act should be criminalized in general and negligent act should be punished exceptionally only when there is enough justifiable grounds. This paper examined the validity of critics' arguments and concluded that we can find reasonable grounds of the regulation of criminalizing negligence in Dishonoured Cheques Act in the legislative intent of the regulation taking the backgrounds of the Act into account.
Abstract
The healthy circulation of check is largely depend on the trust in capitalistic society. For instance in case the originator issues his payment instruction by check, it is common practice for the bank of beneficiary, which is the payee, to enter a provisional credit in the beneficiary's account as soon as hi pays in the check to his bank. Thus it is necessary for modern society to protect the function of check in many ways, especially by laws. Some critics have argued that the regulation of criminalizing negligence in Dishonoured Cheques Act cannot be justifiable in that this Act imposes penalty on those who draw a dishonoured check not only with intention but also with negligence, which is against modern legal principle that intentional act should be criminalized in general and negligent act should be punished exceptionally only when there is enough justifiable grounds. This paper examined the validity of critics' arguments and concluded that we can find reasonable grounds of the regulation of criminalizing negligence in Dishonoured Cheques Act in the legislative intent of the regulation taking the backgrounds of the Act into account.
참고문헌 (19)
- 김대웅, "부정수표단속법 제2조 제2항 및 제4조 범죄에 관하여", 사법연수원 정연논총, ~ (2010)
- 김형완, "手票不渡의 制裁手段에 관한 硏究 : '부정수표단속법'을 중심으로", 박사, 법학과 상사법전공, pp.2012
- 박혜진, "경제형법으로서의 부정수표단속법에 관한 연구", 석사, 법학, pp.2002
- 윤성승, "부도수표에 대한 법적 규제 검토 - 부정수표단속법을 중심으로 -", 경찰법연구, 6(2), pp.290~318 (2008), 한국경찰법학회
- 윤천희, "부정수표단속법" (2001), 법률문화원
- 이정호, "부정수표단속법 제2조 제2항의 위헌성", 대전지방법원 실무자료연구, 4 (2000)
- 이주원, "특별형법" (2011), 弘文社
- 이천현, "파산범죄에 관한 연구" (2005)
- 이현종, "부정수표단속법 제2조 제2항 위반죄의 구성요건에 대하여", 서울지방법원 실무논단, ~ (1997)
- 정동윤, "부정수표단속법상의 문제점", 대한변호사협회지, (58) (1980)
- 최광율, "부정수표단속법의 개정과 그 해석의 문제점", 법정, ~ (1966)
- 한옥신, "부정수표단속법을 시급히 개정하라", 법전월보, (16) (1965)
- "제54회 국회 제1차 법제사법위원회 회의록", ~ (1966)
- "제165회 국회 제6차 법제사법위원회 회의록", ~ (1993)
- Recent Case, "Criminal Law - Statutory Offenses - Bad-Check Laws As Involving Imprisonment for Debt", Harv. L. Rev, 45(742) (1932)
- Note, "Constitutionality of Bad Check Statutes", Yale. L.J, 41(638) (1932)
- Neil Kibble, "Dishonoured Cheques: A Comparative Analysis", Journal of International Banking Law, 16(77) (2001)
- M. Vasseur, "Le cheque sans provision en France 1865-1992" (1992)
- Winfried Hassemer, "범죄와 형벌" (2011), 나남
