청대 건륭기 만주족의 根本之地 만들기 -京師 旗人의 이주와 만주의 封禁을 중심으로-
Making "Place of Manchu Origins" during the Qianlong
0
조회
0
다운로드
9
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
In the early Qianlong reign, the Eight Banners were bedeviled by economic dislocation and martial declension. To solve these problems, the Qing government decided to relocate the bannermen in Beijing to Manchuria and simultaneously to enforce the policy of closing Manchuria, i.e. fengjing (封禁). Qing specialists have long believed that these two decisions made by the Qianlong emperor were not related each other: the former has been mainly discussed as one of the many economic policies to improve life of the bannermen in the capital, while the latter mostly examined from the perspective of agriculture and land reclamation in Manchuria. In fact, however, these two policies were taken to achieve a same goal, that is, making “Place of Manchu Origins (genben zhi di 根本之地, genben zhong di 根本重地),” by which the Qing government expected to resolve both the serious economic crisis of the bannermen and the steady acculturation of Manchus to Han customs. This policy came to transform the meaning of “Place of Manchu Origins” from a common noun indicating a “very important place” to a proper noun specifying “a fundamentally crucial place for the Manchus.” After the Qianlong reign, Manchuria as the "fundamentally crucial place for the Manchus" became a place for all the bannermen living in both Beijing and Manchuria. It was a place where privileges for bannermen in Manchuria should be protected, population pressure in Beijing (the home for half the entire banner populations in the Qing empire) be resolved, and finally, the Manchu culture and language be preserved.
Abstract
In the early Qianlong reign, the Eight Banners were bedeviled by economic dislocation and martial declension. To solve these problems, the Qing government decided to relocate the bannermen in Beijing to Manchuria and simultaneously to enforce the policy of closing Manchuria, i.e. fengjing (封禁). Qing specialists have long believed that these two decisions made by the Qianlong emperor were not related each other: the former has been mainly discussed as one of the many economic policies to improve life of the bannermen in the capital, while the latter mostly examined from the perspective of agriculture and land reclamation in Manchuria. In fact, however, these two policies were taken to achieve a same goal, that is, making “Place of Manchu Origins (genben zhi di 根本之地, genben zhong di 根本重地),” by which the Qing government expected to resolve both the serious economic crisis of the bannermen and the steady acculturation of Manchus to Han customs. This policy came to transform the meaning of “Place of Manchu Origins” from a common noun indicating a “very important place” to a proper noun specifying “a fundamentally crucial place for the Manchus.” After the Qianlong reign, Manchuria as the "fundamentally crucial place for the Manchus" became a place for all the bannermen living in both Beijing and Manchuria. It was a place where privileges for bannermen in Manchuria should be protected, population pressure in Beijing (the home for half the entire banner populations in the Qing empire) be resolved, and finally, the Manchu culture and language be preserved.
참고문헌 (60)
- "淸高宗實錄", ~
- "淸史列傳 권20 阿里袞傳", ~
- "淸宣宗實錄", ~
- "淸世宗實錄", ~
- "軍機處滿文錄副奏摺", ~
- 谷苞, "西北通史", pp.216~236
- 김선민, "人蔘과 疆域 ― 後金-淸의 강역인식과 대외관계의 변화 ―", 명청사연구, 30(30), pp.227~257 (2008), 명청사학회
- 노기식, "중국의 청전기 만주 및 조선관계 연구동향, in 중국의 동북변강연구동향분석", pp.86~89 (2004), 고구려연구재단
- 稻葉岩吉, "滿洲發達史", pp.311~316 (1915), 大阪屋號出版社
- 梁詩正, "八旗屯種疏, 賀長齡, 皇朝經世文編 권35 ｢戶政18｣ 八旗生計", ~
- 鈴井正孝, "雍正年間に行われた井田制について", 歴史, 11 (1955)
- 林士鉉, "季東北移民實邊政策之研究", pp.5~10 (2001), 國立政治大學歷史學系
- 范咸, "八旗屯種｣, 賀長齡, 皇朝經世文編 권35 ｢戶政18｣ 八旗生計", ~
- 舒赫德, "八旗開墾邊地疏, 賀長齡, 皇朝經世文編 권35 ｢戶政18｣ 八旗生計", ~
- 石橋秀雄, "淸朝中期の畿輔旗地政策", 清代史硏究, pp.224~238 (1989), 綠蔭書房
- 송미령, "康熙帝의 淸 帝國 구상과 滿洲族의 정체성 － 예수회 선교사들의 기록을 중심으로 －", 역사학보, (196), pp.127~157 (2007), 역사학회
- 安雙成, "順康雍三朝八旗丁額淺析", 歷史檔案, 2, pp.100~103 (1983)
- 王景澤, "對淸代封禁政策的再認識", 北方文物 (1997)
- 王景澤, "淸前期經營東北的政治戰略失誤", 延邊大學學報 (1996)
- 韋慶遠, "淸代康熙時期“生息銀兩”制度的初創和運用", pp.166~185 (1989), 中國社會科學出版社
- 魏克威, "嘉道時期吉林的封禁與開發", 東北師大學報, (1) (1992)
- 魏影, "略論清代京旗回屯的失敗", 北方文物, (1) (2008)
- 魏影, "清代京旗回屯思想述論", 江南社會學院學報, (4) (2006)
- 魏影, "清代京旗回屯問題硏究" (2010), 黑龍江大學出版社
- 魏影, "乾隆朝京旗回屯述略", 歷史檔案 (2007)
- 윤영인, "만주족의 정체성과 한화이론에 대한 서구 학계의 신간 소개", 만주연구, 2 (2005)
- 윤휘탁, "‘변지’에서 ‘내지’로 : 중국인 이민과 만주(국)", 중국사연구, 16, pp.49~73
- 정혜중, "光緖年間 동북관리와 1907년 동삼성 설치 - 동북 봉금지대의 내지화", 중국학보, (54), pp.379~400 (2006), 한국중국학회
- 李喬, "八旗生計問題述略", 歷史檔案 (1985)
- 李治亭, "東北通史" (2001), 中州古籍出版社
- 李治亭, "東北通史", pp.898~915 (2001), 中州古籍出版社
- 이화자, "조청국경문제연구", pp.66~67 (2008), 집문당
- "청사 만주족이 통치한 중국", pp.152~ (2000), 신서원
- 任桂淳, "淸朝八旗駐防興衰史", pp.89~126, 三聯書店
- 張杰, "柳條邊,印票與清朝東北封禁新論", 中國邊疆史地研究, (1) (1999)
- 張杰, "試論清前期的東北封禁", 社會科學輯刊, (5) (1994)
- 張杰, "清代鴨綠江流域的封禁與開發", 中國邊疆史地研究, (4) (1994)
- 田志和, "論清代東北行政體制的改革", pp.63~64 (1987), 哲學社會科學版
- 林士鉉, "清季東北移民實邊政策之研究", pp.313~314 (2001), 國立政治大學歷史學系
- 定宜莊, "淸代八旗駐防硏究", pp.189~193 (2003), 遼寧民族出版社
- 定宜莊, "清代京旗移駐東北屯墾始末", 석사, pp.1985
- 趙啓重, "淸代東北的封禁政策", 黑龍江社會科學 (1992)
- 刁書仁, "略論乾隆朝京旗蘇拉的移駐", 北方文物 (1994)
- 刁書仁, "明淸東北史硏究論集", pp.62~65 (1995), 吉林文史出版社
- 趙中孚, "近代東三省的地權關係與封禁政策", 中央硏究院近代史硏究所集刊, (10), pp.284~
- 周藤吉之, "清代滿洲土地政策の研究", pp.342~353 (1944), 河出書房
- 中國第一歷史檔案館 소장, "軍機處漢文錄副奏摺 156卷, 第395~397號", pp.395~397
- 魏影 王小紅, "乾隆朝京旗回屯述略", 歷史檔案, (1), pp.82~ (2007)
- 陳鋒, "淸代軍費硏究", pp.17~86 (1992), 武漢大學出版社
- 川久保悌郞, "清末に於ける吉林省西北部の開發" (1935), 歷史學研究
- 佟冬, "中國東北史(全6冊)" (1998), 吉林文史出版社
- 胡焕庸, "東北地區人口發展的回顧與前瞻", 人口學刊 (1982)
- Christopher M. Isset, "State, Peasant, and Merchant in Qing Manchuria, 1644~1862" (2007), Stanford University Press
- "Lakcaha jecen de takūraha babe ejehe bithe. In Lakcaha jecen de takūraha babe ejehe bithe", pp.1~
- Mark C. Elliott, "The Limits of Tartary: Manchuria in Imperial and National Geographies", The Journal of Asian Studies, 59(3) (2000)
- Mark C. Elliott, "The Manchu Way: The Eight Banners and Ethnic Identity in Late Imperial China", pp.43~541 (2001), Stanford University Press
- Owen Lattimore, "Manchuria: cradle of Conflict", pp.7~ (1932), The Macmillan Company
- Pamela Kyle Crossley, "Manzhou Yuanliu Kao and the Formalization of the Manchu Heritage", The Journal of Asian Studies, 46(4), pp.761~790 (1987)
- Peter C. Perdue, "China Marches West: The Qing Conquest of Central Eurasia", pp.256~345 (2005), The Belknap Press of Harvard Univ. Press
- Robert H.G. Lee, "Manchurian Frontier in Ch’ing History" (1971), Harvard University Press