Reparations and Reconciliation in East Asia as a Hot Issue of Tort Law in the 21st Century: Case Studies, Legal Issues, and Theoretical Framework
0
조회
0
다운로드
1
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Reparations and reconciliation issues have been still marginalized in tort law in spite of their pragmatic and theoretical importance in East Asian legal scholarship. On the other hand, there are already many reparations lawsuits, especially relating to Japanese invasion and colonization, on forced slave labor, comfort women, massacres in China. In this article, first, we’ll deal with why these legal cases have been unsuccessful so far in Japan, and the ways to overcome legal obstacles. Second, we will discuss the mechanisms of reparation and its goal: reconciliation and changes in international and racial relationship. The important role of an apology, comparison of legal and moral reparations and the related issues will also be considered.
Abstract
Reparations and reconciliation issues have been still marginalized in tort law in spite of their pragmatic and theoretical importance in East Asian legal scholarship. On the other hand, there are already many reparations lawsuits, especially relating to Japanese invasion and colonization, on forced slave labor, comfort women, massacres in China. In this article, first, we’ll deal with why these legal cases have been unsuccessful so far in Japan, and the ways to overcome legal obstacles. Second, we will discuss the mechanisms of reparation and its goal: reconciliation and changes in international and racial relationship. The important role of an apology, comparison of legal and moral reparations and the related issues will also be considered.
참고문헌 (28)
- KUNIHIKO YOSHIDA, "LECTURE NOTES ON TORT LAW (HUHOUKOUIHOU NADO KOUGIROKU)", pp.52~ (2007), Shinzan Pub. Co.
- KYOJUU HUKUSHI, "PROPERTY, HOUSING WELFARE, AND REPARATION PROBLEMS IN THE MULTICULTURAL AGE (TABUNKA JIDAI TO SHOYUU", pp.Yuhikaku Pub. Co., HOSHOU MONDAI)
- URBAN WELFARE, "DISASTER RECOVERY, WAR REPARATIONS AND A CRITICAL ‘RULE OF LAW’", pp.SENSOU HOSHOU TO HIHANTEKI ‘HOU NO SHIHAI’)(Yuhikaku Pub. Co., TOSHI KYOJUU
- BARKAN, "THE GUILT OF NATIONS: RESTITUTION AND NEGOTIATING HISTORICAL INJUSTICES" (2000), Norton
- BARKAN, "TAKING WRONGS SERIOUSLY: APOLOGIES AND RECONCILIATION" (2006), Stanford U.P.
- ROY BROOKS, "ATONEMENT AND FORGIVENESS: A NEW MODEL FOR BLACK REPARATIONS" (2004), U. California P.
- SHOUICHI KOSEKI, "WHY WAS THE ART. 9 OF JAPANESE CONSTITUTION DRAFTED? (KENPOU 9 JOU WA NAZE SEITEI SARETAKA)(Iwanami Booklet)" (2006), Iwanami Pub. Co.
- "LAW’S EMPIRE" (1986), Harvard U.P.
- Margaret Jane Radin, "Reconsidering the Rule of Law", BOSTON U.L. REV, 69, pp.813~ (1989)
- Robert Cover, "Foreword: Nomos and Narrative", HARV. L. REV, 97, pp.67~68 (1983)
- Robert Cover, "NARRATIVE, VIOLENCE, AND THE LAW" (1992), U. Michigan P.
- "THE REPORT OF TRUTH FINDING OF JEJU 4·3 EVENT (JEJU 4·3 SAKEON JINSANGJOSA BOGOSEO)(The Fact-Finding Committee of the Jeju 4·3 Event and Redeeming Honor of the Victims, 2003)", ~ (2003)
- Ko Chang Hoon, "US Government Responsibility in the Jeju April Uprising and Grand Massacre: Islanders’ Perspective", KOREAN J. OF LOCAL GOV’T STUD, 8(2), pp.123~ (2003)
- Suzuki Ken, "Reparation after the War from the Chinese side (Chuugoku kara mita Sengohosyou), in YASUHIRO OKUDA ET AL., JOINT RESEARCH: REPARATION FOR THE WAR IN CHINA (KYOUDOU KENKYU: CHUGOKU SENGOHOSHOU)", pp.187~188 (1994), Akashi Pub. Co.
- DAVID MILLER, "NATIONAL RESPOSIBILITY AND GLOBAL JUSTICE", pp.135~ (2008), Oxford U.P.
- MICHAEL SANDEL, "JUSTICE: WHAT’S THE RIGHT THING TO DO", pp.208~223 (2010), Penguin Books
- Masao Maruyama, "The Structure of Political Decision-Making (Maturigoto no Kouzou), in: THE SELECTION OF WORKS BY MASAO MARUYAMA (MARUYAMA MASAO SHUU) vol.12 1982~1987" (1996), Iwanami Pub. Co.
- Kaimipono David Wenger, "Too Big to Remedy?: Rethinking Mass Restitution for Slavery and Jim Crow", LOYOLA OF LA L. REV, 44, pp.177~ (2010)
- Kunihiko Yoshida, "The Reparations for the Ainu people: A Critical Analysis of the Recent Commission’s Report from the Civil Law Perspective (Ainu Minzoku no Hoshou Mondai---Minpougaku karano Kinji no Yuushikisha Kondankai Houkokusho no Hihanteki Kousatu)", NOMOS(KANSAI UNIV.), 28(19), pp.33~35
- "THE HANGYOREH NEWSPAPER", 8~9 (2010)
- HIGASHIKAWA JIGYOUJOU NO KIROKU) (2nd ed.), "THE MATTER OF CHINESE SLAVE LABOR: A REPORT ABOUT THE LABOR SITE OF HIGASHIKAWA, HOKKAIDO (CHUGOKUJIN KYOUSEIRENKOU JIKEN: HOKKAIDO", pp.1976, SHIZUO KANAMAKI
- GORO NAKAMURA, "AGENT ORANGE IN THE BATTLEFIELD (SENJOU NO KAREHAZAI)" (1995), Iwanami Pub. Co.
- PIERRE HAZAN, "JUDGING WAR, JUDGING HISTORY: BEHIND TRUTH AND RECONCILIATION" (2010)
- Takao Matsumura, "The Massacre of No Gun Ri, Korea in 1950 (Kankoku Nogunri niokeru Gyakusatsu), in: MATSUMURA ET AL. EDS., THE SOCIAL HISTORY OF MASS SLAUGHTERS IN THE 20th CENTURY (TAIRYOU GYAKUSATSU NO SHAKAISHI: SENRITSU NO 20 SEIKI)", pp.119~ (2007), Minerva Pub. Co.
- The Associated Press, "Panel Reveals New Details of 1940’s Experiment" (2011), THE NEW YORK TIMES
- PHILIP GOUREVITCH, "WE WISH TO INFORM YOU THAT TOMORROW WE WILL BE KILLED WITH OUR FAMILIES: STORIES FROM RWANDA (Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 1998)(Japanese translation: HILLS OF GENOCIDE: HIDDEN TRUTH OF RWANDA MASSACRES(1)(2)(JENOSAIDO NO OKA)" (2003), Wave Pub. Co.
- Tooru Ikuyo, "The Legitimate Self Defense and Emergent Action and the Third Parties’ Damage in Civil Law (Minji jouno Seitoubouei", Kinkyuhinan to Daisansya Higai), 1984, pp.48(3), ~
