서유럽 중세광학의 성격 논쟁 광학인가, 시각학인가?
The Debate over Nature of Medieval Optics in Western Europe: Optics or Visual Science?
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
This paper deals with the debate between A. Mark Smith and David C. Lindberg on the Big picture of medieval optics as perspectiva. A. Mark Smith argued that medieval optics was cognitive science in the modern sense, yet Lindberg expressed a reserved position that Smith’s argument be acceptable only to a certain extent. In order to contextualize this debate historically, the paper has examined the accounts of medieval theorist, Robertus Grosseteste, Johannes Peckham and Dominicus de Clivaxo, and presented the modern translation for perspectiva. Furthermore, the paper pointed out that widespread interpretation of medieval optics is anachronistic, revealing its mere prejudices of medieval optics.
Abstract
This paper deals with the debate between A. Mark Smith and David C. Lindberg on the Big picture of medieval optics as perspectiva. A. Mark Smith argued that medieval optics was cognitive science in the modern sense, yet Lindberg expressed a reserved position that Smith’s argument be acceptable only to a certain extent. In order to contextualize this debate historically, the paper has examined the accounts of medieval theorist, Robertus Grosseteste, Johannes Peckham and Dominicus de Clivaxo, and presented the modern translation for perspectiva. Furthermore, the paper pointed out that widespread interpretation of medieval optics is anachronistic, revealing its mere prejudices of medieval optics.
참고문헌 (30)
- Alexander Neckam, "De naturis rerum libri duo" (1863), Longman
- Alfarabius Latinus, "Le De scientiis Alfarabii de Gérard de Crémone" (2017), Brepols
- Aristoteles Latinus, "Analytica posteriora(Translatio Iacobi)" (1968), Desclée de Brouwer
- Aristoteles Latinus, "Metaphysica(Translatio Iacobi)" (1970), Desclée de Brouwer
- Aristoteles Latinus, "Metaphysica(Translatio media)" (1976), E. J. Brill
- Aristoteles Latinus, "Physica(Translatio vetus)" (1990), E. J. Brill
- Averroes Latinus, "Aristotelis opera cum Averrois commentariis: Quartum volumen", Apud Junctas
- Dominicus de Clivaxo, "Les questions de ‘perspective’ de Dominicus de Clivaxo", Centaurus, 10, pp.18~22 (1964)
- Dominicus Gundissalinus, "Domingo Gundisalvo De scientiis" (1954), Madrid
- Isidorus Hispalensis, "Etymologiarum sive originum libri XX" (1911), Clarendon Press
- Johannes Peckham, "Tractatus de perspectiva" (1972), The Franciscan Institute
- Robertus Grosseteste, "Die Philosophischen Werke des Robert Grosseteste, Bischofs von Lincoln" (1912), Aschendorff
- 湯若望, "曆法西傳"
- 김율, "성 알베르투스 마그누스의 『신명론주해』에 나타난 빛과 아름다움 개념", 서양고전학연구, 56(2), pp.157~182 (2017), 한국서양고전학회[DOI]
- 김성근, "동아시아 근현대 물리학 용어의 성립-메이지 일본의 ‘물리학 역어회(1883)’ 설립을 중심으로-", 동서철학연구, (85), pp.291~314 (2017), 한국동서철학회[DOI]
- 류전희, "원근법의 변화와 고전 광학이론 - 중세에서 초기르네상스까지 -", 대한건축학회논문집, 25(02), pp.167~174 (2009), 대한건축학회
- Grant, E, "중세의 과학" (1992), 나남
- Lindberg, David. C, "서양과학의 기원들" (2009), 나남
- Carter, B. A. R, "The Oxford Companion to Art", pp.840~861 (1980), Oxford University Press
- Dod, Bernard G, "The Cambridge History of Later Medieval Philosophy", pp.45~79 (1982), Cambridge University Press
- Lička, L, "Studying the Arts in in Late Medieval Bohemia: Production, Reception and Transmisiion of Knowledge", pp.251~303 (2021), Brepols
- Smith, A. Mark, "Getting the Big Picture in Perspectivist Optics", Isis, 72(1), pp.568~589 (1981)
- Trachtenberg, M, "Perspective as Practice: Renaissance Cultures of Optics", pp.19~70 (2019), Brepols
- Lindberg, David C, "oger Bacon and The Origins of Perspectiva in The Middle Ages" (1996), Clarendoon Press
- Panti, C, "Roberto Grossatesta" (2016), Pisa University Press
- Raedts, P, "Richard Rufus of Cornwall and the Tradition of Oxford Theology" (1987), Clarendon Press
- Raynaud, D, "L’hypothèse d’Oxford: Essai sur les origines de la perspective" (1998), PUF
- Raynaud, D, "Optics and The Rise of Perspectiva: A Study in Network Knowledge Diffusion" (2014), The Bardwell Press
- Smith, A. Mark, "From Sight to Light: The Passage From Ancient to Modern Optics" (2015), The University of Chicago Press
- Weijers, O, "Répertoire des noms commençant par C-F" (1996), Brepols