Daechuri as Symbolic Battleground: Failure to Integrate Divergent Frames for Conflict Interpretation
0
조회
0
다운로드
6
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
This study examined how government negotiators’ and opponents’ different frames for construing others’ motivations prevented a settlement and intensified the Daechuri policy conflict over appropriation of land for a military base. Although communication- and consensus-based processes have been acknowledged as useful methods of conflict resolution, the issue of how participants’ divergent definitions and interpretations of the situation may inhibit effective communication has rarely been empirically examined. Employing frame analysis, this study explored how two parties’ motivations and issue interpretations were persistently mismatched over time without reaching consensus. The results revealed that government negotiators tended to oversimplify opponents’ motivations as being economically driven, while they were in fact more complicated. These results suggest that communicative negotiation will not likely be conducive to effective conflict resolution unless it is based on thorough understanding of the situation.
Abstract
This study examined how government negotiators’ and opponents’ different frames for construing others’ motivations prevented a settlement and intensified the Daechuri policy conflict over appropriation of land for a military base. Although communication- and consensus-based processes have been acknowledged as useful methods of conflict resolution, the issue of how participants’ divergent definitions and interpretations of the situation may inhibit effective communication has rarely been empirically examined. Employing frame analysis, this study explored how two parties’ motivations and issue interpretations were persistently mismatched over time without reaching consensus. The results revealed that government negotiators tended to oversimplify opponents’ motivations as being economically driven, while they were in fact more complicated. These results suggest that communicative negotiation will not likely be conducive to effective conflict resolution unless it is based on thorough understanding of the situation.
참고문헌 (71)
- Adams, W. M., "Managing tragedies: Understanding conflict over common pool resources", Science, 302(5652), pp.1915~1916 (2003)
- Ahn, H. -K., "The participation and its patterns in policy process: The Korean case in an age of authoritarianism and modernization", Korean Journal of Policy Studies, 5, pp.45~52 (1990)
- Alvesson, M., "Taking the linguistic turn in organizational research: Challenges, responses, consequences", Journal of Applied Behavioral Science, 36(2), pp.136~158 (2000)
- Amason, A. C., "The effects of top management team size and interaction norms on cognitive and affective conflict", Journal of Management, 23(4), pp.495~516 (1997)
- Andranovich, G., "Achieving consensus in public decision making: Applying interest-based problem solving to the challenge of intergovernmental collaboration", Journal of Applied Behavioral Science, 31(4), pp.429~445 (1995)
- Astley, W. G., "Organization science, managers, and language games", Organization Science, 3(4), pp.443~460 (1992)
- Benford, R. D., "Frame disputes within the nuclear disarmament movement", Social Forces, 71(3), pp.677~701 (1993)
- Benford, R. D., "An insider’s critique of the social movement framing perspective", Sociological Inquiry, 67(4), pp.409~430 (1997)
- Benford, R. D., "Framing processes and social movements: An overview and assessment", Annual Review of Sociology, 26, pp.611~639 (2000)
- Bingham, L. B., "The new governance: Practices and processes for stakeholder and citizen participation in the work of government", Public Administration Review, 65(5), pp.547~558 (2005)
- Bogason, P., "The democratic prospects of network governance", The American Review of Public Administration, 36(1), pp.3~18 (2006)
- Braun, V., "Using thematic analysis in psychology", Qualitative Research in Psychology, 3(2), pp.77~101 (2006)
- Cacioppo, J. T., "Relationship between attitudes and evaluative space: A critical review, with emphasis on the separability of positive and negative substrates", Psychological Bulletin, 115(3), pp.401~423 (1994)
- Charalambides, M., "Policy conflict analysis for quality of service management", Paper presented at Policies for Distributed Systems and Networks, the Sixth IEEE International Workshop (2005)
- Corvellec, H., "Sensegiving as mise-en-sens—the case of wind power development", Scandinavian Journal of Management, 23(3), pp.306~326 (2007)
- Crotty, M., "The foundations of social research: Meaning and perspective in the research process" (1998), Sage
- Daft, R. L., "Toward a model of organizations as interpretation systems", Academy of Management Review, 9(2), pp.284~295 (1984)
- Drake, L. E., "Communicative framing theory in conflict resolution", Communication Research, 23(3), pp.297~322 (1996)
- Dutton, J. E., "Keeping an eye on the mirror: Image and identity in organizational adaptation", Academy of Management Journal, 34(3), pp.517~554 (1991)
- Edelman, M., "Politics as symbolic action: Mass arousal and quiescence" (1971), Markham Publishing
- Fiol, C. M., "Consensus, diversity, and learning in organizations", Organization Science, 5(3), pp.403~420 (1994)
- Fischer, F., "Citizens, experts, and the environment: The politics of local knowledge" (2000), Duke University Press
- Fischer, F., "Reframing public policy: Discursive politics and deliberative practices" (2003), Oxford University Press
- Fiss, P. C., "The discourse of globalization: Framing and sensemaking of an emerging concept", American Sociological Review, 70(1), pp.29~52 (2005)
- Fligstein, N., "Social skill and institutional theory", American Behavioral Scientist, 40(4), pp.397~405 (1997)
- Folger, J. P., "Coding social interaction, In Progress in communication sciences" (1984), Ablex
- Foreman, P., "Members’ identification with multiple-identity organizations", Organization Science, 13(6), pp.618~635 (2002)
- Gioia, D. A., "Identity, image, and issue interpretation: Sensemaking during strategic change in academia", Administrative Science Quarterly, 41, pp.370~403 (1996)
- Goffman, E., "The presentation of self in everyday life" (1973), Overlook Press
- Goffman, E., "Frame analysis: An essay on the organization of experience" (1974), Northeastern University Press
- Goffman, E., "The interaction order", American Sociological Review, 48, pp.1~17 (1983)
- Golden-Biddle, K., "Breaches in the boardroom: Organizational identity and conflicts of commitment in a nonprofit organization", Organization Science, 8(6), pp.593~611 (1997)
- Hill, V., "An approach to identifying consensus in a subfield: The case of organizational culture", Poetics, 27(1), pp.1~30 (1999)
- Holton, J. A., "The coding process and its challenge, In The Sage handbook of grounded theory" (2007), Sage Publications
- Hong, Y.-D., "Paradox of hope", Hangyurae, ~ (2012)
- Hsieh, H.-F., "Three approaches to qualitative content analysis", Qualitative Health Research, 15(9), pp.1277~1288 (2005)
- Imperial, M. T., "Using collaboration as a governance strategy: Lessons from six watershed management programs", Administration and Society, 37(3), pp.281~320 (2005)
- James, W., "Principles of psychology (Vol. 2)" (1950), Dover Publications
- Jeon, J. -S., "Analysis on the conflicting points of the locational conflict", Korean Journal of Policy Studies, 15(2), pp.101~115 (2001)
- 김헌민, "The Process of Conflict Resolution in Public Project Disputes", The Korean Journal of Policy Studies, 23(2), pp.147~170 (2009), 서울대학교행정대학원
- Kubal, T. J., "The presentation of political self: Cultural resonance and the construction of collective action frames", Sociological Quarterly, 39(4), pp.539~554 (1998)
- Lee, S. H., "Policy conflict and its settlement in Korea: The case of regulatory reform", Korean Journal of Policy Studies, 8, pp.33~57 (1993)
- Levi-Strauss, C., "Structural anthropology" (1974), Basic Books
- Luhmann, N., "Society and interaction, In Social Systems" (1995), Stanford University Press
- "Familiarity, confidence, trust: Problems and alternatives" (2000)[URL]
- March, J. G., "Exploration and exploitation in organizational learning", Organization Science, 2(1), pp.71~87 (1991)
- McBeth, M., "Public opinion for sale: The role of policy marketers in Greater Yellowstone policy conflict", Policy Sciences, 37(3), pp.319~338 (2004)
- Miller, M. M., "Frame mapping and analysis of news coverage of contentious issues", Social Science Computer Review, 15(4), pp.367~378 (1997)
- Moe, R. C., "The emerging federal quasi government: Issues of management and accountability", Public Administration Review, 61(3), pp.290~312 (2001)
- Moynihan, D. P., "The ties that bind: Social networks, personorganization value fit, and turnover intention", Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 18(2), pp.205~227 (2008)
- Neale, M. A., "The effects of framing and negotiator overconfidence on bargaining behaviors and outcomes", Academy of Management Journal, 28(1), pp.34~49 (1985)
- Nelson, P., "Analyzing communication in and around organizations: A critical hermeneutic approach", Academy of Management Journal, 36(6), pp.1547~1576 (1993)
- Nelson, T. E., "Media framing of a civil liberties conflict and its effect on tolerance", American Political Science Review, 91(3), pp.567~583 (1997)
- O’Reilly, C. A., "Work group demography, social integration, and turnover", Administrative Science Quarterly, 34(1), pp.21~37 (1989)
- Park, C. -M., "Authoritarian rule in South Korea: Political support and governmental performance", Asian Survey, 31(8), pp.743~761 (1991)
- Perloff, J. M., "Biases resulting from the use of indexes: An application to attributional style and depression", Psychological Bulletin, 103(1), pp.95~104 (1988)
- Provan, K. G., "Modes of network governance: Structure, management, and effectiveness", Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 18(2), pp.229~252 (2008)
- Quirk, P. J., "The cooperative resolution of policy conflict", American Political Science Review, 83(3), pp.905~921 (1989)
- Rich, M. J., "Distributive politics and the allocation of federal grants", American Political Science Review, 83(1), pp.193~213 (1989)
- Rouleau, L., "Micro-practices of strategic sensemaking and sensegiving: How middle managers interpret and sell change every day", Journal of Management Studies, 42(7), pp.1413~1441 (2005)
- Rumsfeld, D. H., "Positioning America’s forces for the 21st century", US Department of Defense
- Sewell, W. H., Jr., "Geertz, cultural systems, and history: From synchrony to transformation", Representations, 59, pp.35~55 (1997)
- Smircich, L., "Organizations as shared meanings, In Organizational symbolism" (1983), JAI Press
- Suchman, M. C., "Managing legitimacy: Strategic and institutional approaches", Academy of Management Review, 20(3), pp.571~610 (1995)
- Suddaby, R., "Rhetorical strategies of legitimacy", Administrative Science Quarterly, 50(1), pp.35~67 (2005)
- Tucker, L. R., "The framing of Calvin Klein: A frame analysis of media discourse about the August 1995 Calvin Klein jeans advertising campaign", Critical Studies in Mass Communication, 15(2), pp.141~157 (1998)
- Weick, K. E., "Enacting sense making in crisis situations", Journal of Management Studies, 25, pp.305~317 (1988)
- Weick, K. E., "The collapse of sensemaking in organizations: The Mann Gulch disaster", Administrative Science Quarterly, 38(4), pp.628~652 (1993)
- Williams, D. R., "Beyond the commodity metaphor: Examining emotional and symbolic attachment to place", Leisure Sciences: An Interdisciplinary Journal, 14(1), pp.29~46 (1992)
- Wilson, M. A., "The wolf in Yellowstone: Science, symbol, or politics? Deconstructing the conflict between environmentalism and wise use", Society & Natural Resources, 10(5), pp.453~468 (1997)
- Yoo, Y.-W., "Daechuri compensation amounts to five hundred thirty million won on average", Chosun Ilbo, ~ (2006)
